Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance 2002-08 Chapter 5/Arbor ORDINANCE NO. 2002-08 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA AMENDING THE CODE OF ORDINANCES BY REPEALING THE EXISTING CHAPTER 5 ENTITLED ARBOR IN ITS ENTIRETY, AND ENACTING A NEW CHAPTER 5 ENTITLED TREE PROTECTION ORDINANCE; PROVIDING FOR APPLICABILITY; LEGISLATIVE INTENT AND PURPOSE; DEFINITIONS; PERMIT APPLICATION AND PROCEDURES; DESIGNA TION OF SPECIMEN OR HISTORIC TREES; TREE REPLACEMENT CRITERIA; PROHffiITIONS; EXCEPTIONS; TREE PROTECTION DURING DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION; WAIVERS AND APPEAL; REMEDIAL ACTION; PROVIDING FOR THE REPEAL OF PRIOR INCONSISTENT ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORA TION INTO THE CODE; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the City is granted the authority, under 2(b), Article VIII of the State Constitution, to exercise any power for municipal purposes, except when expressly prohibited by law; and WHEREAS, the Florida Constitution, Article II, Section 7 provides "It shall be the policy of the State to conserve and protect its natural resources and scenic beauty." WHEREAS, the City Commission is committed to preserving and enhancing green areas of the City and by assuring the preservation of existing trees on public and private property and taking steps to require maintenance of existing and the installation of new trees in the City; and WHEREAS, trees aid in energy conservation by cooling the atmosphere, reduce air pollution by removing particles such as dust and pollen, increase oxygen production, slow surface water run off, reduce soil erosion, provide food, nesting sites and protection for wildlife, enhance scenic beauty, and provide other environmental benefits; and WHEREAS, the City Staff has reviewed the current Arbor Ordinance and has advised this City Commission that the current Ordinance should be substantially revised in order to preserve and protect the citizens of the City of Winter Springs and to promote a more aesthetically and environmentally pleasing community; and City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 1 of 19 WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Winter Springs, Florida, hereby finds this ordinance to be in the best interests of the public health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Winter Springs. NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS HEREBY ORDAINS, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Repeal of Prior Chapter 5. The City of Winter Springs Code, Chapter 5, is hereby repealed in its entirety. A copy of Chapter 5 is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" for reference purposes to indicate the provisions hereby repealed. Section 2. New Chapter 5 Created. A new Chapter 5 of the City of Winter Springs Code is hereby created as follows: CHAPTER 5 - TREE PROTECTION AND PRESERVATION Sec. 5-1. Applicability . This ordinance shall be applicable to all land lying in the incorporated area of the City of Winter Springs. Florida. Sec. 5-2. Intent and Purpose. (a) Purpose. The purpose of this Chapter is to establish protective regulations for Trees within the City in order to maintain and protect the City Forest. to better control problems of flooding. soil conversation. air pollution and noise. and to make the City a healthier. more attractive and safer place in which to live. (b) Intent. The intent of this Chapter is to encourage the protection of the maximum number of Trees within the Primary Tree Protection Zone and of large Specimen Trees within the Secondary Tree Protection Zone. It is further the intent of this Chapter to encourage the protection of Trees native to Central Florida. To this end. it shall be unlawful to cut down. damage. poison. or in any other manner destroy or cause to be destroyed any Tree or other vegetation as covered by the provisions of this ordinance except in accordance with the provisions set forth herein. Notwithstanding. in case of emergencies involving natural disaster such as. but not limited to. flood. freeze or other natural disasters. the requirements of this ordinance may be temporarily waived by the City Commission by resolution. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 2 of 19 Sec. 5-3. Definitions. As used in this Chapter. the following terms shall have the meanings indicated unless the context clearly indicates otherwise: (a) Caliper. Measurement of Tree eight (8) inches from soil level. (b) City. The City of Winter Springs. Florida. (c) City Forest. The ag~regate of all street Trees and all park Trees. (d) Crown. The mass of branches. twigs and leaves at the top of a Tree. with particular reference to its shape. (e) DBH Diameter of trunk at breast height. (approximately four and one-half (4 ~) feet from the ground of a Tree base). (f) Desirable Trees. Trees particularly adaptive to Central Florida identified as "desirable trees" in Appendix B of this Chapter. as may be amended by the City Manager. (g) Dripline. The vertical line running through the outermost portion of the Tree Crown extending to the ground. (h) Encroachment. The protrusion into a vehicular accessway. pedestrian-way. or required landscape area. (i) Heavy Machinery. Mechanical Land Clearing. earth-moving. or earth-working equipment with a gross weight in excess of 5.000 pounds. For purposes of this ordinance. all machinery which utilizes steel tracks for traction shall be considered to be Heavy Machinery. regardless of wei~ht. (j) Historic Tree. A Tree which has been found by the City Commission to be of notable historic interest to the City based on its age. species. size. historic association or unique characteristics. (k) Land Clearing. The removal or grubbing. bv any means. of any type of vegetation from land. not including. however. activities governed by a Tree Removal permit. (l) Person. Any individuaL firm. corporation. partnership. ioint venture association. principal. trustee. municipal corporation. political subdivision. or special district. or any agent or representative thereof. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 3 of 19 (m) Preferred Plant List. Preferred Plant List shall mean the list of plant materials and corresponding Tree Replacement Credit shown in Appendix "c". which may be amended from time to time by the City Manager in writing. (n) Primary Tree Protection Zone. This shall mean the front. side and rear yard areas as established and required by the Land Development Code of the City as the same may. from time to time. be amended. (o) Protected Area. An area surrounding a protected. Historic. or Specimen Tree within which physical intrusion is prohibited in order to prevent damage to the Tree. roots and soil around the Tree base. the dimensions of which shall be established by the City and set forth in the Tree Removal permit. in according with Section 5-14. (p) Protective Barrier. Shall be a circle of one-inch to two-inch wide stakes spaced a maximum of eight (8) feet from each other at the perimeter of the Tree Protection Zone and which extend out of the ground at least eighteen (18) to twenty-four (24) inches. with the top two (2) to four (4) inches marked by flourescent orange paint or tape. (q} Replacement Trees. Replacement Trees shall at a minimum comply with the provisions of Subsection 5-9. (r} Secondary Tree Protection Zone. This shall mean all areas not included in the Primary Tree Protection Zone. Subdivision street rights-of-way and easements are also defined as being within the Secondary Tree Protection Zone. (s)Specimen Tree. A Tree. other than an undesirable tree. dead tree. or diseased tree. that is twenty (20) inches or more in diameter. (t) Stem. The main trunk of a plant: its primarv axis that develops buds and shoots instead of roots. (u) Topping. The severe cutting back oflimbs within the Tree's crown to prevent normal growth to such a degree so as to remove the normal canopy and disfigure the Tree. (v) Transplant. The act of relocating an existing Tree upon the same lot. (w) Tree. Self-supporting wood. perennial plants of species which have a trunk with a diameter of at least four (4) inches measured at Caliper and normally grow to an overall Crown height of a minimum of fifteen (15) feet. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 4 of 19 (x) Tree Protection Zone. Shall mean that area located around the perimeter of the Tree in which no activity such as clearing. filling. excavating. storage of materials. parking of vehicles. or any other activity that in the opinion of the Forester may damage the Tree may occur. This zone is calculated according to Appendix D to this Ordinance. (y) Tree Removal. Shall mean any act which will cause a Tree situated on real property to die within a period of two (2) years from the time of the act including. but not limited to. by cutting. girdling. relocating. interfering with the water supply. applying chemicals. regrading around the base of the Tree Trunk. (z) Tree Replacement Assessment. Tree Replacement Assessment shall mean the total amount of monetary compensation owed to the City of Winter Springs as provided in this Chapter for the replacement of trees cut destroyed. or removed as a result of development or redevelopment. (aa) Tree Replacement Credit. The Tree Replacement Credit shall be equal to one- hundred ($100.00) dollars and no cents in Tree replacement value. (bb) Tree Trunk. The main Stem of a Tree apart from limbs and roots. (cc) Undesirable Trees. All types of Trees identified as "undesirable trees" in Appendix A of this Chapter as amended from time to time by the City Manager in writing. Sec. 5-4. Permit Required for Tree Removal and Land Clearing: Separate Violations: Criteria (a) Permit Required. No Person shall engage in Tree Removal or engage in Land Clearing located within the City. without first obtaining a permit as provided in this Chapter. It shall be a separate violation of this Chapter for each Tree removed and each day a person is engaged in Land Clearing without a permit. (b) Criteria. Upon receipt of a completed application and verification on-site by the City Forester. a permit may be issued for Tree Removal under the following conditions: (1) Trees located on building and construction sites as shown on City approved plans. provided said Trees are replaced elsewhere on the property in accordance with 95-9 of this Chapter. (2) Trees located within ten (10) feet of a structure or other improvement provided said Trees are replaced elsewhere on the property in accordance with &5-9 of this Chapter. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 5 of 19 (3) Trees severely diseased. severely iniured or dead. (4) Trees that interfere with the construction or repair of public utilities. (5) Undesirable Trees. per Appendix A. (6) Trees removed by the City or other governmental agency and which are located within a public road. drainage rights-of-way. or permanent utilities and drainage easements. (7)Trees that have been approved bv the City Forester and which shall be replaced elsewhere on the property. (8)All Trees and plants. within a licensed Tree nursery. planted for harvest shall be exempt from the terms and provisions of this Chapter only if Trees are planted and growing on the premises of the licensee and are for sale or intended for sale in its ordinary course of business. (c) Review Standards. When making a determination on whether to approve or deny an application under this Chapter. the City Forester shall apply one (1) or more of the following standards of review deemed relevant: (1) Necessity to remove Trees which pose a safety hazard to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or threaten to cause disruption to public services and public easements through Encroachment. (2)Necessity to remove Trees which pose a safety hazard to buildings and other improvements on a lot or parcel of land. (3) Necessity to remove diseased Trees or Trees weakened by age. storm. fire or other iniury that pose a safety hazard to people. buildings or other improvements on lot or parcel of land. (4) The extent to which Tree Removal is likely to result in damage to the property of other owners. public or private. including damage to lakes. ponds. streams. or rivers through runoff or erosion. (5) Any proposed landscaping including plans whereby the applicant has planted or will plant Trees to replace those that are proposed to be cleared. (6)Topography of the land and the effect of Tree Removal on erosion. soil retention and the diversion or increased flow of surface water. