HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004 07 26 Public Hearings 401
CITY COMMISSION
AGENDA
ITEM 401
Consent
Informational
Public Hearing X
RegulaIr
July 26. 2004
Meeting
/~rr
Mgr. I Dept
Authorization
\,
REQUEST: The Community Development Department presents to the City Commission a
request for a conditional use to allow multiple family dwellings in the C-l (Neighborhood
Commercial) zoning district, pursuant to Section 20-234 of the Zoning Chapter of the City Code
of Ordinances.
PURPOSE: The purpose ofthis agenda item is to consider a request by CPH Engineers, on
behalf of Morrison Homes, the applicant, to allow multiple-family residential units [town-homes]
as a conditional use in the C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial) zoning district. The subject property
is on the north side of SR 434, generally west of Sheoah Boulevard, between the Winter Springs
Golf Course and the Golf Terrace Apartments.
APPLICABLE CODE:
Sec. 20-82. Duties and powers, general.
The board of adjustment shall make recommendations to the city commission to
grant any variance or special [or conditional use] exception as delineated in this
chapter.
(1) The board of adjustment shall have the additional following specific powers
and duties:
b. To hear and make recommendations to the city commission on special
exceptions as authorized under the terms of the city's zoning ordinances;
to make recommendations to the city commission on such questions as are
July 26, 2004
Public Hearing Item 401
Page 2
involved in determining when special exceptions [or conditional uses]
with appropriate conditions and safeguards, or to recommend denial of
special exceptions [or conditional uses] when not in harmony with the
purpose and intent of the zoning regulations. In granting any special
exception [or conditional use] with appropriate conditions and safeguards,
violation of such conditions and safeguards, when made a part of the terms
under which the special exception is granted, shall be deemed a violation
ofthis chapter. The board of adjustment may recommend a reasonable
time limit within which the action for which the special exception is
required shall be begun or completed, or both, The board of adjustment
may recommend the granting of special exceptions where the applicant is
seeking a minor deviation from zoning requirements so long as the
granting of such special exception does not cause a change of character in
the neighborhood, does not constitute a rezoning of the property in
question or does not create a hardship for any of the adjacent property.
The board of adjustment may also recommend the granting of special
exceptions within C-1 neighborhood commercial districts when the
applicant has not sought a use listed in section 20-232, when the use
sought will not cause an undue hardship to the area of the city, will not
create a hazard or threat to the health, safety and welfare of the
community, will generally comply with the character of the neighborhood
and when the use is in harmony with the intent of the zoning ordinances of
the city.
Sec. 20-83. Procedures.
(a) Upon receipt, in proper form and with appropriate fees, an application for a
variance, special exception or conditional use as delineated in this chapter, the
board of adjustment shall schedule such application for consideration at a public
meeting.
(b) All such applications will be process within sixty (60) days of receipt of same.
(c) All meetings for consideration of a variance, special exception or conditional
use shall be noticed for at least seven (7) days prior to the date of the meeting in
the following manner:
(1) Posting the affected property with a notice of the meeting which
indicates the matter to be considered.
(2) Posting in city hall a notice of the meeting which indicates the
property affected and the matter to be discussed,
July 26, 2004
Public Hearing Item 401
Page 3
(3) At least seven (7) days prior to the meeting, the board of adjustment
shall also notify all owners of property adjacent to or within one hundred
fifty (150) feet ofthe property to be affected of the time, date and place of
the meeting. Such letter must also indicate the variance, special exception,
or conditional use requested, and must require proof of delivery.
(d) All interested persons shall be entitled to be heard as such meetings or to be
heard by written statement submitted at or prior to such meeting.
( e) In the event a special exception, variance or conditional use is not authorized
by ordinances of the city, the person requesting the unauthorized action must
submit an application pursuant to section 20-28,
(f) Appeals to the board of adjustment may be taken by any person aggrieved or
by any officer, board or bureau of the city affected by any decision of an
administrative official under the zoning regulations. Such appeals shall be taken
within thirty (30) days after such decision is made by filing with the officer from
whom the appeal is taken and with the board of adjustment, a notice of appeal
specifying the grounds thereof. The appeal shall be in such form as prescribed by
the rules of the board. The administrative official from whom the appeal is taken
shall, upon notification of the filing of the appeal, forthwith transmit to the board
of adjustment all the documents, plans, papers or other material constituting the
record upon which the action appealed from was taken,
(g) The board of adjustment shall fix a reasonable time for the hearing of the
appeal, give public notice thereof, as well as due notice to the parties in interest,
and make recommendations to the city commission for the appeal within a
reasonable time. Upon the hearing, any party may appear in person or by agent or
by attorney. For procedural purposes, an application for a special exception shall
be handled by the board of adjustment the same as for appeals.
