HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021 12 13 Awards/Presentations 101 - Wastewater Treatment Process Selection • AWARDS AND PRESENTATIONS ITEM 101
,n m=ared CITY COMMISSION AGENDA I DECEMBER 13, 2021 REGULAR MEETING
1959
TITLE
Wastewater Treatment Process Selection
SUMMARY
This presentation is a overview of the selection methodology the city is using
to choose wastewater treatment processes that will drive the design of the
new wastewater plants.
RECOMMENDATION
6
• o
•
•
•
•�' ,�'S,. F- 1. � �
a � ,
x.5-1- „jl � 156Q
r e
i r
1I_• r QrJ� �
cv co
_>
� Q
(6 0
Q N
o .o Q o
W0 7
O =3N N
U .� N � N
' O
z) u) n
U
Q
z/;dd aweualij
i
oufta
tn
s
Q
Q
s
x�dd'615060 uoge;uasaid 6;y�;;ory aN jUMjS 00
CD
T
V
LL
Q0
00CD
y/ O
l
CD
0
CD
W
L^7,
W
M
L
V I
OW%
ryoo
Ln
a
4 o
= J
E
J
L V
J �L .N
J
o
Q� Ln Ln cyi J N
.N = 0 V) I I Q
s a
)gdd'615060 UOWIUasaid 6;yq;;oryaN JdMJS 00
s �
is g
m cc
y 6J m E a �a
M
ea —
— & V
V
u
Ln
t� 4
758
ZU V j UV i
e I �
a-J i
z 0 �
+, � �L N
V1 s }'
•— N ra 4-+ O
S cn
a)
N 4-j
N ca .- ra cn
N 0 Q
co a o o x Q
V V W N +-+ O
Ln
ca }'
=3 oO V N � N —
Ln
Ln N E N
LL `~ m p[ �+ 0— J _0
i N �1 Q
O N
Q w
z m � u a- z Q)
cn V N O i N E
0 LnL/) a Ln c O
LLn
Q Ln
>gdd'61S060 UOWIUasaid 6;yq;;oryaN JdMJS 00
us
r
• � N
V
04
_ V
■ ' In
In
3
74
T ■ I J �-•
1
L 1 L
^� —4
a-J i
4
a-J LL N
V1 : s }'
•— N ra 4-+ O
N 4-J
N ca ra cn
N 0 Q
co a o o x Q
V V W N +-+ O
N � �' E •`� z C: s
ca }'
Q L 7& O V N -0 N -
N = a"' a_,
L � a� i L U N ELU
N
i N >1
� O N p i V
Q w
Z u m � u a- z �
m cn V N O i N
.N •"' % �' ' =3 :2
L/) a Ln c� O
Lun
Q Un
M
r
O
O
V
V o,
Q �
142,
� V
Q
O
0
0�
V i
o�
x�dd'615060 uoge;uasaid 6;y�;;oryaN jUMjS 00
N
1 i O
V N O
•
•
Ln
Ln
Ln
1
•
• 1
•
1 • •
3
A•- Vf
• N CC ++
•
ac oQ � u
1 1
• •
N
•
Ln Ln
• Q
Ln
Ln
1 1 •
0 • = p m Q
• Ln •
• Ln •
•
1 • 1
1 1
• �+ N
Ln U 1 = �
1
•
0 u CC O
0
N O
4
C 'O re d Nq >
Om
v O
_ } v
N o v
Z ¢
�� cQ 0
C Z O O 4 4 m L —
V LL a 9
O
C) a E
a)
m E c ol,
m a, c �
" us a m OC m L3
o o mmQ
u o 0
Go y m ® m `y H1 ° d ® -C
o ' o m c Z Z a
m u °V
•� '° ' oa �' m �w � O �c v
m
Zo 9 z ci N fY7
o ¢
,
c1 a
`0�n o E
a�
L C
O p C
g oZO0Z u a°c4 a .am
pm E m m z - - m v o l a
O ftl °. LL
_ fl.
