HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006 02 27 Reports McGinnis Housing Crisis
Date: February 27,2006
The following Article was provided by
Commissioner McGinnis on February 27, 2006
during "Reports".
Orlando
Sentinel
FOUNDED 1876
KATHLEEN M. WALTZ
Publisher and President
News
CHARWTTE H.
HALL
Editor
and Senior Vice President
Opinion
JANE E.
HEALY
Editorial Page Editor
and Vice President
MANNING PYNN Public Editor
Housing crisis
Our position: Florida isn't even using the
tools at hand for affordable housing.
Between 2001 and 2004, the
average salary in the Or-
lando area went up 3 per-
cent. The cost of housing
increased 41 percent. In 2005, the
gap widened even further when
housing costs escalated faster than
almost any other area of the nation.
Meanwhile, this area has been the
nation's condominium-conversion
capital. About 20,000 apartments
this year have been converted to
pricey condos.
All this translates into an afford-
able-housing crisis, which has seri-
ous implications for Central Flori-
da's service-based economy. Solving
this crisis requires new approaches
by state and local governments.
Florida actually had a head start
addressing the need for affordable
housing in 1992 when lawmakers
approved the William E. Sadowski
Affordable Housing Act. That law
created a trust fund that gets its
money from a small tax on real-es-
tate documentary-stamp fees. Mon-
ey in that fund is used to help build
affordable housing - single-family
homes and apartments - through-
out Florida. The money is matched
with private, federal and local dol-
lars. Apartments built with that
money must be affordable for 50
years. Families of four who make
120 percent or less of the area's me-
dian income are eligible for the sub-
sidies.
The problem is that the Legisla-
ture has gotten fickle. Though the
documentary-stamp tax last year
raised $692 million for the fund, law-
makers limited to $193 million the
money that could go toward the sub-
sidized housing. The money over
that cap has been raided over the
years for other needs, such as
schools and the environment. This
year $250 million is going to help
Floridians who lost their homes dur-
ing hurricanes.
Those needs are important, but
this fund wasn't created to serve as a
grab bag or a disaster fund It's need-
ed to address ongoing affordable-
housing needs.
It's important for lawmakers to
remove the spending cap and ensure
that every dime of the fund is spent
on affordable housing.
Another egregious failure is thatf
local government's comprehensive
growth plans are supposed to ad-
dress affordable housing but don't.
That law says "the public and pri-
vate sectors shall increase the af-
fordability and availability of hous-
ing for low-income and moderate-in-
come persons."
Yet the plans submitted by local
government are filled with bureau-
cratic mumbo jumbo, or simply list
the affordable housing that exists in
the community. They aren't worth
more than the paper they are printe~
on.
What's needed is a law with teeth.
It needs to set specific goals for af-
fordable housing. And then local
government needs to make develop-
ers live up to those goals by either in-
cluding affordable housing in proj-
ects or paying toward a fund that
could provide such housing else:)
where. ·
Tackling this issue is critical to
Florida. Having a good economy
shouldn't mean hardships.