HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022 02 22 Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting AgendaCODE ENFORCEMENT
BOARD
REGULAR MEETING AGENDA
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2022 - 5:30 PM
CITY HALL - COMMISSION CHAMBERS
1126 EAST STATE ROAD 434, WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
1
CALL TO ORDER
Roll Call
Invocation
Pledge Of Allegiance
Approval Of The Agenda
Swearing in of Code Enforcement Officers and Other Individuals giving testimony
AWARDS AND PRESENTATIONS
100. Not Used
CONSENT AGENDA
200. Approval of the Tuesday, January 25, 2022 Code Enforcement Regular Meeting
Minutes
Minutes
PUBLIC HEARINGS – CONTINUED CASES
300. Not Used
PUBLIC HEARINGS – REPEAT CASES
400. Not Used
PUBLIC HEARINGS – NEW CASES
500. Case# 2021CE002897
34 Jackson Circle
Yesenia Newman
City Ord 13-1 General Prohibition
Additional Case Information
Presentation
501. Case# 2021CE001969
722 Lakeside Drive
Anthony Kouis
Caroline Kouis
IPMC 304.10 Stairways, Decks, Porches and Balconies
WS City Ord 13-2(C) Overgrown yard
IPMC 304.2 Protective Treatment
IPMC 304.9 Overhang Extensions
IPMC 302.1 Sanitation
IPMC 304.6 Exterior Walls
Additional Case Information
Presentation
2
502. Case# 2021CE002770
700 Cottontail Court
Heather Williams
WS City Ord. 13-2(c) Overgrown Yard
IPMC 304.7 Roofs and Drainage
Additional Case Information
Presentation
PUBLIC HEARINGS – NON-COMPLIANCE CASES
600. Not Used
REGULAR AGENDA
700. Not Used
ADJOURNMENT
PUBLIC NOTICE
This is a Public Meeting, and the public is invited to attend and this Agenda is subject to change.
Please be advised that one (1) or more Members of any of the City's Advisory Boards and
Committees may be in attendance at this Meeting, and may participate in discussions.
Persons with disabilities needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should
contact the City of Winter Springs at (407) 327-1800 "at least 48 hours prior to meeting, a written
request by a physically handicapped person to attend the meeting, directed to the chairperson or
director of such board, commission, agency, or authority" - per Section 286.26 Florida Statutes.
“If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the board, agency, or commission with respect
to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the
proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of
the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal
is to be based” - per Section 286.0105 Florida Statutes.
3
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
JANUARY 25, 2022
CALL TO ORDER
Chairperson Matthew Criswell called to Order the Tuesday, January 25,
2022 Regular Meeting of the Code Enforcement Board at 5:30 p.m., in the
Commission Chambers of the Municipal Building (City Hall, 1126 East
State Road 434, Winter Springs, Florida 32708.
Roll Call:
Chairperson Matthew Criswell, present
Vice-Chairperson Maurice Kaprow, present
Board Member Michael Burns, absent, excused
Board Member Stephen Gildea, present
Board Member Howard Parsons, present
Board Member Dennis Robinson, present
Board Member Harold Thomson, present
Senior City Attorney Jennifer Nix, present
City Clerk Christian Gowan, present
Deputy Chief Matt Tracht informed the Board that Items 501 and 503
would be pulled from the agenda. The City Clerk then swore in those who
would be providing testimony.
REGULAR AGENDA – PART I
700. Election for Chairperson of the Code Enforcement Board for
Calendar Year 2020
Chairperson Criswell opened nominations for Chairperson of the Code
Enforcement Board for the calendar year 2022.
Board Member Robinson nominated Board Member Matthew Criswell
to be the Chairperson. Board Member Criswell accepted the nomination
and no other nominations were made.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE);
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
MATTHEW CRISWELL WAS ELECTED AS THE CHAIRPERSON
4
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 2 OF 8
701. Election for Vice-Chairperson of the Code Enforcement Board for
Calendar Year 2020
Chairperson Criswell opened nominations for Vice- Chairperson of the
Code Enforcement Board for the calendar year 2022.
Board Member Robinson nominated Board Member Maurice Kaprow to
be the Vice-Chairperson. Board Member Kaprow accepted the
nomination and no other nominations were made.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE);
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0
MAURICE KAPROW WAS ELECTED AS THE VICE-CHAIRPERSON
AWARDS AND PRESENTATIONS
100. Not Used
CONSENT AGENDA
200) Approval of the Tuesday, October 26, 2021 Code Enforcement
Regular Meeting Minutes
"MOTION TO APPROVE." MOTION BY VICE-CHAIRPERSON KAPROW.
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER GILDEA. DISCUSSION.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE);
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0
PUBLIC HEARINGS – CONTINUED CASES
300. Not Used
PUBLIC HEARINGS – REPEAT CASES
400. Not Used
5
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 3 OF 8
PUBLIC HEARINGS – NEW CASES
500) Case# 2019CE002583
530 Julie Lane
Lisa J. Rambert
WS City Ord. 20-142 Operating an guest and tourist home in a RC-1
zoning
Zoning Uses Permitted within zoning for RC-1
Note: The Respondent, Ms. Lisa J. Rembert, was present.
Mr. Drew Smith, Shepard, Smith, Kohlmyer & Hand, P.A., represented
the City and presented the case to the Code Enforcement Board. Mr.
Smith asked questions of the witnesses and entered the following
information into the record:
• City 1 – A copy of an email communication sent by Ms. Rembert
on December 21, 2021;
• City 2 – A copy of Florida Statutes Sec. 509.013;
• City 3 – A copy of Florida Statutes Sec. 509.032;
• City 4 – A copy of Agenda Item 502, adoption of Ordinance 2011-
08, from the October 10, 2011 City Commission Regular Meeting;
• City 5 – A copy of the City Code, Chapter 20, Article III, Sections 20-
103; 20-142; 20-143; 20-207.
Mr. Roderick O. Ford, Esquire, The Methodist Law Centre, 5745 SW 75th
Street, # 149, Gainesville, Florida, represented Ms. Rembert and entered
the following information into the record:
• Respondent 1 – A copy of the City Code, Chapter 20, Article I,
Section 20-1. Definitions
• Respondent 2 – Respondent’s Trial Brief and Memorandum of
Law
The following individuals provided testimony:
Ms. Lisa Rembert, 530 Julie Lane, Winter Springs offered testimony
regarding her interpretation of several legal definitions within the City
Code, and admitted renting or leasing the property via vacation rental
sites such as VRBO and Air BnB to others as a vacation rental. The
respondent further testified that she has rented the Property as a
vacation rental on multiple occasions in the last twelve months and she
estimated having rented the Property four times for less than seven
days, and having rented the Property three or four times for more than
6
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 4 OF 8
one week. Respondent further testified that she currently has one
pending ten-day vacation rental booking.
Mr. Christopher Schmidt, Director, Community Development
Department offered testimony regarding permitted and prohibited
uses within the RC-1 Zoning District, in which the respondent lives.
Deputy Chief Matt Tracht, Winter Springs Police Department offered
testimony on the procedures of notice and the violation. Deputy Chief
Tracht also showed photos from “Presentation” and provided evidence
of several listings of the Property for lease/rent on multiple vacation
rental sites. Deputy Chief Tracht recommended a fine of two-hundred
and fifty dollars ($250) a day if the respondent did not cancel remaining
reservations and stop bookings on the property by 5:00 PM on January
27, 2022.
Extensive discussion occurred among Board Members regarding
homestead status of the property, restrictions on rentals, guest
limitations, and average lengths of stays.
Mr. Smith offered closing remarks for the City, noted that Ms. Rembert
admitted to renting the property as a vacation rental on numerous
occasions and was still accepting reservations in violation of the City
Code.
Mr. Ford offered closing remarks on behalf of Ms. Rembert. Mr. Ford
argued that the issue was a constitutional property rights issue and
that the City had no right to limit Ms. Rembert’s use of her property.
“I MOVE TO FIND THE RESPONDENT IN VIOLATION OF THE CITY CODE
AND ORDER THAT REPSPONDENT BE GIVEN UNTIL 5:00 PM, JANUARY
27, 2022 TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION MEANING TO CANCEL
REMAINING RESERVATIONS AND CEASE BOOKINGS OR HOLDINGS ON
THE PROPERTY WITHIN FORTY-EIGHT (48) HOURS OF THE BOARD’S
ORDER. IN THE EVENT THE RESPONDENT FAILS TO COMPLY BY THIS
DATE A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY DOLLARS
($250.00) SHALL BE IMPOSED EACH DAY THE VIOLATION CONTINUES
THEREAFTER.” MOTION BY VICE-CHAIRPERSON KAPROW. SECONDED
BY BOARD MEMBER ROBINSON. DISCUSSION.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE)
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
7
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 5 OF 8
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
501) Case # 2020CE001997
622 Locust Court
Adrien Love – Trustee
WS City Ord. 12-53 Disabled Vehicle
WS City Ord. 13-2 (c) Overgrown Yard
WS City Ord. 13-2 (b) Junk and Debris
This item was pulled from the agenda.
502) Case# 2021CE 000429
618 David Street
Charles R. Mcinturff
Connie L. Mcinturff
IPMC 304.7 Roofs and Drainage
Note: The Respondent was not present.
Ms. Terri Sanchez, Code Enforcement Specialist, Winter Springs Police
Department introduced the case, offered testimony on the procedures
of notice and the violation, and showed photos from the “Presentation.”
Ms. Sanchez recommended a compliance date of February 28, 2022 and
a two-hundred and fifty dollar ($250) per day fine if this was not met.
“I MOVE TO FIND THE RESPONDENT IN VIOLATION OF THE CITY CODE
AND ORDER THAT REPSPONDENT BE GIVEN UNTIL FEBRUARY 28, 2022
TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION. IN THE EVENT THE RESPONDENT FAILS
TO COMPLY BY THIS DATE A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF TWO HUNDERED
AND FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) A DAY SHALL BE IMPOSED FOR EACH
DAY THE VIOLATION CONTINUES THEREAFTER.”
MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER ROBINSON. SECONDED BY BOARD
MEMBER GILDEA. DISCUSSION.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE)
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
8
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 6 OF 8
503) Case # 2020CE001997
622 Locust Court
Adrien Love – Trustee
WS City Ord. 12-53 Disabled Vehicle
WS City Ord. 13-2 (c) Overgrown Yard
WS City Ord. 13-2 (b) Junk and Debris
This item was pulled from the agenda.
504) Case# 2021CE000442
674 Venture Court
Michael T. Boulet
WS City Ord. 6-195 Maintenance of Fences
Note: The Respondent was not present.
Ms. Sanchez introduced the case, offered testimony on the procedures
of notice and the violation, and showed photos from the “Presentation.”
Ms. Sanchez recommended a compliance date of February 28, 2022 and
a two-hundred and fifty dollar ($250) per day fine if this was not met.
“I MOVE TO FIND THE RESPONDENT IN VIOLATION OF THE CITY CODE
AND ORDER THAT REPSPONDENT BE GIVEN UNTIL FEBRUARY 28, 2022
TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION. IN THE EVENT THE RESPONDENT FAILS
TO COMPLY BY THIS DATE A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF TWO HUNDERED
AND FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) A DAY SHALL BE IMPOSED FOR EACH
DAY THE VIOLATION CONTINUES THEREAFTER.”
MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER GILDEA. SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER
PARSONS. DISCUSSION.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE)
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
505) Case# 2021CE000519
209 North Alderwood Street
Randy A. Marvin
IPMC 304.7 Roofs and Drainage
IPMC 304.2 Protective Treatment
WS City Ord. 13-2(D) Dead Tree
Note: The Respondent was not present.
