HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009 09 15 Public Hearings 502.5 WSRL-1, WSRL-2, WSRL-3, WSRL-4, WSRL-5, WSRL-6, WSRL-7, WSRL-8, WSRL-9 Date: September 15, 2009
The following presentation was shown to the Code
Enforcement Board during Public Hearing 502.5 by
Captain Glenn Tolleson on September 15, 2009:
Evidence
WSRL -1:
Code Enforcement Bureau
City of Winter Springs Code Enforcement Board
Case Number 1220900003297
Benjamin Griffin
101 Privado CT., Winter Springs, FL. 32708
Section 12 -83 Adherence to Red Light Traffic
Control Signal
Hearing Request by Respondent July 14, 2009
Captain Tolleson
Code Enforcement Bureau
Section 12 -83 Adherence to Red Light Traffic Control Signal A motor
vehicle traffic facing a traffic control signal's steady red light indication shall
stop before entering the crosswalk on the near side of an intersection or, if
none, than before entering the intersection and shall remain standing until
a green indication is shown on the traffic control; provided, however, the
driver of a motor vehicle which is stopped at a clearly marked stop line, or
if none, at the point nearest the intersecting roadway where the driver has
a view of approaching traffic on the intersection roadway before entering
the intersection in obedience of a steady red traffic control signal, may
make a right turn (unless such turn is otherwise prohibited by posted sign
or other traffic control device), but shall yield right -of -way to pedestrians and
other traffic proceeding as directed by the traffic control signal at the
intersection.
Code Enforcement Bureau
Section 12 -89 Appeal To Code Enforcement Board
(C) The following shall be permissible grounds for an appeal;
1. At the time of the infraction, the vehicle was not under the care, custody, or control of
the owner or an individual with owner's consent, established pursuant to affidavit as
provided in Section 11.
2. The motor vehicle driver was issued a citation by a law enforcement officer, which was
separate and distinct from the citation issued under this section, for violating the steady
red traffic control signal;
3. The motor vehicle driver was required to violate the steady red traffic control sigal in
order to comply with other governing laws;
4. The motor vehicle driver was required to violate the steady red traffic control signal in
order to reasonably protect the property or persons of another;
5. The steady red traffic control signal was inoperable or malfunctioning; or
6. Any other reason the code enforcement board deems appropriate.
Code Enforcement Bureau
On June 26, 2009 at 9:15 AM, at the intersection of the East Bound lane 2 SR
434 and Winding Hollow Blvd., a Blue Jaguar, Florida Registration N64 OJD
passed through the intersection on a steady red light, captured by video
recording traffic control equipment and was in violation of Section 12 -83.
On June 30, 2009, the violations recorded images were reviewed by Captain
Glenn Tolleson, a sworn Police Officer with the City of Winter Springs and found
that probably cause did exist to issue a notice of infraction. That infraction was
issued on July 1, 2009 to the registered owner Benjamin Griffin.
On July 14, 2009 1 received Mr. Griffin's request for hearing and on July 21,
2009 American Traffic Solutions received Mr. Griffin's request to contest the
infraction and a hearing to the Code Enforcement Board as prescribed in
Section 12 -89 of the City Code. Additionally, the system requires and schedules
an administrative review of all evidence and the infraction which was set for July
29, 2009.
On July 29, 2009 the administrative review was conducted by Captain Glenn
Tolleson of all the evidence and recorded images and upon re- review probably
cause did exist and hearing set for September 15, 2009.
C I ty c f Wlmor Springs
RrrJ I irjIaCmhlw.i: Fr l ri nl x rrr
PQ Box 55995
Phoenix, AZ 860TS -9995
ME M
BENJAMIN GRIFFIN
1411 PrUVAE)C GT
WYlNTM SPRINGS. FL 22r768 2801
NOTICE r 1224900
P IN A 2221
LlaR' and Pay1uith y VIca o M=Qmard�.
wwr.V hlatl onlr'o. aorr
Amount D-uc: s 1215.410
n— rhwlr =,77)d2n A
1+;.�• u>Im yrl Ir vlaa rr Mmpm mm ar uwY Vmrrtrrllrlm uy% nr w6i }n Ir .n.'Irfir .n.r Tn YP�' ina•'.tiun lrlc rn Irnn ai R1P.YLTPrR naur&
NAME: BIENJAMINU'NIFFIN DUE: 11f j
i
lF4TICEff- 7lasa[ssXsJ:ltrr VERSION: ISSUED: ufJUl,1L?
PLR 1 1=7 ND40 J 1i l A l l=: FL 7TFE:
Make your ohco-k o-rmancy ordcrpayahlr No poirr�-- a =vo s rat
xill lk ad for thisNotiac of Inirao-h
hm m a f Ir y 1sT Nllnfar %p r Ind
4 6O NOT VAIL CAC11.
-J VHnta tha Na-acv an tha tNntat yrour paymant.
Inaerl lhi5 t--3 ccupcn in the enckmed
onvaopa Lv-h :ha itltlnosr: 1m'ttha rlgrdj chowng
LI rwrAr IhW rri R:GTM.
Vau rnust rar}+xle LYIh r= lhar i paymarrt or a
hP.7rI rPrll .—,i hp*) P lhP nl IP r7;w„a
Uly 01 W ntor �;prinq
RFo-d I irght C'.;ir e.ra Fnfnrcer k-nt
Rn Fhnx 749
CinunnaLi, OH 1527x1 -2803
IJu lhlr11111111 r11 l lr 1 1 1 1 1 1 rr 111/11/11 rr l 11111111
AMOUNT DUE. 112:x_00
1 122 ❑91111003297 ❑DOOD3472221 225 ❑❑6
PIN I
05Rfi'7IU'r
M. 10 AN
G63R -L3LQ VAIM NIDI1 OLLOW OLVD
Yl net rn lM2>$
197 TJ4/LG LT
x.rcti
u Y lriKe
r!ai.