(h) Any variance, special exception or conditional use which may be granted by
the council shall expire six (6) months after the effective date of such action by
the city commission, unless a building permit based upon and incorporating the
variance, special exception or conditional use is obtained within the aforesaid six-
month period. However, the city commission may renew such variance, special
exception or conditional use for one (1) additional period of six( 6) months,
provided good cause is shown and the application for extension shall be filed with
the board at least thirty (30) days prior to the expiration of the six-month period,
Any renewal may be granted without public hearing, however, a reapplication fee
may be charged in an amount not to exceed the amount of the original application
fee. It is intended that provisions contained within this subsection are to be
retroactive to the extent that any variance, special exception or conditional use
previously granted shall become void if a period of time in excess of twelve (12)
July 26, 2004
Public Hearing Item 401
Page 4
months shall have lapsed, and a building permit based upon and incorporating the
variance, special exceptions or conditional uses has not been issued prior to
expiration of such time limit.
Section 20-234. Conditional uses.
(5) Multiple-family residential with a maximum allowable density no greater than
that allowed under a Medium Density Residential future land use designation and
with at least two (2) parking spaces for each unit provided with an enclosed
garage.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The site was included as part of the Highlands, Section 3 (Plat Book 17, Pages 48 and 49, 1972).
The approximately 15 acre site is depicted as a separate parcel by the Seminole County Property
Appraiser's office. A final subdivision plat to properly create this lot may be required before a
site or subdivision plan may be approved.
The site has C-1 zoning and a Commercial Future Land Use (FLU) designation. A maximum
density of9,O units per acre is provided in the C-1 zoning district for multi-family development.
The applicant proposes 94 townhouse units on 15 gross acres (total site, including both uplands
and wetlands; the Comprehensive Plan sets forth density for the residential designations per gross
acre) - a gross density of 6.27 dwelling units per acre. This proposed density is consistent with
that of a Medium Density Residential Future Land Use designation (3.6 - 9.0 dwelling units per
acre), For comparison, the adjacent Golf Terrace Apartments site has a High Density Residential
FLU designation, which allows 9.1 to 21 dwelling units per acre.
The treed site abuts properties with recreational, multifamily, vacant, and commercial properties,
To the north is the golf course, to the east is the golf course country club/restaurant site, to the
west are Fountaintree Drive and the Golf Terrace Apartments, and to the south, on the opposite
side of SR 434, is an area outside of the City boundaries, There is an approximately 1 acre
triangular shaped parcel (the Casselberrys' property) that is located on the north side of SR 434
and abuts this site but is not a part of the City.
Another applicant (Davis Heritage) requested a conditional use to construct apartments on this
parcel in 2003. A controversy over affordable housing and City financial involvement led to the
applicant withdrawing the application. In contrast, this is a townhouse development, where the
property is subdivided and individual sites are owned. Staff would not object to condominiums
at this same site (town-homes require subdivision since the land is subdivided, but
condominiums require a site plan since, although the units are individually owned, the land
remains in common ownership and is not subdivided).
A revised concept subdivision plan (with 94 units instead of the previous 99) is provided for this
review, based on the City Commission's comments at the June 28,2004, meeting. Conditional
July 26, 2004
Public Hearing Item 401
Page 5
use approval does not convey any subdivision approval and does not vest the applicant for
anything depicted on the plans that may be inconsistent with City regulations (although staff did
a brief review of the plan for consistency with the Code), A full subdivision plan submittal and
review is required before any site work may begin. Additionally, the City adopted Ordinance No,
2003-43 in January, which requires an applicant to demonstrate that the development meets the
City's aesthetic review standards. No building permit may be issued for the site without this
approval. Further, any subdivision requires a final subdivision plat, consistent with Chapter 177,
Florida Statutes and Chapter 9 of the City Code of Ordinances, before a building permit may be
issued. As noted above, a plat may be required to properly create this 15 acre site - before it is
further divided into town-home lots with common areas.
CHRONOLOGY:
May 3, 2004 - Conditional Use application and fee received by City
June 3,2004 - BOA recommends approval
June 28, 2004 - City Commission deferred the item until the July 26 meeting
FINDINGS: 1. The site has a C-1 zoning and a Commercial Future Land Use (FLU)
designation.
2.Staff finds the concept of multi- family development within the C-1 zoning
district, at this location, to be consistent with the general zoning and with the
public interest. This finding did not address specific subdivision plan issues.
Those issues will be addressed during the subdivision plan review process.
3. The C-1 zoning district now specifies a maximum density of9.0 units per acre
for residential development (the applicant proposes 6.27 units per acre) and
parking for at least 2 automobiles within an enclosed garage.
