HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001 02 26 Regular C Torcaso Park Expansion Master Plan Study
, .';;..t--.
,
COMMISSION AGENDA
ITEM[ C
CONSENT
INFORMATIONAL
PUBLIC HEARING
REGULAR X
2/26/2001
Meeting
MGR. It--- /DEPT C-5J?
Authorization
REQUEST:: The Parks and Recreation Department is requesting the City Commission approval
of Concept F of the Torcaso Park Expansion Master Plan Study for the application
of a Community Development Block Grant and authorize the City Manager to apply
for this grant on behalf of the City of Winter Springs.
PURPOSE: The purpose of this item is to apply for potential "CDBG" Grant Funds in the amount
of $ 485,080 for Torcaso Park expansion.
CONSIDERATIONS:
. On June 28, 1999, the City Commission directed staff to consider the area around the Police
Station for recreational uses.
. On January 10, 2000, the City Commission discussed the property and possible sports fields and
recreational activities and referred it to a Parks and Recreation Workshop.
. On Mar(;h 20, 2000, a Recreation Workshop was held and the Commission consensus was to
bring back the information and budgetary amount to explore the wetlands.
. On May 22, 2000, the City Commission approved $ 5,000.00 for Environmental Services, Inc.
to do a wetland study and present a report containing estimated costs to mitigate the wetlands.
. On Sept1ember 25,2000, the City Commission directed staff to look into the development, for
recreational uses, the south 3.4 acres of a parcel adjacent to the Police Station (wetlands #4 area).
. On Novl~mber 27,2000, the City Commission approved $ 1,530 for SRI to do a Torcaso Park
Expansion, Master Plan Study. This information is necessary for a CDBG Grant Application.
,
,.
..~.
. The recommendation of Concept "F" is a combination of balancing the general needs of the
surrounding community with a reasonable project budget and providing a significant
improvement to the park without extensive long term operation and maintenance costs.
. Concept F included parking 60 cars, full size soccer/football field, splash pool 8 features,
mitigation, sidewalk, cleaning, fill, walkway lighting, landscaping irrigation, environmental
design and permitting, AlE design and permitting, and project contingency for a total of
$ 485,080.
. Staff is in the process of completing a neighborhood survey and all the required grant exhibits
to meet the March 2, 200 I grant deadline.
FUNDING:
N/A
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff is recommending that the City Commission approve Concept F of the Torcaso Park
expansion master plan study, for the application of a Community Development Block Grant
and authorize the City Manager to apply for the grant on behalf of the City of Winter Springs.
IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE:
. Application deadline, March 2, 200 I
. Staff review, April, 200 I
. Published recommendation list, May 200 I
. Public comments, June, 2001
. County Commission Approval, July, 2001
. Funding available, October, 2001
A TT ACHM[ENTS:
Attachment A
SRI, Torcaso Park Expansion, Master Plan Study.
Attachment B
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program. Consolidated Plan
Development Process, Project submission sheet.
COMMISSION ACTION:
2
:<;:.
Attachment 'A
.
SrI
15 Feb 01
. Chuck Pula, Director
Park and Recrc::ation Oepartment,
City of Winter Springs .
1000 EastSR.434 ' ...
Winter Springs, Florida 32?08
. .
Re: Parks Improvement Project
Torca~o Park Expansion:
Chuck
We have completed the Master Plan. Study for the above referencedpf?ject and have attached a copy of the
,final drafl for your review.' . . .
I'le~se let us know',ifyou wo~ld like us to proceed any further with this project and / or if you need any'
additional iriformation 0 clarifications. '
~ards
~,
Pr sident
.'
~l .
Starmer RanaJdi Planning and Architecture Inc. AA-002984' ,
890 Nqrthem Way Suite E-I Winter Springs, Rorida 32708 Phone 407 977 .] 080 Fax 407 9771019
info@sllarch.com
;. .