9
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 7 OF 8
Ms. Sanchez introduced the case, offered testimony on the procedures
of notice and the violation, and showed photos from the “Presentation.”
After brief discussion, Ms. Sanchez noted she would remove the violation
regarding City Code Section 13-2(d), Dead Tree from consideration for
this case.
Ms. Sanchez recommended a compliance date of February 28, 2022 and
a two-hundred and fifty dollar ($250) per day fine if this was not met.
“I MOVE TO FIND THE RESPONDENT IN VIOLATION OF THE CITY CODE
AND ORDER THAT REPSPONDENT BE GIVEN UNTIL FEBRUARY 28, 2022
TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION. IN THE EVENT THE RESPONDENT FAILS
TO COMPLY BY THIS DATE A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF TWO HUNDERED
AND FIFTY DOLLARS ($250.00) A DAY SHALL BE IMPOSED FOR EACH
DAY THE VIOLATION CONTINUES THEREAFTER.”
MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER PARSONS. SECONDED BY BOARD
MEMBER THOMSON. DISCUSSION.
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE)
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
PUBLIC HEARINGS – NON-COMPLIANCE CASES
600) Case# 2021CE000660
207 Bennett Street
Kathleen M. Thomas
WS City Ord. 20-434 Commercial Vehicles
WS City Ord. 20-438 Vehicles Parked on Yard
Original Hearing Date: April 27, 2021
Note: The Respondent, Ms. Kathleen Thomas was present.
Ms. Mariah Quinn, Code Enforcement Specialist introduced the case,
offered testimony on the procedures of notice and the violation, and
showed photos from the “Presentation.” Ms. Quinn recommended a fine
for the four instances that she had observed the violation since the April
hearing.
Ms. Kathleen Thomas, 144 Shadow Trail, Longwood, Florida 32750 offered
testimony regarding her attempts to evict and difficulties due to COVID.
10
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA
MINUTES CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD REGULAR MEETING –JANUARY 25, 2022
PAGE 8 OF 8
Discussion followed on previous compliance, the responsibility of
respondents to notify Code Officers regarding compliance, and the fact
that this case should have come as a Repeat Case. The Board asked what
their options were regarding fines.
Attorney Nix reviewed City Code Section 162.09(2)(c) and noted that this
offered the Board guidance on their ability to reduce any potential fines.
Further discussion followed on the respondent’s plans to evict her
tenant, timelines for the proceedings, and the status of the property
currently.
Ms. Quinn noted that to her knowledge the property was currently in
compliance.
“I MOVE TO FIND THE RESPONDENT IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE CITY
CODE AND THAT NO FINES SHALL BE IMPOSED.”
MOTION BY VICE-CHAIRPERSON KAPROW. SECONDED BY BOARD
MEMBER GILDEA. DISCUSSION
VOTE: ROBINSON (AYE); KAPROW (AYE); CRISWELL (AYE); GILDEA (AYE)
PARSONS (AYE); THOMSON (AYE)
MOTION CARRIED 6-0.
REGULAR AGENDA – PART II
ADJOURNMENT
Chairperson Criswell adjourned the meeting at 9:19 PM
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
_______________________________
CHRISTIAN GOWAN
CITY CLERK
NOTE: These Minutes were approved at the ________________, 2022 Code Enforcement Board Regular Meeting.
11
The following documents were
submitted into the record related to
Item 500,
Case# 2019CE002583
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
The following documents were
provided in reference to Items 502
and 505 respectively at the January
25, 2022 Code Enforcement Board
Regular Meeting
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
Reported Day/Date:
Mon 11/22/2021 20:05
Time Dispatched:
11/22/2021 20:05
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
11/22/2021 20:10 11/22/2021 21:09 Mon 11/22/2021 20:10 Mon 11/22/2021 21:09
Subdivision:
NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
No
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N I S 22CJR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 INFORMATION ONLY- CIVIL DISTURBANCE 7777777777 9000 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
2021CJ019484 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:55
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
Yes
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ019484
Event #:
20213262641
94
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
W135 - Winter Springs Police D
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 135 407-327-1000 Comments: ASSISTING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Montana, Cristina
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WS2 - Winter Springs Police De
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: ASSISTING SGT.
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Smith, Allison
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
REPORTING PER-ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
J
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, PEYTON LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
504 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:XX
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
JENNIFER LYNN KENAST NOK:PARENT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#:
DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, YESENIA RIVERA
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
504 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
2021CJ019484 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:55
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
Yes
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ019484
Event #:
20213262641
95
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:11/22/2021 23:07 Reporter:MEYER, PRESTON D M29353 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\pmeyer Mod Date:11/23/2021 03:51 Related Case #202160001133
On 11/22/2021 at 2005 hours I was dispatched to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a civil disturbance between neighbors. Upon my
arrival I was met with, Jennifer Lynn Kenast, she advised the following;
She took her dog out to use the restroom and the dog went onto her neighbor, Joseph David Newman, property. She went to
retrieve the dog and her neighbor got very upset. Her daughter, Peyton Lynn Kenast, started to videotape the interaction between
them. Jennifer’s daughter showed me the video. Jennifer advised she wanted her daughter to record because there is an
investigation about Joseph stalking her daughter.
After watching the video I went to speak with the neighbors at 34 Jackson Circle. Upon my arrival I was met with, Yesenia Rivera
Newman, she advised the following;
Her husband noticed the dog around the fence separating their property. She advised he noticed that the daughter was filming him
from around the corner of the fence.
While speaking with Yesenia, Joseph walked out of the home and wanted to tell me what happened. He advised the following;
He noticed the dog by the fence and saw the daughter videotaping him. He walked over and started to film her. He did not know
why she was filming him. He stayed by the fence until he walked away to go inside and Jennifer called the police.
After reviewing both parties’ videos I determined that there was no crime committed.
While speaking with Joseph he pointed out there were BB gun marks and BB’s ammunition on the ground. He showed me the
marks on the house and told me they were new. After looking at the side of the house I determined that this would be criminal
mischief and pulled a new case number and a new report would be done to discuss the damage.
No further information.
No law enforcement video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
MEYER, PRESTON D M29353
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:12/27/2021 19:38 Reporter:JAMESON, DYLAN J J51393 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\DJameson Mod Date:12/27/2021 19:40 Related Case #
On 12/27/2021 at approximately 1859 hours, I responded to 36 Jackson Cir in reference to a disturbance. Upon arrival I met with
Jennifer Kenast who stated her neighbor, Joseph Newman, had just caused a disturbance in front of her home. She stated that
Joseph stayed on the public road and walked in front of her home yelling at her about her vehicle lights hitting his home. She
wanted the event documented.
I then made contact with Joseph who stated he had a video of this event. In this video Joseph exited his home, it appeared that
Jennifer’s vehicle is in the road as she is pulling into her driveway. During this time her headlights are faced towards Joseph’s
home. He then walked towards the vehicle yelling about the lights. The video stopped while Joseph was still on his property.
This concludes my involvement in this case.
There is no police video of this event.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
JAMESON, DYLAN J J51393
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CJ019484 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:55
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
Yes
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ019484
Event #:
20213262641
96
Officer Reporting:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Reviewed By:S75100 SMITH, ALLISON
Assigned To:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
INFORMATION ONLY- CIVIL DISTURBANCE
Officer Shift:D
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
11/23/2021
11/22/2021
11/22/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 11/22/2021W146
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
2021CJ019484 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:55
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 4 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
Yes
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ019484
Event #:
20213262641
97
Reported Day/Date:
Mon 6/21/2021 21:30
Time Dispatched:
6/21/2021 21:30
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
6/21/2021 21:36 6/21/2021 22:18 Mon 6/21/2021 21:25 Mon 6/21/2021 22:18
Subdivision:
RANCHLANDS
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A UNKNOWN RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 01 00 0 00 N N I 22IP Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 DAMAGE PROP-CRIM MISCH 200 DOLS AND
UNDER
806.131b1 2900 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JAMES CHARLES
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:UNKNOWN
602 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:UNKNOWN
505 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
VICTIM- ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
511 Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:VIC/WITRelationship:
Foul Play Suspected:
Extent of Injuries:
False
None
Injury 1:
Injury 2:
NOT APPLICABLE
NOT APPLICABLE
202160000590 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:22
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000590
Event #:
20211722931
98
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
W141 - Winter Springs Police D
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 141 407 327 1000 Comments: ASSISTING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Preston, William
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WS2 - Winter Springs Police De
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 4073271000 Comments: ASSISTING SERGEANT
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Smith, Allison
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PROPERTY
Qty:
Model:
Status:None
Units:
Brand: N/A
Details: GUTTER DOWN SPOUT
Owner#:
Evidence Tag:
Item#:1 Offense#: 1
1 Serial#:
N/A Size: Color: WHI
Damage: Criminal
Mischief
Recovered Date:
Property Narrative: White down spout from gutter.
Est Value:$50.00
$0.00
YGUTTER
Rec. Value:
NCIC:
Theft Type:N/A
Owner:NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
PCN:NIC:
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:06/25/2021 18:08 Reporter:SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\ESchwartz Mod Date:06/25/2021 18:42 Related Case #2021CJ010025
On 06/22/2021, at approximately 2136 hours, I responded to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a disturbance. Upon arrival, I made
contact with Jennifer Lyn Kenast, who advised me of the following:
She rode in a separate vehicle to dinner and when she returned home with her family, she observed her neighbor, Joseph David
Newman, yelling at her husband. Joseph stated he would get a gun and shoot him (her husband) if he keeps yelling at him. She
advised that they have been gone all night.
After speaking with Jennifer, I made contact with her husband, James Charles Kenast, who said that when he got home and was
unloading his truck, Joseph started yelling at him and accusing him of shooting a BB gun at him. James said he didn’t own a BB
gun and did not shoot anything. He did yell back and used profanity.
After speaking with James, I made contact with Joseph, who said while he was standing outside with his dog, his neighbor started
yelling at him for no reason and then heard what he said to be a BB gunshot whiz by in the air. He then started yelling at his
neighbor and stated that he would hit him with a rock if he came to his property.
Joseph brought me to the side of his house and showed me his gutter, where he said it was shot with a BB gun. After looking at
the marks, it did not appear to be from a BB gun. He also stated that he knows that he should have reported the incident earlier
when it happened.
I advised both parties to refrain from going onto each other’s property, and this incident will be documented. Both parties agreed
to try and maintain the peace. I provided both parties a business card with the case and event numbers.
On 06/25/2021, at approximately 1833 hours, I made contact with Joseph who advised he had no further evidence to submit. I
explained to Joseph I created a report for Criminal Mischief and provided him with the new case number.