BOA ACTION:
At its regularly scheduled meeting of June 3, 2004, the Board of Adjustment
recommended that the conditional use request be approved.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
The Board of Adjustment and staff recommend that the City Commission
approve the conditional use to allow multi-family development, at a density of
6.27 dwelling units per gross acre, in the C-1 (Neighborhood Commercial) zoning
district at this approximately 15 acre site, pursuant to Section 20-83 and Section
20-234 of the Zoning Chapter of the City Code of Ordinances.
July 26, 2004
Public Hearing Item 401
Page 6
CITY COMMISSION ACTION:
ATTACHMENTS:
A - Authorization
B - Conditional Use Application
C - Draft BOA Minutes
D - June 28, 2004 City Commission Minutes
E - Concept Design
/"
.,
ATTACHMENT A
LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION
As authorized agent for the real property more particularly described below and made a
part thereof, I authorize CPH Engineers, Inc., its designated representatives, designated
consultants and counsel to submit any and all applications related to the conditional use
permit for the property described below.
Parcel I.D.:
33-20-30-5l5-0I02-0000
~I&r
Vor Morrison Homes, Inc.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF O~cc...
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer dilly authorized in the state
aforesaid and in the County aforesaid to take acknowledgements, the f~regoing
instrument was acknowledged before me by ~~ ~ -r t f\J
who is personally known to me or who has produced identification.
-
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this ~
dayof~(Lv_ 2004. . .
. 0...,.. ::T:~::~~5
. ~_ . .. NO. .0(),044023
. ~.. . . .' ~ l~ Otl)ef I,D,
~.
~a1ecr w
L.J Ylumy ~oulllJalY
Stnlets
.
1/
o
HydrolOgy
SUbdMsiolllines
ParoelS
County Zarling
,/I,.l~lAc
,/1,.'0 Runl6.1Cl1lG
,/1,.5 R&nJ.Mc
,/1,.3 fbGll,3I\c
ReI C.:u1ty Homes-lAc
R. 1AA.i\A Sirq'.e F a!lt.21700
It.1AAA~ Fam.l3!l:XJ
R.1AA~Fam.11700
R,'A~FM1'!OO:l
R.1 ~Fam.a.m
R.1B~FM1.8700
R-l00~FlIm.5OO:I
R.2 O:lcl:wl T\\t1 Famity.9XK]
R.3>\ LhJj.FamiJyo 1QOU
R.3 ltot'&-F a'ltiiy-13DtJ
R-4 Mt.aioF8tl1ity
R.A,H ~ HOU!litlg.:m:l
~ 1 SitrJi!l Fam Md!lil<I H<ll11e.
~2 SitrJIll FMl Mdlile 1i<ll11...
RLt<i3 Tnl'od T Rl'fI:!lr Plri,.loo:l
RPR~~
CIP O!ioe
cs ~ cammCn:itll
Ctl~N~
Comm,
C.l R~Camm_
Cammo:flies
C.2 RtllaJ.Comm<SC:i3l
C.3GlnCamm~llttl
\Vktestt!e
t.'.lAVery~~
M.l~
t.4.2Impld.GeIn ~
POD~Urilee..,
PCO~Commert:i;ltDit.1.
~
~
.II'D
iiJ
III
D
.~,"4'."
",-. .'.~
.-......,.
IJ:MI
~
~
p;;;:f1
~
~
E
g
II
III
II
~.'1::.'
~
~
~
II
iii
Jmm
~
JW:l
~
II
II
&I
.
.
~.'~.'''.
~
~
~
B
II
II
II
ra:mI
'.~
UCU~Commuri<iy
PU Rtt&: lMdand ~
Ofa
.. F aoiliUes
.lTiil
~ GoII Couts(,)
mJ Pa(kS
Rec
Owner Addr
Parcel
Owner
ATTACHMENT B
, ,
.BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
1126 EAST S~ATE ROAD 434
WINTER'SPRINGS, FL .3.2708-2799
(407)327-1800
)1Jo tJ (J7J 7
FOR:
x
S~ECIAL EXCEPTION
VARIANCE \
'CONDITIONAL USE \
ADMINISTRATIVE DECISI01\.
APPLICANT: CPH ENGINEERS,. INC./JAVIER E.';, 0~p~NQ~E 407-425-0452.
ADDRESS: 111'7, E. ROBI~SON ST., O~LANDQ ", FL 32801
CONDITIONAL USE TO ALL'OW FOR ."RESIDEN'TIAL
2 PURPOSE OF REQUEST:. .
USE PER SECTI~N 20-234 OF THE CITY OF WINTEH ~PHING~ CUVE
OF ORDINANCES.
1.
3. ATTACH A COPX OF THE PARCEL SURVEY.
4. ATTACH AN 11 x'17 MAP SHOWING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY AND
SURROUNDING PARCELS.
5. ATTACH LEGAL'OESCRIPTION.
6.