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 6 of 19 (7) Good forestry practices, such as the number of healthy Trees that a given parcel ofland will reasonably support and the proven techniques that sustain healthy trees. (8) Necessity to remove Trees in order to construct approved and permitted improvements to allow economic enioyment of the property, including: (A)Need for access around the proposed structure for construction equipment (maximum often (10) feet). (B) Need for access to the building site for construction equipment. (C) Essential ~rade changes. (D) Need for locating street or road rights-of-way, utilities, drainage ways, as well as the need to provide reasonable use and property access. (9) The extent of any damage or demonstrated hardship which would result to the applicant from a denial of the requested permit. (10) The species and size of the Trees proposed for removal. (11) The following factors shall also be considered: (a) Trees forming the current canopy. (b) Preservation of the next generation of Trees. Sec. 5-5. City Forestry Office. (a) Establishment of Office. There is hereby created within the Department of Community Development, the Office of City Forestry. The Community Development Director shall head this office and the City Manager shall appoint one (1) or more employees of the department to act in the capacity of Forester for the City. (b) Scope of Authority. The City Forester shall be charged with the responsibility and authority to review and oversee all activities within the City limits which involve Tree RemovaL Land Clearing, or danger to and by any Tree. (c) Responsibilities. The role of the City Forester shall include, but not necessarily be limited to: City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 7 of 19 (1) Receiving and processing applications for Tree RemovaL Land Clearing and other permits under this Chapter. (2) Inspection of all property subiect to an application. (3) Confirming all information provided by the applicant is correct and accurate. (4) To approve or deny all permit applications under this Chapter. (5) To issue cease and desist work orders upon Persons in violations of this Chapter. (6) To bring violators of this Chapter before the Code Enforcement Board. (7) To issue code enforcement citations for any violation of this Chapter. (8) To augment the City's Forest by the planting or approval of planting of additional Trees on public property. (9) To keep a permanent record of all Historic or Specimen Trees designated by the City Commission. (10) To educate the public regarding this Chapter and the importance of maintaining a City Forest. (11) To handle other related iob duties assigned by the City Manager. Sec. 5-6 Permit Application. (a) Filing Application and Pavment of Fees. An application for Tree Removal and Land Clearing shall be filed on official forms provided by the City's Forester. The applicant may be required to pay a fee as may be established by resolution of the City Commission. If the applicant is not the property owner. then the applicant shall attach the written permission of the property owner to the application. Completed applications shall be returned to the Forester. along with the following: (1) A Tree inventory consisting of a scaled aerial photograph or drawing of a scale of one (1) inch equals three hundred (300) feet or greater indicating: (A) Property boundaries. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 8 of 19 (B) The location of all individual Trees including the Tree's common or botanical name. (C) An indication of all Trees proposed for removal. (D) Within the Primary Tree Protection Zone. a plan shall designate the Trees to be retained and those proposed to be removed. relocated or replaced. Those Trees proposed for removal. relocation or replacement shall also be identified by common or botanical name. (E) Within the Secondary Tree Protection Zone. a plan shall designate the Trees to be retained. and those proposed to be removed. (F) The location of existing and proposed improvements. if any. including structures. paving and utility easements. (2) Reasons for the removal of Trees. (3) The appropriate permit fees. (b) Time for Application. Applications for a Tree Removal or Land Clearing permit shall be made prior to removal or clearing; except that in the following cases. application shall be filed when indicated: (1) All new subdivisions shall be required to submit an application for a Tree Removal or Land Clearing permit. at the time of initial submittal of the subdivision plan. to the City Forester so that due consideration may be given to protection of Trees during the subdivision design process. (2) Any commercial. industrial. multi-family or other use requiring site plan approval under the City land development regulations shall be required to submit an application for a Tree Removal and Land Clearing permit at the time of site plan submittal so that due consideration may be given to the protection of Trees during the site plan design process. (3) All new single-family and duplex dwelling units shall be required to submit an application for a Tree Removal and Land Clearing permit at the time of application for a building permit; the Tree inventory may be shown on the building permit plot plan. (c) Exempting Portion of the Tree Survev. Upon request. the Forester may permit an applicant to omit certain portions of the Tree inventory where compliance with the City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 9 of 19 requirements set forth herein would be unnecessarily burdensome and the exempted portions are not needed for the City to evaluate the application. (d) Permit Fee. A nonreturnable permit fee to be establishing by resolution of the City Commission shall be paid for purposes of processing the application. enforcing the provisions of this Chapter. and inspecting the real property subiect to the application. (e) Posting of Permit. The permit must be posted upon the property and visible from the street to be valid. Sec. 5-7 RESERVED. Sec. 5-8.Specimen or Historic Trees. (a) Designation. Certain Trees. herein referred to as "Specimen" or "Historic" Trees. are of especially great concern to the public because of ecological value. of indigenous character. size. age or historic association. Determination that a Tree is a Historic Tree shall be made by resolution of the City Commission. and the City Forester shall keep a permanent record of all Trees so designated by the City Commission. Specimen Trees are all Trees (other than "Undesirable Trees" identified in Appendix A dead trees or diseased trees) which are twenty (20) inches or more in diameter. Designation as an Historic Tree may occur in anyone of the following ways: (1) An applicant may request designation of an Historic Tree as part of any master plan. preliminary subdivision plat. or site plan application. To do so. the applicant shall submit an expert evaluation by a landscape architect. horticulturalist. city forester. or other horticultural expert as part of the application. (2) A property owner may request such designation at any time. To do so. the property owner shall submit an expert evaluation by a landscape architect. horticulturalist. city forester historian or other horticultural expert. (3) The City's Forester may recommend such designation as part of their review of any application for development. stating in writing their reasons for such designation. or may make such designation as part of an overall Tree protection planning program for the City or portion thereof. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 10 of 19 (4) Historic Tree designations shall be subject to approval by resolution of the City Commission and the City Commission may grant tree replacement credits. upon grantin~ an Historic Tree designation. (b) Removal. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Chapter. Specimen or Historic Trees shall not be removed except for extraordinary circumstances and hardships and only by final permit approved by the City Commission. Sec. 5-9. Tree Replacement Guidelines. (a) Tree Replacement. All Trees that are removed or destroyed and subject to replacement by this Chapter shall be replaced by a species of Tree cited in Appendix B. Desirable Trees or Appendix C. Preferred Plant List or such other Trees properly approved by the City Forester. Replacement shall occur within ninety (90) days of removal or destruction unless a greater replacement period is provided for good cause by permit. (b) Criteria for Replacement Trees is as follows: (1) Characteristics of Replacement Trees. The replacement Tree( s) shall have at least equal shade potential. screening properties. and/or other characteristics comparable to that of the Tree(s) requested to be removed. (2) Size of Replacement Trees. Replacement Tree(s) are to be made according to a standard of one (1 ") inch DBH total replacement for each one (1 ") inch DBH removed. unless (1) the Trees are replaced with Trees from the Preferred Plant List: or (2) otherwise agreed upon by the City Commission and applicant. Acceptable spacing and design standards are the only criteria that shall limit the number of Trees used to meet the inch for inch requirement. (3) Tree Species. Relocated or Replacement Trees shall include only species defined as Desirable Trees (Appendix B) under this ordinance. (4) Transplanting and Maintenance Requirements. All Trees transplanted pursuant to this ordinance shall be maintained in a healthy. living condition. Any such Trees which die shall be replaced and maintained by the property owner. The City shall retain perpetual jurisdiction to ensure compliance with this Chapter. (5) Waivers of Replacement Tree(s) Specifications. The number of required Replacement Trees may be waived by the City Commission. if the City City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 11 of 19 Commission determines that the remaining number of Trees to be preserved on site are of sufficient number and quality to substantially comply with the purpose and intent of this Chapter and a tree replacement fee is paid to the City's "Tree Bank." which is hereby established. Monies collected in the Tree Bank shall be used for enhancement and maintenance of trees on public lands. Substitute Tree( s) allowed under this Waiver provision must have the approval of the City Commission. The value to be paid into the tree bank should be based upon wholesale market value of the trees being replaced. (6) Replacement Alternative. As an alternative to the one for one Tree replacement requirement set forth in this Section. an applicant may elect to comply with the followin~ Tree replacement guidelines: (A) Applicant may deduct from the number of Trees to be replaced. Tree Replacement Credits based on the number of replacement credits as provided in the Preferred Plant Material List provided that: (i) All plant materials are Florida Grades and Standard One (1) or better: and ( ii) All plant materials are properly installed; and (iii) The landscape plan for the proposed development or redevelopment to which the credits are to be applied is prepared bv a landscape architect licensed bv the State of Florida; and (iv) The Developer shall guarantee survival of retained and replacement trees for a period of one (1) year from the completion of construction. unless a greater time period is required by development agreement. If retained or replacement Trees die during that time period. the Developer shall replace the tree in accordance with a remedial action under Section 5-17 of this Chapter. (B) For each tree located within a public conservation area dedicated to the City as part ofa development proiect. three (3) replacement tree credits may be applied to the total number oftrees required to be replaced by this Chapter. However. the minimum tree requirement set forth in Section 5-13 shall still apply. Such public conservation area must be at least one (1) acre with widths not less than 125 feet. unless otherwise approved by the City Commission. In addition. trees approved by the City Forester to reforest such conservation City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 12 of 19 area shall also be applied to the replacement requirement on a one-for-one basis. (C) If the City Commission determines. due to site conditions or configuration. it is impossible or impracticable for the applicant/developer to meet the requirements for Tree Replacement. under this subsection. the City Commission may allow the applicant/developer to pay into the City's "Tree Bank" the amount it would have spent on Replacement Trees. (e) Replacement Cost. The cost of replacing the Trees shall be incurred by the party that removed the Trees or property owner. Sec. 5-10.Prohibitions. (a) Placement of Materials. Machinery. or Temporary Soil Deposits. It shall be unlawful to place materiaL machinery. or temporary soil deposits within the Tree Protection Zone before or during construction. Before or during construction the builder shall erect and maintain suitable Protective Barriers around all Trees to be preserved. Upon written request. the City Forester. on a case by case basis. may allow material or temporary soil deposits to be stored within the Protective Barrier if no other storage is available. (b) Climbing Spurs. It shall be unlawful to use climbing spurs or other similar device to aid in the climbing of a live tree. where such device causes the puncture or tears the bark of the tree. (c) Tree Spiking. It shall be unlawful to introduce any type of poison or reactive material to a Tree for the purpose of causing it to die or become diseased. (d) Structure and Pavement Location. It shall be unlawful to place any structure or impervious paving within eight (8') foot radius of any Tree Trunk or Stem having a diameter of four (4") inches or more at Caliper. (e) City Trees. It shall be unlawful to trim. prune. or remove any tree which is within the City's rights-of-way or upon any other City property without the permission of the City evidenced by the appropriate permit. (f) Attachments. It shall be unlawful to attach anything to a Tree or Stem. including nails or spikes. having a diameter of four (4 ") inches or more at Caliper. other than protective wires. braces or other similar noniniurious materials. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 13 of 19 (g) Cut and Fill Guidelines. It shall be unlawful to remove or add any material or ground within the Tree Protection Zone unless otherwise permitted by the Forester. (h) Encroachment of the Dripline. During the construction stage of development. the developer or property owner shall not cause or allow Land Clearing. the use of heavy equipment or material within the Dripline of any Tree or groups of Trees to be retained. Neither shall the developer cause or allow the disposal of waste material such as paint. oil. solvents. asphalt. concrete. mortar or any other material harmful to the life of a Tree within the Dripline of any Tree or groups of Trees. or where planting beds are to be situated. (i) Shearing. Hat Racking. Topping or Poodle Trimming of Trees. Trees intended for shade purposes shall be allowed to reach their mature canopy spread. Excessive shearing. pruning or shaping shall only be allowed with a permit by demonstrating necessity or without a permit in times of emergency only. Sec. 5-11. RESERVED. Sec. 5-12. Permit Contents; Expiration; Removal After Expiration of Permit. (a) Permit Contents. The Tree Removal permit. when issued. shall specifically identify which Trees shall be permitted to be removed. The removal permits merely authorize the removal of the Trees specified therein. Nothing in this Chapter shall be construed to require the removal of such Trees by the permittee. (b) Permit Expiration. Any permit issued under this Chapter shall automatically expire six (6) months after issuance. except for permits issued in conjunction with a building permit which shall automatically expire six (6) months after issuance or at such time the building permit expires. whichever is later. (c) Restrictions on Tree Removal After Permit Exviration. Trees not removed during the life of the permit may not be removed without the issuance of a new permit based upon a new application. (d) Permit Displav. The permit shall be located and maintained upon the site at all time. Sec. 5-13. Minimum Tree Requirement. No certificate of occupancy shall be issued on the types of construction indicated below unless the underlying parcel has at least the required minimum number of approved Trees: City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 14 of 19 (a) Any new single-family or duplex dwelling unit on a lot ofless than 6.000 square feet or greater: not fewer than two (2) Trees. (b) Any new single-family or duplex dwelling unit on a lot ofless than between 6.001 and 10.000 square feet: not fewer than three (3) Trees. (c) Any single commercial. industrial. multi-family or other structure requiring site plan approval under the City land development regulations: no fewer than five (5) Trees or approximately three (3) Trees per acre. which ever is greater. Sec. 5-14.Tree Protection Durin2 Development and Construction: Periodic Inspection. (a) Restrictions During Construction. It shall be unlawful for any Person. during the construction of any structures or other improvements. to place solvents. paint or masonry materials. construction machinery or temporary soil deposits within the Dripline of any Tree for which a Tree Removal permit is required but has not been obtained. This provision includes soil that is placed in the Dripline permanently for the purpose of a grade change. unless the grade is changed according to the guidelines described in the Florida Division of Forestrv. Department of Awiculture and Consumer Services Publication. Tree Protection Manual for Buildings and Developers. (b) Burden of Tree Protection on Property Owner. It shall be the responsibility of a developer or applicant to ensure that any Tree shown on the Tree inventory for which a Tree Removal permit has not been obtained is to be protected. The property owner shall guarantee survival of retained trees and Replacement Trees for one (1) year from completion of permitted construction. unless a greater time period is required by development agreement. If a retained or replacement Tree dies during that time period. the property owner shall replace the Tree in accordance with a remedial action approved under & 5-17 of this Chapter. (c) Protective Barriers Required. Posts shall be used as Protective Barriers to the roots and Trunk of every Tree on the parcel being developed. The posts shall be placed at points not closer than one-half radius of the Dripline of the protected tree. unless the structure has been permitted by the City to be erected within the Dripline of a Tree with a wide canopy. Each section of the barrier shall be clearly visible (flagged with brightly colored plastic tape or other markers). No attachments or wires other than those with a protective or non-damaging nature shall be attached to any Tree. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 15 of 19 (d) Site Inspections. The City Forester may conduct periodic inspections of the site. It is the responsibility of the applicant to ensure that all provisions of this Chapter are met. Sec. 5-15. Voluntary Tree Planting. This Chapter shall not be interpreted to restrict. regulate or limit the voluntary planting of any Tree within the City. The provisions of this Chapter govern only the planting of Trees which are required to be planted or retained under this Chapter. No tree or plant shall be planted within a City rights-of-way or easement without express permission from the City Forester. Sec. 5-16. Waivers and Appeals. (a) Waivers. The City Commission may grant a waiver to provisions of this Chapter where the applicant demonstrates that the literal interpretation of the ordinance will deny the applicant reasonable use of the property or where such waiver can be demonstrated to be consistent with the purpose and intent of the ordinance. The preservation of any approved Tree over four (4) inches in caliper may be considered as the basis for the granting of a waiver from the literal application of the provisions of the City's land development regulations. If. in the determination of the City Commission. the sole basis for the request for waiver is to preserve such Tree which would otherwise have to be removed. it may direct any required waiver fee to be waived. (b) Appeals. Any Person adversely affected by an administrative interpretation of this Chapter may appeal that interpretation to the City Commission by filing a written notice of appeal of said interpretation within thirty (30) days of said interpretation. Failure to file an appeal within said time period shall result in the administrative interpretation to be declared final. The City Commission shall decide said appeal within thirty (30) days of the City's receipt of said notice of appeal and the City Commission's decision shall be final. Sec. 5-17. Remedial Action. (a) Violations Require Remedial Action. Where violations ofthis Chapter have occurred. remedial action shall be taken to restore the property consistent with a restoration plan approved by the City Forester. The restoration plan may require Tree replacement at not more than a ratio offourto one (4: 1) and require mitigation of any other damage to the property. as well as Tree replacements. (b) Replacement Formula. Each Tree destroyed or receiving maior damage during construction must be replaced bv either a comparable size and desirable type of Tree as listed within Appendix B or four (4) Replacement Trees before issuance of a City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 16 of 19 certificate of occupancy or certificate of completion. Undesirable Trees must be replaced with a desirable species. (c) Property Owner to Guarantee Survival of Replaced Trees. The property owner shall guarantee the survival of the Trees required to be placed under Subsection (b) above for a period of two (2) years from the date the certificate of occupancy or certificate of completion is issued. unless a greater time period is required by development agreement. If the replacement Tree dies. the Tree shall be replaced in accordance with this section. Sec. 5-18. Enforcement: Penalties. (a) Enforcement. The City may enforce the provisions of this Chapter by any lawful means including. but not limited to. issuing a civil citation. bringing charges before the City's Code Enforcement Board or special master. and seeking iniunctive and equitable relief (b) Penalties. In addition to all other remedies set forth in this Chapter. the following civil fines shall apply to violations of this Chapter: (1) Failure to obtain a permit. . . Fine not to exceed $5.000.00 (2) Removal of a Tree without a permit. . . Fine not to exceed $5.000.00 per Tree. (3) Any other violation of this Chapter. . . Fine as provided by law. (c) Civil Fine Determination. In determining the amount of the civil fine. the following factors shall be considered: (1) The gravity of the violation. (2) Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violation. (3) Any previous violations of this Chapter committed by the violator. (4) The number and size of the Trees removed. (5) The historical significance of the Tree removed if the Tree was deemed Historic. (6) Whether the violation is irreparable or irreversible in nature. City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 17 of 19 (7)The remedial actions offered by the violator to restore the property consistent with his Chapter. Sec. 5-19.Authorization to Adopt Rules and Regulations and Fees for Implementation. The Citv Commission is hereby authorized to adopt by resolution. such rules and regulations and fees as are necessary or proper to implement this Chapter. Section 3. Repeal of Prior Inconsistent Ordinances and Resolutions. All prior inconsistent ordinances and resolutions adopted by the City Commission, or parts of prior ordinances and resolutions in conflict herewith, are hereby repealed to the extent of the conflict. Section 4. Incorporation Into Code. This ordinance shall be incorporated into the Winter Springs City Code and any section or paragraph number or letter and any heading may be changed or modified as necessary to effectuate the foregoing. Section 5. Severability. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, word or provision of this ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, whether for substantive, procedural, or any other reason, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this ordinance. Section 6. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the City Commission of the City of Winter Springs, Florida. ADOPTED by the City Commission of the City of Winter Springs, Florida, in a regular meeting assembled on the 8th day of April, 2002. PAUL P. PARTYKA Mayor ATTEST: ANDREA LORENZO-LUACES City Clerk City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 18 of 19 Approved as to legal form and sufficiency for the City of Winter Springs only: Anthony A. Garganese, City Attorney First Reading: March 11, 2002 Second Reading: March 25, 2002 Third Reading and Adoption: April 8, 2002 Effective Date: April 8, 2002 City of Winter Springs Ordinance No. 2002-08 Page 19 of 19 PART II CODE OF ORDINANCES Chapter 5 ARBOR' EXHIBIT A Chapter 5 ARBOR* *Editor's note--Ord. No. 71109 I, adopted March 22, 1999. substantially amended former Ch. 5 to read as herein set out. Former Ch. 5, 995-1-5-5, pertained to the same subject matter and derived from Ord. No. 451, 9 1, adopted March 27, 1987. Cross reference(s)--Code enforcement board to enforce certain ordinances of the city, 9 2-56 et seq.; beautification board. 92-76 et seq.: buildings and building regulations, Ch. 6: flood damage prevention. Ch. 8; land development, Ch. 9: motor vehicles and traffic. Ch. 12: nuisances, Ch. 13: planning, Ch. 15; signs and advertising.Ch. 16: streets, sidewalks.and other public places, Ch 7; zoning, Ch. 20. Sec. 5-1. Intent and purpose: applicability; definitions. (a) Intent and purpose. These arboreal standards of the city dedare the tangible and intangible value of trees and plants to the citizens and the community, in that they playa vital role in the natural ecosystem of the city, benefiting the air, water. soil, wildlife and other vegetation of the environment, and in that greenery as well contributes to the aesthetic aspects of life. Therefore, precedent to any activity which requires alteration of the natural vegetation on the land, an application shall be presented to the city for review of the extent and necessity of removal or destruction of trees. No activity shall proceed until a permit has been acquired from the appropriate city office, as prescribed hereinafter in this chapter. All activity undertaken without such permit shall cease and desist immediately upon issuance of notice by the city. b) Scope of applicability. The regulations enacted hereinafter shall apply to all real property within the city limits. (c) Definitions. As used in this chapter, the words and phrases listed below shall construed according to the meaning specified herein: (1) Bona fide logging operation: The good-faith operation of the business of felling trees of merchantable size for lumber, cutting them into suitable-length logs and hauling such logs to some point for transportation to and/or manufacture at 'sawmills and markets. (2) Buildable area: That portion. of a site within the yard area on which a structure or improvement. including driveways and parking lots may be erected. (3) Caliper: Measurement of treeeight (8) (inches) from soil level (4) City forest: The aggregate of all street trees and all park trees. (5) Crown: The mass of branches, twigs and leaves at the top of a tree, with particular reference to its shape. (6) D.B.H.: Diameter at breast height, (approximately four and one-half (47/2) feet from ground at tree base). (7) Drip line: The vertical line running through the outermost portion of the tree crown extending to the ground. (8) Encroachment: The protrusion into a vehicular accessway. pedestiair.