City of Winter Sprin~
Torcaso Park Expansion
Master Plan Study
Draft Submittal
15 Feb 01
Prepared By
.
sri
:, ~
City of Winter Sorine:s
Torcaso Park Expansion
Master Plan Study Draft Submittal 15 Feb 01
Table of Contents
1. Executive Summary
2. Concept Drawings
a. Master plan concept a
b. Master plan concept b
c. Master plan concept c
d. Master plan concept d
e. Master plan concept e
f. Master plan recommendation
3. Opinion of Construction Value
.
SrI
-: ;
Purpose:
Methodology:
City of Winter Sprines
Torcaso Park Expansion
Master Plan Study Draft submittal 15 Feb 01
Executive Summary
This study was commissioned by the city of Winter Springs to investigate expanding the site to
provide additional amenities. The site's expansion would take place to the north, on to the Police
department property and requires mitigation of approximately ,82 acres of low quality wetlands.
Although there is considerably more land available on this Police Department site it was
determined by a previous wetland mitigation study that impacting these wetlands beyond wetland
no. 4 in the southeast corner of the site would be impractical from both an environmental and
financial perspective.
This study was undertaken by a professional design team consisting of a registered architect with
the finn of Starmer Ranaldi Planning and Architecture Inc (sri) as well as consultation with an
environmentalist from Environmental Services Inc. (ESI), and Mr. Pula, director of parks and
recreational services for the City.
This team visited to the site and came up with a list of possible amenities to be provided on the
site. The list of possible amenities that were discussed, are as follows:
1. multi-purpose sport field for soccer, football, and general team play
2. ball fields for baseball or soft ball
3. a splash pool (zero depth pool on a concrete slab with various play features such as
umbrella fountain, arch fountain, interactive foot fountain, riding spray toys, etc)
4. a competitive pool (a "L" shaped pool with one leg being a 25 yd, 6 lane competitive
swim pool and the other leg being a shallower training, teaching, general swimming
area)
5. a multi-purpose pool combining the 25yd, 6 lane competitive pool area with a break
out area at mid length of the 25 yd pool which fans out to a zero depth pool and
includes pay features similar to the splash pool noted above)
6. off street parking
7. basket ball courts
8. tennis courts
Summary:
Conclusion:
The resulting submittal herein contains both the traditional scope validation report showing each
of the identified improvement items, their associate opinion of construction value, and whether
they conform to "immediate needs" or not, as well as a "modernization vs demolition" analysis.
The optional concept design solutions, shown herein range in price from $ 485,000 to $ 1,010,180,
and from a few amenities to several amenities.
The concepts "a" and "b" were quickly abandoned because the parking area and driveway through
the site creates an unnecessary vehicular / pedestrian conflict. Concepts "c", "d", and "e" began to
crowd the site and came with a price tag that was felt to be too excessive for the project.
The resulting recommendation of concept "f' was a combination of balancing the general needs of
the surrounding community with a reasonable project budget, and providing a significant
improvement to the park without extensive long tenn operation and maintenance costs.
.
SrI
Torcaso Park Expansion
J ~ ~" '06'MOO
II
1l
LECIEII)
cp COMPETITIVE POOL
... &1'U6>' I"OOl.
mp I"\JL Tl-~ M"t-A5tJ I COMP POOt..
bb BASl<ETB.6l.I.
lid ......L "'AMON!>
cP COVERfO PAvtLK:N
df 01tI~~ POI.HT AN
fp Fl51-l1WO PIER
III ~Tlor.l IC:.1OfK
pe f'.A~JNG
rp """'"
rr RE5'f'R1:)Q"'$
.t 5OCCE!It I FOO~LL FIELD
vb \IOU.S:Y eAU..
tI raT LOr PLATG~
" YOUT'" LOT FUT~
NORTf.l FLAMINUO
MOSS
MASTER PLAN
~Qp.~ept a
NORH-l
{)
NTS
.