TAX,PARCEL ~DENTIFicATION NUMBE~:
, ,
'33-20-3~~51~-OIOj~0000
. . .:
7. LOCATION ~F PARCEL (street Address. .apd/or .:N~arest Cross
streets): SR 434/FOUNTAINTREE DRIVE
8. PRESENT ~ONING:
C-1 .
, ': 'COMMERCIAL
FUT~RE ,L~NO USE:
"
By Signing belo~'I understand that City of Winter Springs Officials
may enter upon my property to inspect that portion. as relat.es to
this application:
(If the ap~lic~ntis not the owner of the subject property, the
applicant must attach a letter of authorization signed by the
owner) ,
J VIER E.
\
" .
PERSONS ARE ADVISED THAT, IF THEY DECIDE TO APPEAL ANY'DECISIONS
MADE AT THESE MEETINds/HEARINGS, THEY WitL NEED A,RECORb OF THE
PROCEEDiNGS AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE, THEY WILL, NEED TO INSURE THAT A .
VERBATIM'RECORD OF THt PROCEEDINGS IS M1DE, 'AT'THEIR 'COST, WHICH ,I '.
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE,'~~
BASED, PER SECTION 286.0105. Pf.nJHntl ~lT1nl'l'f'mt:'o 'J.'
'-''-'I'' ~..... ~__...,. oA.oA.._"-
~
ATTACHMENT C
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
DRAFT UNAPPR.OVED MlNUTES
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
REGULAR MEETING
JUNE 3, 2004
I. CALL TO ORDER
The Board of Adjustment Regular. Meeting of Thursday, June 3, 2004 was called to order
at 7:00 p.m. by Chainnan Thomas Waters in the East Conference Room of the Municipal .
Building (City Hall, 1126 East State Road 434, Winter Springs. Florida 32708).
Roll Call:
Chaimian Thomas Waters, pJ'e6ent
Vice Chainnan Jack Taylor, absent
Board Member Gary Diller,present
aoard Member Kathryn Fairchild, present
Board Member Howard Casman, present
Board Meri1ber Kathryn Fairchild led the Pledge of Allegiance.
Under "Agenda Changes," the Regular Agenda Ilem was pulled by the recommendation
of the City Attorney, Anthony Garganese.
n. CONSENT AGENDA
CONSENt'
A. Approval Of The May 61 1004 Regular Meeting Minute~.
"I MAKE A MOTION. WE APPROVE mE MINUTES AS PRESENTED."
MOTION BY ltOARD MEMBER DILLER.. SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER
FAIRCHILD. DISCUSSION. WITH CONSENSUS OF THE BOARD THE
MOTION WAS APPROVED.
MOTION CARRIED.
Ill. PUBLIC HEARINGS AGENDA
P\)8UC HbRlNGS
Commwlity Development Department
A. Request For A COllditiollal Use To Allow Multiple Family Dwellings In The C-l
(Neighborhood Commercial) ZODiDg District, Pursuant To Section 20-234. Of The
Zoning Chapter or The City Code OrOrdiDanc:eS.
.."... I
DRAfT..
@
~I'" ...- ,.......
~~
~'\
-,
llo"'-
7i'f~V'~
~::~~~
~'IC,~
~~
~J.-J
h-~.......~
~~
r'~'.a1
~ L...,. --l1
;-~/i}
oJ..", c:.._ c-~-....-,. .... _,_
"
. em' OP WINTER. SPRINGS
DRAFT UNAPPROVED MINtms
1I0AJU) OF ADJUSTMENT
REGULAR MBtTING - JUNE 3. ~004
PAOE20F4
Ms. Eloise Sahlmom, AlCP,ASLA, Senior Planner, Cormnuniry Development
Department presented the Agenda Item.
Ms. Sahlstrom said, "5taffis recommending approval of this Item."
Mr. Zaliier Omana. CPH Engineers, nee P1'esident, Planning Operations, 500 W Fullon
Street, Sanford. Florida: Mr. Omana indicated, 'This will not be affordable housing.
This will not be 'Section 8' housing. These will be townhomes developed by Morrison
Homes in the range of. S150,OOO.OO. $170,000,00 (one hundred fifty thousand dollars-
one hundred seventy thousand dollars) plus."
Chairman Waters asked, &CHow much tree remova.l do you anticipate?" Mr. Omana said,
"We do not know at this time.u Mr. Omana added. "We will make every attempt to .save
as many of the trees out there." Chainnan Wate~ added, .'cari you work around all the
wetlands or, are you going to mitigate any?" Mr. Oman a said, "We are trying'to work as
much as possible to keep the wetlands." Chainnan Waters said, "Vou say you will make
it[mitigate] offsite?" Mr. Omana said, "That is one of the options. Our.initial intent is to
mitigate onsite. n
Chairl7ffJn Warers opened the "Public Input" portion of the Agenda Irern.