-way, or required landscale area. (9) Green area: Any portion of the site which is planted and maintained in grass. shrubs arid trees or maintained as a natural drainage area (exclusive of concrete or asphalt or other paving material). (10) Landscaping.' Landscaping shall consist of. but not be limited to. grass, ground Covers. shrubs. vines, hedges, trees. berms. and complementary structural landscape architectural features. such as rock. fountains. sculpture. decorative walls and tree welis. (11) Landscaped dividing strips: Landscaped areas containing ground cover, shrubs. and trees, or other landscaping used to partition parking areas into individual parking bays. (12) Park trees: Trees. shrubs, bushes and all other woody vegetation in public parks and all open areas owned by the city or to which the public has free access. (13) Parking areas: Any area. excluding public right.of.way, used for the purpose of driving. maneuvering. parking, storing, or display of motor vehicles. boats. trailers. mobile homes, and recreational vehicles including new and used automobile lots. other parking lot uses, and paved outdoor sales areas. (14) Parking spaces: A parking area used for the temporary. storage of a single vehicle to serve a primary use;' groups of space's' and the abutting accessway are called parking lots. (15) Shrubs: A seif.supporting woody species of plants characterized by persistent stems and branches springing from the base. (16) Single-family lot: An area of land developed for and restricted to a single-family residence. (17) Specimen trees: Trees of significant size, type, age or historical value. (to be determined by the city forester). (18) Street trees: Trees. shrubs, bushes. and all other woody vegetation on land lying between property lines on either side of all streets, avenues, or ways within the city. (19) Tree: Any living. self.supporting perennial plant which has a trunk diameter of at least four (4) inches measured at caliper and normally grows to a minimum overall crown height of fifteen (15) feet. (20) Trees planted for haNest: All trees which have been planted, or shall be planted. with the bona fide intention at the time of such planting to be commercially harvested in the future. Said trees shall include, by way of illustration, but are not limited to Christmas trees, slash pines. and pulpwood. (Ord. No. 711. I. 3-22-99; Ord. No. 726, 9 6-28-99) Sec. 5-2. City forestry office. (a) Establishment of office. There is hereby created within the department of community development. the office of city forestry. The community development director shall head this office and shall appoint one (1) or more employees of the department to act in the capacity of forester for Winter Springs. (b) Scope of authority. The city forester shall be charged with the responsibility and authority to review and oversee all activities within the city limits which cause removal of or create danger to any trees. (c) Responsibilities. The role of the city forester shall be dual: (1) To preclude removal of trees on private property prior to review and approval of development proposals. (2) To augment the city forest by the planting or approval of planting of additional trees or public property. (Ord No 711, S I. 3-22-99) ; 30,01 I !:29 A~I Sec. 5-3. Regulations applicable to privately held property. jf (a) Permit to alter natural landscape. Application for a permit to disturb natural vegetation or alter existing to:Jography shall oe submitted prior to the following activities: (1) C;.;tting down. removing. or damaging trees oefore. during or after construction. (2) Land-clearing, land-removing, or land-filling operations, including propulsion of a bulldozer, payloader, front-end loader, backhoe, dragline, power shovel, road grader, dump truck, dredge, fill spreader. or other heavy duty equipment. None of the preceding activities shall .:Jroceed until the city forester has reviewed the proposal and issued a permit prescribing the extent of operations being approved and the replacement trees specified. (b) Scope of review. The permit application shall be supported by drawings, plans or :ljphotograpl1s as necessary to depict the present nature of the land. the proposed alteration, and the : objectives that may justify the removal of trees, alteration of the existing topography, and/or the disruption of the natural vegetation. These submittals shall include all the following information pertinent to the stage of development under review. .. ...... - '. (1) Proposed location o~ streets, parking areas, utility or drainage structures, buildings, and any other physical improvements anticipated: (2) Specific location of all specimen trees within these areas to be removed along with their botanical names and current sizes: (3) ?oposed grade changes of more than one (1) foot depth; (4) ?roposed protective barriers to preclude damage to uninvolved trees. (5) A tree survey of all trees four (4) inches or more in caliper. :If (c) Permit to be specific as to stage 01 development. The city forester shall review the . above-prescribed submittals and act upon the request either independently or as and agent of a staff-wide review, depending on the development stage of a project: (1) Predeve/opment stage. The city forester may review and issue permits for land alteration incident to surveying. soils investigations. and preparation of initial development plans. (2) Preliminary plan/preliminary engineering. The forester shall act as an advisor to the city staff in reviewing preliminary development/engineering plans and recommending the extent of lane clearing to be authorized. The city forester shall subsequently issue a permit prescribing the alteration of preliminary development/engineering plans. (3) Final engineering stage. The city forester shall consider requests for additional tree removal coincident with final engineering plan review only when a developer shall show that unexpected or unanticipated factors preclude any reasonable alternative solution than destruction of additional trees.:rl'le city commission must sanction these requests along with final en!;jineering approval before the city forester may issue an additional permit for additional tree removal. (4) Site plan. The city forester shall act as a advisor to the site plan review board during its review of plans of commercial or multi-family site development proposals. A permit which specifies exactly which specimens or stands of trees may be removed to develop a site must be acquired before any modification of a site may take place. :Ir(d) Genera/ criteria for issuance 01 permits to remove trees. Trees may be authorized for removal , only if they fit into one of the following categories; the validity of the status of a tree as eligible for removal shall be verified on site by the city forester prior to issuance of a permit for removal: (1 ) Trees located on building and construction sites as shown on approved plans may be replacec elsewhere on the property or mitigated by a monetary replacement to be determined by the city forester of the current wholesale cost of the tree being removed which shall be used for enr.arlcement and maintenance of trees located on public lanes. ; ;0,01 ! I:~ A~I (2) Trees within ten (10) feet of a proposed or an existing structure or other improvement that restrict construction may be replaced elsewhere on the property or mitigated by a monetary replacement to oe cetermined by the city forester of the current wholesale cost of the tree being removed which shall be used for enhancement and maimenance of trees located on public lands. (3) Trees severely diseased. injured or dead; (4) Trees that interfere with provision of above ground utility installations and which will be replaced elsewhere on the property: (5) Trees that have been approved by the city forester to be replaced elsewhere on the property. (6) Trees that appear on the Florida Exotic Pest Plant Council's List of Invasive Plants, Class 1. (e) Public removal 01 trees on private property. Only under the following circumstances may city employees prune or remove trees growing on private property: (1 ) Any dead or damaged. or diseased tree which constitutes a hazard to life and property shall be removed by the property owner upon justification and notification by the city forester. The property owner must have the tree removed within fifteen (15) days or show just cause why it has not been removed. If no action is taken within fifteen (15) days of notice, city employees may remove such trees and bill the property owner. Unpaid bills shall become a lien upon the property. (2) Tree limbs and shrubs overhanging public rights-of-way if such branches obstruct the light from any streetlight or obstruct the view of any street intersection creating a hazard to vehicular or pedestrian traffic. (All limbs will be removed following standard arboricultural standards.) (Ord. No. 711, 9 f, 3-22-99; Ord. No. 711, 99 2, 3, 6-28-99; Ord. No. 734, 9 1, 9-27-99) Sec. 5-4. Official green plan for public property. (a) Initial plan. The city forester under the guidance of the d!rector of community development, shall develop an official Winter Springs Green Plan which provides to the city commission the following information: (1) Documentation on the current nature of the city forester consisting of parks, rights-of-way, easements and public facilities; (2) Proposals for the care, preservation, replacement, and planting of new trees and plants on city land; . (3) Projected budgetary data for at least the subsequent five (5} years. (b) Annual report. Each year the city forester shall submit to the city manager through the jJ community development director a written report on the progress toward implementation of the ; green plan. including suggestions for additions and revisions to the plan. When ratified by the city commission, these modifications shall become incorporated into the official plan. (c) Interim reports. Whenever requested by the city manager, the city forester shall investigate or analyze a site or concern and file a report of findings on the matter. (d) Implementation 01 city green plan. The city forester shall cause the official green plan to be implemented to adhere to the following guidelines: (1) Street tree species to be planted. No street trees shalf be plan tee without written permission of the city forester. (2) Spacing. Trees shall be spaced the optimum distance for each species. (3) Distance from curb and sidewalk. Trees and shrubs shall be plantec so as to aIlow proper visibility and to avoid root damage to curbs and sidewalks. (4) Distance from street comers and fireplugs. No street tree shall be planted closer than tvventy (20) feet to any street corner, measured from the point of the nearest intersecting Curb or curbline. No street tree shall be planted within ten (10) feet of any fireplug. (5) Proximity of street trees to utilities. No street trees shall be planted under or within ten (10) linear feet of any overhead utility wire, or within five (5) linear feet of any underground water line, sewer line, transmission fine or other utility installation. No trees shall be planted in the city rights-of-way without the written approval of the city forester. (e) Maintenance of city trees:. (1) Tree topping. It shall be unlawful for any person, to top any street tree, park tree or other tree on public or private property without a permit from the city forester. Topping is defined as the severe cutting back of limbs within the tree's crown to prevent normal growth to such a degree so as to remove the normal canopy and disfigure the tree. (2) Damaged trees. Trees damaged by natural causes and trees under utility wires or other obstructions where other pruning practices are impractical may be topped with approval of the city forester. (3) Tree sculpturing. Trees in commercial areas may be topped only when topping is part of a landscaping plan, design or program to sculpt trees to accommodate a desired design or design theme. (f) Interference with city forester. It shall be unlawful for any person to prevent, delay, or interfere with the city forester or any designated agents while engaging in and about the planting, cultivating, mulching, pruning, spraying, or removing of any street tree or park tree. (Ord. No. 711, 9 I, 3-22-99: Ord. No. 726, 94,6-28-99) Sec. 5-5. Enforcement. (a) Assessment. Failure to comply with the reforestations standards may result in charges being Ifbrought against the individual or company violating the arboreal provisions and requiring a hearing . before the code enforcement board which has the power to levy fines up to two hu rfd red fifty dollars ($250.00) a day per violation, as set forth in section 2-60 of the.Winter Springs City Code of Ordinances. The City of Winter Springs may seek injunctive or other legal relief as offered by law. (b) Reforestation. Ally person violating any of the arboreal provision set forth herein shall be .'jJrequired to appear before the city forester which shall be empowered to specify the number and - types and sizes of trees to be pianted by the individual to compensate the public for the loss of existing trees. The guidelines in subsection (c) below shall apply to the reforestation of land illegally cleared: ~ _ j] (c) Reforestation point standar~s~ - .... . (1) Minimum points required per acre. The minimum number of tree points required in each zoning category per acre of land (excluding areas dedicated for rights-of-way for streets) are as follows: a. Residential (including residential PUO)- Twenty-five (25) points per acre. b. Neighborhood commercial districts (including commercial PUO)-- Twenty (20) points per acre. c. General commercial and industrial districts (including industrial PUO )--Fifteen (15) points per acre (2) Tree point s:andarcs. Number of Points J }fJ O! I !:19 .-\..\.1 a. Specimen tree (as designated by city forester) . . . 5 b Large tree (40 feet high or 35-foot crown) . . . 5 c. Medium tree (i 8 feet high or 12 -foot crown) . . . 2. d. Small/nonjuvenile tree (8 feet high and 2-inch caliper) . . . 1 e. Small/juvenile (8 feet high and 1-inch caliper) . . . 0.75 f. Native shrubs material. . . 0.1 .Plus five tenths (0.5) point for each five (5) feet of additional height after twenty (20) feet. (3) Bonus points. Bonuses may be awarded for native species in addition to the tree pOints listed above: a. Specimen tree. . . NA b. Large tree: . . 