v o
v 7 •D „d,vi h vWi V ••
H m m m o z
a '°.m
c E
d! O m u
L 3
W � m
v
Ql m ¢ 3qZ ¢
v
to 1A 7
O L
D c
Z Oe O F
m Z N 4C w 0 O y
x
CL 'E v �v ° ,SOC z
� zo �
3L
bo
0 E x x o
o �
Ac
¢ z
” £ Z a a
CL 'E
2 a a O Z
� a
w
X
m ffi O
y 'vi oa ° ¢ 1° Zo
mq � ¢
� mzdw
H F Q O V
N ® C
a p SS ® u n N Y z
Q ° VI d Q
4477 �
ao y •v �, a77 �r, mmm ,m, mzOaO ,O
o 0 Z c •• E m u - -
�
v m c
� L �
N O
� � o
O u
�n 6L m N U 6 u Z l =z p
m d c O «
y t 0 c m m O�j a a Z q N u a:a 0 z O a a lJ Zo„aK O ud LL m
a > >q0 V = a ,a p � d a a � A O ¢ vs� a `mm LLm
F < h m a a ✓
g � u m °�•- a� � ,n N
3 0 3 ° z
° m
o z E
)gdd'615060 UOWIUasaid 6;yq;;oryaN AdMAS 00
�
_
) ; 7
� -
§
§
\ �
k
k )
k �
\ § ) \�
\\]� >
az
cu
E . }
) \ _
m §}c z
&
_
0
R
.�
\ tw
o f
§
(
_ § ,
\ � c \ z
\ �� �\
) ( °{
I
ti
T
•
4w
O
Ie��
W
S m Q
LLO
Aw >
Q
4w 0
m
`� a)
V � 4-J
Q . . -0co o
- H N N O D
Q O z m z
s mN
V
4�
N O
� V u
� O oC 2
z m
�coo
Ln A 0 a� a� � �
•E x
V1 � z V) Q a) 0 � m
}, Ln z
N
>gdd'615060 UOWIUasaid 6;yq;;oryaN JdMJS 00
co
� T
s
4
o �
LL
o
N
i
CC �
V
� � o
4w _� �J 4-j
4 `� Q)
V ca 0
•� Q > >
cn
p
HJ
O ca 01ZJ� zl
S � Q m o
V 00 V1 Q)
Ln
o
V
^ N
0
a--+
• •
�-Coa\
CL
I o
m
Ln
1E1� � ml
�l w
S. 4-0-0
z
>gdd'61S060 UOWIUasaid 614 1101D!JI]dM]S 00
^rf
W
V)
V DC
LL U
c�
V �
. . V
W
L4 0
LL N
W
O
L
LL p�
L
a
Q
LL[
Z
m a
O
ca s
o �
a� LU
� � I
� � z
VI
m Ln
LL
Z
-
>gdd'615060 uogeIUOSOid 6;yq;;oryaN ldM]S 00
T-
04
Z in
m + _ a�
O Ln
� a�
Ln +, v
Ln L U
v p �
O 4- v 0
UJ
Q O O � >
QO_
V M O' v o
(1) v O 2
}' O _ M
_0 cLn > O Ln O
N '_ `�l O O O
O
v ra Ln
Ln �
• Ln O 4 ' O v
`
L 0 to
MFU o Q
• u 0 O � OU `n N vi
0 Om
C)7 —
a� _0 M .r- M L a� ro L L
i � L O Q i M p U }'
M N ro ro N �
- � Vl J ate+ N +'
4 rp L
s Q � moo � � 0o �� O
L a) O + J
N U Q = L UJ UJ a-+ O
UJ n O O L 6) in N N rB a
LMM
p Ln M N Ln ru fo ru Q 0 N �
+ M L 0) L Q L U aL+ U m
-0
OO� L •�N Q
vo vv= >
�LN CTOcO
ro �`n 0 �
O
O } p4 C Lm: a- -0 U O L �l
4- OU UJ VLn u-)
L Q pO U pl r0to to
0UJ pl U a- p
VM N pO M M 'Ln L N p QL
N
Q O Q r0 O L ' L O O fo L Vl M L Vl fo
• UJ V OE T3 J 4- '� UJ ro > N Q
O M 7 0) > L U O 0-
M
O
a� a� M
F O Z � � • • • Kinin • • - ou � wZ
4,
a' Ln
�^ Ln a�
v
Q u °' o M
v
4mJ LU
Ln 0
u v 4, � �
Ln4� O v, 0)
4, U v
a- Q .L -0N N ra ro
0OiUL O O _ roO Z ro ro 0 n vCD-
0
�a- O � w w