srI
I:; Fe\::> "'I
~
rp
rp
':l
-A
^
[
Pi
MOSS
Torcaso Park Expansion
J ~ '""'" '='M~
l~
1~
NORT~ FLAMINGO
Police Statio
MOSS
MASTER PLAN
~Q~sept b
NORTI-l
{)
NTS
LE8EIG
cp COl'1F'ETlTlVE POOL
ep .......... POC<.
mp r'U..:TI-~ ~~ I CO'1P POOl..
bb """"'TeALl.
bel BALL DIAl1CNO
cp CQ~REP PAvlLlCN
elf ORlltoK.Jt..t:i FC:lHTAIN
fp Fl~INC. PIER
III ~T'JO.l KIOSK
,. PAl'OONG
rp POID
rr RES~
.f !lOCCEpit I FOOTeAl.L FlELO
vb vouey &ALL
II TOT L.OT PLAYu~
JI .,..~ LOT I"'LAT~
.
srI
I!:> Peb (l)f
I
I
rp
^"
.;=2 - -. ;
J-=l
~---
--~
MOSS
Torcaso Park Expansion
J \ ,~,,~~
l~
1~
NORTI-I FLAMINUO
cP 1\\
Police StatloU
MOOe,
MASTER PLAN
~~!J~ept c
NORTH
{)
NT5
LEGEIIII
cp CGr'F'eTlTlYE POOl..
ap 91"LAO" FOG\.
rnp f'lA. TI.pJy;:poee SPLA~ I CO'1P p::tOOL
bb~
bel BALL. DIAMOND
CP CO'\o'E!if:ED PAYfL)ON
elf DRlNKIl-O FOlHfAIN
fp Fl~ PI!R
Ik ~AnOI'lI<106lC.
p. P.A!IOK.~
rp """"
rr f;E51"ROC1M5
.f 50CCER I FOOrel4lL FIeLD
vb VOLLEy eA1.1.
II TOT LOT F'LATG!'iIOlNO
" T~ l..OT P\..,AT{,RC'U.CI
.
sri I
I:;Fel::> ~I :
=--
@
I
I
rp
'"
.
IO-?S ROA/J
@
MOSS
Torcaso Park Expansion
J ~ ~~" ,=,~
II
II
NORTI-l FLAMINUO
d I
Police Statio
MOSS
MASTER PLAN
~~~~ept d
NORTI-l
{)
NT5
-
~GEJID
cp COMF'ETlT1vE POOl.
ap !f'I.A"'''''''L
mp MUlTI.~ ~ I CG:MP POOL.
bb """"""''''-L
bel BAL.\.. Ol~
cp CO\IEICC PAvu..~
elf DRIt<<lNG FOUNTAIN
fp Fl....., ,.,...
Ik N'OIO'1Ane>< I<IClO'<
pII I'A"""'"
rp """"
rr ""~""""'"
.t !O::CER I POOTe.Al.L Flao
wit vOW&l' I!loAL1.
II TOT l..OT ~AT~
WI TOJTIJ l-OT PLA-rOROJNO
I
. I
srI'
\:0 Fe!:> 01
I
I
bd 1
rp
~ .~-
- ....
.
40'
MOSS
Torcaso Park Expansion
J \ "'~" "'''~
l~
1l
NORTf.l FLAMINGO
Police Statio
MO!;!;
MASTER PLAN
~Q~~ept e
NORTH
{)
NT5
_.. 11111111 I
LEGEIG
cp COI"'F'ETITIVE POOL
ep ~A~ POOl-
rnp M.l. TI-RJlIii:PCl!E ~~ f CO"lP POOl.
bb",,~
bel ......c t>IAMaI<D
cp CO'IE~ P~VIUCN
df ""'OK'" PCU<T At<
fp F1'''''..''...E''
III tNFOR"1A TION KIOSK
pa p""",,,,,
rp PCND
rr ~f"RO(;;MS
at !CCCER I FOOTeALL FIELD
vb vou..ey e.ALL
te TENNI$ COJRr
.
sri
15> Feb ~I
". ~ - - ~ (~ ,
till]
rp
MOSS
Torcaso Park Expansion
J ~ '""'",=rn~
l~
1~
NOF1TI-I FLAMINGO
Fire St n 0
~
MASTER PLAN
~Qn~ept f
c=P 1\\
Police StatloU
MOSS
NORTi-l
{)
NTS
LEGSD
CIl COt'F'ETIT1YE POOl..