1.0 c. Medium tree.. ."0.5 d. Small/nonjuvenile tree . , , 0.25 e. Small/juvenile tree. . , 0.1 (4) Minimum number of small, medium, and large trees. A minimum of fifteen (15) percent of the number of trees counted toward these Iree point standards must come from each of the three (3) size categories of small, medium, and large. To determine the number of trees which will be needed to meet this fifteen (15) percent requirement, the following rules of thumb may be used: a. Determine the total points on the site as follows: T = Number of acres X Points required per acre b. Determine the minimum number of medium or large trees needed for fifteen (15) percent requirement as follows: Minimum Number = T X 9 percent c. To minimize the number of new small trees to be planted retain the following number of medium plus large trees: Medium + Large Number To~al = T X 30 percent (5) All plant material must be properly planted and protected from construction damage to be eligible for tree points. (Ore. No. 711, 9 I, 3-22-99) APPENDIX A UNDESIRABLE TREES Common Name Acacia Australian Pine Australian Pines Australian Pine Benjamin Fig Bishopwood Bo Tree Brazilian Pepper, Florida Holly Brazillian Pepper Tree Cajeput or Punk Tree Cama Eucalyptus Camphor Carrotwood Castor Bean Catclaw Mimosa Chinaberry Chinaberry Chinese Tallow Tree Chinese Tallow Chinese Tallow, popcorn tree Cork Free Cuban Laurel Devil Tree Downy Rosemyrtle Ear Tree Ear Pod Tree Earleaf Acacia False Banyan Florida Holly or Brazilian Pepper Golden Shower Tree Hydrilla Jacaranda Java Plum Laurel Fig Lead Tree Melaleuca, Paper Tree Mimosa Monkey Puzzle Murray Red Gum Orchid Tree Paper Mulberry Punk Tree Rice Paper Plant Scientific Name Acacia Spp. Casuarina Species All Casuarina Species Casuarina Equisetifolia Ficus Benjamina Bischofia Javanica Ficus Religiosa Schinus Terebinthifolius Schinus Terebinthifolius Melaleuca Species Eucalyptus Camuldulensis Cinnamonum Camphora Cupianopsis Anacardioides Ricinus Communis Mimosa Pigra Melia Azedarch Melia Azedarach Sapium Sebiferum Sapium Sebiferum Sapium Sebiferum Thespesia Populnea Ficus Retusa Alstonia Macrophylla Rhodomyrtus Tomentosus Entelobium Contortisliquum Enterolobium Contortisliquum Acacia Auriculiformis Ficus Altissima Schhinus Terebinthifolius Koelreuteria Elegans Hydrilla Vertic illata Jacaranda Acutifolia Syzygium Cumini Ficus Microcarpa Leucaena Species Melaleuca Quinquenervia Albizzia Julibrissin Eucalyptus spp. Eucalyptus Camaldulensis Bauhinia Variegata Broussonetia Papyrifera Malaeuca Leucadendron Tetrapanax Papyriferus Page 1 of 2 Common Name Scientific Name Rose Apple Rosewood Schefllera Silk Oak Silk Oak Suckering Australian Pine Surinam Cherry Taro Tropical Soda Apple Tropical Almond Tung Oil Tree Water Hyacinth Wedelia Weeping Fig Woman's Tongue Syzygium Jambos Dalbergia Sissoo Schefllera Actinophylla Grevillea Robusta Grevillea Robusta Casuarina Glauca Eugenia Uniflora Colocasia Esculenta Solanum Viarum Terminalia Catappa Aleurites Fordii Eichhomia Spp. Wedelia Trilobata Ficus Benjamina Albizia Lebbeck F:\DOCSICity of Winter SpringslOrdinanceslArbor Tree Protection Appendix A.jd Page 2 of 2 APPENDIX B DESIRABLE TREES Common American Elm American Holly American Holly Bald Cypress Beautyberry Bougainvillea Box Elder Buttonbush Cabbage Palm Cassia Chapman Oak Cherry Laurel Chickasaw Plum Chinese Elm (Drake) Chinese Fan Palm Coral Bean Crape Myrtrie Dahoon Holly Devil's Walking Stick Dwarf Yaupon Elderberry Elderberry European Fan Palm Flatwoods Plum Flowering Dogwood Fringe Tree Green Ash Hercules Club (Toothache Tree) Hopornbeam Indian Hawthorn Ironwood Japanese Blueberry Juniper Juniper Torulosa Laurel Oak Live Oak Loblolly Bay Loblolly Pine Longleaf Pine Loquat, (Japanese Plum) May Haw Myrtle Oak Needle Palm Persimmon APPENDIX B DESIRABLE TREES Genus Ulmus 1. Llex Taxodium Calicarpa Bougainvillea A. Cephlanthus Sabal Senna Q. Prunus Prunus U. Livistona Erythrina Lagerstroemia Llex Aralia 1. Sambucus Sambucus Chamaerops Prunus Cornus Chioanthus Fraxinus Zanthoxylum Ostrya Rapheolepis Carpinus Eleaocarpus Juniperus 1. Q. Qyercus Gordonia P. P. Eriobotrya Crataegus Q. Rhapidophyllum Diospyros Species Notes Americana Opaca Glabra Distichum Americana D D Negundo Occidentalis Palmetto Bicapsularis Chapmanii Evergreen Caroliniana Angustifolia Parviflora D Chinensis Herbacea Indica Cas sine Spinosa D, Araliaceae (ginseng family) Vomitoria Schellings Canadensis E Canadensis Humilis Umbellata Florida D, Showy white spring flowers Virginicus Pennsylvanica D Clava-Herculis D Virginiana Indica Caroliniana D, wet Decipiens Spp. Torulosa Laurifolia E Virginiana E Lasianthus E Taeda E Palustris E Japonica E Aestivalus Myrtifolia E Hystrix Virginiana D Page I of 3 Common Genus Species Notes Pignut Hickory Carya Glabra Pindo Palm Butia Capitata Pipestem Agarista Populifolia Pittosporum Pittosporum Tobira Podocarpus, Yew P. Macrophyllus Podocarpus, Nagi Podcarpus Nagi Pond Pine P. Serotina E Pond Cypress T. Ascendens D Privet, Chinese Ligustrum Sinense Privet, Japanese Ligustrum Japonicum Privet, Florida Forestiera Segregata Red Bay Persea Borbonia Red Mulberry Morus Rubra Red Buckeye Aesculus Pavia Red Bud Celtis Canadensis Red Maple Acer Rubrum D River Birch Betula Nigra Rusty Lyonia Lyonia Ferruginea Salt Mytrle Baccaharis Halimifolia Sand Pine P. Clausa E Saw Palmeto Serenoa Repens Scrub Oak Q. Geminata E Shiny Lyonia L. Iucida Shumard (red) Q. Shumardii D Silver Maple A. Saccharinum Silverthorn Elaegnus Pungens Simpson Stopper Myrcianthes Fragrans E, aka Naked Wood Slash Pine Pinus Elliottii E Snowbells Styrax Americana Southern Red Cedar Juniperus Virginiana E, var. silicicola Southern Magnolia Magnolia Grandiflora E Sparkleberry Vaccinium Arboreum Sugarberry Celtis Laveigata Swamp Black Gum Nyssa Sylvatica Swamp Dogwood C. Foemina Swamp Bay P. Palustris Sweet Acacia Acacia Farnesiana Sweet Gum Liquidambar Styraciflua D Sweet Acacia Acacia Farnesiana Sweetbay Magnolia M. Virginiana E Sycamore Platanus Occidentalis D Titi Cyrilla Racemiflora Tough Bumelia Bumelia Tenax Tulip Poplar Liriodendron Tulipfera Turkey Oak Q. Laevis Deciduous Viburnum, Walter's V. Obovatum Viburnum, Sandanka Viburnum Suspensum Viburnum, Sweet V. Odoratissimum Page 2 of 3 Common Genus Species Notes Virginia Willow Itea Virginica Washington Palm Washingtonia Robusta Water Oak Q. Nigra E Water Ash F. Caroliniana D Water Hickory Carya Aquatica Wax Myrtle Myrica Cerifera Weeping Willow Salix Babylonica Wild Olive Osmanthus Americana Willow Salix Caroliniana Willow Oak Q. Phellos D Winged Elm U. Alata Yellow Haw Crataegus Flava Yellow Anise Illicium Parviflorum F:\DOCSICity of Winter SpringslOrdinanceslArbor Tree Protection Appendix B.jd Page 3 of 3 APPENDIX C PREFERRED PLANT LIST TREE OR LARGE CREDIT AVERAGE CREDIT NET SHRUB NAME SIZE RATIO COST VALUE GAIN Bauhinia galpinia 10 gal., 5' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Butia-Pindo Palm 30 gal., 5' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Camellia 25-30 gal., 5' 3-1 $ 145.00 $ 300.00 $ 155.00 Canary Island Date Palm 30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Cardinal Holly 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Chickasaw Plum 25 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 95.00 $ 200.00 $ 105.00 Chinese Fan Palm. 30 gal., 5' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Crataegus 15 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Date Palm, P. dactylifera 30 gal., 4' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 European Fan Palm 30 gal., 4' 3-1 $ 150.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Festive Holly 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Flowering Dogwood 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Fringe Tree 15 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Grape Myrtle Standard 45 gal., 8-10' 5-1 $ 350.00 $ 500.00 $ 150.00 Japanese Blueberry 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 120.00 $ 300.00 $ 180.00 Lerapetalum Standard 15 gal., 5' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 Ligustrum Standard 45 gal., 8-10' 5-1 $ 300.00 $ 500.00 $ 200.00 Little Gem MagnolIa 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 Loblolly Bay 25-30 gal., 8' 2-1 $ 90.00 $ 200.00 $ 110.00 Myrtle Oak 15 gal., 5' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Needle Palm 25-30 gal., 5' 4-1 $ 200.00 $ 400.00 $ 200.00 Oakleaf Holly 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Pygmy Data Palm, dbl. 30 gal., 4' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Pygmy Date Palm, triple 30 gal., 4' 3-1 $ 150.00 $ 300.00 $ 150.00 Red Bud 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Red Buckeye 15 gal., 5' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Robin Holly 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 125.00 $ 300.00 $ 175.00 Sago 30 gal., 3' 3-1 $ 150.00 $ 300.00 $ 150.00 Simpson Stopper 25-30 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 90.00 $ 200.00 $ 110.00 Spartan Juniper 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 115.00 $ 300.00 $ 185.00 Sweet/Tea Olive 15 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 50.00 $ 200.00 $ 150.00 Tabebuia 30 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 75.00 $ 200.00 $ 125.00 Torulosa Juniper 25-30 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 90.00 $ 200.00 $ 110.00 Upright Yaupon Holly 15 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 90.00 $ 200.00 $ 110.00 Walter's Viburnum Standard 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 Weeping Yaupon Holly 25-30 gal., 8' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 Windmill Palm 30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 150.00 $ 300.00 $ 150.00 Yaupon Holly Standard 25-30 gal., 6' 3-1 $ 100.00 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 Yaupon Holly Multi-trunk 25-30 gal., 6' 2-1 $ 90.00 $ 200.00 $ 110.00 Footnote: 1. Costs subject to change. 2. Credit ratio; for each preferred tree planted, credit may be applied toward the replacement requirement. (Example: For each Yaupon Holly at 25-30 gallon, 6' tall planted, a credit of2 trees will be applied toward those trees.) Page 1 of 2 TREE OR LARGE CREDIT AVERAGE CREDIT NET SHRUB NAME SIZE RATIO COST VALUE GAIN Butia-Pindo Palm 65 gal., 8' 4-1 $ 200.00 $ 400.00 $ 200.00 Canary Island Date Palm 65 gal., 8' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Chinese Fan Palm 65 gal., 6' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Dahoon Holly 65 gal., lO'x4'x2' 5-1 $ 225.00 $ 500.00 $ 275.00 Date Palm, P. dactylifera 65 gal., 5' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 European Fan Palm 65 gal., 5' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Little Gem Magnolia 65 gal., 8' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Live Oak 65 gal., 14'x6'x3' 5-1 $ 300.00 $ 500.00 $ 200.00 Red Maple 65 gal., 12'x5'x2112 4-1 $ 225.00 $ 400.00 $ 175.00 Sago 65 gal., 4' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Spartan Juniper 65 gal., 6' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Torulosa Juniper 65 gal., 6' 5-1 $ 250.00 $ 500.00 $ 250.00 Windmill Palm 65 gal., 8' 5-1 $ 300.00 $ 500.00 $ 200.00 Winged Elm 65 gal., 12'x5'x2112 4-1 $ 225.00 $ 400.00 $ 175.00 F:\DOCSICity of Winter SpringslOrdinanceslArbor Tree Protection Appendix C.jd Footnote: I. Costs subject to change. 2. Credit ratio; for each preferred tree planted, credit may be applied toward the replacement requirement. (Example: For each Yaupon Holly at 25-30 gallon, 6' tall planted, a credit of2 trees will be applied toward those trees.) Page 2 of 2 APPENDIX D CALCULATING TREE PROTECTION ZONE The following guidelines shall be applied to determine the Tree Protection Zone: 1. Evaluate the species tolerance of the tree: good, moderate, or poor (See list on next page) 2. Identify tree age: young (< 20% of the trees life expectancy), mature (20% - 80 % of the trees life expectancy), or overmature (>80% of the trees life expectancy) 3. Using the table below, find the distance from the trunk that should be protected per inch of trunk diameter. 4. Multiply the distance by the trunk diameter to calculate the optimum radius (in feet) for the tree protection zone. . Example: A healthy 60- year old, 30" diameter California black walnut (poor tolerance, mature age) 1.25' x 30" = 37.5'radius tree protection zone. Species Tolerance Tree Age Distance from trunk feet (per inch trunk diameter) Good Young 0.5' Mature 0.75' Overmature 1.0' Moderate Young 0.75' Mature 1.0' Overmature 1.25' Poor Young 1.0' Mature 1.25' Overmature 1.5' Source: Trees and Development. a Technical Guide to Preservation of Trees During Land Development, Nelda Matheny and James Clark, 1998, International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, IL 'J:J= :c -~ ~. .~ ia-.!!! "iic i:~Q cS u l'O -. ... ~E~~~g~ ~l5.i~u6..~ ~e"02581'1l ~8c::I~8'O ~ fO't:l .... 0 o~gij~l..~ r;Q.'D"'~ ~ ~~~.Qbr:-"2cJ C~l'O...,03uu 0-=8Fo_5c tU.E Sl.... A.i.E6,2 B ~~.9 C! '5 cO2 ~C'O~&.--E~ Ci'd"'5D~"''O fO,f;Cbw J:ObO .a !1 ~ "5 S 2".5 41 t; ... .... ::: 8 8 'ito "'_c::..__ )!OO':::'vo"'::1 .0.... u.!!s....o.2 !lO!ia'B'B!ic:~ 1~~&.E:~~8. 0...,11'1.....0...._ 63.s~.Eg.s~~ '8'8" 8c,,~ .~ ~ ~~ri - .... ~ 5 )( co::.. ~ S s :i"3"a ~ ~ ~ ~"'("'( CLI .... >,::1 ~ .6 Q.I ~~(;- .o-5..x , v ~~.5 Eo". o .c "" ='O~ u~~ ... 8 c. 41 .... cO ... CLI'8 ~8 l.: ..::i oS bO ] ~ " ~ ~ ~]j 'S :: a~ ~] ]"5 -.s:::: '<~ u ~ ..x u ::I .0 o :a o C ~~ Cli fO ~~ ::1- .0 0 '0 u tilE. .:J. :; o ~ ~ ;.,. C OJ -5 .. ~ >. .0 .. o OJ ~ & '" >.. .0 a1 -= ... 11 So ~ '" < - " ..... '" lU U > s:: 'l:I I! .!!~ lU 0 ~- ....' ~ ~ '" ; - 0 ~ 1.R~' ~ G~ II c: 1.1 S e o u ~ ::l l tE : t. Q..4J :!;l38 :I toO'" ... C 0 ~o- o..~c .... .c :! 0...1.1 v~o .. .... , .. ... ,s C -;a . 8-513 .. >' > B:O~ uc:t: u - 0 ~~.;; ~o~ 1J...~ ... Q. ';j .!!5~ .0 be J! , I! .s · 41 4i ~b2 C:C:u e~5 3: - ... O:!'C ~~~ 1.1 iV t '8 "8 Z ~~ 1.1 E lIS ~I~~ 5 !:i!O ~IH E I 11:1 C c: o E s:: o u ... fJ ",::2 ... '" "'oc "'0 " . ~o::: Cl.I .... 0.. ~ c.. .... o -[ Vl e.' o .c .... ..... Cl.I .. 8~ ... ClJ "8 u ~ r::I U .z >, c: _ t Cl.I Qj ~ Qj "0-5"0"0.0 01000- u:::EuuG .... o .... .a ... .... >.. . 