Yl Al mrDW h l4 M! WOh4:G 0- .4 Ud £h rr h lrRClhr.i lr lun 1. l rMW 11 dill I I F
Ih Yr_VIrimG r
crr��a��ugexme�r tinv
oavRaoa
un hG JtY911M �hRlltV F n F J1
rrnnx 4 CGLJlYl M'G 1lR:LVY.7 MtL]
Yr_L5'� M ri I n J1 kt� FY�G IYFY4� 1 r[]N PHl l4 Li Y IL 1'tnol I Y
nr a or ILQe4
u hVIrd0lnl
NOTICE r 1224900
P IN A 2221
LlaR' and Pay1uith y VIca o M=Qmard�.
wwr.V hlatl onlr'o. aorr
Amount D-uc: s 1215.410
n— rhwlr =,77)d2n A
1+;.�• u>Im yrl Ir vlaa rr Mmpm mm ar uwY Vmrrtrrllrlm uy% nr w6i }n Ir .n.'Irfir .n.r Tn YP�' ina•'.tiun lrlc rn Irnn ai R1P.YLTPrR naur&
NAME: BIENJAMINU'NIFFIN DUE: 11f j
i
lF4TICEff- 7lasa[ssXsJ:ltrr VERSION: ISSUED: ufJUl,1L?
PLR 1 1=7 ND40 J 1i l A l l=: FL 7TFE:
Make your ohco-k o-rmancy ordcrpayahlr No poirr�-- a =vo s rat
xill lk ad for thisNotiac of Inirao-h
hm m a f Ir y 1sT Nllnfar %p r Ind
4 6O NOT VAIL CAC11.
-J VHnta tha Na-acv an tha tNntat yrour paymant.
Inaerl lhi5 t--3 ccupcn in the enckmed
onvaopa Lv-h :ha itltlnosr: 1m'ttha rlgrdj chowng
LI rwrAr IhW rri R:GTM.
Vau rnust rar}+xle LYIh r= lhar i paymarrt or a
hP.7rI rPrll .—,i hp*) P lhP nl IP r7;w„a
Uly 01 W ntor �;prinq
RFo-d I irght C'.;ir e.ra Fnfnrcer k-nt
Rn Fhnx 749
CinunnaLi, OH 1527x1 -2803
IJu lhlr11111111 r11 l lr 1 1 1 1 1 1 rr 111/11/11 rr l 11111111
AMOUNT DUE. 112:x_00
1 122 ❑91111003297 ❑DOOD3472221 225 ❑❑6
I'ur nR t. r_Jrdrnan C 1VL1L1 -�O/ appmvtd by Winker v- n-R-' {:rkY
ar d ma{o-r .thialf i liable to-r pYrr.ant o-+ i vrl
prnwlt'/ nT Iii n M th. rhl'J
me rrrd. Infi, Iniav�r<r -ilrn .y,n4,prrk wl,H r,Hn+r nrwphlr_ irv.l'tl r_ atinh-r-I mnrtl,nrJnn �YtMm wht nr #F,t m +r.Tr_
ao-rrkral rr9nal +or M1 tl, ak wH.c li i dirackran o-F trsti al irnd-kn9 abradY red appal. Lk Haa bean dr Mrminaal r aR Your vah..M H.at prat aadad It, an
Intr r.ar. #Inn I,y trrhrdnfl 71,r ti. wlk n ih� +wrr r .ldr< ni InM r�trflnn ,.rhrn t1,r #rwifl r. awrirN r t1,t t7lrr r_Nnn k, whlrh Vnrrr vrhl Jt
ir ,vrv11n0, wr, rvmldln� _v clrnr7 rrd r:IUntil .1 yr.ir vrrm mnlrin4 _v rIOH+ hnnnl #io-_ Y fnllwrl r M nnmr 7n n mnlrvM #hr nlr_nrFy -k1 ni-np Ilnry
ur d riurr� wry p.tv�.rL ul Ll- purl rru.r 1 Lhu a Lur I� W i uaLlway v F,u V Ii d a ri w wl aIu",wa'An ,y 1r 11 u urr Ihw_ .L.� s 11,
Failu L... Pau Llr,_- r
kr�n L rr 1.1 Uu� l3..l.- will r v,dl a I..Lu Ill— r� u Ll .,I -1 Y_
11 }waw 4u _11. kart Y Lhrr -vrl u lariirlRy r wyu rsR a Ii r...W L- Aw.I LI.. irti u 16 Lr1 llir Llur r JrLar, .L wrll L" isl.rrrsi..rrJ drr yJnnr�..l.r ul
IHrhlllty .-H wn nrdrr v br fn #rrtrt r;i+.ln. #Yryi r wn wm+,rrni rrp rrr th' mwxlmr.rr. r.I_II RFnwlty, pl.-a. nor wdminl. #rar #1w
Mo po-rn {a wrll b• m aria rd agarnai Yo.a for Rhrr vil pin :I {y., Your +.,I-- {o rr. po-nd mart U It rn col It tram pray.aEinp ba m.Rip.Rrd
n n., n yell ♦nr ti,, r`nfnrnnm t ni r,.rnh r,rnamv hV.1 1 _tin#Inn In rl-rr n hIm n1 Nrvht
f INr I'AYMrNT- Th. Pm-14 w 1 1+ ara.kr .n PW yrrrr Ilntlr I. H, F7 11 1-.. wnr
,n m vrr+.v VInIwFlnnlnM r.nm l 1 n ,vlrh Y .r N-1- P J rl MIN N rrwn W .h In im-
m hnr nn i► frnnf rd rhl' 1- r nk rhr S't arnvrvnlrnnr R+r
YP.YMI =N I LSY YHC Nll=_ C-r 11 Wll Irrr ',.UU y.rri. I. lh.rr c r I
M"HT 1 MA IN hAwll 'it rhMr rr nntrr {p InL. +hr Tlhd M Vifl..trr 3. frrlrwl In rlv _k -1 rnwL -,IV h rh, rarryrn r,rIn rl #hr I:— A F.