No police video available
No further information at this time.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
202160000590 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:22
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000590
Event #:
20211722931
99
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:S01092 SCHWARTZ, ERIK B
Reviewed By:S75100 SMITH, ALLISON
Assigned To:S01092 SCHWARTZ, ERIK B
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
DAMAGE PROP-CRIM MISCH 200 DOLS AND UNDER
Officer Shift:D
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
07/02/2021
07/02/2021
12/26/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 06/21/2021W142
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
Rpt Date:12/26/2021 22:25 Reporter:SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\ESchwartz Mod Date:12/26/2021 22:28 Related Case #
On 12/26/2021, I attempted to contact Joseph Newman in regards to this incident and to see if he had any further information to
provide. This yielded negative results. At this time I am inactivating this case.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
202160000590 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:22
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000590
Event #:
20211722931
100
Reported Day/Date:
Mon 11/22/2021 20:05
Time Dispatched:
11/22/2021 20:05
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
11/22/2021 20:10 11/22/2021 21:09 Mon 11/22/2021 20:05 Mon 11/22/2021 21:09
Subdivision:
NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
No
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A OTHER RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 01 01 0 00 N N I S 22CJR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 DAMAGE PROP-CRIM MISCH 200 DOLS AND
UNDER
806.131b1 2900 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#:
DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
VICTIM- ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, YESENIA RIVERA
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
504 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:VIC/WITRelationship:
Foul Play Suspected:
Extent of Injuries:
False
None
Injury 1:
Injury 2:
NOT APPLICABLE
NOT APPLICABLE
R/S: U/U DOB: or Age: 1
SUSPECT
XX UNKNOWN, 00000-0000 Phone:
Name: UNKOWN, UNKNOWN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:UNKNO
WN
Eyes:UNKNOW
N
DL#:XX DL State:
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:SUSPECTRelationship:OBTS#:FBI#:
State#: Local#: Misc Id: Other Id:
202160001133 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:01
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160001133
Event #:
20213262641
101
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
W135 - Winter Springs Police D
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 135 407-327-1000 Comments: ASSISTING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Montana, Cristina
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WS2 - Winter Springs Police De
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: ASSISTING SGT.
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Smith, Allison
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PROPERTY
Qty:
Model:
Status:Case Evidence/Seized
Units: ea
Brand: VERBATIM
Details: 1 CD-R WITH SIX PICTURES OF THE DAMAGE ON THE WINDOW
FROM THE BB`S
Owner#:
Evidence Tag:PDM1
Item#:1 Offense#: 1
1 Serial#:
CD-R Size: Color: MUL
Damage: Criminal
Mischief
Recovered Date:
Property Narrative: 1 CD-R WITH SIX PICTURES OF THE DAMAGE ON THE WINDOW FROM THE BB`S
Est Value:$1.00
$0.00
YCD
Rec. Value:
NCIC:
Theft Type:N/A
Owner:NEWMAN, YESENIA RIVERA
PCN:NIC:
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:11/23/2021 01:51 Reporter:MEYER, PRESTON D M29353 Clearance:Open Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\pmeyer Mod Date:11/23/2021 04:25 Related Case #2021CJ019484
On 11/22/2021 at 2005 hours I was dispatched to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a civil disturbance between neighbors. While
speaking with, Yesenia Rivera Newman, at 34 Jackson Circle. She advised the following;
Her husband, Joseph David Newman, was pulling weeds about a week ago and saw two blue/green BBs on the ground. He looked
up and saw new damage to their home from the BBs coming in contact with the window on the side of the home. She advised they
had reported previous damage done from BB`s coming in contact with their home. Yesenia let me know that the damage her
husband noticed was new. She advised the only way that the BBs could have come in contact with her home is if they were shot
from her neighbors at 36 Jackson Circle. Yesenia let me know that the neighbors do not like the floodlight they have. The damage
is relatively close to the floodlight.
Joseph did not want to fill out a statement form.
Yesenia filled out a sworn written statement and wishes to press charges.
I provided Yesenia with a victims rights brochure and nondisclosure form
I placed a CD with pictures of the damage on the windows in property and evidence under PDM1
Based on gathering all the facts someone committed Criminal Mischief under 200 dollars and under. (F.S.S 806.13 1b1).
No further information at this time.
No law enforcement video
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
MEYER, PRESTON D M29353
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
202160001133 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:01
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160001133
Event #:
20213262641
102
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Reviewed By:S75100 SMITH, ALLISON
Assigned To:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
DAMAGE PROP-CRIM MISCH 200 DOLS AND UNDER
Officer Shift:D
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
11/23/2021
11/23/2021
12/02/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 11/22/2021W146
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
Rpt Date:12/2/2021 18:33 Reporter:MEYER, PRESTON D M29353 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\pmeyer Mod Date:12/2/2021 18:40 Related Case #
On 12-02-2021 at 1828 hours I called, Yesenia Newman, to see if she had any new details or evidence to tell me about. Yesenia
advised the following;
She did not notice any more BB`s or property damage.
I let her know with the lack of evidence I would be inactivating the case. I told her if she notices anything new to please call the
police department and the case will be reopened.
No further information.
No police video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
MEYER, PRESTON D M29353
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
202160001133 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:01
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160001133
Event #:
20213262641
103
Reported Day/Date:
Tue 7/28/2020 17:27
Time Dispatched:
7/28/2020 17:27
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
7/28/2020 17:32 7/28/2020 18:25 Tue 7/28/2020 17:27 Tue 7/28/2020 17:27
Subdivision:
NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N I 22IR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 INFORMATION ONLY- NEIGHBOR DISPUTE 7777777777 9000 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
WINTER SPRINGS P.D.
Offense Indicator: 1 Other Id: 151 407-327-1000 Comments: INVESTIGATING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
CASTRO, JONATHAN A
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIRCLE WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:1
SSN:- Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XXX
505 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:UNKNOW
N
DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:US
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
1262 MARINA POINT #110 CASSELBERRY, FL 32707 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:1
SSN:- Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XXX
511 Wgt: Hair:WHITE Eyes:UNKNOW
N
DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:US
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
1262 MARINA POINT #110 CASSELBERRY, FL 32707 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, YESENIA RIVERA
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:1
SSN:- Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XXX
504 Wgt: Hair:BLACK Eyes:BLACK DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:US
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
2020CJ010837 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:24
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CJ010837
Event #:
20202102284
104
WINTER SPRINGS P.D.
Offense Indicator: 1 Other Id: 131 407-327-1000 Comments: FTO ASSISTING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
JONES, ANDREW
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:07/28/2020 19:10 Reporter:CASTRO, JONATHAN A C41494 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\SPhilbrook Mod Date:07/29/2020 00:12 Related Case #
On 07/28/2020, at approximately 1727 hours, I responded to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a neighbor dispute. Upon arrival I
made contact with Jennifer Kenast who advised me of the following:
Jennifer and her new neighbor at 34 Jackson Circle, have been having issues since the new neighbor started building their new
home. Jennifer said, the new neighbor has crossed over to her property multiple times and has not stayed on their side of the
property. Jennifer had to build a $10,000 dollar fence to keep the new neighbor’s equipment off her property. Jennifer also
informed me, the new neighbor has been rude to her and her husband and they constantly argue. Jennifer has kids that live with
her and mentioned that the new neighbor does not go the speed limit on the road and almost hit one of their sons. Jennifer
recently spoke to Officer Chavez about the situation via cellphone and was advised to maintain the peace. If the dispute happened
again to contact the Winter Springs Police.
Jennifer completed a sworn written statement.
I made contact with the new neighbor who I identified as Joseph David Newman by his Florida driver license and he advised me of
the following:
Joseph bought the land and is trying to build his new home without any issues. Jennifer at 36 Jackson Circle, has been interfering
with his work. Joseph informed to me, Jennifer and her husband have been complaining about everything they do from the time
he starts work on the home, until the time he leaves for the day. Joseph has tried to communicate with her nicely and tried to
keep the peace, but Jennifer continues to argue about the property line and the equipment being on her side. Joseph believes
Jennifer is the one crossing property lines and has been over multiple times on his side to remove materials from her property.
Yesenia, Joseph’s wife has been watching the incident unfold. Yesenia has attempted multiple times to remove her husband from
the situation, but Jennifer continues to antagonize the verbal dispute.
Joseph’s wife, Yesenia Newman, completed a sworn written statement.
I advised both parties to refrain from going onto each other’s property and this incident will be documented. Both parties agreed
to try and maintain the peace. I provided both parties a business card with the case number.
No further information at this time.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
CASTRO, JONATHAN A C41494
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2020CJ010837 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:24
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CJ010837
Event #:
20202102284
105
Rpt Date:07/30/2020 14:23 Reporter:Ballew, Thomas b83921 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\tballew Mod Date:07/30/2020 14:23 Related Case #
On 07/30/2020 at approximately 1400 hours, I spoke with Jennifer Kenast over the phone in reference to continuing issues
involving her neighbor at 34 Jackson Cir. Jennifer advised that her neighbor, Joseph Newman has been building a house for the
past year and has been utilizing a generator. For the past year the generator has been on the other side of the house furthest from
Jennifer’s property.
On 07/28/2020, Jennifer had to call the police because when she went to address an issue with Joseph he began yelling at her and
approaching her. Since then he has moved the generator from the other side of his house to where his and Jennifer’s property
line. It is not on her property and not touching her fence but it runs all day and is loud. She advised that he runs it in the
appropriate times outlined by ordinance. She believes he did this to harass them further after the incident the other night.
As of right now it does not sound like Joseph is violating the noise ordinance. Jennifer advised that she wanted to document this
for her records. I advised Jennifer to call if any other issues should arise or if the current issue violates the ordinance.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Ballew, Thomas b83921
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:10/20/2020 15:37 Reporter:SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\SSchmidt Mod Date:10/20/2020 15:47 Related Case #
On October 20, 2020 at 1509hrs, I arrived at 36 Jackson Circle. My response was in reference to a harassment complaint. Upon my
arrival I met with Jennifer Kenast who advised that after Code Enforcement left her neighbors residence at 34 Jackson Circle
today, her neighbor Joseph Newman, said to her "Hey!" while she was throwing away trash and then flipped her the "double bird."
Shortly thereafter, she advised that he turned on his generator again, and has no reason for doing so except to harass her.
While I was on scene with Ofc. Chavez, I heard the generator and observed Mr. Newman using an edge trimmer on his lawn. I
asked him about the generator and he stated that he needed it to use the compressor so he can finish building his shed. He stated
he can not use the electric in the house because it makes the compressor blow a fuse. I asked him about why he was using his
edge trimmer if he was building his shed, and he said the air compressor needed to "build up compression" before he could use it.
Mr. Newman appeared to be using his generator for a legitimate purpose. While speaking with Ms. Kanast again, I could hear Mr.
Newman use the air compressor.
Ms. Kenast wanting a supplement added to this case for documentation purposes. There were no violations observed while on
scene.
No police video.
Event 20202942159
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:11/3/2020 18:32 Reporter:COLANGELO, ADAM M C76550 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\AColangelo Mod Date:11/3/2020 18:44 Related Case #
2020CJ010837 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:24
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CJ010837
Event #:
20202102284
106
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:C41494 CASTRO, JONATHAN A
Reviewed By:P00265 PHILBROOK, SHAUN P
Assigned To:C41494 CASTRO, JONATHAN A
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
CIVIL DISPUTE
Officer Shift:B
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
07/29/2020
07/28/2020
07/28/2020
Section:W Unit:Date: 07/28/2020W151
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
On 11/03/2020 at approximately 1812 hours, I responded to 34 Jackson Circle in reference to an information report. Upon arrival I
made contact with Mr. Joseph Newman who stated the following;
Mr. Newman stated his next door neighbor at 36 Jackson Circle made a threatening comment to him earlier today and wanted to
make a report of it. Mr. Newman stated his neighbor told him "if I catch you out in the street I`m going to fuck you up". Mr.
Newman said he was prepared to defend himself if necessary.
Mr. Newman stated he is tired of the neighbor`s children walking by his house and flipping him the bird and telling him to "fuck
off". He also stated the neighbors keep poking their heads around the fence and watch his house.
Mr. Newman stated he and his wife are preparing to file harassment charges against the neighbors for the ongoing dispute.