gdd'61S060 uoi;ejU—Ad NVAJJoryaN AdMAS 00
N
N
O Q
0
Ln Q o
O
V O
• 4ma
oft" oft"
V ,I•,
0� Loft
0
0 Z3
V V
Lft-
a o
O
o
Z
x�dd'615060 uoge;uasaid 6;y�;;ory aN jUMjS 00
M
N
Ell
• 0
' ' V
Q
V 0
V �
LU
_
� O
o
4
4
p V
W
L^
1dd 15060--IMUasaid 6;yq gory DIN JdMJS 00
14,
N
01
V
N
• — N
N �
V
Q N �
V
u o o
4
u +r ca
V
O �_ N 4-1 > N
X N
N N N N N
O } cn cn
0
O � � V
LL— >1Q F— L
Ol a 0 U \
N i
ca N a 0 C: V O LCL
N ca al �,
N _ 4-N � � � — �; � N O � z
O Q
N = a� O N
LU O VN -0 O i 0 0 5 Q) 0
V
+�Ln 0 OV O u O ate-+ Q N + a_ N +
i + i
Ln
O -0 O N U- 0
O Q N O
Z � Qo! oC LA �' a- u LA 6- Lna- Li- wQ Qcn
i
X
N
O
Q
O 4LL
o
'r■w�/� � U
V °7
V) a
Vf >
O � ^
s V •X V
G7V40
_ V�+ G7
• ~ W 40
40 40 m c
t = 400 V) o
E E
_ 4-1
O E
LU H V 7.0 LL D V
• � N M =� �
)gdd'61S060 uOlMuasaid NLN JJOID!JI AdMAS 00
a
v
Vu
Q
0
0
v �
aa,
'n cn
V
a.+
Q7
LO
4x
6L
0
¢ � Q . 000000
•
0
H O ooao
_ •
1 a v
LU
W I►
0
=s
Ln
v
i N
C5) N
N -c-
ElfO
Ln -0
_ V C:
_ 3: (3) ca
+, x
Nca N
._ -C 0) (3)
i N u 4� C: C:
s C:
Ln ,_ W
VI
N V v'
Sol Ln vi
(3) (3)0 4-
V C: -0
+� ca
0 —
(3)
V '+� (3) --l-Z
. O L
e ee
L
0 �
V
� 4
Q
.� V •
V 0 w •
�-
� 4
LU
4
L C
•� R
x�dd'615060 uoge;uasaid 6;y�yory uiN jUMjS 00
ti
N
•
LM
40
• fA •-
> L
• 0 •w LM H i
Go 0
H uu 0 V O
•
V •
i
W
0 s 0 s 0
•- 0 •- 0 •- 0 E .>-
s s s
Q • H H H i
V , W W W W
CL
>gdd'615060 UOWIUasaid 6;yq;;oryaN JdMJS 00
co
N
1
• •
1 • 4-0 •
•
• • 1 1
1 • U
1 1 •
O •
\ 1 •
/L1
O
4- 1 L mi
L
O c -
F
CO L10
� xc c
O w a ad
�
_ Y w
L cr - a `O c —
aii c = 'U Z, sn b 'K m '
Y co P LL []
O N W T d M aT+ (U
E E
a
Vl QC —
• rp a 4.1 LL U
v
cu
N
>C � U C
j (U G
4 C
W
m ai
N
pTp N N
rO E p 6 O O B O c C
Q 4 d O Oaj v
O CLJ
> CLJ
p N 7 0 t] ]
omice �[]
V l
u t +. L 1 F F F F
ai na Z5
p C LL v N L di N da CC
• c N N a a
W W W W W F F
Y ' ® LL v � 4l
yO Y
aj
O E a s
N Q N Q N N O u V
V d O C W F 0 LJ W U C C
V m U f0 V L9
,Caj v 0 w p O r.i n's V vi lri d
C6 m
aj
di
^, U a m a G
W
L
Rdd'61S060 uo WI-1-ld 6114 IIIAIIA A,g",,;_:,t;
0)
N
L
a-J
D
LL
s
L
0
L
• O
•
O
^, M
W
W
s
V N
N
U c
N
�--�
cr
CL L +� a
LJJ Z a
c
E
w
4-1
�••� co c
— O
O Q 4-
L 4�
V
M
z
V a T
E
Q c 4 E i(N
;,F V
N W Z z z
z z
4
VLLo
a z ca 4-
o
m V �
Mo
V a }'
�--� Q cn
°1 c o
F U
/ cN
Cc o
O V E
Gl
V °`
r
M
LL
LL
W
O
co
a
V
4 dA
N
V) Z
aLno �
z
4O bO
}'ccO
U
r-I r-I
V Z
z Z
X _
Q z z
N