r rrd. ul Ur ti r-L_. VU r"' ZAIL L'A'SH_ Lda .0 W I L L. N-U- A. {raved rwrr.a.J urr llr. Iy wl yuvr Ya Yr-i ar.L
CNT IM rCRSbN= You m.Y PaY In p.non by th..k nmy ordrr r CiV Iloll. 1128 C. ^u+' Rd_, 0434. WI.-r 2prlr,,7., rL 32746 ar Mrd- �Prl.p. route
LFrYrrla riwl L '3 UU N. Mu FWdJ. Wii law bpr nyr_ t YLIVILL Mu Jay Ih1 wrk�lr Fl r'JaY larlwr.r G.US} y_i r_ Errs 'UU N.rrr. C�J
YILW YU ULt IMai V LY ANL] 4fIVLS]- I---L ul LI,
Ih rao-rd.d maps aaH •ad.o o-1 yo-ur violakro-n will bt rubmrkbFi a�,dr.ct !h. {:ode Ln#orcrmanl U rrrr �o-n prc<r adr.p io-r
Jrjla �-w4urr ul llx .wrLakv... Yuu ruY Yuur r,r.yuv unJ vwhv aanliiiu ul w.Yi ul.J rurr lrrlv.aiuri. Yuv will wl yaaaa NvLiva- .1 .rrrJ Y1N Il yrrnlvwl Ilru
rr I- Inr:ldr ihr mri h- If yrnri rin h.,�ry Intrrr.r•i nrdu+ Yrc n y -I- yn r vlrlrn nnrl 1_�D nr ,hr wl nhrr T,�wln pnllnr r]re.,nnrrvni, .,i'a�i Naar" R ,A, Wlni.+r
SNrirrlp FL 827ffB
T Irr7r ARl TWf} WAYS YrO TI IIS Ylf}I ATIMFQ
17 Yfsr1 mwY ,hr< I-r -Lhlnn M rFr J'fll pd•rv. hlr tillln lnfl wnrl mar �.fi ,hr rd� ,n Fri lrmr on ff- r-_ Appr•wrnnrr kr-ft rh, r- I. r nr rd Yn ur
r.q vitrt rtna.1 b. rrad trrior. 1,. L7u. L7.M .Lkrd an 1,t }rant of Y1.. rioh'- Upon ry rrpt. k"ou Yell W r_tr`id p+ 1,i d.ka. krma d as akro-n at Y• r Galt LntaaarmarrL
H irrw. Ir yuu uru ruurr. IiaLly aft u hlu,r rr 11 ur rwil Lu r* PUUi aL ruvl Iruu�irry. .,rl �JIriirri�L Ulirr, fuu ur 62G., will J„a J ku ,r u„� L,vlr.,lky .,l �,uurrl�
[mi) 11 11- Ua'r s ul Yuur uu rLt L ul Yti d1.111u.LYt aRlLn wm Uiri A 611. U.Ly W %Y..Lt:r 2f N1..lr L)r Jrri.awau_ yw iay l iipul: rUlwlar.L ral Mril F9L k11I Ly
nnri .,nh �u rn llnrilnfl rimllmrvntm lnn r Yrx lr rr itlrl a.lc nM ni rlr rrinn fln nl�tk,n will hr n „Ar'wl�rt nnr7 ualn n dw kr '1111- r r71 �1rrF _lI re ihF. ,&r Lr llnn rr h-bilkM rd :ln
adrnrmrtralrw ht..ay�. You ,w 11 b. _o- .d in wnt"R o-t .nor shop to k-.
-11 1 IN
Yeti rnaY arownlo-ay a.r, A+hd.vd a a
i Mo-n �Sr.Fonr✓b rl rkY k www.Vral. aficnlrfia.00-m. Y- -11 yro ur Mo-4 or M .nd M. `71-d on +h. irons rrt U,r. r.obcr tlo- do,w.lo-.d iha
15;JwiL_ 1 1Vrwl,.ri! A 1, r-- p+LA �:y� w�rJ_ Lyi.uJ. and ruiI.L. mM .all +Y7ww V•V Ju uuriLrrl,.l:u.. W ■.0 CiLf ur SrL rZ Epr:.r WUI.aLiuir Pra --4..y C-01-- PO
nn,r SAR.LS, rhr,rrar_ AJ R�rf _A M nr.ra n_ rv. -tivM Mr,hr ai iF rlwhr nn .hF tnr,trf M,r Fl -AInF
QUESTIONS. I r yw iiW y yuusai n. piva w i Ia L Su iu'r Lvll ri LU ,.L 1 8M 784 4111 Fern. 6_06 AM G.ElCPU EST_
IF Y1.-tU Ah{t A Mt =M1AL �AhL t+_}WI_PNY W Yuur IrLWr IL1 111llrnry Ifiw Uri— dlu,Li w 1h Err wpW uL 1U r Nulty W Him hfrulwl. rl.,��rrrw �.ill.i. Y{} UU, aHL
LS_
P h.. -Z. A7 ]Lr)7n nirwwf
6a: Lawli I—u ur lJ 1cLu. r1 Ll LiulLr m pui Liu.l u u ru-4 u 1 f .ui ralrl.ir,i�L. uliv udjudiu lli hlcawiull
1 uLrrrnL Il1rs• lurin .ryu..R lu r 1lwrru iy wrja d.lr5,, Ih1rr r -dater ul Ir.11y Ywn. riiai rukartawlwJyr 1
Lh.rl .L ur1 Lnr rJ Ley 111r Llur LJalr ul II— w -rlaur
lar valid ruyw��l_ I ulldcr W id LIwL 1 1 .--L ,dl_r1J D. h.u.r. my in pusjaln_ I ul u. iUur Lu U n-t I wil14u 1,wmriud .ar LI1u LIuLc. Lhu wr1J Iul Li ur iF,u
pl. 1 -_6. 1.1....... 1.111.,1, i.l.