Ms. Laura Reeve.J, Properly Manager, Golf Terrace Apartments, 1 Laurel. Oaks Drive,
Winter Sprlng.J. Flon'dtz: briefly addressed the Board.
Ms. Sahlstrom said to Ms, Reeves, "Usually, Laura) the City [Winter Springs] will
require development to have secondary access points!' Ms. Sahlstrom added, liThe City's
position and Staifis going to be that we very much do want a connection between the two
(2) projects,"
Chairman Waters confinned witll Ms. Sahlstrom. "In this particular case, we do not have
to meet the six (6) [Variance] aiteria." Ms. Sahlstrom agreed.
17rere was no orher "Public Input fl.
"I MAKE A MOTION THAT WE RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF THE
'CONDITIONAL USE"TO ALLOW MULTI FAMILY DEVELOPMENT AT A
DENSITY OF 6.6 (SIX POINT SIX) D'WELLINGS UNITS PER GROSS ACRE IN
A 'e-I' NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICT AT THIS
FIFTEEN (15) ACRE SITE." MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER DILLER.
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER CASMAN. DISCUSSION.
CHAIRMAN WATERS SAID, "IF YOU VOTE 'YES', YOU ARE VOTING TO
RECOMMEND THE lelT SSION TO APPROVE IT. IF YOU VOTE
eNO', YOU ARE VOTING DENSITY OT TO APPROVE IT. CORRECT?"
Q)
("[:\. ..
~J" J~~ J"'I,
,........ I " \ I 1_ ,_.... _ ._ ... _
^~r.=~,
t'........./'ClE'
~\
~~:~: ::a:..
~~~.:...'J'
"..-. ,~o".
J.I,'~~
~~~
~~~h,~",
..~~>w;
-.......
~~,
t~:_l
~
.~:
.J WI~-C:::")-C:::l:Jl:J'" J. J. . oj r
"'l!;,Jf .,.Ie:...., '-'l"-'.L
CITY OF W[NTE~ SPRINGS
DRAFT UNAP1'R,OV![) MlNttICS
. BOAllD OF ADJ'USTMtNT
RBGULAR MBSTTNO- J\ME 3. 2004
P Ava 3 OF 4
VOTE:
BOARDMEMBERCASMAN: AYE
CHAIRMAN WATERS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER FAIRCHILD: AYE
BOARD MEMBER DILLER.: AYE
MOTION CARlUED.
IV. REGULAR AGENDA
RtGQLAR
Community Deyelopmeut Department
A. Request For A Variance By Dauie) Finch From Section 20.103. or The City
Code Of Ordinances, To Encroach 4 Feet (4') Into The 15 Foot (15') Rear Building
Setback To Replace An Existing Screened Porch Or Florida Room At The Rear Of
The House..
This 'Agenda Item' has been pulled by the City Attorney, Anthony Garg.anese.
v~ FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
No discussion.
VI. REPORTS
In other business, discussion ensue~ regarding the status of previous Agenda Items.
Ms. Sahlstrom informed the Board Members that the next Audio Conference Training,
cLand Use, Planning, and Environmental Law' will be Wednesday, June 23~ 2004 from
. 4:00 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. in the Commission Chambers.
Board Member Diller announced that he does not wish to be reappointed to the Board of
Adjustment.
c;j)
DRAFT
t)tJ\.....
C'CJh J':'t:' Jf:lI""
~~
t!I,.. -.
t!.;..;:!<'::;;~
'''''-'''-):4
H'''-'V
~-::~...:~
It '~:''fJ,j;J)
.,i_J~'.~;
(~~r..-:t
~I~'u~
~~
r....-.."1~\
~!"~ .,-c.l
~'''-oo.r.
~....:.:V
.. SI2I'd ~J.Ol
VII. ADJOURNMENT
Chainnan Waters asked, "Do I have a Motion to Adjourn?"
~ em OF wlNttR. S PR/NOS
DRAFT UNAPPROVED MINUTES
BOAIU> 0' ADIVSTMtl"lT
FJ:GUI..AR MBETING.. JUNE l. 2004
P^OE40F4
"SO MOVED." MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER DILLER. SECONDED.
DISCUSSION. WITH CONSENSUS OF THE BOAllD TIlE MOTION WAS
APPROVED.
MOTION CARRIED.
Chairman Waters adjourned the Meeting at approximately 7:3.6 p.m.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMiTTED BY,.
JOAN L. BROWN
DEPUTY CITY CLERK
APPROVED:
THOMAS WATERS. CHAIRMAN
BOARD OF ADruSTMENT
NOTE: Th* MinllleS wm: approved ,t the
. ~OO4 9011" or Mjumnm\ Regular Ml:etinS'
DRAfT
<::t~ '..1
.C) I:> )::'c- J Cl~
en"'IT~ 1'- ,,....,,,,"" ',-1 I I""'"
~~
I:'" ...... :-"!i
H..I~":;'
~,-:::.:..':lll\
(;~~;.~
G.",,~'.~
l"-"'ljI.....