'P 'PLA'" f"""..
mp ru..TI-~ ffl.A5tolICa1P FOOL
lib BASl<ETB<>U.
bd ""'-L DIAMOND
cp ~REO PAvrLICN
ctt DRlt-KfNCi Fa.NTAIN
fp ,"".., PIE"
III I~AnONl(.lClI&K
pa PAI'KIN6
rp ~
rr RE&TROOI"'1&
.f 5OCCER: I FOOTe.AU.. FJEl.D
YII VOL.LET ~ALt.
te TENNIS CC\JRT
tt TOT LOT F'LA YGIltOltNO
.
sri
I:' Fe!:> ""
I
'l/
@
@
rp
..,
..
.
"
MOSS
~,
Torcaso Park Expansion 15-Feb-01
Opinion of Construction Value
Improvement Item Cost concept a conceptb conceptc conceptd concepte concept f
parking (40 cars) $ 60,000.00 $ 60,000.00 $ 60,000.00
parking (60 cars) $ 90,000.00 $ 90,000.00 $ 90,000.00 $ 90,000.00 $ 90,000.00
200' baseball field $ 65,000.00 $ 65,000.00 $ 130,000.00
150' baseball field $ 58,000.00 $ 58,000.00
full size soccer I football field $ 55,000.00 $ 55,000.00 $ 55,000.00 $ 55,000.00 $ 55,000.00
splash pool (8 features) $ 175,000.00 $ 175,000.00 $ 175,000.00 $ 175,000.00 $ 175,000.00
competitive pool $ 280,000.00 $ 280,000.00 $ 280,000.00 $ 280,000.00 $ 280,000.00
combined camp I splash pool $ 450,000.00 $ 450,000:00
basket ball court $ 35,000.00 $ 70,000.00
tennis court $ 35,000.00 $ 70,000.00
mitigation wetland 4 (.82 acre) $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00 $ 35,000.00
pool equip structure comp pool $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00
sidewalk $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00
clearing $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00
fill $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00
walkway lightin $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00
landscaping $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 10,000.00
irrigation $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00 $ 8,000.00
subtotal $ 686,000.00 $ 754,000.00 $ 716,000.00 $ 616,000.00 $ 851,000.00 $ 406,000.00
environmental design and permitting $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00
ale desian and permitting $ 0.08 $ 54,880.00 $ 60,320.00 $ 57,280.00 $ 49,280.00 $ 68,080.00 $ 32,480.00
project contingency $ 0.10 $ 68,600.00 $ 75,400.00 $ 71,600.00 $ 61,600.00 $ 85,100.00 $ 40,600.00
total $ 815,480.00 $ 895,720.00 $ 850,880.00 $ 732,880.00 Ih'} Ji II Ii N' II fJ If H if $ 485,080.00
. .
Attachment B
S E :vI I N 0 LEe 0 C ~ T Y
CON SOL I D ATE D P LAN D EVE LOP i\l E NT
PROCESS
PROJECT SUBMISSION SHEET
N:L\-fE OF PROJECT:
CONTACT PERSON:
Torcaso Park Expansion
Chuck Pula, Parks and Recreation Director
TELEPHONE NUMBER:
(407) 327-4761
N~\.."{E OF APPUCANT:
City of Winter Springs
ADDRESS OF APPUCA1'iTS: 1126 East State Road 434
Winter Springs, FL 32708
LOCATION OF PROJECT (city, neighborhood, community, census tract, etc.)