r Ifln�rl-
Frr 11 rL Nr .w.
CITY OF S+AER 5F Ci&
RFf1 f IfiHT f'.A M FNF f:FMF NT
11213 E 5{aLe RUJiJ
MrterSgring5, rL3270D
dEC:L ARATIONPAFFIdAVIT
Lk UFFWII(NU iLL-9= 1120 297 c-a W cIoid.ed: 7MU2009 tO= 56 :4.d4M
�a .i riaer� v.r. .�.r r iir�� .w;e.� .-n d.r�vY i.i� @,a.i ,A.o..
rr J�c�Yaarr�a nnin7 r2Cmnn n Pi AM Fes.. l ..r t
w u.rs�.l r�aa rwr eu al w, ti# n+r 4 a u�•�s�M a�ss�r.`w
r +i•WrF+rw.•M a it sr•�+
rw w n F�� w .vy �w
N•m R F3.R r.......� ..�Z r �•4 N-+ .....y...�
r•• ar r r...� r
,.r. r .r .a... r
Maa �v n a .0 rr �M`M �•.•w
vwv wsrrw� sr
Yw -M1N r•-n wr s •t.. •n.t
....r'+s .�a .ter r.. y +�....y
YYIi•rNY }iiYUNlu.�+'a�7 YTUYnW4
4�YTgYF Rr A wwrws -ww1 Iwsw l.1Rw ul�cV ltrw rwMw•II11 u! �l� 5alal I-
'�.l .M f Y4ril #..F r{r w•.er r••• �}.s �s a. r. w.� r-.� 4++, a.
r.lmww� rvw
�Y Jrw�asi rWw 1.� Fsa awaam. w ry+rs aa..+wwr
w.� •wr�.m wo�crfs��r� w� w'�a
Jy
rr J�c�Yaarr�a nnin7 r2Cmnn n Pi AM Fes.. l ..r t
`r
rN
hh7
tG
U�
.1a ham andrehmthep� porGana��regLe :l lore eei,un �FU� heari
Kv
r}PR.CrI,W�y"rn! Miii hYrn as a reuesi f�Ta r e n r�pinIhaN� a� fnfrSr_haT U F ,O
�L r ul�dcrblaM Ihar rnta3e allentl 6hls hnerrgl in p9ryon. I also undcr�{arb Ihek f NiU pp a s� wn
CPeArta P,IlnM tlen anE brine name ovine pfyltrw LI+4hlnl�
$r_hsdu9ed HOTln9
SP 15 M
17�- 4�l�JSSl�i�
JILL 8 209 IIfF
2 -11v
0
v
z
t
71
N
N
O
CD
0
CD
0
CD
N
CD
a
w
W
0
R
Q
N
W
A]
0
a
i
C7r
V
9
O
M
0
r
z
m n
V
M
r
G7
1 i Q
T
m
i r
57
m
CD m z
zztn
g
I[
N
CD r
y
m
M Z
n 0
M
3
m
z
1
City cf Winter Spri ngs
Red Ligh: Camera Enforcement
126 E. Slats Rani, 9434
Winter Springs, F_ 32. -2715
DATE: 0711712009
PLATE: FL N6-f0JD
BEWAMIN GRIFFIN
161 PP VAr --O CT
4VMTER SPRINGS, FL 3:74 &2891
Notice of InfraoWn 122090 €003297
PIN 2221
The hearing late bebTe the Wiinrber Springs Code Enforaemem Board for the ahoy=- rrEMioned vidalion has been
sdhedAed for.
Og r 1:�12009at 7:00 FM
Wirber Springs Code E nforcemenl Board
1129 E. State Roed, #434
Winlar 5prirgs, Florida 3�7O0r2715
If you chrose not to appear, }ou waive the rig to canfesk or aDpea this infraction and must pay ife ciril penally on ar
before the day of your riGieduled hearing. A persan wfiQ i5 fot ic 34 V after a hearing or who recueria a hearing and
thereafter fails to fppe3r a1 the time anJ place of the hearing, is lialie f€r 1he civil penalty plus admini3tratwe hearing axis
in the amoint cf Twenty Five Dollars 25.001.
If the Crass of yotr contest is one of the af9rrrative de�enses of ined in the Cite of ViirAer Springs -Ordiranca 2006 9
has been deiermired Thai the evidence you pr3vided is inconclusive. You roay bring adlitional evidence to your Hearing
and it will be examined by the HearinE O firer.
If you have any gjestions, please ontaGi Customer Service at I BM- 7PO4111, between its hours of 2:O9AM an€ 5:00PIJ
E5T.