~~--4
....::~,
~'Q..lenlI
r;J~
r.-::::.:~
ul'!'Jr-..;...a
IB-~
~
TOTAL P.elS
ATtACHMENT D
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - JUNE 28, 2004
PAGE 16 OF 30
PUBLIC HEARINGS
408. Community Development Department
Presents To The City Commission A Request For A Conditional Use To Allow
Multiple Family Dwellings In The C-l (Neighborhood Commercial) Zoning District,
Pursuant To Section 20-234. Of The Zoning Chapter Of The City Code Of
Ordinances.
Mr. John Baker, AICP, Senior Planner, Community Development Department presented
his opening remarks.
Commissioner Blake said "Point of Order" - and spoke of the role of CPH Engineers,
Inc, in relation to this Agenda Item,
Tape 2/Side A
Discussion.
Mayor Bush opened the "Public Input" portion of the Agenda Item.
No one spoke.
Mayor Bush closed the "Public Input" portion of the Agenda Item.
Mr. Javier E. Omana, Vice President of Land Planning Operations, CPH Engineers, Inc"
1117 East Robinson Street, Orlando, Florida: addressed the City Commission and stated
that regarding "A potential conflict of interest - is something that has been studied by our
firm by the Board of Directors of our firm and I believe has been adequately handled.
We wouldn't have taken on this, Commission - had that particular issue not been
clarified. As it stands right now, CPH Engineers, Inc, will not - be part of any review on
behalf ofthe City on this particular job, whatsoever."
Commissioner McGinnis inquired, "What is the price range of these townhouses?" Mr.
Omana stated, "My understanding from Morrison Homes is the townhouses will range
from one hundred and fifty (150) to two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000.00) - a unit,
not a building."
Deputy Mayor Miller stated, "You have very short driveways it looks like."
Furthermore, Deputy Mayor Miller added, "It appears from your - depiction of what the
places are going to look like, that some of them are going to be two (2) car garages, and
some are going to be one (1) car garages?" Mr. Omana responded, "Correct." Deputy
Mayor Miller pointed out that "I am not happy with the number of units that are crammed
in here. If it is a twenty foot (20') driveway, we are going to have this debate again."
Furthermore, Deputy Mayor Miller added, "There is no parking for visitors and I think
your units are - too close to the road."
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - JUNE 28, 2004
PAGE I70F30
Manager McLemore stated, "I think the comment is fair to put you on notice - I think
you are on notice that this is an issue." Mr. Omana said, "Very much so." Mr. Romano
added, "These issues that you have intimated were clearly pronounced by Staff and we
have taken notes; we know the Code very well, we need to accommodate those things to
Staffs satisfaction and also to your satisfaction, before the Site Plan is approved."
Discussion.
Attorney Garganese suggested to the City Commission, "If you are going to approve
Multi-Family, you should set a density that you are comfortable with; that you think is
compatible and in harmony with the area."
Mr. Omana stated, "The ninety-nine (99) units may not be reachable because we still
have to go through the Water Management District permitting and the Army Corps of
Engineers," Commissioner David W. McLeod said, "Looking at this elevation, it appears
that - [State Road] 434, you really are not showing us an elevation of what it may look
like from [State Road] 434. You really are showing us an interior elevation."
Commissioner McLeod suggested, "I think the limitations that perhaps this Commission
should put on this is that the maximum would be the 6,6 units per acre, based on what
you presented to us this evening, as your layout and with regards to the Wetlands,"
Discussion ensued on elevations, wetlands, and Gateway standards.
Commissioner McGinnis said, "I am comfortable with the density as it is right now." Mr.
Omana stated, "The entire Board and Staff will have, when we come through - and the
Site Plan approval process will have architectural elevations, full landscape plans - for
your review."
Deputy Mayor Miller noted, "I am not comfortable with the number of units,"
Furthermore, Deputy Mayor Miller stated, "I would be willing to approve this
Conditional Use for this type of development if it were one-third less than that."
Commissioner McLeod said, "I think the acreage - 6.6 units per acre that you have
requested is reasonable." Discussion.
"I WILL MAKE A MOTION TO POSTPONE THIS PUBLIC HEARING ITEM
UNTIL THE SECOND MEETING IN JULY 2004 - WHICH IS JULY THE 26TH,
2004." MOTION BY COMMISSIONER BLAKE. SECONDED BY DEPUTY
MAYOR MILLER. DISCUSSION.
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
CITY COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING - JUNE 28, 2004
PAGE 18 OF 30
VOTE:
COMMISSIONER McGINNIS: AYE
COMMISSIONER BLAKE: AYE
COMMISSIONER GILMORE: AYE
COMMISSIONER McLEOD: AYE
DEPUTY MAYOR MILLER: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
Mayor Bush stated, "I would make the recommendation to Staff that Applicants should
know how the Commission feels about this and not let the people come in and have to go
through this - I think: you should do a better job of informing the Applicants."