There is no police video of this incident.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
COLANGELO, ADAM M C76550
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2020CJ010837 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:24
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 4 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CJ010837
Event #:
20202102284
107
Reported Day/Date:
Wed 12/22/2021 14:22
Time Dispatched:
12/22/2021 14:22
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
12/22/2021 14:28 12/22/2021 15:07 Wed 12/22/2021 14:28 Wed 12/22/2021 15:07
Subdivision:
RANCHLANDS
Incident Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N I 22IR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 INFORMATION ONLY- VERBAL DISTURBANCE 7777777777 9000 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
WS4 - Winter Springs Police De
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: ASSISTING SGT
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Philbrook, Shaun
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JAMES CHARLES
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:UNKNOWN
602 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
REPORTING PER-ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#:
DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
2021CJ021364 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:30
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ021364
Event #:
20213561794
108
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Reviewed By:P00265 PHILBROOK, SHAUN P
Assigned To:M29353 MEYER, PRESTON D
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
INFORMATION ONLY- VERBAL DISTURBANCE
Officer Shift:A
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
12/22/2021
12/22/2021
12/22/2021
Section:WS Unit:Date: 12/22/2021W146
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:12/22/2021 17:27 Reporter:MEYER, PRESTON D M29353 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\pmeyer Mod Date:12/22/2021 17:55 Related Case #
On 12-22-2021 at 1422 hours I was dispatched to 34 Jackson Circle in reference to a juvenile disturbance. Upon my arrival I
witnessed an individual at 36 Jackson Circle who later identified as, James Charles Kenast, yelling at the complainant, Joseph
David Newman. While James was yelling, Joseph did not say anything back and continued to set up spotlights. I walked up to
James and he advised the following:
He was working on his yard and Joseph started yelling at him. He advised earlier in the day his wife and daughter were yelled at
by Joseph. James advised he is tired of the constant harassment from Joseph. He advised he tells his kids to argue with Joseph if
he starts arguing. He advised he wanted this interaction to be documented.
After speaking with James, I spoke with Joseph, he advised the following:
He was setting up spotlights around his house because of all the catalytic converter thefts happening around Central Florida.
While setting up the lights James and his kids started to yell and videotape him. Joseph let me know every time James` kids see
him they give him the middle finger. Joseph advised he wanted this interaction documented.
I advised to both James and Joseph I would be completing an informational report.
No further information at this time.
No police video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
MEYER, PRESTON D M29353
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CJ021364 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:30
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ021364
Event #:
20213561794
109
Reported Day/Date:
Mon 6/21/2021 21:30
Time Dispatched:
6/21/2021 21:30
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
6/21/2021 21:36 6/21/2021 22:18 Mon 6/21/2021 21:25 Mon 6/21/2021 22:18
Subdivision:
RANCHLANDS
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N I 22IP Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 INFORMATION ONLY- NEIGHBOR DISPUTE 7777777777 9000 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE DEPT
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 8 4073276579 Comments:
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
LT. D. ACCOMANDO
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JAMES CHARLES
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:UNKNOWN
602 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:UNKNOWN
505 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BROWN DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
511 Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
2021CJ010025 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:58
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ010025
Event #:
20211722931
110
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:06/22/2021 01:23 Reporter:SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\asmith Mod Date:06/22/2021 03:25 Related Case #
On 06/22/2021, at approximately 2136 hours, I responded to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a disturbance. Upon arrival, I made
contact with Jennifer Lyn Kenast, who advised me of the following:
She rode in a separate vehicle to dinner and when she returned home with her family, she observed her neighbor, Joseph David
Newman, yelling at her husband. Joseph stated he would get a gun and shoot him (her husband) if he keeps yelling at him. She
advised that they have been gone all night.
After speaking with Jennifer, I made contact with her husband, James Charles Kenast, who said that when he got home and was
unloading his truck, Joseph started yelling at him and accusing him of shooting a BB gun at him. James said he didn’t own a BB
gun and did not shoot anything. He did yell back and used profanity.
After speaking with James, I made contact with Joseph, who said while he was standing outside with his dog, his neighbor started
yelling at him for no reason and then heard what he said to be a BB gunshot whiz by in the air. He then started yelling at his
neighbor and stated that he would hit him with a rock if he came to his property.
Joseph brought me to the side of his house and showed me his gutter, where he said it was shot with a BB gun. After looking at
the marks, it did not appear to be from a BB gun. He also stated that he knows that he should have reported the incident earlier
when it happened.
I advised both parties to refrain from going onto each other’s property, and this incident will be documented. Both parties agreed
to try and maintain the peace. I provided both parties a business card with the case and event numbers.
No police video available
No further information at this time.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:06/24/2021 16:06 Reporter:Accomando, Daniel a15746 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\daccomando Mod Date:06/24/2021 17:08 Related Case #
On 06/23/2021, I met with Mr. Newman in the lobby of the police department. Mr. Newman advised me of this case and explained he
had pictures of the suspected BB damage his house. I advised Mr. Newman to send the pictures to me so I could add them to this
report.
In the pictures it appears there was some type projectile shot at the residence. Due to the limited amount of damage it appears to
have been low velocity. In the pictures it is impossible to tell where the projectiles were shot from but, Mr. Newman advised he
believes his neighbor was shooting at one of his flood lights to disable it.
I uploaded the pictures to this report.
This information will be forwarded to the case officer.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Accomando, Daniel a15746
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:06/25/2021 17:50 Reporter:SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\ESchwartz Mod Date:06/25/2021 17:52 Related Case #202160000590
Do to further evidence a Offense Report was pulled see case # 202160000590.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
2021CJ010025 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:58
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ010025
Event #:
20211722931
111
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:S01092 SCHWARTZ, ERIK B
Reviewed By:S75100 SMITH, ALLISON
Assigned To:S01092 SCHWARTZ, ERIK B
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
INFORMATION ONLY- NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
Officer Shift:D
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
06/22/2021
06/22/2021
06/22/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 06/21/2021W142
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
SCHWARTZ, ERIK B S01092
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:11/23/2021 03:43 Reporter:MEYER, PRESTON D M29353 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\pmeyer Mod Date:11/23/2021 03:51 Related Case #2021CJ019484
On 11/22/2021 at 2005 hours I was dispatched to 36 Jackson Circle in reference to a civil disturbance between neighbors. Upon my
arrival I was met with, Jennifer Lynn Kenast, she advised the following;
She took her dog out to use the restroom and the dog went onto her neighbor, Joseph David Newman, property. She went to
retrieve the dog and her neighbor got very upset. Her daughter, Peyton Lynn Kenast, started to videotape the interaction between
them. Jennifer’s daughter showed me the video. Jennifer advised she wanted her daughter to record because there is an
investigation about Joseph stalking her daughter.
After watching the video I went to speak with the neighbors at 34 Jackson Circle. Upon my arrival I was met with, Yesenia Rivera
Newman, she advised the following;
Her husband noticed the dog around the fence separating their property. She advised he noticed that the daughter was filming him
from around the corner of the fence.
While speaking with Yesenia, Joseph walked out of the home and wanted to tell me what happened. He advised the following;
He noticed the dog by the fence and saw the daughter videotaping him. He walked over and started to film her. He did not know
why she was filming him. He stayed by the fence until he walked away to go inside and Jennifer called the police.
After reviewing both parties’ videos I determined that there was no crime committed.
While speaking with Joseph he pointed out there were BB gun marks and BB’s ammunition on the ground. He showed me the
marks on the house and told me they were new. After looking at the side of the house I determined that this would be criminal
mischief and pulled a new case number and a new report would be done to discuss the damage.
No further information.
No law enforcement video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
MEYER, PRESTON D M29353
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CJ010025 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:58
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 3
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ010025
Event #:
20211722931
112
Reported Day/Date:
Fri 10/8/2021 9:07
Time Dispatched:
10/8/2021 9:07
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
10/8/2021 9:07 10/8/2021 09:08
Subdivision:
Incident Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
03 00 00 0 00 I 50IR Open
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 WS CITY ORDINANCE - 13-1, GENERAL
PROHIBITION
77-777 9800 Yes C No
2 WS CITY ORDINANCE - NO BUILDING PERMIT 9-
606
105.1FBC 9800 Yes C No
3 WS CITY ORDINANCE - 5-10 ATTACHING ITEMS TO
TREE
77-777 9800 Yes C No
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age: 41
A
REPORTING PER-ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:
Wgt: Hair:Eyes:DL#:DL State:
Place of Birth:
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:10/8/2021 09:10 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:10/8/2021 09:40 Related Case #
2021CE002897 Printed On: 02/08/2022 8:43
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002897
Event #:
20212810947
113
Sec. 13-1. - General prohibition.
Nothing may be done on any lot which may become an annoyance or nuisance to the neighborhood. No refuse pile, unsightly
objects, or dead, damaged or diseased trees, that may pose a health, welfare and safety threat in the discretion of the city forester
or code enforcement manager, shall be allowed to be placed or suffered to remain thereon. In the event the owner shall fail or
refuse to keep premises free of refuse piles, unsightly objects or growths, or dead, damaged or diseased trees, then the city, upon
reasonable notice to the land owner, may enter upon such land and remove the same, or contract with a third party for the removal
of the same, at the expense of the owner and such entry shall not be deemed a trespass.
(Ord. No. 44, § 44.76, 1-8-68; Ord. No. 2002-09, § 2, 3-25-02)
Parcel 03-21-30-5BJ-0C00-007A
Owner(s)
NEWMAN, YESENIA
Property Address 34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Mailing 34 JACKSON CIR
WINTER SPGS, FL 32708-3424
Request Mailing Address Change
Subdivision Name NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES SEC 03
Tax District W1-WINTER SPRINGS
DOR Use Code 01-SINGLE FAMILY
Exemptions 00-HOMESTEAD(2021)
Agricultural Classification No - Additional Information
From: Jennifer Kenast >
Sent: Thursday, October 7, 2021 11:55 AM
To: Ted Johnson
Subject: Re: Code of Ordinance
EXTERNAL EMAIL:
[Caution: Do not click on links or open any attachments unless you trust the sender and know the content is safe.]
Hello,
Thank You for your response. I have a neighbor who resides at 34 Jackson Circle who has not only turned the security light on his
home to point towards mine but has added 2 additional lights on a trees. He leaves the house light on all night at times. I have
purchased 2 trees and blackout curtains for my bedroom, but need to buy additional trees to still block the light. The 2 lights he
added to 2 trees come on every time I pull into my driveway. Those 2 lights literally only light up a few feet of his property and
mostly on mine. This is being done out of spite due to past issues with him. I am just wondering why the code of ordinances only
talks about in pool lighting crossing a property line and not other forms of lighting. I have addressed this with the Winter Springs
Police department and Code Enforcement and they tell me since it lights up a portion of his yard there is nothing they can do
since there is nothing on the codes so I would like to find a way to include home/additional lights like Sec 6-222 talks about the
pool lighting.
Hello,
I spoke to someone about 2 weeks ago but unfortunately I didn`t get his name and he said he would call me back and haven`t
heard. I am trying to figure out the process to request a code be modified or changed. How would I go about the process? I am
looking to have lights on homes added to Nuisances since it is a form of light pollution.
Thanks
Jen Kenast
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:10/15/2021 13:19 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:10/15/2021 13:27 Related Case #
2021CE002897 Printed On: 02/08/2022 8:43
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002897
Event #:
20212810947
114
Today, I met with Joseph Newman of 34 Jackson Circle. This was regarding his outdoor lights that were point towards 36 Jackson
Circle. Upon arrival, I observed the generator running in the back of his pickup truck. It had a power cord feed to an air
compressor that was closer to his garage. I knocked on the door and was met by Mr. Newman. I informed him of why I was there
and inquired to when this would stop. He was adamant that he wanted it to end, and live peacefully amongst neighbors. He
invited me inside where she showed me that we were working in the bedroom closet installing shelves. I observed the air house
running into the closet with a nail gun attached to it.
