HomeMy WebLinkAbout1993 05 18 Regular
...
----
CDIRMIT
AVIS
AUTERIA & COMP~ HA.
CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS
May 20, 1993
Board of Trustees
City of Winter Springs Pension Fund
1126 E. State Road 434
Winter Springs, Florida 32708
Dear Trustees:
Enclosed please find a brief analysis of the proposals that were presented for retirement
plan services.
."--
A separate analysis is submitted for asset management services and plan administration
services.
Please be aware that some of the information is slightly different than originally presented.
In order to present comparable information to the trustees, I contacted the five companies
to clarify their data.
Rates of return for Investment Management & Research, Inc. are not presented because Mr.
Talbot had not submitted adjusted information by the time I delivered this to the City
Manager.
Please do not hesitate to contact me with any questions.
Very truly yours,
McDIRMIT, DAVIS, LAUTERIA & COMPANY, P.A.
J9~ Dt.v~
Bob Davis, CPA
r-
612 E. COLONIAL DRIVE. SUITE 350. ORLANDO, FLORIDA 32803-4603. (407) 648-0713. FAX (407) 839-3975
PRIVATE COMPANIES PRACTICE SECflON . AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF CEKTIFIED PUBUC ACCOUNTANTS' FWRIDA INSTITUTE OF CERTIFIED PUBUC ACCOUNTANTS
..,
::J s:: ::J )> )> (') C/) r
< c < CIJ *::J 0 - 0
CD ::J ." m IDCD CIJ ...&.::J ::J m: 0
!!l- e5" X' .0 O)!!l- CD . C - ~
"'" - 01>> I>> C/)
3 -0' CD C 0) 3 CIJ o- S cr
CD 0) a. ~ ::J CD C Ps:: N' ::J
:J o :J ::J 00) ~. (1)
fit (') ...&. ...&.::J ...&. ...&.)> ...&. ...&.(1)- a.
0 (11 0 (11 0 (11 8::J -
0 ,<8 0.:D (1) :T
m" '< ,<0 '< '< '< .., I>>
'< '< '< )>CD .,HO (')
::J .., .., .., 3 .., .., .., 0 .., .., .., s::
- CD C 0- -CD ~.
CIJ ::J o ~ I>> ~3
)> - o ::J ::J CD
0 C CIJ I>> ::J
0 ::J r.:::::, <0 -
0 - 2 CD ."
C - CD 3 CD
::J ~ - CD CD
- ........ 0 ::J
~- - 0
- ." ::J
CD
CD
e
0"0" ~;f
1>>= Ci)
s::..... CIJ-
~ _.(1) ..,
C/)- 50 oCIJo. 0) i~
CD 5- ...&. ...&. ...&. ...&. ...&. ...&. ';!llg~ ::J 0
:"" ~ :"" 01 -
o -. e5" ." p 0 ~ ..... ~ !N .., ~i
C S. -0'0' i\) ...&. Ot ...&. i\) ..... ~. ~O".o~ s:: c:,.) I>>
~o. 01 (fl. ...&. (fl. 01 (fl. 0 ~ ::J
I>> ::::!. (fl. (fl. (fl. (fl. (fl. (fl. ;}.~ C a.
-'c ;s:o. o' 3:
CD 0) CD -.0) 0
CIJ- m'l>> ::J ..,::J;}. C !~
CIJ ;;;!.CD ..,
::J::l. -<
<0'< '<
r
Q: C/) ~~
3:(11 ...&. 0" CD 15
51\) ...&. I\) ...&. '" alJ:n~ 0
." co !=D ...&. ...&. .0 -. 0 ...&. ~r ~o
c o' ." P <0 '" ..... p1 ~ !N 01 CIJ::JO ..,
c:,.) ~ I I (11 or
::J -0'0' ...&. ...&. ex> I Cu Q: c I ~"T1
a. ...&. co I\) ...&. cP- I ex> 0) ~.o 8 I ..... ::J
CIJ I>> ::::!. (fl. (fl. cP- cP- cP- (fl. cP- ;}.CDC a. 3~
;s:o. o' 0 f;~
m'O) ::J CD ::J I>>
CIJ "'o.i ~~ G)~
..,
-< m:D
3:(1)
m"'C
s:: (') ~;;g
." o' o~ (') z
a: < :T ::JI>> "'CQ "'CG)
CD CD I\) ...&. ...&. 0) I>> ~ ffi 3 ~!J>
.., ex> ..... ~ ~
~ 0 ..... ...&. ~ 0) ex> S"O (1)f;
I Cu 0 I Ot ~ I Cu Co Q: o'~ "'C."
ID I (11 I I ~ 3 g. G) ~6
." I (fl. I 0 ..... I ...&. (fl. ~fr
CD cP- cP- cP- (fl. o' ~ "0
C I>> :;, a >::D
::J 0 ::J I>> 5'3
a. :T ~ < -. c: fi)~
CIJ CD ::J "C
" f!l.