Commissioner McLeod added, "I don't think: the Commission can be pre-read on the
issues. "
PUBLIC HEARINGS
409. Not Used.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
410. Not Used.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
411. Office Of The City Attorney And Office Of The City Manager
Request That The City Commission Approve On First Reading Ordinance 2004-31
Which Shall Amend Chapter 6 Of The City Code, Relating To Minimum Setback
Requirements For Principal Buildings Located On Property Zoned Planned Unit
Developments.
Commissioner McGinnis left the dais at 8:56 p,m,
"MOTION TO READ BY 'TITLE' ONLY." MOTION BY DEPUTY MAYOR
MILLER. SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER McLEOD DISCUSSION.
VOTE:
COMMISSIONER BLAKE: AYE
DEPUTY MAYOR MILLER: AYE
COMMISSIONER McLEOD: AYE
COMMISSIONER GILMORE: AYE
Commissioner McGinnis returned to the dais at 8:57 p,m,
COMMISSIONER McGINNIS: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
~
--\
,
)>
--\
~
l~
~~
.~~L
\)~~
\~\
~~
~~
-:-\~
::i
-(
t=:e:vHTAIHTRee:.
~l~
~~~. :];
· 1~~\
~")> \"t
:\fi~~
~ ~~
~~~~
&~ ~ "jj
~ -\~
..
. .
~~~.
-;:..'
FYi:
7~
~~
l\~
-
~~.'
~s:
~~ w
'- ~
-
~
.
~zg
+ i:
~ ~::z
.- c:: ~
,~ =i\~-
~ ~)> ~
! ~~
~
~
~
\\\
~-r
~
~
=
~.d
~
tJ')
ft>
rLl
=
=
e
~
~
~
r-l'
a.
r/)
..... .
ft
~
~
II
.-.
~
\0
\0
>
o
~
S
.......
ff
(ij
II
\0
.po.
C
8.
M-
CIl
"
/p r WAU.--- fl-v'J"-S
-~/~~~; ~
d!..r.:;>r' ~ -( + ~. ~
--- '.d'f-J<> ~ " C
~~~~~~ ~~ ~
~.Y ~. ,:z. ~
\ '-.... ')0 \\ ~ ~
~~.f )~ ~
~I~~. ~ ~
~. -\
~~ d'~~~l~
~~ :J. \.~..
~\ '\
i ~'~
:z.
~
.t
~~
~
o
8
CIl
(IJ
tJ
~
~.
II
0'1
tv
~
C
~.
M-
(IJ
--
~
-~
\ll
-
~
Z
.
I
.
.~~
~
~
.... .
o
~
r
~
g
~
o'
II
v)
~
~
{:)t:J
C> ~
! ~
'~ 0
~~
~ e
~
<. (t)
(t> a
~~
~ ~
~~
v; ~
.... ~
tI'l ~
'~
_~ -e ~ ~
~~t:f-::z
~~~~
~
\
to .
tfJ ..-j
git
ftEP
p,..::::
(Ii 0
.2 ~.
E. (JQ
~ ......
p.CIl
S"f\'
MQ
g"o
CIJ~
~~
~ .....
WCll
~g
(6 0
g.Hi
< f;L
~ ~
......<
o CiI
So
Cb]
g(ll
o g
~
::L~
~ ~
.~ ~
S'CIl
(JQ"Cj
p.B
&;'<:
ci ......
;:l. p..
Q ~
ftP-.
<:
~
~
C6
0'
~
~
~
I
~
-
~
w
~
s:
,
I
..
~.1
, ,," ,
~~
I~
~ 0 v; J
p' ~ a
Q
(J) t-1 ~
~ tp
:;0 r::.
~ ~ CIl ........
v) ~ ~ p..
~ ~ 0-' S'
rc ~ (JQ
~ -. ::r:
..... ~
p.. ~ ~ (ll
.... .
CIi (JQ
0 CIi ~
~ ~ s
~ C) tI)
cT ~ ~
~ V;' ~
(J.)
1-1 .p,.
0
<
tt>
~
.-. ....... tv w .~
0 0 Va Va N
~ ~ :::1 ~ 0
~ =
. 5'
irQ
~
....
~
f"t.
~
~.
(:l
~
...... ...... .p,. ,.w ~
Vl 0 0 Va 6
~ ~ ~ ~ <
.... .
~
tt>
~
~
~
.
:S
~
tP'?
~(J
~'1)
~i'
~'.'..~.L).
l:
f1 .
~\
\
~~
.
~
~
~\
.
-t
.
--i
"i
.