0 "8 Vl. ~-6 u....o>.. .] .Vl ~f)~~ -.t::- 0- U oou ClJ vi5:vi~ ... Cl.I "8 u .c u ~ Q.J r::I ~ ~ ..c: ~ t>o J: ... o C "C >- Vl ~' ~ o vi .... GJ "8 u ~ '8 u I I ~ Cl.I .... ~ ~"C .....!i-~~ ,c_::lE ~ ~ c:~=~~ ~ 1.1 gi-~~ ~ ]~~"Ct ~OCl.l"8 ~==~ ~ IOCl.I~~E ooe'" a..... ~B~3 " ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 0 n ., ~ ~ ns ;... to ... ~~~~B 1U"~ ~~ ~~~~ >.. C:~...'" >Cl.I. C:u'" c:>c> ;:: ClJ "..." ....u... Cl.Il'lS"'1O '" E __u ... -c:~ ~~ ~ E '=I _]:o~ '=0 i!idb!l>- Gi...t v ...o~~~~... ....~~ ~~. :=~ ~ a. F '0 c: ~ DO 'I: ::l 'v .v 'V ~ 5~C:~B5...~_ ~~~ c:lIS....c o.~o.3: 0. DOid- ~3:c: 8'05'0 ~ 8c:~g~~~ ~O::l En 858~ 1.1 "'1I:I"'c~-~E ~~1U ~v ~c:...c: .b s;!.c:o- C'Gl)i O'iJ -0.n:.o08_0 u o.u_. C "0 'i ...Q::J ... .....~~a...J~-g:::i~G~ .~5~~cO.e:~ .2 >""''tJ-:.:... 1Oa::l'Q.....~U....o~Qj>..Qj 11:1 ~'5 -~- ~o.c~ II:Ig~31O~1I:I ~ '=-;:::~ ~ 8.2.'1:' "0'" 0 E ~ 0 o.-.c _~.2.:::l . c ~....s~-f)-oEic:n~.5Oco be ._"' .... c:: ~~~ 4."')--"", c~~~>g~~ogo:~ Cb~~>-~~ cV~5u~~-00uc::lEo~~~~~.o 2"'~ ~vc~"'5 08 ~C~=~C~ 0.0.s~B8.~~~O~E~w~~u8e"'~~~ ~u w~ u...~ u- ~.t::_..c:_ o=~u~~~~vo~~'~~ ~ ~1I:I~e OC:EC~OEcC~O E~ 'Oos~e- ,,:: CLI '- f! .:; ~ I! ~ ~ co 0 3 ~"- c.... C 050~~-o~~_oi~o~::l~'0000 -o.-oc~-ooo_ ~ oO=~V_U co~-~~cF:_5~~a_lU~ij~c~ ~it~~Ct~~~~t~5~~R~ctg B~Be~EB ~~~B'gng ~J1 &~_~ ~]_~ Eg~~~~5~~~~e~E~~a~~E~ ~ '2:.:..'2 o 0 ..- 0 ... '+2=~ "0 '" .0 !II ~ :3~~ ... . ~ 11:1 ~ .a~c>c:: 11:1 c: 1.1 .. U ~ ." 5 ~ E ofj;~; CIUj:l.,~o. ","'E'CE; .!!~8;e E2uoco ~[E:~!. .....;J~IU?-- 8 ... .2.:: .2. ~ ..g.s~.s~ B '0 ;a >..;; .0 ~e~~~E C1:l~IU;.:o l:!u-5E~'O ~"ul:!~u B)!a~s~ GJO"'-c......~ '1;;D00800 ~~S5l~~ e .~ 11 C ... ... I ~ 1.1..... 8.~~ -5B~gB Eel..5p::,s.s sl 00 ~ oS ... ~ t 5~ "\ - t!-S = ~ ...:: :: -:c, ..... ~ 41 ... "0 41 - .!) 'Il ... _ U G.I .~ N ... r::I .. :x:J{ ~ "" ... 1.1 '0 o ~ !! I'll U ~ "8 n E 'O"')!'8.:. o 800 0 ~j:l.,oog "C o o ::>0 i!. .., ... u "8 ~ ~ :2 GJ '8 ~ '0 o o DO tJ - cO ... ~ ~ CoI 11 -0 o 5 .:. 8 t1, ~ '" ... ~ "8 ~ CoI e u '8 ~ ~ l!! u '8 ~ c:: ~ c:: .~ .;:: l::! e ] ~ ,sa '- ;g. .~ :: c ... is ,- Sti~s .::r:C~ci.. ~ ~ E 'g ~ .5: -S *= ..:: ~ 1: .s .S ~ .2 -<-<~~~ ~ ~ oE ~ .. c: .r; ;;;z ~ r;; l':I ~ Cl.I ~ ~ c: ' ...... 0 l':I E :=i5 :::l.....r; :> ~ ;: v; ~ O::E~~~ ~ ~ ,. Vi "" 'S .~. ~ ~ - c:: oS E \.I CQ S 5! .~ e oS .sa ~ :::: ci5 .c:: ~ ~ ~ oS i: ~ !:: ~ S: g, oS a " CQ ~ :~ i:- oC' e .~ c:: ~ ~ c ~ ~ c - ~ CQ .~ ] ct: ~ u of U 'E 41 VI .!: e:; ~ Jl! c:: 5 .E E ;:l l.j .- -g :0 ... .f! :u - .c: ~ :0 .r; ~ :0 [ ;:. .c. ~ :0 ... ~ cz .s: U ... :c >.. ~ a ... -= ], :; ~ c::: .... c :,.. o o ... 41 "C o U "" ~' nl.c Of) ~~ >.= C .... .. I,.l .....'" 0 .r; Q.I !:: -'0-0 III 0 >.. ::EUVl "C _ 4J I'll _ :Ej-(l 6 5 ~ E E 41 o ~ ~ _:;U ~ C ~ ~ u 4) o.~o- ~...~ 13 C . V)o~ .~ ~ ~c:..c: ~ 8 ::; "0 _ ~ t <<; ~~~ I'll U ..~o -o;a- 16 '3 ~ ... v C ...:cll)~ .Q~]DO .... 0. 0 ~ 8 &..,...... M ... u'O u "'""" ... tJ >- 2,g]~ 5:;...J c: Gi .E ..; .5 (3 "'" ~;a oJ U ~.... .s'5S;i ClJ Cl.I e ~ ~ ... '8'0 ~~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ;:; .:: ~e ~ a ~ !? '" ::: ~ '- _e- 00 ~ '. c Cl.I.c. ;:a ~~~ c ~ E ~ !I 52 c:-- - CQ __ ._____~,.~._#<IJ~........._.. ~ .lIC ... ftI o "t:l c: III ~ C ClJ .c. ~ ~ >.. J:J .. o .i ~ ::l o ... >.. J:J .. '" .:; 'iI '0 .... c: DO ~ " .... C,I v 1.1 J;! llS CI lie 1:1::... ~ :s o .\') .. o c "R ~ OJ. o .s: ...%! f..I.c. "8,~ u:c c C "C >. '" ! .:.l ~ :; 8~ ~~ :>. ;::... ~~ -X ~. .. .... tQ "' 00 vi vi <E cu: OJc"'Q./ ::.:..E-EE ;...::>0.._' ~. ~ :5 ~ ~ ....- :so~oo :s _we ..!!~1IQ..~ .!! '!ic>cc ;; "0 >1lII'lItQftII ~ r .... ",b~~~ ftII i ~;2j;g~ t ~ ~t!o~~~ j tQ OC"'ti"'''' oc .... laE-::EE c -g c .a '~ -a .a ~ ::: gg~gg ~ .2 ~'B""B:e :!! ... ~2.s22 ~ 8 :g;;!'I1;;~ :g ... ...cacc '" g >.8c88 ~ Q./ .o-a-.... .0 u"':oco 00 oc caQ./...:l(....... Q./ G"'.s~=ij; c oE:!!t&.t1~ ~ ...o~-o"'-- ... CI"'t::...Q./gg c "':30>.:::::~~ 0 .!lZ",u_ '"il'il'U "'d~Q./~E_..el': "'---"'ftI"'~fG'" Soc..c.....;cc ...... 0 GJ" Q./ Q./oc 0 I ~ ~ ~'8 ~ '8 -g ~ ~ I .5::>cz::~>~~>~ tl Cl GJ 8 S o U 8~ (:)8 Q./ ~ C u u::; 4:2 j ~ ei':::! ~ I:l .... ::s~ i'e !8 GJ C ~ ~~ c o.!:! Cl ~'5 o :C::s E~...c:: ~ ~~ ! ~ .- ~ Q./ ...] ~~ .~ E .a~ ;:..Q e{\ ~~ aa C j~ 1.1 0 ._~ .cu :;:E c... .. ::s GJ c t::oo iiiiS:: 88 00 00 u iJ ~s ~~ -a ~~ :S~ ::: c g.~ aa ~ ] 1.1 ;.c ~ g! c.~ .. o c " :>. Vl ~ .. .. .. 41 41 ftI '8"80 UUvi .. Q./ 0 ~ -6 .......%!..fn' OJ OJ OJ .. GJ oc '8 '8 00'8 ~ 8uuxuc fa '" '" OJ .2 ~ f 8 'O;s ... ....!! B ~ ~..;..; 41 ~~~~ ~ ~ c.c.s .. -SE_ - ~ - - 0 ~ ~515.E 5 ~ e e OJ " r:g.g.~ c O-"il" o ~~>GJ :c ll!t.lGJe ~ ~"" Q./ J::I =i5== '" o~ .-- g ... ~ :t ,,; 1.1 E"2 "2 :g ~ ""~M ~ '2.!lZ.!!"O C ,S~\.!~ t! :!~~~ .!! ..IOIQ~ B gee III >-,UOJGJ- Qj~",:O:Oo ~ asec OJ 0 CI. 0. id '8 s ~~ ~] ~~&~~~ I Q./ II -:.i. ... .. OJ Q./ "''8'8 g~~ .!l .. ... '" '8.!l ~ e"' II! ' . t ''']''0 8]8~08 c:.":;Q.,,,,,ClCl ~ ~ oS ~ S. ~=ijE Q ~~ !!! c c j o v 1; c:2 :Co- xij:S :a "::I E .0,.1;.;1.1 bO~ ~ "' ~ g 6iVl~ ~ u~.s ~l:l ... .e.. 'i! t:.., ~:S!i r:i.~"e ~ ~ a.. a.".,. ~ ;lI: l1 5 ;;r"oQ ... .l:::t:t:a2.~ !:I..~--=% ~t;~.s~~ ~aaaaa c C r: '6. ~-~ ",,,, -c.J 0. C 0. 0. .- ~ f'I ~ S -=:cv "'''' :s:2>. 1.11.1 .~ 1.1 5 ftI E E iI",-,=c.u - ~ :g to!.~ € ~~~<1~~ .. :::I ti3 =:; ~ '0'8 8u o t: 'P V:)' ~ -B .:::. .!!.P ::x: :>.; "' o .8 := Q./ 0 ............ r: "" r: .. C:C::.:..- r: o Q./ 0 0 ....~ 0 c.... > -= :C:::l III ';C '~ ~r3;SB ~ ,... ~ :3=~ _ ~ x "'"'-~ III - 1.1 cc!:.E C ~ '0 E~"'''' e ~ =ot: ~2. ~ '" e '" :; '" ~ ftI tlO tgo.o.~..c c. r: B~e8-gt) E :g .sg.~~~~ 8 ~ ~~ g gilt; g Q./ """'..... .e-.e, '" ~ .e, 1.1 I:;"g ~~~"' ?:- fa ~ftI:s:s~~ 3 oS c -e .E ,S ~ ~.!d .= ~ ~~]'5~]~G ~ t) E'E''2i .13'5 2 5~~~~]~~ fa -"'E!s.l::-.ae j2 g-g...._28~..... B >.~..!:! 0 0 8':: B 0 . >-eoi7'C"'uoui: =;;OJc~~5~c~'" ..."0 ",,e Q./ ~ ~id ill" Q..J-... "'-- ""...- 1r:::l..!:!oBB ,!!u,8 ~]~E.s.E~~B.s g t:l ~ '" ~~ 8 o e i ~ ~ ~ ~ ! .~ -E ~ ~ 1.1 1.1 .. ftI .~ o oS,S u;a '~'- S :s .gS ~-E ~a ~ III .D ~ c~ ~ ;loG ~ i ~ ..~ tlO~ ~ ao :x: .. QJ -0 8 c Cl.I :::l 8 ~ Q./ :9 G 41 ~ '00. o 1.1 u~ g c %~ B ~ ',C= ~ ;S a~:E e '" "'''3.!! o.i ~... ~c~ :J ",~;:l ~~ ~~ ~~~ !:'I 0 ~_c o.llI", ~::J... ....c.~ :;0 'tl"" OE'O g~ c::~ toe: ....2 idS ~UtQ ~o ,g.2 585 ~ ~ ~ ~S ~ ~u ,eo ~ ilio... 0 _ -eo.~llI= g,...~ .a~'C:::l:!! ~l!.= ~-3-~~..!:! ~c~ v 79>.0 ;i>. og"c,c~ _v.o oCZ:: Q./-o.::l c';:" .. 's"'" ....jiu "g.s..!:!'s e f:!_.GJ-8= '" - o.~", ~ .a..o OJ .s ~.g.g. -g~~e", rr::"'c::l'" 'l::O~""'C B ~ :;-8 ;. e E ~ 8 u-.J:all.l'il:::lac&: >""32>Sl ~r: -::1"'1.10__ 410 -Z;;Q./'-Cl.-U~-o. r.r:'t::..,.!!:oog~ Vi S s.~ ~ .l! ~ E cz: "C 8 o ~ G '8 9 .. o o c.. ~ ~ ~ "' j~ ~j :i ... ~ 'S~~s 5S.t:g ti .g :t't: .t: 'N - 2.. S- ~ a o~ I .B I (3 ci. l't "'1;;- t: j ~ a ~ ~~ .~ ~~-gto ~6 oo's ~ '0 1.1 V ~ o 'O~ ::s .. ,c.:w: "2::1 cz:< ~ ~ :s .!I ~ '" ~ t ~~ GJOO ... C ~;E .. 1.1 '0 8 .:.i. :;I o '0 ; :>. C OJ .c ':G ~ ~ ... o e: !3 o '" >- .c " .:; '[i '0 .... t: ~ '" < o c: 't1 >.. I ~ ~g I .cC.c t: ~.lI..- Zl 0 11 I .8.c aCU.c c: :l _ 00 00-0 .~ I G ~ :E (1) , ;a . ...= C;c CU"O ~ s:: _Ill c.... g,,= a ~ E"O o~ ~~ . a:: :ll -"'Icu..... 1350 .... tQ ... "2..;5 ... '" .. nl 0 cu a:O~ ~~~ 'tl 00:l S::.5 - ",~.5 ~t:bO .9 c.-E .......;s: ~~~ \6.ot,,-a o 0 s:: ... .... 0 ~5;J .,., .. rQ ,,"CUllO ~~] ~I ~ s o U .>0: ~ o ~ >.. 5 ::3~ @;:;: .bO ~~ .Eg 2-E :6~ ~4 "illO 01; =- -E.5 c 5 o E ~.!! tlOc. ]g. -s .... .~ ~ .... :l U 5' tQ~ IlOIlO IlO s:: s:: c: "2"2 "2 222 c.c. 0. ... .... ~... ~ ~.- ~ o'O~o ~........., ~ C 5 '" c ~~~G ---0- Fa~EFa w . (:) (5 g -5-6 .g ~ ~~ ~ . ..,~. 0; -5 d:.c .,g "C ~ ....::l .. l! ~-g~~~~ cI:UU::Z:UX ~ "' :0 cu E ~ .s ~ c: ... .0 :2 :6 ~ .:;; 't1 c: . "' '" ~~ ~] c.ll! ...B ~ ~ .....S ~ ~ !a c: .. .., cu ~ ;2:9 .. u "0 <3 ;, "0 o U .. u -g U V '0 o U ... .... ... ... w U U ell U GJ "C-g~"O-g 8uu<3u ... o R V) Qj~fQjb "08"0"0 o .Q 0 U uu g GJ 6 o .... '" ~ rQ ... ~ II 'tS 8 .... DO GJ ~ ~ ell ell ~ &I ~ ~ ... ':;j ... G S ... rQ "' ~S .. ~ 4:i .. ~~~ "0 88 g"O"CI ~~" u 8~g8i ~~~] 410 8 ~88 ~ -g -g '8 c:::... ~ O~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O~ ~ ~ ~ 6 "~ cu ... 1:S.s;: '5"- f: .5 ~ ~ ~ 3.€ .u i: .2 ~ D l:l'~ :g1:S e~ ~ 0 to & r; -~::s .R::s~ ._~ .- S !t:- "S a l:l ~ ~.g C - ~ ~ ~ 's: ~ ~ ~ ] E ~ ~li ~ oS ~ e .~ .!::! .E,.~ ~ ~ ~ fa:a.~ ~!ij ;.,.~.g:l ~.lJ~:s.g ~Si a "l:: ~ '" :0 .S ~ l:l ~ ..Q "'"t: - r; s:: .!;.S ~.s~.s._O~._~.g ~ -e 5ae~E ~ ~i ~ cu ~~~ >( ~>(~I::]lI-~i ~ J:: ~ :s Cf ~ ~ J1]~~ v Ii;; ~ J: ~ Ii;; &.... - ~ 0 ~ :i ~ V) t:i; t.t; t:i; GGG GG ::::;e::t::::;:::;;: --~ tI ] :b ~ "~I~ .. ~ '" ~ ~ ~ .0 ~ ... ~ ..c: ....~ :c ~ :a .c O~! ~8 f ~ (5 u ~ ~8~.~= .c '" G:i r; r~ '" "'. .Q~ .:;; -= ,Q"'c:~~a ~ 0 .c ... 0 ev .2- ..r.; .58~]S~~_6c: 8 "' "" ::a "\l ~v c: ";; .i; oX C :g~ .:= - Q,I c:s::-...~&. 6 ij -g . r"'c: e ~. Q,I ~ o ",=,_ lU V t cu "E- :;-5 ell-- O.~ ~.E- ='- <3 ... ... ~ ~}1 ~ 0 :9~ u ~ uo~g~ ~<a~ caO a C] :I: ::s .,-J' =:-- ".-----.....-----.-.-.- ~c~ g~gcgc ~~~ ~~~~~;s . ."CO =4_fO_tG ~ Ii::: t.I ,fg :;; -:! :;; ~ :;;i o C ~ v c ~ C > C > ~ u ~ C t.I", U "' t.I ~ U {~~ E..i:~i:~ cu ~~ t:~f~E~ i! ~.Q ~"'","''''l'' ~r- c.3:o.:tc.$ ~ E"CI ~ E'O E'tS E-o '" 0 c: C 0 C 0 c: 0 c: "CI Vllloij V nl"V III VCQ C .. c... .. c: ~ c ... c: I'd ~o- 000000 '" :c o~ 0:0 0:0 '" III~ .e-ll!all!.&~ ..2 'v"" ::>"Q,I:>"Ui"lU '0 ::::;'evE ~f"'~;""'3nl o . "2.~ =fi -~ -= -= "'~'sSlo .5Sl.5Sl,SSl sa c: - >- t ~ >..;; >-"ii >- ~~~.oe j,2oC.!:!.Q.!:!.o cS S::"2 0 .c'BS'Bc:~ III ..c....urQc.ac:~c; .!! 'B - ~ ~~ 1! ~ ;; ~ c; B~E1;;ll!E-=>E.t:E::: cu-....2..~....c....2....2 ~.:08~::l080.808 :aoccuS:!CQ,lClIJCGJ t.I"'''''''''tl'''rQ'''rd'''''''~ E C ... Cue: .. s:: .. c: ... ~ "''''0''' UOQ,l~UO Qj~-c.-";::Ioc..- -0. _-.8"'E~_!;f".8 g", oS ~ .s ~ ::l .~ E ~ .s c::: .s ~ I I I I ~ ~ -to t.I v s:: ll! Q,I ~ oj llO c: -E j v o o S .B d Q,I llO V ; ;.... 4:i ~ 'B7i "0 s:: ~.s eoS :Ji ~ a ~ s:: .., >- 5 oS III ~ E .. o t:: :3 o '" >. .0 .. " -= Ii ~ u C DO '" ... - - < - " .... u u u > C ~s 1)- t:l:S u u S o II) .. u "0 o U .. u "0 o U .. t:J 0 ~"O.a 00>. UU." 1lI o ..I:; ... .. u .. .. .:::l 0 Uo.U~.t::C "0 GJ 00 '0 o lU"8 ._ >. Uc..UUJ:VI g~t~g t ;=~:S~;:: D .:::1.0....0 ~ "'='" =3 e~~:;;!:! l3. C > C > C ~ B !i~j! ~j Co~o.~l1 0..... e'l:lS"OE; ed 8~858 SS ... d ... C'" ... 0.. &.ggg8. 8.~ ~~,9,~~ _~ .a= g==.2.~ ~-S ";COCO.5 c-.::: C-.,,'""'" ~-~ ~e~es"B-ee'B 5]13~i~~$.CQ ~.c .s .c i '5 i3.c g 'I:l~~~~G./G./l:::: .~e~e~S~E~ .,-,.....,c......a:;.....""""""c ~08080oou ... ~ ..-~,..,- G./C:UCG./c::c::c.o 2 ~ C ~ E ~ ~ ~ e 8. ~ &. oS:! 8..!! oS:! oS:! c. ~ 0 0_ 0 ~ 0 0 0 ~ u-i:i-GJ...._~CJ CI:-Sc::ECI:.5.5.5c.. II II o U .. .... ftI ... .. "'"'l;7 o 0 ~~ G./ e C! u ~ 5 .u II) .s l:I 5 :: :: t: - - .s ~ i:l ~ ~..t: ~~ Uu ... ~I ~ c', >! u c ~ g ~I ~ ~ 01 = c ui ~u ~ ~ ~ GJ G./ E f G./ U "B ... '8 ~~~ e :::: ?::- %- ~ .~ ~ u .s: "0 S. c:: !: -"="1:: S oc: oc: '::::CQ c::~~ ~ = = E E E aaa G.I III ::;, ~ .t::. ?: .:..& U :::J l:Q "88 "8 ~ > o !)" ...- >o~ !)" "0 "0 OOOC>O "OCt: to ";: -= "8~~ 1(1)-- IQ..Q..Q Co. .... .... u ... ... ... ~~~j] 0- t: - t: ~ ==t::ci.t! €.~E~e ~ ~ e l:I !:l l:Il:I=t:>>& :::::~s.s c: c: ...~ I: e aaauu c .. o 8~ ~ ~ so "il to 5'00.........1:; ~"C~;:= .., 0 - v a.il ... 0- '=E~~!2 ~~~;v~ c..v;c::::r:u '2' .9 -:u N ~ !9 C ~ ... 0. e o 1.1 .. o o So ~ =' :E '2 ~ .c u G.I e - o ... C ~ G.I "0 ... .5 ~ ~; ~ ~] :; ilB .0 ... u ::! ~ S ;; 20 :s ::!~ u '0] e ~ o~ : ...... Q..I 0>" ~ - go t:J 8;; ~ .. v .9:= ~ u?: e Vo .c ~.s -g G./ 'I:l 0> "0 c: . ~ ~'E~.9 i; 0 l; u :a.....o:o G.I~"':C E ..0-2 a.' .. 0- .... ~ ~E-c.... .s~.9~ o .a >. VI ...: :; u ~ >. "tC 01111: coO... "0_", ~ (3' ::E c:: s e ~ Ii 00- :: "". ~.5 ~:: $ 8: ~"s.to ~... ..~)> !:! 0 !::) ~ 1; g ~ 0 &E&tl:::G~~ SES~~c$~ e -a. ~ ~ ~:: ~.g (J uU(J (,JQ o t ~ ~ c: .. ~5 B .. .::Ie. " 15 Q..I'" 6 ~ 0.0 .... C ~ 0 -;0 .U t.9 ~~~ :.: J; ~ ~.:2-e 'I:l~.E .s:s~ ~ "'- o~;;; "''0- ~a2 ~B 2 e-~oS:! u 0 0 ~~.s g t:) ggg t.:)Oc.. ~ 6 ~ ~ c:: ~ \J ~ ~ i ~ ~. .!:i ~ " l:) !: i: -- ~ ... c ~.2 O~.9 - cu.;: ..!!: =c !::. 0 u - 0.5 t:: = ~ .~ v;~ t:J 0 "O,a 0>. UV) ~ III U ~ >.. .. fl ~ '8~"8 U~U c i....:. o 0 S "Zl ~ D ~:€ ~ ~ ... ~ '" .:3 ~~ E. ~ E~ ~~~ a~ [00. s~ s....e 8 E 8 ~ 8 o.!! og ($ ~[ s..sg ~... ~~o'~ .2..;:) oJ :3 .s~ :S=c a~ "B~~ .5ii3~~ij -5 ~ 11'5 S '5 u"'cu~u s~=eoe '-"cW')t:"""'......... 0_... 0 >... 0 c2eci~ ~ c-o~f!-:!! c- U III G.I &J U "OJ2i "0"0 0 ~o..,-o- .5 F-"O-.5-~ ,5- III e ~8 ~o 1:! U U :!eB U u U '0 "Coo 000 ~~~ E u .a Q. l:I ~ ~ ~ -l:Il:I~ci. ECi:t:ic. 1: ~~ii.'" ~~~g~ S~J3ecZ C III .M 0 iU .,g o 2.... ~ \J _ E ~ E GI - 41 ~ l3 ~ ~.j~ ... o .a >.. VI .r;:' u .C ] '" ~ ?:- =' oS o ... GJ 2 o 0. a.i ~ ;C :c .. 0. o lU o V c:.. = cO c." C ... >.. "2 "0-;:: 2 c:: I'C ....; ~-= Coo u G "''''''0- 8:::l 1IJ ~ ... iC .=: 0. ........."'''''' 22~~ C ~ lU ... _ftS. c; ~ ]_0:; o 0 0.... .......~'" .5 .5 ~.~ '5 <5 .;: --,.g ~ u >. e -g ": tL.U~ .:Jl.:>J!.'..I:; .. t: ... .. :a ~ U~G.I..!!!_.t:: "8='8uu~ Ut.:)Uv;vi:J: ...; ~....:.. ... c ] .g .... ~ '" N 2:;; ::!c~ BE3 41.....0 vii..!! 5 =-~ OJ c: ~ -....0 e ... ..:; . co", tlO_ 0 ~ oS ~ E:'t:l C I\: >. c g -c ... III o.G.I=::J ... e =-.0 8t=~ "-<:.5' .0 oS.~ .C:ll C ~ ~c:; ftI_'ti"iU ~8E~ B.....c:: >...... 0 e 'B~=41 e ce-2' ut2.!:!8. l~ ~-~ I "0 8 00 ~~ ~ ~ - U u .....~'8"B ~~8~~ ~ ":: 5 ~ :: t: 0- '_ ;; oe=: ..~ s.._ ;:: Co !2 ~~!~~ ~ 1t.. ;: ~_ l:I 000 ... .E - t!~~-=:.:: ~c;!::!~ ~~~~~ .l: ;... V 4U eo .r::..::; ~ Yo _ .M Ii :. .0 .::~ cc~ .:; l'Q r; _ ~ o~ ~;;:- III t 0' = .~ E~~~..c: .o(~:r.-<~ .~._........ '-~- -~-_. . ._-----:.- ~ "8 U 'I:l 8 o ~ U 'I:l C '" >- 6 .c ~ ~ 1; ... o ., ~ o .. J; I: ~ :~ e 5 ~ .~ c..; ... .., .:; Cj "C Ie ClI .f: ~ (5 -;; ~ < U - .t:: ;a "" :; o c!I:S >.. u E ~ ~ ~. }; ... o c: "'C >.. V) u' 9 '3 .c t>O :I: -'" :0 U ~ >.. c: u ..c - >.. III '" };o O~ ~t~ f - "E1ij3"O ~~ ~~~ ';;E ~~ E'B:;; .5.B -e~ ~5~~~o ...of! oE...g't:lZ ~o... Q.i;;t::~;;B:O .cC:lJ;Q>_ _ >....=1 C Q. ~ ~ ~ Q. cl'll.e-Sg't:l~~~ -E-a-vfa~..J'" C)ClOcuB...!:; .~ e.5-5!180~:s~ ...r:: I'll Q.::l I'II"'ii 02'8~--~:o=> .SQ.oa::;~~..!!c..; e 5 ~ E .:t:;:: E -g (5 c:~.ccu.s~OraO GJl:I"'- ....... > :l 0.5 iV ~::3 ~'O cu-c.... .v....u~ tIOU"'~C't:l ~ .s ... cu 0 '" cu 0 0 ..; ~ ~ g = -e ~ E 0.:0 ] c:- o N2cu...O_r:: :l ::::ec~E""-c8'" '0'- .EUo__c~",cu]e.s >..Q.i~ 00 e ~o ~"'-ftl __v........ -ldrJOV ==.g~c::c:~ cu.cl:l....<;l .9-e~~c~~v..,t:iij '^ ... Q.~ ~ 0 - _ 41 C e .c "" ~ ... 0 0 9-:gc: '" -C .... u v u cu CJ ..- 4J --. '" "' ~ _ AI 2S ~ ::.E..9~::>~ l;O~~ 6 " :3. c: U. e e o u M ., II V ~ ~. III ., "0 8 CI;... Q., ~ I'll ... CIJ "'C o ~ ... o J!. ... ... g 8 c..~ ., s. ._ ~. ~ iC .:::: :g ~ cu ~ '0 ~ v,'~ t::; .~ E oS ~ .;::. ~ ~ ~~.!a .... - - - ~ ... .s-.~ ~S.... .;::...::.. cu e llJ c: c: o C ... c: o U - :l ] ~ :0 .~ ~ o - :l c: -;:c ?; .:.<: .... ~ 05 c ;s c c ~ :: > 0 ... ..;~~ E~c ~g2. :J.J CC ......-... . . -......-....-.,,-. 8 o ':: ... .~ 'Eo ';;: ~ !:: .~ ..::.. .. ... "'C u v "'C ~ E ~ ~ ~. -",' <5 .c ...:;; c: '" ~o "'C :c 0 _'" ~ CoO C1JU~ I -9, >- .c' ... .... ~ c .... v .... 0 ... ~ ... QJ 0 :a 8~i-g~O~i~ VlU;:r;cn~V)~ '- o c '" ... CIJ B oS _'0 o c -5 ::: "0 CoO 5 ~ c ~:a :a e;.c 5 :l 8 e '.5-'" ~ ~ :: 0 -...'" .. 081:10 cu ;....a ~ ~~~ "2 2~~ J) ~lCo. toO .... 0 0 ,C .... .... .... C '2 ~ cu 41 0 2 '" a :l ~ ... '^ &" 1; - ~ .8::0 ~~~~~ o.~e;i~ E'g~~; :!e5.5~ I ~ ~-J1-:5 8 ~.sg~..s .!i '0 '^ i t'lI ... E I'll .., - o ... c '" ... u '0 .E ~'8 ..a 0 8~ ~ O~~ ... u 8 ... u '8 U .... u "'C 8 .:.fo' Ri U ~ C>... 5 ... -s 0 Ill! ~V) t ~ '0" 88 c' '2'2'ij ~~ c~- .gg~.gftj ~.s .~.g~ "'-'::"'t'lIQJ "'I'IIQJ !:l':ii~.!::l~ ~-- :3~to 'iO=,BCiiu 't:lg :3"'cu 5S5E~ ~~ 55~ ~B~f~ ~-i ~~-E So ~ a. C!.r i ~ a. 6..F 6'Cee~ "2-: est, 858 e t: 8 ~ e 8 c ~g"""'~ ~~ 80~ .e.~i!~ S~ &&~ ~~~~e e= ~~~ -::::I --:::1 .Q Ill' 2..2..:3 .E~.E.s5 ~E E.5~ ~se~~ 8.~ G~'~ ~ ';:1 --E :liG "2"2S '" id~550Q.iEU~",1'II0Q.i'g '5ii1-5ifi ~~ c: &;-5-2; ~iG e~Ee~1!!5:;-e6e5eB -g........~~&~2........CJ~~ ovoo_~-c"C::!oo_:c_ C cuE-~g '" ...3vE-g '" 0 t<i"'", "C:"':l~I'II~"C_ . t g t !I .s g 0 ~ ~. ~ QJ .5-_5 -] -~ E B'f3 -5 ~-2 -c '2 B~ -:5 J1 .5 0: ..5 ..s :i .~ 0: cs. 5 .s ..s :J .~ ~ ~ '" .. cu '0 o ~ cu G ... '8'" ~ ~g .1: ~ I: ~'5.a ~ oS't:E~ .s.s~ ~ ::: )(,~ ~ ~ .~ .s. .... :lc::~~ .s s .:: -I:: I:: " ::: .... I:: - c:: t::; Et:~!:C::~ ~ Ln 1; ~ ,S .S C ;::- .... .... c; cs 'I: .~.:t ~ _ ~ C) - ~ - ro_ 't: C 't: ~ cv ~ :.:i ~~ a:: ... :l .!: c: ~ e ;;v6:, i:$_ O:lEt - ,.. ~f!!!v; u ~ .9- ~ t :: .9- ~ ~ u::::l u 0 t~ ~ ... E E i3 S( =' fC U~ " 8 co o ~ o c.. cu ~ '8 ... ~g E C) ~ 1: ~ .S Q ~ ~ eS C)~ s_ 1: l: C [ ~~ .S! .5 -- C) C) ~~ ~~ .!!! "0 c:: :ao r.l E E -5 a VI .!!! '" o~ ~fo '" '" E E E" u .;: ..c: c: -= r.l ~E ... 'a. 0- f\) .0 I'll ... V ~ E ..0 .., .. -....c t-a.-:: ~~~ '. --. .. ~ '..- .-'. _. "--.- , (5 .g >- VI lJ' 5 CJ -c..o8 0::::1 Ut,? . S .........5 g~Q. 't:liGo "'CIJ'iI ~ to > '" cu u -v'O C:s.c CUt;- €_ i '" FO" 0. CIJ E t,~ e C 0 ... IV ~ 1~~ ~ ~:o -1.10 .500- ";;lO.... iJ - ~ '2Ec. tel 0 ' .c-~ ~ ~ C s 5 e _...~ O~1: ... 0 I'll ~ -- c . u~.5€ 1~8.s~ -:Ji_ QJ ... ~E . 't:l cu QJ 8'8'8 C)~~ .:ol ... .. (J " fJ >.. 6 .z:: -:; ?- >.. .0 (5 ... l.I ~ o .., >.. .D ... 1\1 -= 'i; -a ~ c: 00 -;;; '^ -<C ~ e ~ .::: ~ ~ 'l:a 1: ' l:; 0._ ~ ~e ~ 1::2 ~ ~-- ~~~ ... o C "0 ;:>. V') ~ if :I " ~ 8 oX ~ o s ~ .g >. >- oo5o~"t.lt1t1 .g~~.a.g.g"O"O~ 8i'~~~uu88o ... o .a >. V'l t1' tI 88 ,,' c . ~ c:t;E ~,!;g. :S~Qj ::I 00;:> ~e-8 5c-5 E ~'i ~:o" Kt- ~ E t.i ftI 8 l>Ov C 0 8... ~ ~ V ftI o.llIe ~~4J =,E:o .s:ae o 0. e~t; -E~ 5 0 t.i .J::-oo "- .~ e C 4J e ~:g E .......~ ~ o.!:!._ "- ......s-;; 0 ~ cvi.... tJictj; - ... ~- ~ ... g '5 -5 a..!:! oS ;:J .~ .s ~ !~ II ~~ III =0 Ie ;c -0 " C C ftI ftI " GI V v 5 ; ~~ :6:6 gcct --=- ~~:sE -......:;; ...--.:1 55E5 e ., t.l E t:......€ I'll ... I'll ... o..~~o. E'g-o E 8 :i :; 8 ... C C ... 8.~~ g ........ tIS ra .e. . t t ~ C' ftl ... l.o' .:1 -:::I =' :E~~g ill >.. >..- o.o.cCj '2 "0 "0 "2 ftllll41-5 ~~~IJ e a a e .... 0 0.... o v v 0 CUClJC "' '" ~ Id .. C c t1 -a ~ &.-0 :5 ~ I.5 %l c U 8 c <3 -- o 0 ..... Q,/ ~ > c ~ e ~~ Q,/ 0 =:... '"0 8 toO OJ - :!! 6.1 "8 ~ 6.1 e 8"8 <.?~ ~ B ftI ... 88~gg8"8'8~ L?L?~<.?<.?o(58~ GI ~ c V ~ Cl " ~ s ~ ]- ~ !:S ~a ~.~ ~E~~ E~.B.2]~~g~ ~ .~ -a 1: ~ ~ ~ a- ~ !g:i e i1 ~.8.a ~ ~ ~~~~~}}~~ ~ j ~ ~ ~ '[0 ~~ .~ 'S I~~~ ~-o 0 {! t: s:: e a ~ ~ C III "0 .... C :I ,,' Be- ~"O .c cu v'::: "0 .... fU _~ :E ~ . C o 8. ~ v 'cz: ::3 . Sl ~ -0 ~ ~-e ~~ ra- ...."0 -000 ;~ tl 0 o ::I' - 0 ... "'" 815 .::~ o '" c= ~j .!:! tl g 0 .5..0 ClJ ~ tI '8 ~ aj o ..c: '" E bO :E ... .. .... 0 0 III C C "0"0"0 0>..>. UV'lV'l ...; ~. C,I ~ c. c ~ c .c o 5 ~ 'U a ~ e;-~ .!:!>.e;- \:1: ,g E Clot:: .0>.. III "' OoCl,ltl >">'rao 0.. III ~.o.c~"'..o-~ ..0 .r;::-- u.c ".oJ '"0 E "'e ::l S J:I E 5 got E; 0 'c 0 "8 (j "3G1ClJoWJ.=; ~o Cj.c: Q 4J.!!4JClJe.c~t:l~ ~ -':0.. l' li~!ii~i~-11-~~-r <~?~~~~~o =0 < V'l ~ "C 8 ~ ~ .. ,.;.c.c OAio~t1 .a"'8c~fo a,u~:Ex o t: ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 -Si V) c ;; ~. R .2P ..c: V'l :I:&j~ ~ ~"O~.:::!'O o85:ii38 ...; :a ....;. '" (5 C ~ ~ ~.~ ~-2 ~ ~:s f2 8- E ~] .rl 'l:l ~ ij C 0 C O "'I Ill. <0 III ... ... ~~ 0.. "0 ... '0 -eo ~ III u 4J ",'" ~ ~ 1; .5 c.."O 4J ... ......._t1 ~ e~.5 .2 R~~<"l '" ..9 .8 ~ .!! - c ~ ... ~o"E 8"'~ go '0 ~'~"E ""iJ t: --~1lI .&'OB~ ~ o .!! ~,S' ~ - ~ '0 CIJ 5~2. cG.g-s ~ e: 11~~::l -....",j c CUcu 0 -0'" . '0...'0.... o C'lI'" 8'0 00 III ~ C C '" v C ~ C ..0 c-ra"O;t--...- '!::j .a ......; ~0~..;t1C'C1 \:; ~ ~.9]~.s-B.Q'2~ [ ~.0"8"8ra-gEQ~l'll .....8- :si .s.......:j....~~FL=......; ... '0__0 O_"'iJO....= o coo~5-0.c:o"'oSl S j5ijAi8~~ge2~13 Ai ~JL~g::;]]-g~E.!1~ ~ ot2~E..Q.E~~J!Sl~-a g ;c "0 ~ '" ~ ~ ~ .. g "Q,/ cu ... _ 4J .. G C'lI "8"8t 'OAi (58~~8~ ~ .g E E.9 ts ... $:: E .sj R'=5 ~ ~~ ~'~.B~~] r C,8oj1!:Sts"ol:.::l.. l.~~~ ~g~~~ C g ~~c:a:a:Q: ... ~ ~ IV 2 ~ cu c; ~ ~ ~~2~ :::r ;>...;>... '" c..'O 4J","~""t! ...- C5....o !-is 0- ~ J3!~~~8 .... o ! ~ /!. <0 ... j~~~ 5 ~.l:? ~.st!.s :-~ 1.~ ?'.j8~ ~.~ o~.~ ~l5:cS::cS:: ~ ~ ~ '= a: 4J t:: a. "0 G./ C C I'll ..!!"S.. >-'4U~~ II c 4J J2 a. e-'z:l ~ if a () :L""IV .c ~ -.. V'l cu .5 0.. c g,. .E ~ >.. '" o ~ t! cu ~ oX ... ... a "0 ; ~ II .c ~ >.. .c o ~ g ~ s ... ... oS Gj "0 II ~ -r;;. '" < .... " ..... '" '" u ~ 2 .!!~ '" 0 ~- '" u !3 o II') ... o .a >-. Qj ., VI Qj "0 -u ;.:::. 'C 00~8 UUt:l >-. d .. o &. ... '" ~ o U o "'" r.J' (; C .. 0 C "O..~ .r: ~ ~ou ~ VI ",- .a.!ZS ~ ",' o~>-. J: 0 ..c 5 .. ..c ~~~a;Qj'~~ ::9~"8~1S~i5~ ;:;3;cu~uu~:r: .... ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ III ~ '" tb ~ 4J g ~ ~ ~ .6~.G ~~ ~E2 ~ ~ ~ :6 Sl %~. o.~ ~ ~~ ::: ....0 C ~o ~ bO 82:2 ~ E'5 ....O!J =CQ c", '0":'... 02': a~ fJ.c.... CO O-e "'2~ !~ ~:g ~-g-g 'c- ~.Q "t: (If b .= B C e "d bOe - c ~o ..6-20 .E: CE ~ fo-s ~ ; ~ ~ lS "'u&;l:tGClcij- gfJZ:::25aeo.8 "'~>\C>",~o." --....00;:.... 0....00;:::3- 0.... CQ 0 '...CQ....O ... -g C .... fo-g c ~ - ~-~G.s~~.g~ - s -.... III e... 0"_ ~::siFZ-a::si~~ :1 ~I J I 'C o o 00 tV .oJ CQ 888~ o en.:> ::g "8 <:J '" ~ c u ~ Q '" U II') .'" :s s .2 [: P]- ::: ~ .Ea c ""'Ot:~ ~ ~ :g ~ s::: r:: :: ::: Q;lS:itit ~ d ~ l ~ ~ "'. ~I e. c:j 01 e: ~I U: III III '" .S.s 111.50.0- .5 0. c ~ 0. ~ _~ ..!:! .s;2~~ ~Cl.::lo VlVl~"'" .s 0. III V'l o 4i "'C e o c... :0 =3 00 0 1a V'l _ "CI. "ti ~'" ... 1lI~ o ... '" '" ..ld2~ ::J.....-...41 Sl 5 SL:: c "'O"'O"ClOo. u C (i .... ~5-E25 .a"'O~..!:!'5 CQ"CQO::3>. ~-"''''OIO 'O";l'o.s",u ...c:....~B~ 2 ~ 2 ~ ~o u ,,_:::10 o~oO:O" cece~-g -&,-0&'" ~ ... ..; ;; 1.1 ~ o~au:go ~~~~~~ .. .a .. 0 ~:a .5 ....~~~ > o 0 0... ~ ce....1ii.EB e:a~t~", ~-....-1SE..5 ~.sFZ~.se: I I I "8 ~ tV "iQ .. III -u o ::g ~ III '" ~88i8i ~<:JO~O~ "'0 8 00 4- -gl o:::E .., 5 ~ :::J ~ ~ r: it ILl .5 0. .~ 3 o E u :0 ~ c:: S ~ .~ ~ ~ c::()C::::~.s ~ .5 :a~ ;:) g E t!.c: '" ~.... :g ~ ~ ~ ~ :g t: :: :: :: :: s::: ~E:a:iS:~it ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~.s ~ ~ ~s: G.I C .s.. " ell >- G.lCelIc '" '" .s .;::: 5 -- .. c _. 0- .E:!_O-tl:J..u C o..c :>0 "0 .~ o 13 ~ .2!l g t= ::2;a:C:Clc...~ '" .s ~ 0- .5.~' '" 0 o~ ~...J .. o i~ ~' V'l 12 :; aJ' - 0 ~~ ~ ~5o""~o ~-5cGJGJ';JJ:: OIll"CI"8"8n1~ V;~J)UU~Vl II vi G.I ::i Ill' iG c - ~ QjE.-u -. ~ 5~ 3ui' :.sli ~ Ctij;~ oMQD-'C C a 5 5 &'0 EB "'01::0.2 Cfl;j~'" o Q,::3 E ;:8"'0 CQ e u ~ '" 0 0 --E.t1- .8o.l:le o J:: lC C . ;.=~t:a IG....,~"" 8.ScqB3 ~~~~::: llI'OidnlO "_tJ:a", a.G'O"'~ o",-enl ~.n-~~&; ~~>.s] '" ~ ... G.I "8 s a o 0.. '0 o ~ "8~~ c3o~ '" .. .-..., ca .. GJ '8 ~ g .g 'Eo "S: ~ ~ -E c:: 8~ t: 'C '" ~ t:I ~. t~K 'S c::: ~ "" tl :: ;:s t: S ~ ~ c:: a: a: a:; .~ s ~ .~ 5 oS t: Q; u .s Co. <<I 'c .Sl,) .. ;> ell U C e '" - "'- a. '" 0. N :::: C c"O o'oGJ-g .!:I ~ 0 >c........ " ... o E !S >.. V'l E ~ Jj .. o C "0 >.. VI ~' .. '" o <Ii .. .. ~ 0 ~ 0 :a ..'.g ~ -6 o -8~u~ ~ u ",'..z ",' >-. ,0>.0 c_~..cc.r: "'~"'''':l4l''' ~ -5 ~ -ulll .r: -5 ;: ~ 0"'- ~"'oou u~c.:;.,;:r~:I;~ I I ~ 8 :0 ~ " e e 8~8~ <:J~O~ .l::l- :s t: t: ~ ;., ~E i: .-..., .-:s ~ v 0...::: cs l: 0.. i: ~ ~ ;; ~ S::1i::~..:: .sa=:= t:c::~~ a:Q;~:e "'~ ] ... 0 > o E c e IV _0 III 1.1 ~~ 0 V'l v E E t:: = cu~.!!:t Ei .~ g-; .:J~e..~ .s t."O ~~ ~c e.co ... tV c:: ... ::3 _' t;I .r: ~ .~ .!i "5 -0 ii.= 00.5 '-- "'4J~ CS.". 'Oeo t'" ~e; III .2 ii'll "--. ... ....0 .D cg _D 0.. :llEfr :1.1.'0 ..... u B ~ ;.:.22~ _ "'c_ ~e 1.1"'0>- ~~ ClIGjW')- I'd:; '0--'0 -uBCo. ':;0 cc::l", ",wi ta_O'" ~~ ~::j~S- ....g, eo..u .0 ..c....Ou ~o ."-gce il-~'O -. 'Ou-iwE'" -;:\'Qo '-......~ c-'" 00.. O~~C"""'~ ue-....cco ~ ... ~ ~ ::: l! e o~Bo..!:!..!:!:::J 6i.5~It~~Q ",'0 .. 0 t ~ 1S~ E l! . '" ....."8 g~~ oS ~ :.s ;: -~ 5 ~ _ s: - ,.. i ~.~ Cv ~~b~ ~~-=3 a.~~:-' Q;;c;.c., ~ ~ c :; :i. o 0. x g~;: "V..c:~ ~8~ ~ ~g ;>l:Q"'; .. '- ..- ~ . -.......-.....-..- ..c :a o "0 c '" >.. 5 -= '" ~ >.. .0 ... o ~ 5 o '" >.. .c .. .... = .i: -c .... c :>0 ~ -< 0 c: ... "0 0 -= >- c 0 Vl ~ "0 '" ..: .c >- .. 0 0 C llJ \n llJ' ""0 "8 :3 1;; ~ c o ;:.... ..c: llJ ",' c: ~ ~ CV) U 00 0 0 =' ..c: >. .". . s: III ... ~ ..c: ..~O .. .~ 5 5 ..c:...:V) ;:-.. .:oc: .>( ~ t~~l:l .rJ .. ..- V)li!tAilaAi .a..~ IJ - -g1~-5 ..c:~1J ;:.... >-t"O ." "'~"Oi> 'O"8~ 00 U ." :-:'08'00'" "' 8 8x8~ 8 IJ u~o~ - 0 "' 0 () 0 Oc..() Ul:Q :I:viU Olli UIIi " ~I =1 00 V) I I I I g ~ ~ I si-S~ ~5 ':::::1:0- I "C.c :3--!.'I= ~;~ ~~:3~ O.;.:s'" ,:3="'= _ '" . td~.,. I 0500 .~5~5~ oEIJ~.::EwE'" ... GJ Eo'~1::~'f~ GJ'O..o......."'ca"'"' .~ C''''.".:;: a.~ o.;t ~:3....ucE."E." ~V'lO~j:'ococ x 00'" !::t.cv",u Id GJc!;~"'C"c"'c ~ 02 t ~ c 8 .0 8 0 02-..... '" c.:t:: a.:C == ~O~""'ll;'-'~ o c..r-... o:>...cu >.GJ "'" c: ~ c ::: L.- '" ... "' ~O::l E=~=.a..::::l e :e .- ~ -g .E Sl .E Sl .>( ::l .6 .9 or::. iil ;:....;; >. u"9....cs.O.cu'O I'CI ~ 8~ 0'2"'"2." .0 .....-"'GJ"'lU ~ c: 00'" lU .:; .~.c: c: "Citc:.2c~;au;; 'ggjO~Et;S~ ftI....oe"'.....c:....C! ~I c:0~....t0808 5. ~~:;;~1::~ ~~ 41 ~I "'N4IClUWC...C! C -cu-rd"'c:"OG.lO e. :2 0 '5 Ai 20 0.0 ~ 81 c] ~~ ~ ] ~ .5 & Cl/11 ~ .~; ~ .! D ~ ~B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ llJ G.I "C"'''O 080 ~c:..~ 1!! E ClI '8 ~ ~ ~ I:l ~f:.~ ..2sc:s ~ 0 ~ E] '5 ~. E .c I:l ~.a~ ::s ::s - 2-~;: c:.t.l:,~ .S :a :c ~ I:l ~ ~ u lC ~ c: u 'u In ;s s:: ~ I:l ... ~ "5 go t.l:, CJ ~ c: c: o E e o U "C o o ~ c: o ~ o u .~ c: E ::l 0.. .l "' ~ o "0 o C 0 E llJ ~ ::l o.c- .... 0 c. ~ ~ c: ~8~ ;;z .- III ~ t ::l '" E O'Ei< .,; '251 't'2 c ~"O ~~ .Q ClI :3~' ::l:3~. !.'I > :::Il! =.-c- ; :c E2 'E'35a~. ~ oXa .GJ~ClU oo~ GJ 5~ ~Eo.9E~ec:1'CI E .s~ 0~~~1::-e....~.5 1:: ......:ll: O(Iidc;>"'l'CIo:=ll! '" 0:; ." c... D 0. c.. "0'" >.. 0. Cl/ CQ ~Et~EE~~"5-E ~. ~ ~80ae8"'008-8 .cC ~ B..c........:)cc...::.. "C~ '" ~ 0-:.E1~ ~Jo ~8 9 ~ '0 ....Q~~ a.cO_.r:;::c.. o.t; ~ 0-5>0", .....0=="-- ;G.l:l- c: ~:: .g ~ i>- 0 .2 :!..9 ~ =.... ~ ",::l~ ='3...;:....GJ-::l OlUJ~ ~- ~--"C--o- ~~ '" ~s ~~.E~lg:E~ = ; .9~gC~~~..9E~~c: C c .sOlU::: Uw'" .~~u= .......0... ~I.I::I --lUbO i=l:s 0... ... '~c:o C=c:c ~w cc:~... ~~""'~~-~c~.c:~ olU_.2 ::80~~r~~~~aj~~-~j~~ w-~~-""EI'CI~8g......... .......2- ....o~coo_e 4100 -ooso .o--~~~o M_~~ ~~ ~ ~!a~oij5...~~@~~ ~!a::l~ ~]~t~~~~5&i~ ~]~ac:i ~B~uBB~o-~BB cS S ~~.E~E.E~x~~E~ ~~9E lU " ~ ... '" .. QJ .... "8'8~'" ~~~g ~ .~ ~ ~ a ~ !:S}ii ~~~2 \,)=Q,.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s:: t: s:: s: ~~~~ ~ GJ -5 ]~;:....~ ..!9o..e::: OJ lQ"'lU-5 :3~-e.:>C g c lU u uali:~ 1!!1&~ .. '" ~t2f:!O '0"8'- ~~g GJG.I~ ~-:;e ~~'8"8 ~~~c3 S e,9 ~\l E ~ ~:~ ..., S .t:l.- ... ... c '" ~ e ~ 5 ~ ;; ~ E 6:c5:;~ s~ ~ ~ ~ 0..$ ;g.~ ~ ~ -b S ~ ~ ~ ~ t:l I:! ~~~& E ::l co.... ......;c llJ '8 . -5~'; .:0: 00 V ::I '" '" 0 2iti:O ~ :; 0 ~ ~ ~e:- :::I DlU t; u 0.=.>2 .. ~ao8 ~-:~ 000 ClI G.I lU -~~~ c: o ,,:I: ... III jl ~ /5= ~ ~ r;.~ ~~ tl.s IQ "' C t;; o c: BS ~ .E~ .s g 8. c u ~ 0 ~ ~ ~= ~ 0=:::2lt:-a i~~~~ CO"'.....o o;tjoc eU7ilc:~ e !a it .. llJ 8.!2'O~] <.B5~.5 ~ ::l C c: o B .E a o u .... o $ QJ o .E ;:.... 'ij I 1.3 ~ -'" "'~8 g~o ~ 'C ~ 8 ClI bO '8 ~ 8~88~8 og(.?o~(.? ~~~ !:S U c:s ~ ; ~ &0'c3- .9 t! u .- - ... lEi \1]0- a ~.e.. oS:: _""'U -'-'a !:S I:l t:J el;t~!j~~1S :5 e \;I",=~ca~ !a~~~~~Q" g t:l I:! ~ g e ij &~&$c5-&> ..:0: .:>C ~ "'.:0: o III .!! ." 0 :2-",.>c~~~ ~C3~os~ 0..... ... -g " >. E~~ .c: t: "1'G........~!1~- ~~cxcs~6 .:ol d "C ~ ;:.... C III -= .. ~ >. .0 .. o ~ ::I ~ :>... .Q D -= O\i "0 lU ~. .... ... < - .,-" - ... o .a >- VI o a:;'" -6"8 >-u Vl .;.1," t' ;; -00 8vi .>0:: :a o .>0:: ~ :;l ~ u ... .s ~ ~ <G... ~ -5 ~Ot~tl~ =' .a "8 -; -g i3 ~ bi'u ~ u v; ~f ";0 -5 ~ OJ" .D o .!:: .&:: Vl... ::J t ..... 0 .&::-o~~ ~OO-O :CUU~ l ... 1I ...... ~fo ~~ >-::r: >->- VI .;.1,' ... Vl VI ti:;O~ti '80-6'8"8 u vi e;-U U ... o .a >- VI ~. ;;; ~ J: ... ...' 0 ~.a o >- UVI ~ '" Q.I U ~ "" ~ .... ..c ~ ~ lU...:C .:;~~ ns 0 '" ~uO o -[ Vl o .... ~ t' i~88 1IJ ~ ::s o VI ~ .... c 8- ~ ~ -... ~ ~~.... ;2z~ u :s ~ 5 - II .t:J]7U a5~ =E" lUeU ~ Ie ~ ~ e.u ~o~ ~ U', - 8 ~ (5,.. C :~.fi B.&:: 1IJ -c tlO ~ jod::J-::l > e 0 ...."'O~ .g-o~ e ; a C '41 t ~c_ ~.g B '0 u -0 . .... lIS lU " ~Ee~ :t: 8::J ~ tlO ~ "g"i - 0 ~~~ u ~ 0 D cr '" ...... ~~1l ui Ec:'; ~ ..c .9 2 ..1= llIl 7U <G a:l ::J llIl.., '" 0-0 '" -5!i- ~ t;...t = ~c ~ ~ ::J u... "C -E.!! U .5 ~ B ti ~ 0.. <II '" 8 o.~ EO. ...::J_ .....CI]-O 8 O.:ol u . ...ve~"'O c: 10 "Ill c: ~~c::ijod .!! :c - ..; a ;.~~~'O &i0-:a.... .