I gave him suggestions on light placement as to not shine into the neighbor`s property. Additionally, I instructed him to call our
non-emergency line if he believes that the neighbors light was shinning onto his property.
When I left Mr. Newman had a good understanding that any further issues the courts will be deciding the outcome and that they
needed to find a way to live in a civil manner as adults.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:10/26/2021 09:58 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:10/26/2021 10:00 Related Case #
Lights are still pointing on neighbors` property, will be set for CB in January.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:12/13/2021 10:22 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:12/13/2021 10:28 Related Case #
Jennifer indicated that a shed was placed int he backyard without a permit. Upon research for a permit, none was found. I`m
sending an updated NCV to address the shed and lights attached to the trees. See pictures.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:01/3/2022 15:05 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:01/3/2022 15:07 Related Case #
Lights are still an issue. Will set for Code Board in January.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:01/5/2022 13:04 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:01/5/2022 13:02 Related Case #
2021CE002897 Printed On: 02/08/2022 8:43
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002897
Event #:
20212810947
115
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Reviewed By:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Assigned To:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Clearance:
Comments:
Open
LIGHTS, NOTHING MAY BE DONE ON ANY LOT WHICH MAY BECOME AN ANNOYANCE OR NUISANCE TO THE
NEIGHBORHOOD
Officer Shift:
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
10/08/2021
10/08/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 10/08/2021W2
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
I posted CB notices on property and met with the homeowner Yesenia. I informed her of why this was occurring. Later in the day
she sent me a request to postpone as she was going to be flying back into town that day and would miss this time. I agreed to
push this case to February.
Hi Deputy Tracht,
I received the notice of hearing for January 25th. Unfortunately, I already have an out of town trip scheduled and will not be able to
attend.
Can you please reschedule for a later date?
Thank you!
Yesenia Newan
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:02/2/2022 08:55 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:02/2/2022 08:52 Related Case #
Today I posted new code board notices at the property and CH. Also, it was mailed a certified return receipt, an affidavit of posting
was completed.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CE002897 Printed On: 02/08/2022 8:43
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 4 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002897
Event #:
20212810947
116
Reported Day/Date:
Thu 9/2/2021 6:52
Time Dispatched:
9/2/2021 6:52
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
9/2/2021 6:52 9/2/2021 07:43 Thu 9/2/2021 6:52 Thu 9/2/2021 6:52
Subdivision:
FOXMOOR
Incident Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA HIGHWAY/ROADWAY
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N D3 50SOR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 WS CITY ORDINANCE - ILLEGAL SIGNS 16-57 9800 Yes C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 4073271000 Comments:
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
GUERRA, TERRI
OTHER/GOVT
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PROPERTY
Qty:
Model:
Status:Other
Units:
Brand:
Details: WOODEN SIGN
Owner#:
Evidence Tag:
Item#:1 Offense#: 1
1 Serial#:
Size: Color:
Damage: N/A Recovered Date:
Property Narrative: WOODEN SIGN
Est Value:$1.00
$0.00
JSIGN
Rec. Value:
NCIC:
Theft Type:
Owner:*OWNER NOT ENTERED*
PCN:NIC:
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:R08407 HILL, BRITTANY Officer Shift:A Section:W Unit:Date: 09/02/2021W120
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:09/2/2021 08:02 Reporter:HILL, BRITTANY R08407 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\bhill Mod Date:09/2/2021 08:03 Related Case #
At the request of Code Enforcement Officer Guerra, I went to 34 Jackson Circle in reference to a sign pick up.
I observed a wooden sign with the words “Post the whole truth neighbor Karen”. I measured from one side of the roadway to
where the end of the sign was located and it was approximately 34 feet. Pictures are attached to this report regarding the location
of the sign in the right of way and the distance.
The sign was removed.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
HILL, BRITTANY R08407
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CE002383 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:26
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002383
Event #:
20212450689
117
Reviewed By:s85385 Stephens, Robert
Assigned To:R08407 HILL, BRITTANY
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
CODE ENFORCEMENT - SIGN PICK UP
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
09/02/2021
09/02/2021
09/02/2021
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
2021CE002383 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:26
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002383
Event #:
20212450689
118
Reported Day/Date:
Tue 9/21/2021 7:47
Time Dispatched:
9/21/2021 7:47
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
9/21/2021 8:20 9/21/2021 09:54
Subdivision:
Incident Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 V 22NIR Unfounded
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 WS CITY ORDINANCE - OTHER WS CITY ORD.13-31
NOISE DISTURBANCE
77-777 9000 Yes C No
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:g67806 Guerra, Terri
Reviewed By:g67806 Guerra, Terri
Assigned To:g67806 Guerra, Terri
Clearance:
Comments:
Unfounded
NOISE COMPLAINT
Officer Shift:
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
09/21/2021
09/21/2021
09/21/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 09/21/2021W804
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:09/21/2021 12:39 Reporter:Guerra, Terri g67806 Clearance:Open Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\tguerra Mod Date:09/21/2021 12:54 Related Case #
I responded out to 36 Jackson Cir. regarding a noise complaint for 34 Jackson Cir.. When I got on scene I could hear the generator
going. It was 830 when I got out of my truck. I made contact with the complainant and advised her I would take a reading. I
measured 25 feet from the fence line and put the tripod at the location near the front yard. I got out my instrument to do the wind
speed and temperature. The temperature was 76.1. Humidity showed 72.3 with 0 wind speed. I used the calibration device to
calibrate the sound machine. When finished I attached the microphone to the meter and started the reading. I then slowing moved
the tripod neck so that is was 5 feet from the ground to do the reading. If I did it before I would not be able to see the screen. I
stepped back by the garage for 10 minutes. The whole time conducting the investigation I hear no change in the sound of the
generator. I heard no equipment being used. I did hear a radio playing as well. When finished I collected my reading. It was 27.9
LAeq and 33.9 LCeq it ended at 0910 hours. The noise was not a violation at that time. The complainant also told me about the
shed in the back of the neighbors property that had no permit. I advised her I couldn`t see it from where I was. I walked further into
her yard. There were holes in the fence that I could see into the neighbors yard. I saw a shed. A saw on the ground and a large
radio playing in the garage. It did not appear to have any cords. I advised the complainant I would look into the shed complaint.
When I left I could see the generator on the the back of the a truck pulled near the fence. I also saw a compressor several feet
away. I did not see anyone working.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Guerra, Terri g67806
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CE002626 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:29
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 1
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CE002626
Event #:
20212640816
119
Reported Day/Date:
Thu 8/6/2020 14:02
Time Dispatched:
8/6/2020 14:02
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
8/6/2020 14:02 8/6/2020 14:27 Thu 8/6/2020 14:02 Thu 8/6/2020 14:27
Subdivision:
NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES
Incident Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 I 50IR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 WS CITY ORDINANCE - NOISE METER VIOLATION 13-30 9800 Yes C No
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:08/6/2020 16:33 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:08/6/2020 16:53 Related Case #
Parcel 03-21-30-5BJ-0C00-007A
Owner(s) NEWMAN, YESENIA & JOSEPH
Property Address 34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Mailing 1262 MARINA PT #110
CASSELBERRY, FL 32707-6477
Subdivision Name NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES SEC 03
Tax District W1-WINTER SPRINGS
DOR Use Code 00-VACANT RESIDENTIAL
From: Jennifer Kenast >
Sent: Monday, August 3, 2020 1:20 PM
To: _Police Code Enforcement Bureau <_PoliceCodeEnforcementBureau@winterspringsfl.org>
Subject: Question
EXTERNAL EMAIL:
[Caution: Do not click on links or open any attachments unless you trust the sender and know the content is safe.]
Hello,
I would like to know if a neighbor is allowed to back his generator up to property line and direct the noise on my property?
He is building a home so he is using the generator, there is plenty of room for him to put his generator but due to argument last
week over him placing items on our fence he now backs up a trailer with his generator inside to directs the noise onto my property
up and until the disagreement the generator for the past year has been in the back of the home. No matter where the generator is I
can hear and understand he can run it, but my question is he allowed to direct the fumes and noise at my property. I work from
home and will have children learning from home in a few weeks and I can tell you its a lot louder in my home now that he is
directing at my house.
I don`t want an officer out at my home because it will cause him to more angry if he allowed to do so, but if not then we will take
that step of having someone come out if that is needed. I spoke to an officer last week and he said he can run the generator but
wasn`t sure about intentional directing the noise on to my property. I have read the code enforcement codes online but still unsure
since it specially doesn`t state.
Thanks
Jen
2020CE001946 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:27
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CE001946
Event #:
20202191906
120
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Reviewed By:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Assigned To:t69849 Tracht, Matthew
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
SOUND METER CASE
Officer Shift:
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
08/06/2020
08/06/2020
08/18/2020
Section:W Unit:Date: 08/06/2020W3
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:08/7/2020 09:39 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:08/7/2020 09:51 Related Case #
Yesterday, I met with Jennifer and her husband at 36 Jackson Cir. to conduct a sound reading of the generator that was facing her
property. The meter was set up approximately 30 feet from her property line away from the generator. I conducted a wind,
temperature and humidity reading, conducted a calibration test and conducted the 10 minute sound reading. This reading was
recorded on a noise investigation field sheet. The results of the LAS/LCS are 64.2 & 70.9. The allowable permitted level of sound
in a residential area for 0700-2200 is 60/70.
The sound is occurring as a result of a new house construction project located next door at 34 Jackson Circle. During this test, the
owner came to the property line and started yelling while i was taking the reading. Apparently this neighbor feud has been going
on some time and this is just the latest call for service regarding the two. while still at 36 Jackson Cir. dispatch received a call
from 34 Jackson Cir in regards to filling a harassment complaint against his neighbors. Mr. Newman (owner) requested a police
response. Once done with 36 Jackson, i drove over to 34 and met with Mr. Newman. I listened to his side, told him why I was
there, and that he was in violation of the noise ordinance. Mr. Newman finally moved the generator away from the property line to
which he admitted he did intentionally. I took another 10 minute reading form 36 and obtained levels of 60.9/69.3.
At that time in informed him that he was still over slightly and he agreed to move the generator a little further away. Furthermore I
told him that he would be getting a letter in mail outlining the violation at hand, to which he acknowledged.