~;
(/)
o
tJ
I
;:z;~
~c:
.~]
~
~
~
\
>~
1
)>
,~
.t>.
~
~
~
~
~
Pt2
R2
r
~~~
-x
Z,f:>.
t-,)~0
~e~
OS':c/?
:Ug5C/?
00-
(1)00
(1)-00
(I)(/)'2
r-o
00;;rJ
-oOm
mZ-l
om
. c/?
5
I
~
~
~
~
I
~
~ ~ "3i~
t ~ ~
~~
3 ~_
~ :4:
~ ~~
~ ~~
~
z;;~
f~~
fl'
. : 1
;:)
1 ,.~
\-1
~-'.'~
(~
v'"
ill
ri
~, ...J. Z
p" "0
tD*~sarr1
::;0 -. 0 (f)
rrl (f) rrl ".
~Q ::J~
^ r :::):-
o rrlr
(I) fT1 0 ^
;:d ~ "7l (f)
~~ :u~
G}-lOx
~Vl Ei-l
. 0 ::-l
0):-0
"U --< Z
(f) 00
- Z
OJ 0 I
::;0 Z r
f1l (f) 0
;p. ;;j-l
^ c~
C/) 0:;0
;d ::l f11
fil ~):-
Z (f)
G') OJ-l
:r -<0
c/) :r! ffl
:r:rrl
> (/)2
F -(f)
OJ iTi ~
f1l OF
> ~a
:!! ~
fTJ>
50
a
?J
+
~
-
7l
~
W
N
~
~
~
~
-4
'"
~
o
:7J
o
en
C/)
en
r
o
-u
m
L
I
~
So: I
2 tI) 02
~ ;j en
e m 0 r
~ 2 r= ....
(/) GlO :
i!:im ~
~ O~ ~
t: Oil Z }>
N to) -l tI)
t9 gg '1J
tI) "0 Z ~
C~g Cj
OJ lie _
G) g 0
(:! 0
.... o.-J 0
o 0 Z
rn )> 0
" ~;.u
OJ 0 m
< O-l
-...l ;;:: m
$ '"D ~
:;0 lJ
m m
c/? C/)
Cf) I
<: ==
m -
~."
-0
~O
~-l
g~
~"U
_m
~~
--oC
-:;0
CIJ
90
G'>
~
m
AJ
I
I
.
J
:za
~R
~~
~
~
~
~
f
I..
c:
r.'...
"'-;;-.\\
f-,)
",
c..':.~
c=.)
~"~'"q{
-.
. ,
~ ;
~., ~
':"~ ...
c:: ~.
~.
(J
t')
7~
~~
~
m
~
\
"~,,
~J}
1
\Y
I
\\
~
-4
;:
:z:
'3
\
~
~~ ~~
jl ~~
~\:
~
t\
.. ~
-~
~
t1
~
~
--
~.
-...
N
~
~
-
~
~
~~
~~
\ 71' >!,"~';;-.
"..\ .... .'~.~ ,::.:.
" ,,' '~~~l:\
.; .. '.,J
~..
~- ... .':. ."'.,\. ....... .' ."'.:..;<~.. ...~.'.~:.,~,.1)
, · "\ jJ'
\, :~':'~<~-.'-"'."~"....
., .~ ".1'-
~, \:., , ,'.
;:tz~'; -,\.
.........c...>':-'./
~7;"\ ",.\
~~ ~,'~.,
~ ~\ ..' ... .t~;\\
~ c~~:)
-J\~
~\~<'~.i.',....~~:.' .....":J,~??
'.\:, ~-
"J \ \ ,,'
, '. ~,..,.:."
'~~
--t.<<r
_ ~ tl"A^"'c",.,.."""p
r~~-"",'''.-:'7
1~.'.\ -:::7L.... ,.fL......
~ ~,"
-,?I'G.:..'..'... . '.\.
~~' .'~
'\ ..\
~\A . /
. "',.,:, ,.,
~f :;'~v'
~ . ... .,......:~.' ~...~" '.'t\\.
'\'- ~.~ ~\
L~ '''j
~
.4 ~ __..
j
;
.........' :
1-:
I
'1
,)
.j
. :.1
~j
'1
~:~
,1
,'.j. -
':.,j
'.
:'1
" '~
~
~
~1
:.1
-j
.J
.J
I
;
01
J
.1
:;\ '
~
II!8G"
~
J
:1
::1
I
y.
,;
J
j )
'j ,
,:\
-'1 .
'l j
j
f~ 1
': 11 1
~ "
V j
t.t
tl
'.:~..1
~ I
~~
:i
i,j
:\
,
i I
~
~
~
\j
t
f
~ ~
~~
~!
~
!
]
j
i
+
~
-t
~
~
1\
,
\
I
,
-!J
~A~i??
~Nl? ,
,
='
~
I
TI
-rAAI V
J
I
I
,