Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022 02 14 Awards/Presentatios 101 - Wastewater Treatment Process Selection • AWARDS AND PRESENTATIONS ITEM 101 ,n m=ared CITY COMMISSION AGENDA I FEBRUARY 14, 2022 REGULAR MEETING 1959 TITLE Wastewater Treatment Process Selection SUMMARY This presentation is related to the December 13th, 2021 overview of the selection methodology the city is using to choose wastewater treatment processes and update on progress towards final selection. RECOMMENDATION 5 ca V 4+ r- 0 0 r .� _ o Z a E o N oCa — o Ln LU oC '' 14)• �a = •� = w LU - LL a 0 V =y �L 5 i LA " • • I r 0 J • O O • VJ • CD • �C}]�_ CU • O • C UD • Cd • ` cd • CD • C � rC W � 1 L ■�� i i N � i O ■ � i ■ O i V "dd 61S060-!M-sald 61W JPPIA di1MdS 00 00 Ln Ln O V O Ln = p •V � � O � Q � � � O j0 Ln Q Q � Ln • cn •� •N E a _ •� N O ca pLn E •V L +-J cn Ln ca +, N V o • V •0 Ln Ln� Ln c� •� }, O � � � ca O X }' +, — L7 Ln Ln Ln O +a +, V N O cn Ln L- N Ln •� O X p N .— N ca V Om `•� C N — ca N j � •� 0 C O � (nEo aN aoV 5/ldd oweuol!j .,4�Lji HIM, s �' OIEW Q) N O cn � V � _0 .� .V N D Ln C V cm o � — _ +-' > 4 '� V • O • LL ._ LU cnVI ca = V • b/ldd oweuoli j O r CL- Q of o 0 6 oil3 N O 4--J N N Ln N = N cn 42 }+ O +-+ m _ s 2 40 M N C:� ca fA V N c OLn Z3 N d N m m cn N (6 _0 Q IL _ *0 0 C co � s V Fo E a 40 N "' N n +� (3) co OH L. OD =+ 0 0 4 >1 i }, 40 ( � V Q }' C: O V 40 OQ 4-1 C: 'N I � ( c6 i a a a O w a = o v ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JdMJS 00 , N 0 cn V N a--� 0 cn N V 1 v i E 4--+ V Ln E o V _ V1 a) •v i �O O , CA E N c ' ate+ f6 Vf N L 0 cn 0 �•N a � `� � v °' • X Ln • ••E Z = Q V N O O N V O LLIN E N '= i W W 3 C: _ v cn s +-+ f6 a + V 0 0 L > CAi �� N _ V LL •= Q ca O ca QtA ca ca ' • _ L QLnO V • LL (3) • 0 r_W m • LZ •L V N C5) co�.d IA _00 w • ® Cr( O = H C: ro •m40 N E d- V a * > o N 4 Q E - c' • • • 40 0 • LLI L ' • LL xjdd 61S060-!M-sald 61W JPPI l di1MdS 00 N r s 4 oLM � m 1 LL V �II 40 o40 40 ` _ <40 N T 0 •- a � r M -1 u ~ �1 p �, . . �I � h • 0 � 40 � V - a) > > O Olzl� Izl o 400, s m � Qco V . u 4� o Q) n _0 Ln OU 0 . . Q` (3) N A 0 •4-j � i ii ._ O Vf z ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JdMJS 00 M r Hu (3) N .� x � N O f E N E cN O C N SV •+-, O V C: -C N ff O .� •_ O f U Q f � 0 C 7 S S Z 7 O �V l Vl a N0 = mea V 4� R • � V ndd 61S060-4g 1 -Id 61W JPM�!A JMUS 00 V pl � • - N (6 � � V VE NNS, u V u a� � (6 V N t � •N t c6 aN N 4-1 N 0E N N N N _ u O O O cn cn O t�= E V Z) p J Q + N Q c6 LL. Ol J c6 a� +r N p LL. i p Ln ca cn +� Q 0 O C: 4--+ cn +� O V L— N Ol i i � � �' V N N O Q i z OV N a-1 _� E c6 N E O Q i Ln + +- N +� N i L . cn = Q W N cn L Q E N cn O V N 0 V 'L � � 0 p N Q Q i 0 m 0 N •> V Q .