(Art::lLch Map]
104 North Moss Road
Ba:;ed upon the criteria for which Seminole County is seeking funding requests
(published in the Orlando Sentinel and the Seminok He::::tld on Januaz::; 28,20(1) in what
:lre:l of housing asslsonce, C:lplt:U impro\-emencs, (public facilities & improvements),
~erg~c:; shelter housing J.::>sist3.!lce or homeless prevention lSSlst::L.1Ce does your
actl\-ity qualify?
Infrastructure/Capital Improvements (Neighborhood Parks & Recreation
Improvements).
Wao will administer and implement the activity?
City of Winter Springs/Parks and Recreation
Number of people to benefit from the project: Estimated until survey completed.
NUMBER TO BE SERVED
Total 300 per day
Low/Moderate Income 250 per day
% Low/Moderate served 83%
\ \PD_CSB\SYS\OLD_DP _ VOL1\CP\CD\SEW\PROJ ECTS\CO:-.;SPL....:-J\CPO l-O:!\.\PE'fORfU:'-iDI:-iGO l-01.DOC 10
PROGRAM DESCRIPTION
1. Descripcinn of Project (how gnnr ti.lllJs ",vill be used) (:\ct:tch .\ddicinn:tl Sheets it' nec~ssa.r;:):
Grant funds will be used for the construction of a practice football/
soccer/multi-use field, water playground, and parking lot as part of the
Torcaso Park expansion.
.,
Does [his 1c8':i(y prcsend:: C:xlS[:
If Yes, \,\'here:
NO
3. J uscific1cioa:
End:: \vhy is this project needed:
This project is needed to provide the low/moderate income City Residents
in thp RrPR. a needed field area in which to play instead of the street,
a cool down water playground. and a paved parking area.
-+. How will your gO:llS, performance and success is measured if you are awarded CDBG,
HOME or ESG funds?
It will be measured by the positive response of the neighborhood low/moderate
income families. The residents in the area nave expressed a need for these
improvements and will be surveyed again as to its usage, comments, and
suggestions.
\ \PD_CSB\SYS\OLD_DP _ VOL::\CP\CD\~EW\PROJECTS\CONSPL.\N\CPO I-O::\.\PPFORFt;:-iDINGO I.02.DOC 11
i=
PROGRA~I BUDGET
1. PROPOSED PROGRA.i"r COSTS: All construction related activity requests
must contain the information requested in items <1, b <lnd c below. _~"':S0, ~c~
O;l.-.)'~ 1..3. i rems :;,~ & =.~,
-"
(J) Tot::tl proposed Design/Engin-:ering CO:;t;; :5 79,080
(b) Tot::tl proposed Construction Com
:5
406,000
(c) Tot::tl proposed Oper:ltion:ll Com
s
40,600
(d) Tot::tl requested CDSe Funding
s
485,080
2. ADDITIONAL FUNDING
\Vh:1t ocher sources or- funds h:n-e bee~ sought ror chis projecr :l!1d \vh:lt :l!'e che
SOtus of those requests? Other sources of funds will be used in the project for
len:rnging purposes or "matching" requiremeotS.
Please be aware that other sources of funding awarded and! or available to a
J2Q!ential subrecipient will have a positive impact in the funding decision
(award) process.
Funding Source St:ltus of Request
City of Winter Springs (Bonds) The city expended $ 332,135 to improve
Torcaso Park in FY 99/00 and 00/01.
Name of Authorized Agency Representative:
Ronald W. McLemore, City Manager
Signatur.:--3f Authorized Agency Representative:
/ '
/-rt~,/,j?~/ 4/;"2??-~ ~
. V ./
3-:;-0/
\ \PO_CS8\SYS\OLO_OP _ VOL2\CP\CO\:-JEW\PROJECTS\CONSPL.\:-.I\CPO 1-02\.\PPFORFl:NOINGO 1-02.00C 12