I will follow up on this case.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:08/18/2020 08:05 Reporter:Tracht, Matthew t69849 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht Mod Date:08/18/2020 08:05 Related Case #
Construction is coming to an end, no other complaints have come in.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Tracht, Matthew t69849
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2020CE001946 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:27
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB1 CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2020CE001946
Event #:
20202191906
121
Reported Day/Date:
Wed 9/29/2021 15:28
Time Dispatched:
9/29/2021 15:28
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
9/29/2021 15:29 9/29/2021 16:19
Subdivision:
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 01 01 0 00 I 14IR Transferred to
SAO (Capias)
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 STALKING FOLLOW HARASS CYBERSTALK
ANOTHER
784.0482 130C No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
VICTIM-JUVENILE
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name:
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
505 Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:BLUE DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
CONFIDENTIAL PERSON
VIC/WITRelationship:
Foul Play Suspected:
Extent of Injuries:
False
None
Injury 1:
Injury 2:
NOT APPLICABLE
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
SUSPECT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN:Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
511 Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:SUSPECTRelationship:OBTS#:FBI#:
State#: Local#: Misc Id: Other Id:
IDENTIFIER SECTION
Name:NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Identifier:BUILD OTHER / BUILD OTHER
202160000939 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:03
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WC2 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000939
Event #:
20212722196
122
LE/BUSINESS SECTION
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
ACCOMANDO, DANIEL
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
CASTRO, JONATHAN A
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
COLANGELO, ADAM M
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
CODE ENFORCMENT
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
GUERRA, TERRI
WITNESS/GOVT
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
PRESLEY, KEVIN
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
SCHWARTZ, ERIK B
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-7977 Comments: REPORTING / INVESTIGATING OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
SEELY, DOUG
REPORTING PER-LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: CALL TAKER - WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
Stephens, Robert
OTHER/LE OFFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE
Offense Indicator: Other Id: 407-327-1000 Comments: WITNESS OFFICER
Type:
Address:
Name:Contact:
Phone#:
TRACHT, MATTHEW
WITNESS- LE OFCR
300 N MOSS RD WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
PROPERTY
Qty:
Model:
Status:Case Evidence/Seized
Units: ea
Brand:
Details: USB CONTAINING DATA
Owner#:
Evidence Tag:DWS1
Item#:1 Offense#: 1
1 Serial#:
Size: Color:
Damage: Recovered Date:
Property Narrative: USB, DATA CONTAINING VIDEO AND PHOTOGRAPHS
Est Value:$5.00
$0.00
DTHUMBD
Rec. Value:
NCIC:
Theft Type:
Owner:*OWNER NOT ENTERED*
PCN:NIC:
202160000939 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:03
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WC2 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000939
Event #:
20212722196
123
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:09/29/2021 16:58 Reporter:Stephens, Robert s85385 Clearance:Open Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\cdeisler Mod Date:09/30/2021 10:57 Related Case #
On 09/29/2021, at 1529 hours, I arrived at 300 N Moss Rd. My response was in reference to meeting with to collect
her sworn written statement at the request of Lt. Seely. Upon my arrival, I came in contact with who was identified by
her Florida driver license. I was provided with a six page sworn written statement, which was signed by in my
presence. The statements were in reference to the ongoing harassment is receiving from her neighbor Joseph
Newman. I provided with a victim rights brochure per Amendment six Marsy’s Law. Mrs. Newman also provided me
with a non-discloser form.
This concludes my involvement in this case.
No police video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Stephens, Robert s85385
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:11/8/2021 10:37 Reporter:Seely, Doug s51322 Clearance:Transferred to
SAO (Capias)
Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\dseely Mod Date:11/10/2021 11:15 Related Case #
The following is a capias request for Joseph David Newman W/M 10/06/1967 who resides at 34 Jackson Circle for FSS 784.048 (2)
for the constant harassment against the neighbor victim. The neighbor victim, is at a point that she is willing to
prosecute.
Probable Cause exists for Violation of Florida State Statute 784.048 (2). Over the past year the documented reports of Joseph
David Newman constantly berating the victim, purposely putting a running generator on his tailgate of his truck and getting as
close to the property as possible, and now putting a light on his house and pointing it at the victim`s house is causing distress of
the victim.
Joseph David Newman has been and continues to be unwilling to stop the behavior even after many discussions and reports
written.
Victim, outlines in her sworn statement and detailed documentation that the harassment has been ongoing for
almost two years. It had intensified after 7/28/2020 after Joseph David Newman started screaming at her after she called the police
because he leaned building materials on the victim’s fence. Victim, has also provided many photographs and
video as supporting documentation which were entered into property and evidence under DWS1. A duplicate copy has been
submitted to the State Attorney.
Joseph David Newman continuously puts a running generator on the tailgate of his truck and backs the truck up to as close as
possible to the property line (see attached photograph). This is done even though he has current connected electricity being
supplied to the residence. Victim works from home and the generator can be constantly heard in the background
as a disruption.
Holes have been mysteriously appearing in the fence that belongs to the victim between the two properties that otherwise would
not be there (see attached photograph).
The constant stress of the situation between neighbors is now causing health issues of the victim.
The recent issue, which is currently pending Code Enforcement, is Joseph David Newman has installed residential spotlights on
his property and pointed them at the victim’s residence. (see attached photograph).
Research was done for dispatched calls for service reports, police written reports, to show the constant harassment and are
included with this report.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
Seely, Doug s51322
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
202160000939 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:03
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 3 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WC2 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000939
Event #:
20212722196
124
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:s85385 Stephens, Robert
Reviewed By:s85385 Stephens, Robert
Assigned To:s51322 Seely, Doug
Clearance:
Comments:
Transferred to SAO (Capias)
HARRASSMENT
Officer Shift:A
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
09/29/2021
09/29/2021
Section:W Unit:Date: 09/29/2021WS6
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
202160000939 Printed On: 02/08/2022 10:03
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 4 of 4
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WC2 OFFENSE REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
NoGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
202160000939
Event #:
20212722196
125
Reported Day/Date:
Thu 12/23/2021 15:26
Time Dispatched:
12/23/2021 15:26
Time Arrived:Time Completed:Date Occurred From:Date Occurred To:
12/23/2021 15:33 12/23/2021 15:50 Thu 12/23/2021 15:00 Thu 12/23/2021 15:36
Subdivision:
FOXMOOR
Incident Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
Forced Entry:
N/A
Occupancy:Type of Weapon:Location Type:
N/A NA RESIDENCE/SINGLE
Municipality:
WS
Dispatch Address:
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708
#Offenses:#Victims:#Offenders:#Prem. Ent:#Arrested:Drug Related:Alcohol Related:Call Disposition:Signal Code:Clearance:
01 00 00 0 00 N N I 13MIR Inactive
OFFENSES SECTION
Off#Description Statute#UCR Ordinance
Attempt/
Commit Warrant #DVR Drug Activity
1 INFORMATION ONLY- SUSPICIOUS MAIL 7777777777 9000 No C No N/A
Drug Type:N/A
PERSON SECTION
R/S: W/F DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
36 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: KENAST, JENNIFER LYNN
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:BROWN Eyes:DL#: DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
R/S: W/M DOB: or Age:
A
OTHER/ADULT
34 JACKSON CIR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Phone:
Name: NEWMAN, JOSEPH DAVID
Person Type:
Address:
Job:
Offense Indicator:
SSN: Hgt:Adult/Juvenile:
City of Birth:XX
Wgt: Hair:GREY Eyes:BLUE DL#:
DL State:FL
Place of Birth:XX
Email:
Cell Phone:
OthPhone1:
NOK:
NOK Address:
OthPhone2:
NOK:
NOK Phone:
Emp. Address:Bus. Phone:
Comments:
2021CJ021420 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:53
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 1 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ021420
Event #:
20213571980
126
ADMINISTRATIVE SECTION
Was Crime Scene Processed:No Processed By:
Officer Reporting:S81326 SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J
Reviewed By:P00265 PHILBROOK, SHAUN P
Assigned To:S81326 SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J
Clearance:
Comments:
Inactive
SUSPICIOUS MAIL
Officer Shift:A
Review Date:
Assigned Date:
Clearance Date:
12/23/2021
12/23/2021
12/23/2021
Section:WS Unit:Date: 12/23/2021W138
Routed to:
Assigned Dept:
Referred To:
WS
WS
NARRATIVES
Rpt Date:12/23/2021 16:08 Reporter:SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:O
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\SSchmidt Mod Date:12/23/2021 16:12 Related Case #
On December 23, 2021 at 1533 hrs., I arrived at 36 Jackson Circle. My response was in reference to the complainant stating that
she had received some suspicious mail at her house. Upon my arrival I met with Jennifer Kenast, who I know from previous law-
enforcement contact, who stated to me as follows:
This afternoon she received a package from Amazon. It was a mug that said “eat a bag of dicks.” In addition, there was a gift note
which stated “ Merry Christmas Karen! We hope this will make your holiday is a little brighter! Life is too short to stay mad :) from
your friends.”
Jennifer believes that it was sent from her neighbor at 34 Jackson Circle, Joseph Newman, with whom she has a history with. She
noted that the mug was ordered on December 20, 2021 which was the same day that she believes her neighbor received a letter
from the city in reference to a complaint she made about lights on his trees for Christmas. She said that same day that he started
using his generator a loudly again, and coincidently was the day the mug was shown as ordered on Amazon.
Jennifer stated for now she’s going to keep the mug and try to find out through Amazon who ordered the mug. I informed Jennifer
that at this point it may not be a bad idea to go to the Courthouse on Monday and file a restraining order on her neighbor.
I’ve uploaded photos to café with the mug and the Amazon receipts.
I have no further information of the time.
No police video.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
Rpt Date:12/23/2021 17:33 Reporter:SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326 Clearance:Inactive Nar Type:S
Mod By:WINTERSPRINGS\SSchmidt Mod Date:12/23/2021 17:34 Related Case #
On December 23, 2021 Jennifer forwarded me an e-mail from Amazon which showed the purchase of the mug was made by
Yesenia Newman, the wife of Joseph Newman.
I have attached the email.
I have no further information at this time.
I swear/affirm the above statements are true and correct:
Officer's Signature:
Sworn to and subscribed before me, the undersigned
authority, this _________ day of ___________________, in the year__________________
SCHMIDT, SAMANTHA J S81326
Name and Employee # (Printed)
Name/Title of Person Authorized to Administer Oath.
________________________________________________________________
2021CJ021420 Printed On: 02/08/2022 9:53
Printed by: WINTERSPRINGS\mtracht
Page 2 of 2
Agency ORI: FL0590600
Region:
W
CSA:
WB0 CJIS REPORT
Winter Springs Police Department
For the public:
Juvenile:
Domestic Violence:
No
No
YesGrid:
Dating Violence:No
Agency Report #:
2021CJ021420
Event #:
20213571980
127
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Case: 2021CE002897
Address: 34 Jackson Circle
Winter Springs Florida 32708
Parcel: Property Owner(s): Yesenia Newman
Inspector: Deputy Chief M. Tracht
Complaint: 13-1 General Prohibition- Nothing may be
done on any lot which may become an annoyance or
nuisance to the neighborhood.
Complainant: Jennifer Kenast, 36 Jackson Circle
128
•NCV & CB notices sent via certified mailings, return receipt. Posting at
property and City Hall was completed in accordance with FSS.
•This case stems from a neighbor dispute that has been ongoing since
2020.
•Since July 2020, we responded (36 Jackson) 8 times for various
disturbances. 12 code complaints to (34 Jackson) and 2 disturbances.
129
2019
130
2021
131
132
133
134
135
136
I ask that you find the property owner in
violation of ordinance 13-1 by which, creating
an environment to purposefully annoy and/or
create a nuisance to the residents of 36 Jackson
Circle.
I ask that you order the homeowner to adjust all
lighting as to not shine anywhere within reason
onto 36 Jackson Circle or create anything that
would project light onto 36 Jackson Circle,
within 6 calendar days from this hearing
(February 28, 2022).
If no compliance is met, I’m recommended a fine
of 250.00 per day until compliance is met.
137
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, COMPLAINT NO: 2021CE001969 PETITIONER, vs. RESPONDENT NOTICE OF CODE BOARD HEARING
Please take notice that at 5:30 P.M. on February 22, 2022 the Code Enforcement Board will hold a hearing to determine why you
should not be found in violation of the City Code as follows. The hearing will be held at the Winter Springs City Hall located at 1126
East State Road 434, Winter Springs, Florida.
Address of Violation: 722 LAKESIDE DR. WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Property Owner Name: ANTHONY KOUIS & CAROLINE KOUIS
Property Owner Address: 2453 HOPE AVE. DELTONA, FL 32738-2408
The cited violations are as follows:
IPMC 304.10 STAIRWAYS DECKS
PORCHES AND BALCONIES
REPAIR SCREENS ON THE PORCHES THAT ARE RIPPED
WS CITY ORD. 13-2 (C) OVERGROWN
YARD
CUT AND MAINTAIN OVERGROWN BUSHES IN THE BACK OF THE
RESIDENCE
IPMC 304.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT PAINT IS CHIPPING OFF OF THE OUTSIDE OF THE HOUSE IN SEVERAL
AREAS.