"'U 0" :D
.., - 0) o'
0 C/)2 ClJO" :T
< _CD Ci)" == I>>
a: ~~ I>> CD ..,
CD ..... ;~~ a. ~ "'C
~." CD 0 co ex> ~ ..... ..... ~ ..... ~ N ~ 3:~
c 0- ~ 0 (11 c:,.) 0 c:,.) 0 Q: a. ~ .
_a. ..... ~ en I en ::J::J01 3
,lO::J - (11 0) co I co I>> 3
0) I 0) o' 0.38
0. ::!!o (fl. (fl. (fl. cP- cP- ::J "0
2CIJ (fl. cP- (fl. ::J 9,0 0 "0 0) etm
CD o .., ~ I>> a.
.., - 3~
~ -'1>> CIJ
o.::J
0" 0)0. o;;l ~
0 0 ::J'<
a: - c...
:T ~
cn-
CD ::J
09:
c S.
~o.
-.c
CD I>>
CIJ-
~
el-
CD
0_ p:l ~
~ .....
." (fl. (fl.
o
..,
a:
I>>
<- -
CDO m
:T CD 0)
o -'"0 <0
~~~'mCD :D
;}. 10.0)> 0
01 ~"O 5" 8 m a.
0"_. -< C <0 m. ffi
-. CIJ 0 I '<
o' ::J 0 ::J ~ 3: ~
::J I>> 0 -...... I>> I>>
0.3::Jo;a
~ 3 cs 0<5 0"
:J -. CIJ 00 CD 9-
om- 3
CD -.3 CD
o CD ::J
2.~ .e
o
..,
I>>
::J
a.
o
I~I
1.11
Ao -co
(5m
. 3
~
-
///
Fr.
'"
".........
,
"Tl -c
Q ~
3 a
01
~ mt
o x
-C :D
..., (1)
~ c-
O> ...,
..., :J
~ 00
<:5" :::;;
:J Z
(1)
(1)
a.
(1)
a.
I I I
I I I
I I I
r-
(;h (;h
I\) I\)
o 0
o 0
o 0
'"0"0
: (1) (1)
..., ...,
. , I
, , I
. . ,
--
,--.
"0 "0
~ ~
(1) (1)
(1) (1)
z
aO
::r=?
(1) -C
(') (1)
^~.
00 0
0>Q.;
:J (')
a.-c
o>~
:D3
(1) (1)
"O:J
o -
~~
-. r
:J c:
(03
o
(J)
c:
3
m
~o>
-. (')
:f::r
::r-c
o 0>
0.'<
_. (1)
:J (1)
(Om
m
g.
:J
(0
(;h
.....
9
o
o
(1)
0>
(')
::r
0>
:J
:J
c:
0>
-<
)>
a.
-c Q.; )> 0
m -c (1) !:!'. :J :J
~. 0 :J (1)
(1) (1) O:J c: I
S ~Q.;o> ~ 3"'
o' ::r (') m :D (1)
:J (1) -c ~ (1)
"Tl (') & '::! (') S-
o ^ I~ (1) 0 00
..., 3:J as'
3 (1) ~ ^
00 2. 00 (1) ~
S20 00" ~ o'
:J
~ 5'
, (0
~
-c
00-
(;h
.....
o
o
"0
(1)
...,
(;h
I\)
01
o
"0
0>
'<
(1)
(1)
(;h
01
o
(')-'
::r -,
(1) 00 0
(')_:J
^"O (1)
-,0) b.
OO~3
-'0' (1)
00 _.
00"0 -
c: 0> (1)
(1) :J (1)
a.-:e
::r
(1)
:J
I I
I I
I I
~(;h
:.... ~
ffi 9
o 0
o 0
(;h
9>
0')
.....
9
o
o
z
~
0'
(J)~
;c. (;h ~ :D
.... ...... s. (1)
..- 0 (') _
I\) 0 (1) ::;.
010- (1)
8 0 ~ ~
:J
-
-C
0>
:J
)>
a.
3
5'
00'
-
...,
~
0'
:J
z
o
-
0>
<
a!.
0>
0-
m
a
g~
:J CD
~-
~I
"0 CD
~;a
(J)
3:5
0>
~~
CD^
30
CD Q)
;a-g
~
o
-cGS
~~
00
-. Ci)
o ..,
:J 0
C
"'0
-c
3:'"
~~
QtCD
;a
-c
or
:J
z
g.
~,
0>
0-
(1)
-
I ~
BS20m
5.i'~
c...C1S;a
~~3:
m. i
P'l
-
-co
~~
)>0
c"'M
3:~
I~
~~
O:D
zz
-cCi)
:DC/)
o.
-c"Tl
05
~~
~~