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. Skate Road
Winter Springs, FL 32746
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint N Umber:
Docket Number;
DnCHinonr Niimher, 1220900003297
state Exhibit: 2
Aarsc�s'VF5 08/3Y20[}9 0:2IAM Page 2 c� 7
DATE TIME SPEED PHASE RTIME LANE FRAME
06/26/2009 09:15:25.2 AM 040 R 000.6 2 A
want -t+, 1--0 _A'4 A w rim rkTt- ur%T_T.r%W QT_ M
L
a�
r
-00F,
i0oor
7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RIEU LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E, State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
NN
Cumplaiut Number;
Docket Number;
❑oCUnient Number: 1220900003297
WSRL
State Exhibit: 3
a— T- DOJ3112ON &_2IAM Page 3 of 7
DATE TIME SPEED PHASE RTIME LANE FRAME
06/26/2009 09:15:25.9 ASS 040 R 001.4 2 B
01 -EB R -434 WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
r•
in 1 1
Bel.$
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RIEU LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E, State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
NN
Cumplaiut Number;
Docket Number;
❑oCUnient Number: 1220900003297
WSRL
State Exhibit: q
Jfscs�svPS DOJ3112ON &_2IAM Page A of 7
PHOTO OF LICENSE PLATE
Video Recording of Violation
IL
011
AP
323 Feet from
sign to Stop bar
0 6/ 2 5% 2 0 09 #PRKO�
r_ ITT" C} WI RIT ,J•'I.'I NO C'!--,
i+t LJ LI L:3HI t'jckfA tl+LA tr+IF LMIC: tMe 1 =M1
iy�r r Srar� 1'�nara•I
YYrr16wi 'tPW yr, rL •SlftJU
C a m er;i Ldoh4g RepR o-rt
R
Lao-cLrrrrrgt Y ?ri Pn CM M a 7r47
1 nr_� +I,vi
EB sR -Es'i co Vh'3NDjrJ-a HOLLOW BLVD
r,rf r) %r r r1 ra
ti I
EM $iulm W�lu Pu=rlutil
ri��•.I riymfrrr r�r„r+ iJ�aLll�uKJ 11 Z�_i.Ji7. ULIVtiM
1'Inlani r`n �2 $1204$ EY_1�_2Fs 1'5M
Umplaymaryt Lrd +tir�nr }r �S'1f7 I lnRn Ptii
1'ilx r�rNnn nl Tr tirti r'n��.-1
Upa.— cKm.L I aato I'.a ate
S:L+�Ir C=ulhl rfl WSRL 5
Name
Direction
L'hannel
yVe
Phase
Miri G1r1
Passaue
Max 1
Max 2
Yul C11
RL-d CIr
VValk
Pud CIF
Red PyIt
Add-wd Ir11I1ciI
Max Initial
Max3 Limit
Max3 Slrau
Timc B 4 R .Dduc
Carr IS 4 Rod uc
Time to Reduce
Rcduce By
Min Gap
Mi
n Ern
Pacnace
NIa x 'I
Max 2
Yel Gir
1Pri UIr
V%I;R I k
f'Prl C Ir
Ph�s�
Min :7
M ax L5'
d 40
.intt 40
Lock Call
Flash Cnt
I lash Lxi!
Dual Erl
Sim GAP
1 {P 9Pf Nl P_
cnt Phase
Sraminnin Cnunty Trefflc Endlnee rNnd Tl.minrj Shut Intersectldn, SR 4.94 MD. S3- Windlnn Hallnw #10021
tilt 4:14
Wind Hnll
tit{ 4-:i4
Wind Hnll
II'_
11111 {]d!! 111J [IL�[P
Magk
l55 JhS [7 SI
VI+L
CT
ST
CL
AT
NT
I lost
10.4G.101.1G7
Fort
1l
1
4
5
h
7
a
4
'10
1'1
14
'1,5
M
fjtw
11144 1
Gram 11 l
13114)
7
d
ti
IN
H
11
I
1
=OLPPED
4
1i
11
Ph Mnde
SIIM
Node#
1 C 1J
VEH
VEH
VEH
VEH
VEH
VEH
VEH
VEH
rDLP
DLP
ALP
PED
PIED
PEE
DaLe
1 &Jul -09
Dune By
udicksuri
4ssir
Ain
Nax 9
Nax 2
Yel ch
:Zed Cli
Nalk
3bd Ch
4bsi-
Ain Grl•
3 assaca
Nax 1
Aax 2
YcI Clr
fed Glr
Valk
��d Clr
PI K= OD1 10113
Assrnn
Snit (ell
14 -N -VV
Gond Senn
Alt Phaac Ort 1
=M===M==
lGS6},S
Uond Sew
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
Document I nformation:
Document Type: VIOLATION DATA REPORT
VeF751U11. V 1 -0
Issue Date: 71112DQ9 11:31 34AM
Appearance Date: 712712009 11:31:34AM
Photo Radar Van Operator:
Violation Informati -on:
Violation Date)Time:
612612009 9:15:25AM
Violation Location:
Ea 5RA34 g WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
WINTER SPRINGS, FL
Plate No-1 SUte
N640JD FL
Make 1 Model I Year.:
JAGLf 1 1994
Registered Owner:
BENJAMIN GRIFFIN
Name 1 Add ress
104 PRIVADO CT
WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 -2801
Driver.
Name 1 Add ress
WSRL
state Exhibit: 6
08131)2009 6:21AM page 1 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E_ State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32706
Violation Evidence Report
Complain[ Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
DELIVERED THE REQUEST TO CITY HALL.