s L
a z
. . — oc
N m E
N M �
V a a
0
U
a 0Z
Gl 0
Mi
ca a
Z M
M
V
co
N
M
LL
LL
W
4
O
co
a
V
dA
N
Z
Wrn
T
Q CSC z
aA
44-0 E
o E 0
a m
� 41
Z Z
s L
a z M ;
. . - 0 0
N
0 E
0
Mo
N m oc
� 0
V ' MO
2o
O Q z
a o ami
a� >
o
ca �
ca
z ma E
V
co
M
M
LL
LL
W
C
O
co
a
V
4
W
Q
" ob
r:
N
Z
4 T
0
X Z
Q Q ° to E
V V dA
N m V
Z Z
W
W
N m �
Q a �
V 41
(A a, °
O az
a 4 0
a� —
LL m
E
zm V
Z -
m
LL 11
LL M
W
4
O
co
a
V
4
W
Q -
4
}, to
N 0 E C\uD as
Oi � LnEEE
ccVI Ln M ri
Ln VI VI VI
.� Q 0 N Z a
m H
W `—
Q W
M _
� n
N LJ I
s x
4
. . E o
N u°
L Q
Q O dA w
^/ O O
Z
,z
V
LL
Z
M
Ln
Q
i
N
Ln
O
1 �
• s
•
0
co
M
mar ; ; =
i I1 R
I /lel I and �. I
w d
� I
r i6 i
9 If
II
G1 w
U)
I
:1
LL
�= w
N
I r 3
T
N _
I z o
•, z o
s iil i � o z o
'I I
i
I -
t
0
o
ti
M
mar ; ; =
R
en
� I d
9 If
w
t ,�J
•R sll' I al`s
LL
..
s; =1°
c i
cc
to
w
0
Q
N
LOlz
r I d zo
=3J
I `
I _ I
I
I
I
I
I I-
0
o
co
M
w J2
mar ; ; =
/I
a
w d
9 If
co
c0
LL
I
C u I
I
d �
a
• - _,,-�<„�,i,. ..ate r -
rr
c�-
I� la
L s, ja
m
c i
Cl)
C7
N
,. - - I �• ?moo
s. li azo
it @ oFz
I � azo
I
� I
i
i
I I-
t
0
o
a�
M
C
=1 0
s
I
. a
mar
It
� I
�O
•N y <
I
d - �
`II
I -
a
ff �
--5.— -------------.l._
r.r
cc k
�I
+
m "
~ li
>
N
fr — K.
K
I a
� I
II
r I 2 0
II I � azo
moo
i
11 I -
�� so
�I I o
I
0
I
C
s
I
. a
I I
r
I
�yy
_ g
mar
It
X19 i I�s
ILI
`
CL
W :III, I� la
N
r _
N N
t II a
2 O
I _ w
I
I
I
I -
I
O
O
T
J� j floe
mar
w
i f
s
I
a
I w -
w � I
I"
I
$_ II
R
u
4) lit
d
I -
ILL o' II 'II ala I I I
a � �
F/ N
N
tC a
L1A I�
•, z o
I $ zo
I saw
- - a•a'' • 1 i I. °mow
I
� I
i
i
I I-
0
o
N
��
�rS I I
9
I I ma
I 'd
�a
I
li
— d9
" m' ala
00
K
W '
i Imo` zo
s. li azo
it @ oFz
i I w
� I
I
I
i
I
� I
I a o
o
I
v'�
Q
N
t/1
a--+
X
N
z
Iq
.
0 40
.
V = �
O �
Ln
S �
0
a-J
Ln
N
•r
401
•r
-E
V
o�
o�
oc
x�dd'615060 uoge;uasaid 6;y�;;oryaN jUMjS 00
ti
J
E
O
O
r-I
N J
-, o
W N
m J E VI
OC E U\0 r',' E
M �
Om E VI 0
O VI O —
' m z O
VI U
m N O v
) ~ z L(LIJ
}, 40
5 J
Q
0 O
W N O
N i Z
O
wl
OC \ N O
a E vl N E vl
!-I O U i i N O E E
o m � 0 0 O o m o
O vl 00 `2 Q vi
Ln a� a� •o IY m o
VI U L VI U
m n Z aco
a� a�
�--� ;
Ln Ln
V V0
QVj
NN
^, O OU
W _� J U U
N
E N N
N N Q
LLEES
CL = cn cn N
n' m
2 UA N E vi Z) Z) Z
}Ja mvi EvlQOQo �, � � � a
W r-' L, V zococu 0
m
L m z cn Ln Ln
o �' �' �' o
V
o 1
Z � cNm � Ln
xldd'61S060-11114--d WN Old,_A j21MjS 00