~tl.s~u5 "',C" ... .!!....o .!! ~~e~e2 -d u ~ ~~ ~f oS ~~ DD ~~_ ~~ ~OO >1> ~e III 10 10 c: ~~ ~] i j ~ ~ --0-0 ."0 ~ . :; ~ ~ ; c: a 55~s.fi::8 ~~v'I:l ~ece~.. lUVOU"'.... '" to U 10 E 0 ~:a.s:s=ac VI "" ~ "" 0 ~ ~ ~ a~~E"'-a -0 -0 00 "C F lU"~UO&.i i ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~b~c:... 8a6-gst~ u:su-= v., .,g", [ll [~~ "''''-~E~ ~~~~:i~ ~ ~ :S .. a 8 lIJ~ ~~ 1O~ Ei co ... 1:E 1r ~.s . <G e 5 a g v -- 0 'J:: ::o~o..:o e ~ ~'6 o.>c:- iG lIJ 0 ~ c:E~E o <II l\l ~ ~l:2N E~3 g'O 5 '0 o~E'" - c: e c:: 1:) ~ 10 e U .!! c...!:: :coeo ::s....o~ Vl.5u.5 .,; :;:I o ... oS ::J o '" c " "g ~ 10 ", i ~ - ... 8 . ... '" ... =0 o U '" u "C C ~ ~ E] ~~ ... '" 0- _"'0 ij ~ tl U '0.... FE l ~ _ (5 -&, '" 'C 1l o ... .s-s~ u .- -;:l.c~ -0-0 o..;;~ t:;j a llIl.E - U III <5 ..o~o ~~~ e:2 0 c: E c ~.s ~ ~'8o >_td 0 C 00_ 'S '" &.i u fa D a :a ~ ';; '0 5 II ~ :J = ~ 8 I I I I I 88 llIl tlO U u II ~~ 8 00 e. '" 8888 ]i 0""0 "",c:; -g o l:>O U e -g :::s .... 1IJ lU V ~s 4J- ~B '8 -cl!O 8 ... o~ 4J III 888181 t::Joo~o~ 4J CJ ~ -= ~8~ ~o~ U ~ t -0 "0 '888 :::Eo" .>i. :; o '0 c: '" >- c: ... .s::. :G ~ >- .J:J o II V :; o '" >- .0 ~.g .- eo "= '- l=; E: ~ '_ .:::) - c: - ,- J: g=-e~ ~~ = c: ,=.~ .! ~-- EeE 5~.2. ~!3~!::l:i::!::l~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ 0'0'<5'<5' cS-C' ~ o ~~ ~ B 0 o&JSl "'" 1:; 0. .:.c .~ 0. ~ '" .- f= cr otj;a~ = ", > ;a ci5ai..;:;u g. g s .s c ~ ~ s: __t: !::l !::l ::! 8 ~ ~ a.66 c C .&:: ,_ .S E:Sc'&::, "'5 ~] ~~~~ cEV-~- ~._ .s ~ ~ .:: ~~~i~~ &&&&0'0' c: C C ~ :::~-- ''::; .~ t: -:::- ..::: -- ~ ~ ~ 's: tl l:l !::l ~ E a .. " ~ a. <5-<5- ~ c c: s.s .::~ .... .... !::l ::! ~ ~ 0'0' 4J 5 c:: u ~ c::I U Y VI ~ !::l ::: e " '1: ~~ g ~ :: ~ C/C/ E "2 !::l 5 & ...c ~ ~ o -'" 4J ~ ~.:.c~:O ~~o.~~-;; C:G.I.>o::c:C5o ~ 0;, ~..2 ~G:i ~S~:::-c5 O~a:iU~.5 .>0:: fa o -0 ~ c: .. 4.1 € o z U 5 c: c: o E E o u - ... .::: Cj ~~ ::J ~ .s o .... = u .- .::: 3:u -'" <0 o "E.:.c <<: fa E 0 ::J ';; .c: 0 Vlc.. .:.c r:l .:.0: 0 ~ 0...:.0: >-;:1", G.I ~ 0 = !t w ~oJl .>C ... o~ ., ... OJ 0 ~ c: > is:: ~.x l'JIc<l..:.o: o 0 '" ~-"'o ~.." V fJ " 10 > ::0:1 ] Oil ;;; ~ " .... GJ G,1 IJ ~s ..,- ",8 cu u .. ~ o t.I? ~ u ..-:. ,.:... g ~g ~~~ -.;;~~ .... nI - c:: > ~ U 10 U €~E ~~a I E "C S I 0 e 0 , U 10 U : ~ ~ 8 I c..... Co 1_10....... I ~~ ~ I.=-= - : e 0 C : - '" .- - >..- e.c e ca3C '" ~ '" ..cjij..c i:t:~ E '" E 'Og'O ....u..... ~ ~ ~ D C G:l '0 8.0 ...~..... .5c::.f: n c ~i O. u' .!! '" .. U '0 o ::E .., ~ c u cc :c 5 '0 V) e& ~ .E e 8 ~ is E l:: ..::: cc:: l:I ~ e& '" Q E:: ~ E:: 2 {! .0 ::> 0 J:: .... l!:::J -e,,{:C:I==~-~ 1::-t:-Q.QoE::~ ~ 1 ~ s ~.s ~ e& <5 S 0 ~ \J CO) 4>-'- ~ Q ~ S! ~ !:] ~ .S ~"'~S::J:J:.i:-g cc:: cc:: a:cc::eo:a:: u ~ c c ~ o U e o oS ~ v .5 nI Jj o 8 c e v o 0 v u III ... ... III nI S "'2 "'2Ee~~ cu u;:l::J '" ? ~ "'8 >.."'8 :0.5 E 5 ~"'8.2"'8.so,g~ "' ~ u.;:::, e 0 l:lO-U ,~"'C)":2E~..!!l U IX V1V1....,cQ ... ~ "8 u ~ '" .. ... ~ o ::E G:J -0 o U o e ~ ;>.. V) oj o ....c .. ... 0 ::I '"'CUe.c: "8 -08 -g. ~ U ....,:I: @ t) .cO .~ -0 ~ "' .z >:. "' o ... :0 ... Qj "*'2u'.,; "'C oou= ~ :czeo e '" 10 '" '" 8 ~ ~~-e~ ~ iC..!!i n1fO,2'" 0 u- CC~~ .c 8~ 11I11I-02 V) 0'0 as l:lO ~ ~ ~ ~i'f'O ~ ~~ e-~gc ~ SIO OOOfO '0 t]'" vu--~ t: -..c:: 8 ~ B B ~~ ~ j 0..0.....5 ._.-i....l: .......-o..,oe~...o ~~:::s ~ 2 ~].s .a...a. 0 '" is 0. is e"C .seo=t:......."'~ -"';e"'8c.v "';;it;jE,oc.....o vuocu....o...... cc.:::",~otj~o <<1<<1>.."':=.....10"'8 .r::.c::;!C3",C::l:J~ 'u U "iJ.... ... ~ c >.. III AI_...GJ III 0 fO.c as:lO()'O~Ve~ ........ cre.c..... ~ oo~....o>...9~~ .......~O..,'i:Q.Jc eefO...llI.....u"'~ ~ ~ Qj e > '" c:: .c '" Alu5ni~4:i<<l....., B B l:lO] ~ '8 ~ ~ t .5.5~~V)~~i5,5 c o '.::l '" N ~ e ~ to 0. e o u 8 0. ....... g .s -;a v C '" -5 u e '0 ~ o .5 III ... '" ... ... "C ~ AI III ... .... lG nI ~~"8"8 ::E::E88 '0 o o QO U ~ tJ "8 ~ ci. 0. '" .!3 ~ e& ~ t: .g i .~ ~ 1: o :3 ~ ~ .2 :::l ~ DO .5 0. ~ ~ (; c: -0 ;>.. V) .:.Z :0 o vj .. .... ... 0 "- III U C III "8"8"C~ UU$U '0 o o co U ~ "8 ~ 88 00 Q s:: .E .s ~lo I;j J:: .~ ~ ~~ l: o a 1: ] ~ 0.5 t;l ~ ....:>' :a v o '" uiXi ",' o .c: tl .c l:lO J: a:; III E o '" '0 ... = '" t "0 F ~ '5 In '0 ~ lG 2 '" .., '0 S ~ 8 .. ..... o ~ ... U '0 F .~ ~e ~~ ~ l:: ~ ~ t:? ~ l~ i ~ 8 \I ~ .~] s g E ~ C) li ~.... t"1:C_ocC)cE a!:: e& ~ ~ ..... I; ~ '- ... 1:: t: l ~ .~ e ~ ~] ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ,ij" ~ a s- ~ E ~ !- v)",GJ"S ." ",."c., "'." AI .... ~ ~ ... __G:J ~CLI~ ~: ~ 0 g -s.~~ '" ~~ 1: ~:S~ ~i!'E-g ~ "Bg~ - - 0 ~ - = .~ = ~",__V':. _ =...,~ E~~B ~ c;::... <~uu c :E<> ~ ... o 0 .g ~ ;>.. >- ...., t: G:J~' Jj "8'g~~ uur;J..c:; oJ co 2 CLI > '1:: ~ ~ >- S 02- .Q g's .2 O~. ]j 'OC::::::10 "C .!!"i... ~ ~ 0 = ~ o~;c ~ -.2'0 .2 ~"c '0 -oc/Q ';; 1:~s iI ::l 0 ~ ... .>C 0" ~ ta c: .u CLI v C>O ilJ::l ~E"E 't:l~""o'" 0 "':: ';:3 c ., e S'c8E 'Os '!:QOS !!O ~C:l v;.t:I S - '" .:l~ e~'o GJ....4J4.I .... Etie~:a~ 05Il1o.:aJ~ ~co'8o.~B c::~::E~~.s "8 t:) ~ Q E !:] 88~8 c..t:)...,t:) It:: ~ os "" ~ ~ !; .2 ~ ~ Vi ~ .0 o ~ >- t: '" -5 /Q ~ u o .c !l G:l .. ~"8~ :I:UU ~ (5 '" '0 CLI ~ a lG "'l o ... "e = ~ CLI B .s ~ ~ "C CLI 8 '" :5 ] o o ... .... o .... c: ta .. ~ II 4U ':G ... CI ~ CLI ~ ~"88 ~80 .._~,.....-.._---..."'"--. - --. ~ ~ "8"8 uu ... ~ ,..;. .....:. """" at:-g~s '1::="-':0 !S - n1;:1 "' a.oN.oN :l:S~~i c > c ~ c U lU ilJ IOS U E~E~€ "5"'lGlG", c..~p.,~o.. E:i"OS'OE 8 5 8 ; 8 .. C ... = ... 808 0 g Po ';:3 0. ~ 0.. ......... fU ......... ra .......... ~~~~~ ._~ -~ - .ESlSSl,S ~ ~e~"B ~~5"2~ ~'~~~"B E~EbE ....o....~.... 2v~\.I2 C III C 4U C io:I E '" '" e ~ 8.~' 8.~ 2~B~.9 .5 ".5",s ~ .os 8~ t:)::E .., .. '" .. U ~ .!a ~ ~ ~ j ~ - i:] ~ ~ ~ ;:: 111 .... ~ c: '" '" c: - "r= ;: ::-E ::: :J C ;:: :E< ~ ] v: ~ :.. ~ .. cu 8 '8 t:) -"' ~ o ~ e ... ;>.. c:: u .c: ;: ~ E : :. ~ ;:: i! oS \I t: :c .... 8 ~ ~ ~ -- ~ ~ :: '" I ~. ~ I~ I- I .. I = t: ~ J'. < - - - '-i ~ ~ o en ...~ q; "8 ~ U_] ,.:.:.... ... c .!3 4.1 u.o 4.1 vie;;; " ~~ "0'" ~~ ... 0 .. c .ag g~ , ~~-E ~ IQ . >- ~ ,.= ~~ c;..o ....of? o '" Oil 11.1 Oil e oo~c '" C >- ~ e -0........ -04.1 ~..QJ s$.6 ~.!1 :; :1 :a ~ ..0 5 ~ ~ 6 ! l~ [I - ~ u u :> t: 'D l'S ~ ... - ~ ~B '8 o (j 4.1 e l'S c U ;;C 'D 5 u en - .. ~ ~ ... :os .. :; :os ~ ~ 4.1 ~ C t: o e :: o u VI '" Oil ~ C ~ ca c:Q . ,:.. 'Ii ~ .2 "0 ~ E ~ ~ ~ ~ ... .E ~.::! -c1 4J ::=... i) ::0 ~ ~ ~ t -].S"E "0 ...~ ~ -;:; ~~ ::0 C ~... <II 8 :::l ..c: .g bQ "Ou 0.. S ; 15 .... 'c '0 ...:-= c: 2 C i2~ ~ c.. ~ ~ 11.1 c: 0 ~ ~ ~ dO CI.l 0 "0 cC ~""C 0. ... ..... .QJU ... _ ~ '0 :t. oS is -g -g Ill' d ,2:! ... ~ .,;"d ~ ~ Ot:~1;:l ;~OCJ:lJ:l -a::...~,......-tlj",,,, O-o~ ;;;..!!t:...UU~ ~J3 <W0...8V...... e.O:>........o....C1;:l';;; ..... E!OO>........"'...... o '...- 0 0.0.....- ....2:-::=~C.!!t...~~1I.I t: ~ ~ C ~ ~ ~ C ~ c.E ~~~ 8...!!~ C ~=6 &.8. --.o....900-1I.I...~ ~~ !:!~.s~ltU~."ai~c:: t "0 8 ... o ~ ..... en Oil' ~ ~ 11.1 ,. - -c.. .~ t: :Cc.. ~ ~~ - -~ ~ .~ ~ S =€~~S ~ '8 ,~ -::OQ... :e C::l:: Q :;j .~.,... ~:-~~ '" '" Oil ~ i~ Oil CI.l :E I.J :.-~ E ;; q; ... 5~ z3: ~ c g ~ ... C ::I Cl ~ QJ ~ .... o ~~ .a :9 ~ (3 Oil' .:.ol~-5 ,g ...'C ~ ~~~ v"'_ viU::I: QJ ~ ~ "0 o ~ 8 c.. "8 o 00 " ... '" ... Oil "0 o ~ s 8 :::: ~ c:: ':::;' ~ ci. 0. '" .5 ~ ... <': "0 Oil I.J "0 ~ :: q; :;; q; 3: c: a.. "0 C :::i ... ... QJ 4.1 "0"0 88 .... o ] o C .,; :::l o '" "0 .!! '" .2 lJl 8 c.. 8 8 c..c.. 5 5 .... ~ ;: .5 1:: c::..5 S~ :~~ E~ 5..:: oS .5 ~~ " ~ '" '" ... ::c "t:l 8"0 .... 0 ~ 0 ... .... IQ .... .0 ::; to C'O c.o .- 4.1 '0 .~ ;;~ v;> ~ "0 o U Oil c.. III '" c.. (5 I;:f c:: '" "0 C >-::1 ~Cl Qj.:.t 8~ c o ';:J ~ c<l c: QJ e i a. e o u ! >. ... ::I .5 ;a .~ .s::: I.J CI.l e g .... ~ ~~ ~... . :l'~ ~ .... c<l -"0.... ~"O ;; 'C C E 4.1 IQ i:::: ~ >:. Rl 2~StaO :::l "0 0 '2c "0 ~. U co'" 2 ~-8o. -.s:::c..... :=... 8 .... "l:l ' -.s ~... O~c"" ... ;> ell 0 c:0.s:::.... ~...ut; 11.1 11.1 11.1 ~ OC'CQJ ....,OfO- .: c: ~~ - o ... c: ... ... QJ "0 C ~ ~ ~ ~ 4.1 ... c<l 4J '8 ~ 8 8 c..c.. .~~ .., :>" ::: ~~ e "l:: E' "S 5~ ~><8~ e"i: !:: !:: '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ v '" C ::l ", C o '" '0 c.. :.t. .;J, ~ ~? ,. c: = QJ ClJ;::: .Co ,.. c:: c: ... III Q, -. - ", VI..,.- ~::; (5 .a ">-. V'l Qj o ..c !l .c ..c .~ 00 .....x i 8ClJ .. ~ ~ "'- Cl >. IQ Cl ~ ..c ~ t -fo"O ~8 ... 11.1 "C 8 - o ... c ~ CI.l B .= vi :::l o :a .; '^ 2:! '0 c<l QJ .2 t! ~ ~ti'" :;: '" 0'" 0. ... ... 0. .E ~ ~.s c: ~~~c U "i-:::lQJ(I e ~iiI- E 0. ::l..!!.E 0. .E -.0 C 0 ~ .5.2-;:;~ ~ IJO~-:;;~ ..c .5~~-5 ~~j ~:C~'i "OO"t:l c.."O~"O ;"'~ 8l3.::~ ",i.!! ....Vl..~tO ::i o ~ ~ ...;. -= cog ~ '0 _...",enoO_","1'" "'02~::) ...~... ~~3 0"'''' =-oQ... c;: k...EE;cceeE..... _'sQJII.I_8_QJ"'0 o -"'0 0-1;;'" ...t.g::!_~....g~; ~c"'~5;::l;"'~~ .... cd Q..., ... t; ... a..~..:: QJ~"'::I "'-0 4.1...::1 0 - "'0'- -"'0'" ~B~~~E~~~.= .S ~ 13 "0 g ... ... c: ~ ... .0 ... ,2. ... ;a 8"88 (jt3~ QJ ~ ~ '& .;:.t .!! ... ... 8~ (j~ "8 o (j s: 5 "C ::i. ~ ~ ~"6 e ~ ~ ~ 555 s: ~ .~ ;: ]! 2 c: ..... .., g ~ 53 ~ :; ~ ~ ~ :g ~ ... c: E~ 1i c "il .~ ':l(l ... .... ::: Q,I ::; $ E ~.- < ,.. ~ E Qj c:: .~ i:i .0 ~ ... ... ... ... ~1i '=- ?:' ~& .=-.~ C:;:;~ ;; .~ ~ -< ..>0: :a o t.Zl >- c: QJ -E c<l ~ ... ... ... 4.1 4.1 ClJ "C"8"8 8uu ..: c ~ C QJ 0. 4.1 "0 CI.l ~ .!a E o !Il 4.1 ... ~ ~ ~ ~88 ~ ~(j(j s E ~ :: ~ .8-s=- ~ ~-.& .;::: 5 c:: = Q .s.;:~=S :S 6':; a ;::: ~ ~.::; c: C :::5~JS..5 5 SS$ ~ E ~ E c. :- .5 Qj ~ 'S: -il "2 _'" ::;c ::! Qj -~~ a,!3 ~ V'l__ .... ... .:::J c<l '2 ... ~.g n u .;.i. .. ... c '1:) c "' c- OlI .:: ;; ~ E ~ ~ ~ c '" -f. ~ :; "' ~ .~. ... --:: " .... u " u > C ~ f! 10 u Uo ==- (II a o V) .. .. (II CIJ "8"8 uu ~ c ~ o U -. o C CII G:i B c ~ l'CI 8~ o~ lU e lIS c U ~ C u "0 V) ~ :: :oq ~ 'SE- t: _ i:i E~t ...><~ .. Q . ~..s~ ~c_ ._ C 1.1 =>r-.;a (II ~ c c: ,~ o U ~ CII ..c:.t:J -".2 u u ~~ ~a '" .. ~ CIJ g:::I:; '2 .g c: .!::! r.i C "" E .. .., 0. E o ... ... o 8. >.. .. .:!. c: ;; u C Q ..c: u CIJ E .:l ... ~ o ~ c: :::I >.. c: :J ..r; r.a :2 >.. ~ ... C lU ;; C .'" >.. .&> .. :J of t; ~ "" c: cD 1i < - .. ai ~ ] ~ g L- _ ,:;; '-' r" _./::: -. c:: .c- ~ ti;j .... r~ .~ g ::~. g 5 ...... 0 ~.~ E 13 -e ~ 1; u~ e " s.~ c. 8 .~ ~;~ ~ ~ ~ c: ~c03:: 0:3 C'CI 0 .::. Q U .0 ~ -.r: :::''00.4 -8 G.I u ~ '0 '" "'::1 ~ .E c~..s 50 '0 ~ ~4j.E: EU c 0 ~~... ~~ l'CI u i::'O~ ..J';;; ~ c: t5~r- ~.. - ~ ... ~ ~ ..... ~ 'O.t ~t::~ .~-a ~ o~ ~ l'CI..... "'I~.p r-Z-<,,:::~"" c_..^ '" ......l'CI..lU .g ~.s 's fj .E"S ~ cu =' ell 'a a > ,~ '" 0 Vi' 'OC-;;s :<:"V)"I.0 V)::I- . .~ '<\0'- 7UV)ooo'O~(3\..c: . .,j >.cz:: ,. cO ~ ~ 0\ 0 g (3\.:!\li(3\~'" IU ~- .:;:: (3\~(3\t"') ;>'00..\0.., ..... O\..,.;QJCQJ--'O\u . .,j _ 0 ...., Z::> ell ...... 0\ -C j:Q.... N.... C-QJ- ... I 0-= ~ 8~c.;t;e-:::I ..c: M t: .~........ ..c: ~ .u - t:'" f:..c: IU '" --. oW ...... :a 'ijJS~E~(j50 ell ~:9 .g, fo" fr c:l .0 .g 8 :: .... :::I Cl.I ~>. u.. t:) ;.!.; c.. V)V) C c: r:: 000 ";l "tJ -;:l . 13"e< g;;; ~~._~ eg ~~g~ c~ 88~~ ~z c;ftIUV) e~ 5~~~'" 8"8 teE ~~ iaO c..e-:lU~ c,! 'uc..c:: o C 510 0 t~ oS u~ c..c:l <( "l'CI ~ ~ ..,'" ~ 5 2 ~... ~.a ~o~a .~ ~ Sl CV -"';:l t; o ..., "I O.j;!... 0 .0 Cl.I..q; ......R~:I: < ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ .!2'" d ij ~ ~ .- 15 ffi .g ~ H - ~ .~ ; .s; e ..c: U '2~..q;ec t=~~c::;::::>~~o=, Zo 0 ~ ~ 0 . ~ >.-€ E '%:ZV)'O\OU ClIO E "'1..0 e~..o O~-oCl . 0 IoU 0\ -.:::J \0 0\ .- ..... 0\ \li \0 U VO\ 1:;(3\0\ C ,0\(3\(3\- z....::Io\......::IO.....O\O\I':I W .E..... .E~vi_~c ffi ~ E ;t; v)... E Qj c'" vi 0 8 Yo~' 8 '" ~ 8"C aQJ >=. ",'" ~ .... U :::l '" 0 1':1'- o::~ ~O u o~ c; c o '" .. QJ 0.. ~ cv'" :3 ;> c ~ ~ NOTICE OF PROPOSED CHANGES TO CHAPTER 5 WINTER SPRINGS CODE OF ORDINANCES NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS WILL HOLD A PUBLIC HEAR- ING FOR THE SECOND READING ON PROPOSED ORDI- NANCE 2002-08 TO CONSIDER AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 5 OF THE CITY CODE RELATING TO TREE PROTECTION. A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 25, 2002 AT 6:30 P.M. AT THE WINTER SPRINGS CITY HALL. ORDINANCE 2002-08 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA AMENDING THE CITY OF CODE OF ORDI- NANCES, BY REPEALING THE EXISTING CHAPTER 5 ENTI- TLED ARBOR IN ITS ENTIRETY, AND ENACTING A NEW CHAPTER 5 ENTITLED TREE PROTECTION ORDINANCE; PROVIDING FOR APPLICABILITY; LEGISLATIVE INTENT AND PURPOSE; DEFINITIONS; PERMIT APPLICATION AND PROCEDURES; DESIGNATION OF SPECIMEN OR HIS- TORIC TREES; TREE REPLACEMENT CRITERIA; PROHIBI- TIONS; EXCEPTIONS; TREE PROTECTION DURING DEVEL- OPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION; WAIVERS AND APPEAL; REMEDIAL ACTION; PROVIDING FOR THE REPEAL OF INCONSISTENT ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS; PRO- VIDING FOR INCORPORATION INTO THE CODE; PROVID- ING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFEC- TIVE DATE. A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE SECOND READING OF PRO- POSED ORDINANCE 2002-08 WILL TAKE PLACE AT THE CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS IN CITY HALL AT 1126 EAST STATE ROAD 434, WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA. INTERESTED PER- SONS MAY ATTEND AND BE HEARD. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO THE ABOVE MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK AT CITY HALL, 1126 EAST STATE ROAD 434, WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA. FOR MORE INFORMATION CALL 327- 1800,EXT. # 227. PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES NEEDING ASSISTANCE TO PARTICIPATE IN ANY OF THESE PROCEEDINGS SHOULD CONTACT THE EMPLOYEE RELATIONS DEPARTMENT COOR- DINATOR 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING AT (407) 327-1800. THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING. IF YOU DECIDE TO APPEAL ANY DECISION OR RECOMMENDATION MADE BY THE CITY COM- MISSION WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, YOU WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PRO- CEEDINGS, AND, FOR SUCH PURPOSES, YOU MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ANDREA LORENZO-LUACES CITY CLERK 1. ~