IT SHOD LD BE NOTED THAT MR. GRIFFIN NEVER MENTIONED TO ME THAT HE HAD GALLED OR
VISITED OUR DEPARTMENT ON TAID PREVIOUS OCCASIONS OR THAT HE HAD OBTAINED A
COPY OF THE INSTRUCTION
MR. GIFFIN GALLED ME SHORTLY AFTER HE CAME INTO 7HE STATION. HE WANTEQTO MAKE
SURE THAT HIS L ICENSE WOU LD NOT GET SUSPENDED I F HE DID NOT PAY THE FEE. I TOLD
HIM NO HIS LICENSE WOULD NOT GET SUSPENDED_ I ASKED HIM IF HE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
TO THE CAPTAIN IN CHARGE CF THE RED LIGHT CAMERA SYSTEM AND HE SAID NOT AT THIS
TIME. HE WAS RUSHING TO GET TO WORK.
MR. GRIFFIN CAME INTO THE STATION TODAY ASKING ABOUT THE RED LIGHT CAMERA. HE
3AI0 HE I lAD A VIOLATION DUT DID NOT RECEIVEANYTI I ING IN TI IC MAIL. I IE ASKED ME
SEVERAL TIMES I F THIS WILL GO ONTO HIS RECORD, IF HE CAN GET ARRESTED FOR NOT
PAYING IT IF HE GETS POINTS ON IS RECORD, ETC.. I TOLD HIM IT DOES NOT GO ONTO HIS
DRIVING RECORD AND HE CAN NOT GET ARRESTED FOR NOT PAYING THE NOTICE. I TOLD HIM
IT IS A CODE VIOLATION AND IF HE DOES NOT PAY IT THEY WILL ADD LATE FEES AND IT WILL
EVENTUALLY GQ TO COLLECTIONS AND AFFECT HIS CREDIT. HE ASKED IF THERE WAS
ANYWAY TO FIGHT THE NOTICE. I TOLD HIM TOGO ONLINE AND VIEW THE VIDEOAND HE CAN
ELLC I I HL COUR I UPI ION WHICH WILL ALLOW HIM I O UISPU I t I HE NOI IL:E A I I HE COUL
BOARD. I PRINTED HIM OUTA COPY OF THE NOTICE WITH THE WEBSkTE AND TOLD HIM IS
OPTIONS TO PAY AND DISPUTE. HE SEEMED VERY CONCERNED WITH THE CONSEQUENCES
OF NOT PAYINC. HE WAS INQUISITIVE BUT POLITE.
KHOOPER 07107!2099 D6 52 =30 AM
KHOOP ER 0710712089 06 =41.10 AM
State Exhibit:
WSRL
7
lixsisvPS
08131120i Y9 6.21AM Page 7 of 7
CITY DF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. Stale Road
Winter Springs, FL 32748
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
NO PAYMENT WAS RECEIVED.
MR GRIFFIN CAME IN TODAY EXPRESSING FRUSTRATION WITH THE PROCESS HE STATED THAT
THE IWEBSITE WAS CONFUSING AND THAT VVE DID NOT PROVIDE HIM WITH CLEAR
INSTRUCTIONS ON WHAT HIS OPTIONS WERE NOR DID WE PROPERLY INFORM HIM HOW TO
SUBMIT A REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE HF6ARING_ HE ADVISED HE WAS "OFFICIALLY
REQUESTING A HEARING BY HAND- DELIVERING IT.
HE THEN HANDED ME A COPY OF THE REVERSE PORTION OF THE ORIGINAL NOTICE, WHICH HE
HAD SIGNED. THIS DOCUMENT ALSO CONTAINED INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMITTING THE
REQUEST. HE REPEATED THAT WE GAVE H IM LITTLE OR NO INFORMATION ON HIS OPTIONS OR
HOW TO SUBMIT H€S REQUEST FOR A REVIEW AND THERE WERE OTHER THINGS ABOUT THE
PROCESS THAT HE THOUGHT MISLEADING AND CONFUSING_ ALTHOUGH HE DID NOT
ELABORATE ON THESE. I ASKED HIM IF HE WAS ABLE TO REVIEW THE PICTURES AND VIDEO
AND HE REPLIED, "OF COURSE I DID."
I SHOWED HIM THAT THE INFORMATION ON HOW TO SUBMIT HIS REQUEST WAS PRINTED ON
THE PAPERWORK RIGHT ABOVE WHERE HAD SIGNED IT; I.E. TO SIGN AND MAIL THE REQUEST
(WHICH IS PRINTED ON THE REVERSE OF THE PAYMENT COUPON) TO THE ADDRFSS ON THE
FRONT OF THE COUPON.
HE STATED THAT HE HAD JUST DELIVERED A COPY OF HIS REQUEST TO CITY HALL AND WAS
TOLD THERE THAT HE HAD TO DELIVER IT TO THE POLIO E DEPARTMENT AND NOW I WAS
GIVING HIM THE RUN- AROUND AND SENDIN-G HIM BACK 70 CITY HALL. I TOLD HIM I WAS NOT
SENDING HIM TO CFFY HALL BUT SIMPLY TRYING TO ANSWER HIS QUESTION BY SHOWING HIM
WHERE THE INSTRUCTIONS WERE. HE STATED THAT THE PROCESS WAS STACKED AGAINST
HIM AND HE DID NOT HAVE ENOUGH TIME TO MAIL THE REQUEST_ TOLD HIM THATALL I
COULD DO WAS TAKE HIS PAPERWORK AND FORWARD FT TO CPT TOLLESON. MR. GRIFFIN
THEN MADE A STATEMENT THAT WE WERE "ON NOTICE," AND REPEATED THAT HE HAD ALSO
RE
BWEST 07114f2009 09 :42 :54 AM
WSRL
State Exhibit: 8
Iaxsfav�s 48f31f2R09 6:2IAM Page 6 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RIED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E, State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Cumplaiut Number;
Docket Number:
DOCUment Number: 1220900003297
NOTES
Nate Added By Added Date
Hearing Request made FOR DOG U MEN T that already has A hearing scheduled_
Hearing Scheduled ON: 0911512009 AT 07:00 PM
Hearing Deleted SCHEDULED HEARING
ON JULY 16 1 AGAIN SPOKE WITH MR. GRIFFIN AND EXPLAINED THE PROCESS FOR THE
HEARINGS THAT WOULD TAKE PLACE AND THAT HE WILL RECEIVE A LETTER INFORMING HIM
OF THE OUTCOME OF THE ADMIN HEARING AND A CODE BOARD DATE IF NEEDED WOULD BE
SEPTEMBER 15TH.
I SPOKE WITH MR. GRIFFIN AT 13210 IN 7114109 AND EXPLAINED THAT I HAVE SET HIS
ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING FOR JULY 29TH. MR. GRIFFIN STATED HE HAS REVIEWED THE VIDEO
AND WANTS TO HAVE HIS OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD BEFORE THE BOARD_
Review Scheduled ON: 0712912009 AT 09:00 AM
JAxsis v
SY19TEM
07f2t12009 04 :53 :43 PM
MJHOPPER
0711712009 12: 59.34 PM
MJHOPPEFR
0711712009 12 :58 :55 PM
GTOLLESON
07117/2009 06:45:03 AM
GTOLLESON 0711412009 10.22.21 AM
GTOLLESON 0711412009 10:14:06 AM
WSRL
State Exhibit: 9
DOJ3112ON :2IAM Page 5 of 7
Date: September 15, 2009
The following documents were distributed by
Captain Glenn Tolleson during Public Hearings
New Cases Agenda Number 502.5 at the Code
Enforcement Board Meeting on September 15,
2009:
Evidence Exhibits:
WSRL -2
WSRL 3
WSRL 4
WSRL 5
WSRL 6
WSRL -7
WSRL 8
WSRL -9
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
DATE TIM/ SPEED PHASE RTIME LANE FRAME
C6/26/2009 09:15:25.2 AM 040 R 000.6 2 A
WS01 EB SR 434 WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
1.1°°17.V'
State Exhibit:
saxsi.mws 08/31/2009 6 :21AM Page 2 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
DATE TIME SPEED PHASE RTIME LANE FRAME
06/26/2C09 09:15:25.9 AM 040 R 001.4 2 B
WSO. -EB SR -434 WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
q
ag o f;
o A TP.*
s 3
State Exhibit:
AscsisvP 08/31/2009 6:21AM Page 3 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road Ilik
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
LI
1
E 1
f
g*
■sizA_ Li'
State Exhibit
sascsis 08/31/2009 6 21AM Page 4 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Camera Log Report
Document 1220900003297
Location: EB SR WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
Event Date I Time Status
Deployment Start 6/26/2009 12:00:00AM Operational Tests Passed
Violation 6/26/2009 9:15:25AM
Deployment End 6/26/2009 11:59:59PM Operational Tests Passed
Signs were Posted
CX1(/
\AL L
State Exhibit
A csis
08/31/2009 6:21 AM Page 1 of
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
Document Information: Violation Information:
Document Type: VIOLATION DATA REPORT Violation Date Time: 6/26/2009 9:15:25AM
Version: v 1.0 Violation Location: EB SR-434 WINDING HOLLOW BLVD
WINTER SPRINGS, FL
Issue Date: 7/1/2009 11:31:34AM Plate No./ State: N640JD FL
Appearance Date: 7/22/2009 11:31:34AM Make Model Year:: JAGU 1994
Registered Owner: BENJAMIN GRIFFIN
Name Address 101 PRIVADO CT
WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 -2801
Driver:
Name Address
Photo Radar Van Operator: ,4
1
■fise- C
State Exhibit:
am: s \IPS 08/31/2009 6:21AM Page 1 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
DELIVERED THE REQUEST TO CITY HALL.
IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT MR. GRIFFIN NEVER MENTIONED TO ME THAT HE HAD CALLED OR
VISITED OUR DEPARTMENT ON TWO PREVIOUS OCCASIONS OR THAT HE HAD OBTAINED A
COPY OF THE INSTRUCTION
MR. GIFFIN CALLED ME SHORTLY AFTER HE CAME INTO THE STATION. HE WANTED TO MAKE KHOOPER 07/07/2009 06:52:30 AM
SURE THAT HIS LICENSE WOULD NOT GET SUSPENDED IF HE DID NOT PAY THE FEE. I TOLD
HIM NO HIS LICENSE WOULD NOT GET SUSPENDED. I ASKED HIM IF HE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
TO THE CAPTAIN IN CHARGE OF THE RED LIGHT CAMERA SYSTEM AND HE SAID NOT AT THIS
TIME, HE WAS RUSHING TO GET TO WORK.