IPMC 304.9 OVERHANG EXTENSIONS SOFFITS FALLING FROM OVERHANG. THEY NEED TO BE REPAIRED.
IPMC 302.1 SANITATION CLEAN BLACK AND GREEN GROWTH OFF OF THE OUTSIDE OF THE
PROPERTY.
IPMC 304.6 EXTERIOR WALLS WOOD IS ROTTING ON THE BACK OF THE HOUSE. SEVERAL WOOD BEAMS
ARE ALSO ROTTING AND HAVE CRACKS AND HOLES IN THEM.
If the Code Enforcement Board finds your property in violation of the above referenced City Code (s) you can be fined up to per day for each day the violation continues and you can be charged for the costs that are incurred by the city in prosecuting the case. In the event violation fines and the costs are not paid within a reasonable time there can be a lien filed against the property in accordance with Florida State Statute Section 162.09. The hearing is conducted within guidelines of City of Winter Springs Code 2-60 and Florida State Statutes Chapter 162. You may appear in person or by an authorized representative. If you choose to not attend the hearing you can lose your right to present facts in this case. You have the right to present evidence, exhibits, written and oral testimony. The Code Board will subpoena witnesses on your behalf upon written request to the Code Board through the City Of Winter Springs Clerk’s Office.
PARCEL OWNER: ANTHONY KOUIS CAROLINE KOUIS 2453 HOPE AVE. DELTONA, FL 32738-2408
138
In the event that you appeal the Order of the Code Enforcement Board, you will be required to have an official record of the proceedings. You may, at your own expense, arrange for the official transcript of the testimony and evidence presented at the hearing. I certify a copy of this document was sent by Certified Mail on 02/04/2022, posted on the property, and at a government office as per Florida State Statute 162. Certified Number: 7021 0950 0000 2361 9423 The text of the associated violations, as it appears in the Municipal Code, is stated below:
IPMC 304.10 Stairways, decks, porches and balconies. Every exterior stairway, deck, porch and balcony, and all appurtenances attached thereto, shall be maintained structurally sound, in good repair, with proper anchorage and capable of supporting the imposed loads.
WS CITY ORD. 13-2(C) The existence of excessive accumulation or untended growth of weeds, undergrowth or other dead, or living plant life; or stagnant water, rubbish, garbage, refuse, debris, trash, including but not limited to household furnishings, and all other objectionable, unsightly or unsanitary matter upon any lot, tract or parcel of land within this city be it uncovered or under open shelter, to the extent and in the manner that such lot, tract or parcel of land is or may reasonably become infested or inhabited by rodents, vermin or wild animals, or may furnish a breeding place for mosquitoes, or threatens or endangers the public health, safety, or welfare, or may reasonably cause disease, or adversely affects and impairs the economic welfare of adjacent property, or any other objectionable, unsightly substance or material tending by its existence and/or accumulation to endanger or adversely Effect of health, safety, lives, and/or welfare of the citizens of the city, is hereby prohibited and declared to be a public nuisance and unlawful.
IPMC 304.2 Protective treatment. All exterior surfaces, including but not limited to, doors,
door and window frames, cornices, porches, trim, balconies, decks and fences shall be maintained in good condition. Exterior wood surfaces, other than decay- resistant woods, shall be protected from the elements and decay by painting or other protective covering or treatment. Peeling, flaking and chipped paint shall be eliminated and sur- faces repainted. All siding and masonry joints as well as those between the building envelope and the perimeter of windows, doors, and skylights shall be maintained weather resistant and water tight. All metal surfaces subject to rust or corrosion shall be coated to inhibit such rust and corrosion and all surfaces with rust or corrosion shall be stabilized and coated to inhibit future rust and corrosion. Oxidation stains shall be removed from exterior surfaces. Surfaces designed for stabilization by oxidation are exempt from this requirement.
IPMC 304.9 Overhang extensions. All overhang extensions including, but not limited to canopies, marquees, signs, metal awnings, fire escapes, standpipes and exhaust ducts shall be maintained in good repair and be properly anchored so as to be kept in a sound condition. When required, all exposed surfaces of metal or wood shall be protected from the elements and against decay or rust by periodic application of weather-coating materials, such as paint or similar surface treatment
IPMC 302.1 All exterior property and premises shall be maintained in a clean, safe and sanitary condition. The occupant shall keep that part of the exterior property which such
139
occupant occupies or controls in a clean and sanitary condition.
IPMC 304.6 Exterior walls. All exterior walls shall be free from holes, breaks, and loose or
rotting materials; and maintained weatherproof and properly surface coated where required to prevent deterioration.
_________________________________
CODE OFFICER TERRI SANCHEZ
140
State of Florida Accredited Agency
WINTER SPRINGS POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 300 North Moss Road - Winter Springs, FL 32708 Business (407) 327-1000 - Fax (407) 327-6652
February 10, 2022
Case #: 2021CE001969
Service Address: 722 LAKESIDE DR. WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 NOTICE OF CODE VIOLATIONS The above mentioned property has been inspected on the dates below.
Inspector Date
CODE OFFICER TERRI SANCHEZ JULY 27, 2021
Violation Description Comments/Corrections Needed
IPMC 304.10 STAIRWAYS DECKS PORCHES
AND BALCONIES
REPAIR SCREENS ON THE PORCHES THAT ARE RIPPED
WS City Ord. 13-2(c) (Overgrown Yard) CUT MAINTAIN OVERGROWN BUSHES IN THE BACK OF THE
RESIDENCE.
IPMC 304.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT PAINT IS CHIPPING OFF OF THE OUTSIDE OF HOUSE IN SEVERAL
AREAS.
IPMC 304.9 OVERHANG EXTENSTIONS SOFFITS FALLING FROM OVERHANG. THEY NEED TO BE REPAIRED.
IPMC 302.1 SANITATION BLACK AND GREEN GROWTH ON THE OUTSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE
NEEDS TO BE CLEANED OFF.
IPMC 304.6 EXTERIOR WALLS WOOD IS ROTTING ON THE WOOD BACK OF HOUSE. SEVERAL WOOD
BEAMS ARE ALSO ROTTED AND HAVE CRACKS AND HOLES.
Failure to correct the violation(s) and to notify the Winter Springs Code Enforcement Division of the corrections will result in charges being brought against you before the City of Winter Springs Code Enforcement Board which has the power to levy fines up to $250.00 per day for first offenses or up to $500.00 for repeat offenses per day that the violation remains.
Corrective Action Comments Due Date
Notice of Code Violation See specific correction comments provided. 01/28/2022
Municipal Code Code Text
IPMC 304.10 Stairways, decks, porches and balconies. Every exterior stairway, deck, porch and balcony, and all appurtenances attached thereto, shall be maintained structurally sound, in good repair, with proper anchorage and capable of supporting the imposed
loads. WS City Ord. 13-2 (c) The existence of excessive accumulation or untended growth of weeds, undergrowth or other dead, or living plant life; or stagnant water, rubbish, garbage, refuse, debris, trash, including but not limited to household furnishings, and all other
ANTHONY KOUIS CAROLINE KOUIS 2453 HOPE AVE. DELTONA, FL 32738-2408
141
2
objectionable, unsightly or unsanitary matter upon any lot, tract or parcel of land within this city be it uncovered or under open shelter, to the extent and in the manner that such lot, tract or parcel of land is or may reasonably become infested or inhabited by rodents, vermin or wild animals, or may furnish a breeding place for mosquitoes, or threatens or endangers the public health, safety, or welfare, or may reasonably cause disease, or adversely affects and impairs the economic welfare of
adjacent property, or any other objectionable, unsightly substance or material
tending by its existence and/or accumulation to endanger or adversely affect of health, safety, lives, and/or welfare of the citizens of the city, is hereby prohibited and declared to be a public nuisance and unlawful. IPMC 304.2 Protective treatment. All exterior surfaces, including but not limited to, doors, door and window frames, cornices, porches, trim, balconies, decks and fences shall be maintained in good condition. Exterior wood surfaces, other than decay resistant
woods, shall be protected from the elements and decay by painting or other protective covering or treatment. Peeling, flaking and chipped paint shall be eliminated and surfaces repainted. All siding and masonry joints as well as those between the building envelope and the perimeter of windows, doors, and skylights shall be maintained weather resistant and water tight. All metal surfaces subject to rust or corrosion shall be coated to inhibit such rust and corrosion and all surfaces with rust or corrosion shall be stabilized and coated to inhibit future rust and corrosion. Oxidation stains shall be removed from exterior surfaces. Surfaces designed for stabilization by oxidation are exempt from this requirement.
IPMC 304.9 Overhang extensions. All overhang extensions including, but not limited to canopies, marquees, signs, metal awnings, fire escapes, standpipes and exhaust ducts shall be maintained in good repair and be properly anchored so as to be kept in a sound condition. When required, all exposed surfaces of metal or wood shall be protected from the elements and against decay or rust by periodic application of weather-coating materials, such as paint or similar surface treatment.
IPMC 302.1 Sanitation. All exterior property and premises shall be maintained in a clean, safe and sanitary condition. The occupant shall keep that part of the exterior property which such occupant occupies or controls in a clean and sanitary condition.
IPMC 304.6 Exterior walls. All exterior walls shall be free from holes, breaks, and loose or rotting materials; and maintained weatherproof and properly surface coated where required to prevent deterioration.
Professionally,
_______________________
Code Officer Terri Sanchez
Certified Mailing Number: 7018 0950 0000 2361 9461
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
Property Record Card
Parcel
Property Address
28-20-30-5DL-0J00-0080
722 LAKESIDE DR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Parcel Information Value Summary
2022 Working
Values
2021 Certified
Values
Valuation Method Cost/Market Cost/Market
Number of Buildings 1 1
Depreciated Bldg Value $109,301 $101,289
Depreciated EXFT Value
Land Value (Market)$37,000 $37,000
Land Value Ag
Just/Market Value $146,301 $138,289
Portability Adj
Save Our Homes Adj $0 $0
Amendment 1 Adj $0 $0
P&G Adj $0 $0
Assessed Value $146,301 $138,289
2021 Tax Amount without Exemptions:$2,225.61
2021 Tax Bill Amount:$2,225.61
$0.002021 Tax Savings with Exemptions:
* Does NOT INCLUDE Non Ad Valorem Assessments
Legal Description
CLUSTER J LOT 8
WILDWOOD
PB 19 PG 7 TO 10
Parcel 28-20-30-5DL-0J00-0080
Owner(s)KOUIS, ANTHONY
Property Adrress 722 LAKESIDE DR WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Mailing 2453 HOPE AVE
DELTONA, FL 32738-2408
Subdivision Name WILDWOOD
Tax District W1-WINTER SPRINGS
DOR Use Code 0103-TOWNHOME
Exemptions None
Agricultural
Classification No
Exempt ValuesAssessment ValueTaxing Authority Taxable Value
Taxes
SJWM(Saint Johns Water Management)$146,301 $0 $146,301
CITY WINTER SPRINGS $146,301 $0 $146,301
FIRE FUND $146,301 $0 $146,301
COUNTY GENERAL FUND $146,301 $0 $146,301
Schools $146,301 $0 $146,301
Sales
Description Date Book Page Amount Qualified Vac/Imp
WARRANTY DEED 03/01/1990 02164 1969 $47,000 No Improved
WARRANTY DEED 04/01/1989 02111 1327 $54,500 No Improved
WARRANTY DEED 08/01/1987 01874 1652 $56,000 Yes Improved
~/ParcelDetailInfo.aspx?PID=2820305DL0J000080 Page 1/2
164
WARRANTY DEED 05/01/1983 01457 1482 $54,500 Yes Improved
WARRANTY DEED 12/01/1982 01427 1331 $56,300 No Vacant
Land
Method Frontage Depth Units Units Price Land Value
LOT 1 $37,000.00 $37,000
Building Information
Appendages#Year Built**Bed Bath Fixtures Base
Area
Total SF Living SF Ext Wall Adj Value Repl ValueDescription
1 SINGLE FAMILY 1983 2 2.0 6 1,168 1,733 1,168 SIDING GRADE3 $109,301 $134,112 Description Area
SCREEN PORCHFINISHED 80.00
GARAGE FINISHED231.00
SCREEN PORCHFINISHED 254.00
Building 1 - Page 1
** Year Built (Actual / Effective)
Permits
Permit #Description Agency CO DateAmount Permit Date
00507 ROOF Winter
Springs $9,861 12/9/2014
Extra Features
Description Year Built Units Value New Cost
Zoning
Zoning Zoning Description Future Land Use Future Land Use Description
PUD Medium Density Residential
~/ParcelDetailInfo.aspx?PID=2820305DL0J000080 Page 2/2
165
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Case: 2021CE001969
Address:722 Lakeside Dr.