� V N E S M N Ln Q) i E — • O ca O E N ca } ca Ln + N + V • z G Q � � (n i� U d U G N G d N d W Q Q Ln N V X X 0 � O = 40 � V •= i U 4� a� 0 s0- 40 40 •- L a 40 E W 404-1 a� V ++ i ( /� N i 0 0 W 0 V LL )odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A JPIh!A JMUS 00 LO vi vi • LM CL \ N 4-J wl V OiA V i H i N i CL =O CL .N LU 0 V 0 s E W I V • x E > > > > W wl o s o s o = vi a� N 0 s s s 0 ci V ( W W W W *> ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JMUS 00 ca T L t ° V -:I, -:I, !n m N *' N m Qf v h0 c � > C O N M -zT N r-I } v N C V00 0 w v , r C v1 pip L1 L1 L1 L1 O 0 y N M -zT N N f� 0 we •— v •- +� 2 00 In In In 00 ai \y Q aj m op o 0 0 0 0 ; j 00 MO I- N N T M T T V a Q T O a N {(O+ 0 W � ra - N b E Q -0O a 7) 'x m v E LL to L w � ��° ^, C N W LL D N +1 V 0 + v / 1 4— C ++1 Q V) 1 \� U 0 - v 06 U LL r/ U 1 LL + 4-JC LU j o N �-+ u ^N �+ 0 N W ° 0 U �? - cn 4-, s cn 3: �4dd615060 uogeyuasald 63W yoIh!A dtlMi6 00 ■ a 4 w m r� G � z � w [0 i0C o o z u � w bio Yl 7 CD Q , m m co } O _4-J J w w cn n' w � � J ■ ■ ■ ■ •L ' m 0 VO O O C] 0 0 © O O a Ln q Ln o Ln © Ln o Ln q V 1 ui c c m rri N r.i -1 r © ea aaoa5 O V VI N N V 0 i ,4dd615060 uogeyuasald 63W yoIh!A dtlMiS 00 a� o U rn O >, a) H 4 J N +' 4 ++ cn N >�V V H O o C L O ate-+ cn N N C: uW u ■ m a 4 w m n G cnr- z � w O �7 [0 bio 7 CD i0C o o z u � w Yl Q , m m co > O _4-J J w W cn w W ■ 07 � � � � J Ln Ct Cn fv --I CC O Vo 0 o a o 0 0 0 /� a Ln qLn o Ln © Ln o Ln q V 1 ui c c m m N r+ -1 r © ea caaoa5 O V a, o o N (/) o ° u N Nu m cv V 4— C Q) C: 0 E � 4-1 O :,- V J V W L Z o � ,4dd615060 uogeyuasald 63W yoIh!A dtlMiS 00 rn En � N 70 N = N O U (n O O_ � 4 m i p C � L 03 +. •— N U h _ ♦ p r U �w � ♦ a� 0 L>11 1+ PI L r` C Of N N N� •X 0 Z � N O � o ^, d Q W � J X }, o O C � ^, N N W d L }, U acu Z N C PIS Q Q M V CY i co N to 0 W ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JMUS 00 O N 4- Z in m atei — N O L N M Ln Ln i u Ln v p Ln 04- v i Q O O M > Q0- V M �' CY o a� O 2 *' O 4 _0M _0 c MO vi p 01 0 0 cO N N k Q Ln i N Ni > O 0 Q in • v O �O 01 Ov `n vi Ln 0 �, O _0 > 0- O � ro +� Q 4, -0 vi O a� -0 ro rU ro a� ro C c = i > >_ p i M v }' ro UJru - ro _0 N 4, ate-+ N _ a-' > Vl JZ ate- N � - ++ L N �, ro cm Mi N Q +-+ 01 O ro p O � i p � Q O � Ov v 0 N }i v v _ro a-+ZO ++ in p ro ro ro -0 O O }, + } -0N � Q aN' U N � N pO Z O p ro �r 0 m v o > a--' rtS •L L Q L U L l.J ro Lnro }, _p 4 , O O O zLnO N tvii N t�ii Lni s o >_ =O> LnUJ O 0 Ln % N _ Q N N > c Ol � in 4, in in 0 N ro ++ O _se 7a UJ L QJ i i Ln Ln " ro 'vl M UJ >, -0V O - '� N ro > ro Q }, J > ol -0ro t_n O M v 0 O Q O Z • • • Ul Ul • • J u � W Z L 4-J 4� Ln Ln z Ln 0 v, Q v °' o M — � >_ ro � V Ln u 0- -o LUo v Ln �, v -0 •� v 4- >_ 01 O = 0 —E +-+ O Min LLJ • x v v in Z OFuO L w O ru Bra ro ~ i i v ro p +-+ p > N p in N to Q Z Q 0 a- 0 V LL � w wLLJ xjdd 61S060-Wlu—ld 61W JPIIA dbMdS 00 N O C1 O U Z3 C Q} C N C Ito N 7 . U} Q 'n7 M W Q Y a U M m U O u� rn N � O q} L) Q QJ U U o C m U) cu I/ OD v � C'1 U I X U' O N ! > Q O Q N r, cu� d W c N O -O N O Z N Q O Q N O coI N Q N Of U ` 0 d c fVC Q N Q a V � C � 0 N O _ m Q} U c: U) U Q �I E .1 n' C � � N C � U) ❑ W C ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JMUS 00 N N >' O v v ^ O — p LU v -p v D V p L Ol N c O No > c c -0 LV N * N °V E V N (0 E in E in 0J 0 -O (Vp 0 'p in OV ro O 7 N �_ 7 N O c > V O c f0 a--� �C0 -rV 0 �` N V ° O -pN Wn ro O N o D *1 c v c + c v n ro V c O of E c v ° rou Q ° >> v v O > c - a v cu v v O > Q v c c c c p V E q-- O V ro ro ro > 0 Ln CO v J c o n V c v 0 Q) ro O = Q1 Q v ° + j c c • v ro p L 0 Ol N ,i -gyp c ro N } o ° E • > c v v n t v m E 0 t u p o p ro u E E .� Q p p v v E u c m o E 0 0- �u 5 v a) i 0 D rco Q l¢J v Co C -p >, ro ro t Co 1 v Q V O'i O p V N 7 p r0 L N �, L r`no -O �-.c O v u ro p Q V v v ° N �, >� O E g t v o t O o O- O o f V o E v v v v v p rVo t E N V ? i c c ro Q 0 x o v 2 O .� o o ° v 0 O o t c E O Q v Q = Q t r=o Q ° o- 00 4Z u t v O } i, ro c > + v -0 O Q + E c v v — .Q ro of t -p 0 v Q Q in v �, V }' p o- O .0, Q "2 cE OQ° QE0 L p%%.000 n -0 c E V Qrco +Vr`Qno Ln Q) v Q V -pcvv E 'Eu L UN l/ V v > O N OD O V o0 -0 .i V o o i vO c v -o V4-Jc V c � Eo O QE Vo v o o f c ° EE oc 0)E wuc - 0) V p E � v _> o � o O_ O O O c V -0 V ' c ro ro >�0 ,� Q.'_^ t O'i Q t .c t E c c .* v O 0 E >o v c o v V c t v V t v - � c c -0 •� v p ° m v E ° Q v v E e c o o .o v o - — in +� ro E ° .� v v .c o v o E v p Q c v o t o V Q t t D v v L c ° n ro Q ._^ t o ° D E o v `o o, o,L v c p o, Q o v ox v 0 V w v V in d 2 2 2 2 d � LZ v S Q v �i v w 0 `V° Z • • > • • • • • • • • • • • • d' • • • Ln • • 2 • • • � � v NC V O_ o V 7 + y 1 T 0 N * 0 O t d N O _ C � � c Z • 0- v v E v v a vV V LD V ._ E o u > 0 0 o v v a L o v a a` a` Z a` Q D a 0 v ° w w 0 )add 6LS060--lW1 -ld 61A JJOIPD1 di1MdS 00 M N N a-J L �--+ >1 N L a-J V O N (6 � N � O E > E 0 O N T re cn r — C V u O _ .— Ln O +� }, p Q 'N U Ln X N >1 'E 0 E O O N oO V p u +O p +-J V +Z3-+ Q -0 O O u 0 +_+ O V N p cn +1 -0cn V N Q N % Q O_ O Ln + Ov � Ln +� � O � i > N +J O O c`nn ca O V p Q }' V N > Q Q O (n C) (n . Z 0 d ,odd 61S060--!W1 -ld 61A yoIh!A JdMJS 00 El O c