MR. GRIFFIN CAME INTO THE STATION TODAY ASKING ABOUT THE RED LIGHT CAMERA. HE KHOOPER 07/07/2009 06:41:10 AM
SAID HE HAD A VIOLATION BUT DID NOT RECEIVE ANYTHING IN THE MAIL. HE ASKED ME
SEVERAL TIMES IF THIS WILL GO ONTO HIS RECORD, IF HE CAN GET ARRESTED FOR NOT
PAYING IT, IF HE GETS POINTS ON IS RECORD, ETC.. I TOLD HIM IT DOES NOT GO ONTO HIS
DRIVING RECORD AND HE CAN NOT GET ARRESTED FOR NOT PAYING THE NOTICE. I TOLD HIM
IT IS A CODE VIOLATION AND IF HE DOES NOT PAY IT THEY WILL ADD LATE FEES AND IT WILL
EVENTUALLY GO TO COLLECTIONS AND AFFECT HIS CREDIT. HE ASKED IF THERE WAS
ANYWAY TO FIGHT THE NOTICE. I TOLD HIM TO GO ONLINE AND VIEW THE VIDEO AND HE CAN
ELECT THE COURT OPTION WHICH WILL ALLOW HIM TO DISPUTE THE NOTICE AT THE CODE
BOARD. I PRINTED HIM OUT A COPY OF THE NOTICE WITH THE WEBSITE AND TOLD HIM IS
OPTIONS TO PAY AND DISPUTE. HE SEEMED VERY CONCERNED WITH THE CONSEQUENCES
OF NOT PAYING. HE WAS INQUISITIVE BUT POLITE.
044%
vVsQ -i-
State Exhibit:
*acmis 08/31/2009 6:21AM Page 7 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
NO PAYMENT WAS RECEIVED. BWEST 07/14/2009 09:42 54 AM
MR GRIFFIN CAME IN TODAY EXPRESSING FRUSTRATION WITH THE PROCESS HE STATED THAT
THE WEBSITE WAS CONFUSING AND THAT WE DID NOT PROVIDE HIM WITH CLEAR
INSTRUCTIONS ON WHAT HIS OPTIONS WERE NOR DID WE PROPERLY INFORM HIM HOW TO
SUBMIT A REQUEST FOR AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING. HE ADVISED HE WAS "OFFICIALLY"
REQUESTING A HEARING BY HAND DELIVERING IT.
HE THEN HANDED ME A COPY OF THE REVERSE PORTION OF THE ORIGINAL NOTICE, WHICH HE
HAD SIGNED. THIS DOCUMENT ALSO CONTAINED INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMITTING THE
REQUEST. HE REPEATED THAT WE GAVE HIM LITTLE OR NO INFORMATION ON HIS OPTIONS OR
HOW TO SUBMIT HIS REQUEST FOR A REVIEW AND THERE WERE OTHER THINGS ABOUT THE
PROCESS THAT HE THOUGHT MISLEADING AND CONFUSING, ALTHOUGH HE DID NOT
ELABORATE ON THESE. I ASKED HIM IF HE WAS ABLE TO REVIEW THE PICTURES AND VIDEO
AND HE REPLIED, "OF COURSE I DID."
I SHOWED HIM THAT THE INFORMATION ON HOW TO SUBMIT HIS REQUEST WAS PRINTED ON
THE PAPERWORK RIGHT ABOVE WHERE HAD SIGNED IT; I.E. TO SIGN AND MAIL THE REQUEST
(WHICH IS PRINTED ON THE REVERSE OF THE PAYMENT COUPON) TO THE ADDRESS ON THE
FRONT OF THE COUPON.
HE STATED THAT HE HAD JUST DELIVERED A COPY OF HIS REQUEST TO CITY HALL AND WAS
TOLD THERE THAT HE HAD TO DELIVER IT TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND NOW I WAS
GIVING HIM THE RUN AROUND AND SENDING HIM BACK TO CITY HALL. I TOLD HIM I WAS NOT
SENDING HIM TO CITY HALL BUT SIMPLY TRYING TO ANSWER HIS QUESTION BY SHOWING HIM
WHERE THE INSTRUCTIONS WERE. HE STATED THAT THE PROCESS WAS STACKED AGAINST
HIM AND HE DID NOT HAVE ENOUGH TIME TO MAIL THE REQUEST. I TOLD HIM THAT ALL I
COULD DO WAS TAKE HIS PAPERWORK AND FORWARD IT TO CPT TOLLESON. MR. GRIFFIN
THEN MADE A STATEMENT THAT WE WERE ON NOTICE," AND REPEATED THAT HE HAD ALSO OiC L 3
State Exhibit
4ocsis 08/31/2009 6 Page 6 of 7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
RED LIGHT CAMERA ENFORCEMENT
1126 E. State Road
Winter Springs, FL 32708
Violation Evidence Report
Complaint Number:
Docket Number:
Document Number: 1220900003297
NOTES
Note Added By Added Date
Hearing Request made FOR DOCUMENT that already has A hearing scheduled. SYSTEM 07/21/2009 04:53:43 PM
Hearing Scheduled ON: 09/15/2009 AT 07:00 PM MJHOPPER 07/17/2009 12:59:34 PM
Hearing Deleted:SCHEDULED HEARING MJHOPPER 07/17/2009 12:58:55 PM
ON JULY 16 I AGAIN SPOKE WITH MR. GRIFFIN AND EXPLAINED THE PROCESS FOR THE GTOLLESON 07/17/2009 06:45:03 AM
HEARINGS THAT WOULD TAKE PLACE AND THAT HE WILL RECEIVE A LETTER INFORMING HIM
OF THE OUTCOME OF THE ADMIN HEARING AND A CODE BOARD DATE IF NEEDED WOULD BE
SEPTEMBER 15TH.
I SPOKE WITH MR. GRIFFIN AT 1321 ON 7/14/09 AND EXPLAINED THAT I HAVE SET HIS GTOLLESON 07/14/2009 10:22:21 AM
ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING FOR JULY 29TH. MR. GRIFFIN STATED HE HAS REVIEWED THE VIDEO
AND WANTS TO HAVE HIS OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD BEFORE THE BOARD.
Review Scheduled ON: 07/29/2009 AT 09:00 AM GTOLLESON 07/14/2009 10:14:06 AM
I
ArseL_
State Exhibit:
Ascsis 08/31/2009 6:21AM Page 5 of 7