Parcel: 28-20-30-5DL-0J00-0080
Property Owner(s):Anthony Kouis
Carloine Kouis
166
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Violation(s): IPMC 304.10 Stairways Decks
and Porches
IPMC 304.2 Protective
Treatment
IPMC 304.9 Overhang
Extensions
IPMC 302.1 Sanitation
IPMC 304.6 Exterior Walls
WS CITY ORD. 13-2(C)
Overgrown Yard 167
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Inspector: Terri Sanchez
Complaint: IAN T BRIGHT (Neighbor)
168
Code Enforcement Division
Timeline of Events
•Date you verified complaint: July 27, 2021
•Actions taken: Notice of Code Violation was sent to the owner of the
property.
•September 22, 2021 certified letter was returned and notice was
posted at the property.
•January 6, 2022 an updated Notice of Code Violation was sent to both
subjects on the deed and new address. Notice was also posted at the
property.
•January 24, 2022 the second NCV was signed for.
•February 4, 2022 the Notice of Code Board was sent certified and
posted at the property and City Hall.
169
Code Enforcement Division
Timeline of Events
There has been no contact at this time from the owner.
170
Photos of violations
171
Photos of violations
172
Photos of violations
173
Photos of violations
174
Photos of violations
175
Photos of violations
176
Photos of violations
177
Photos of violations
178
Photos of violations
179
Photos of violations
180
Photos of violations
181
Photos of violations
182
Photos of violations
183
Photos of violations
184
Photos of violations
185
Photos of violations
186
Photos of violations
187
Photos of violations
188
Photos of violations
189
Photos of violations
190
Photos of violations
191
Recommendations
•As of this hearing, I ask that you find the homeowner in
violation of ordinance that I've given testimony to, and
would extend no more than 30 days (March 24, 2022)to
come into compliance. If no compliance is met after that
additional time, I ask that a fine of $250.00 per day.
•At this time I’m available for any questions that you may
have.
192
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, COMPLAINT NO: 2021CE002770 PETITIONER, vs. RESPONDENT NOTICE OF CODE BOARD HEARING
Please take notice that at 5:30 P.M. on February 22, 2022 the Code Enforcement Board will hold a hearing to determine why you
should not be found in violation of the City Code as follows. The hearing will be held at the Winter Springs City Hall located at 1126
East State Road 434, Winter Springs, Florida.
Address of Violation: 700 COTTONTAIL CT. WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Property Owner Name: HEATHER WILLIAMS
Property Owner Address: 700 COTTONTAIL CT. WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
The cited violations are as follows:
WS CITY ORD. 13-2 (C) OVERGROWN
YARD
VINES GROWING UP THE ROOF THAT NEED TO BE CUT BACK.
IPMC 304.7 ROOFS AND DRAINAGE REPAIR ROOF AND REMOVE TARP
If the Code Enforcement Board finds your property in violation of the above referenced City Code (s) you can be fined up to per day for each day the violation continues and you can be charged for the costs that are incurred by the city in prosecuting the case. In the event violation fines and the costs are not paid within a reasonable time there can be a lien filed against the property in accordance with Florida State Statute Section 162.09. The hearing is conducted within guidelines of City of Winter Springs Code 2-60 and Florida State Statutes Chapter 162. You may appear in person or by an authorized representative. If you choose to not attend the hearing you can lose your right to present facts in this case. You have the right to present evidence, exhibits, written and oral testimony. The Code Board will subpoena witnesses on your behalf upon written request to the Code Board through the City Of Winter Springs Clerk’s Office. In the event that you appeal the Order of the Code Enforcement Board, you will be required to have an official record of the proceedings. You may, at your own expense, arrange for the official transcript of the testimony and evidence presented at the hearing. I certify a copy of this document was sent by Certified Mail on 02/04/2022, posted on the property, and at a government office as per Florida State Statute 162. Certified Number: 7021 0950 0000 2361 9324 The text of the associated violations, as it appears in the Municipal Code, is stated below: WS CITY ORD. 13-2(C) The existence of excessive accumulation or untended growth of weeds,
undergrowth or other dead, or living plant life; or stagnant water, rubbish,
garbage, refuse, debris, trash, including but not limited to household
PARCEL OWNER: HEATHER WILLIAMS
700 COTTONTAIL CT. WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
193
furnishings, and all other objectionable, unsightly or unsanitary matter upon
any lot, tract or parcel of land within this city be it uncovered or under open
shelter, to the extent and in the manner that such lot, tract or parcel of land is
or may reasonably become infested or inhabited by rodents, vermin or wild
animals, or may furnish a breeding place for mosquitoes, or threatens or
endangers the public health, safety, or welfare, or may reasonably cause
disease, or adversely affects and impairs the economic welfare of adjacent
property, or any other objectionable, unsightly substance or material tending by
its existence and/or accumulation to endanger or adversely effect of health,
safety, lives, and/or welfare of the citizens of the city, is hereby prohibited and
declared to be a public nuisance and unlawful.
IPMC 304.7 ROOFS AND
DRAINAGE Roofs and drainage. The roof and flashing shall be sound, tight and not have defects that admit rain. Roof drainage shall be adequate to prevent dampness or deterioration in the walls or interior portion of the structure. Roof drains, gutters and downspouts shall be maintained in good repair and free from obstructions. Roof water shall not be discharged in a manner that creates a public nuisance.
_________________________________
CODE OFFICER TERRI SANCHEZ
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
1/15/22, 8:08 PM USPS.com® - USPS Tracking® Results
https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction?qtc_tLabels1=70210350000130663308 1/2
USPS Tracking FAQs ®
Track Another Package +
See Less
Tracking Number: 70210350000130663308
Your item was delivered to an individual at the address at 2:40 pm on October 8, 2021 in WINTER
SPRINGS, FL 32708.
USPS Tracking Plus Available
Delivered, Left with Individual
October 8, 2021 at 2:40 pm
WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Get Updates
™
Text & Email Updates
Tracking History
USPS Tracking Plus™
Product Information
Remove Feedback201
1/15/22, 8:08 PM USPS.com® - USPS Tracking® Results
https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction?qtc_tLabels1=70210350000130663308 2/2
Can’t find what you’re looking for?
Go to our FAQs section to find answers to your tracking questions.
FAQs
Feedback202
203
Property Record Card
Parcel
Property Address
12-21-30-5HN-0000-5300
700 COTTONTAIL CT WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Parcel Information Value Summary
2022 Working
Values
2021 Certified
Values
Valuation Method Cost/Market Cost/Market
Number of Buildings 1 1
Depreciated Bldg Value $188,646 $174,433
Depreciated EXFT Value $21,200 $14,272
Land Value (Market)$58,000 $58,000
Land Value Ag
Just/Market Value $267,846 $246,705
Portability Adj
Save Our Homes Adj $0 $0
Amendment 1 Adj $0 $0
P&G Adj $0 $0
Assessed Value $267,846 $246,705
2021 Tax Amount without Exemptions:$3,970.45
2021 Tax Bill Amount:$3,970.45
$0.002021 Tax Savings with Exemptions:
* Does NOT INCLUDE Non Ad Valorem Assessments
Legal Description
LOT 530
OAK FOREST UNIT 5
PB 31 PGS 89 & 90
Parcel 12-21-30-5HN-0000-5300
Owner(s)WILLIAMS, HEATHER S
Property Adrress 700 COTTONTAIL CT WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708
Mailing 700 COTTONTAIL CT
WINTER SPGS, FL 32708-5140
Subdivision Name OAK FOREST UNIT 5
Tax District W1-WINTER SPRINGS
DOR Use Code 01-SINGLE FAMILY
Exemptions None
Agricultural
Classification No
Exempt ValuesAssessment ValueTaxing Authority Taxable Value
Taxes
SJWM(Saint Johns Water Management)$267,846 $0 $267,846
CITY WINTER SPRINGS $267,846 $0 $267,846
FIRE FUND $267,846 $0 $267,846
COUNTY GENERAL FUND $267,846 $0 $267,846
Schools $267,846 $0 $267,846
Sales
Description Date Book Page Amount Qualified Vac/Imp
WARRANTY DEED 10/01/2016 08806 1529 $100 No Improved
WARRANTY DEED 04/01/2013 08067 1287 $100 No Improved
SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED 06/01/2010 07404 0279 $155,000 No Improved
~/ParcelDetailInfo.aspx?PID=1221305HN00005300 Page 1/2
204
QUIT CLAIM DEED 03/01/2010 07357 1395 $100 No Improved
CERTIFICATE OF TITLE 12/14/2009 07304 0525 $100 No Improved
QUIT CLAIM DEED 09/01/2007 06820 1511 $100 No Improved
WARRANTY DEED 12/01/2006 06526 1396 $297,000 Yes Improved
WARRANTY DEED 05/01/1999 03666 0853 $130,000 Yes Improved
QUIT CLAIM DEED 10/01/1987 01907 1950 $100 No Improved
WARRANTY DEED 04/01/1986 01730 0071 $86,200 Yes Improved
Land
Method Frontage Depth Units Units Price Land Value
LOT 1 $58,000.00 $58,000
Building Information
Appendages#Year Built**Bed Bath Fixtures Base
Area
Total SF Living SF Ext Wall Adj Value Repl ValueDescription
1 SINGLE FAMILY 1986 3 2.0 6 1,800 2,412 1,800 CB/STUCCOFINISH $188,646 $225,249 Description Area
GARAGE FINISHED 552.00
SCREEN PORCH
FINISHED 60.00
Building 1 - Page 1
** Year Built (Actual / Effective)
Permits
Permit #Description Agency CO DateAmount Permit Date
01769 VINYL SIDING, SOFFIT, & FASCIA Winter
Springs $3,500 12/1/1997
00168 CHANGE OUT A/C UNIT Winter
Springs $1,490 2/1/1997
00592 REROOF 33 SHINGLES Winter
Springs $4,700 4/1/2002
Extra Features
Description Year Built Units Value New Cost
SCREEN PATIO 2 10/01/1988 1 $1,800 $4,500
SCREEN ENCL 2 10/01/1991 1 $3,400 $8,500
POOL 1 10/01/1987 1 $15,000 $25,000
FIREPLACE 1 10/01/1986 1 $1,000 $2,500
Zoning
Zoning Zoning Description Future Land Use Future Land Use Description
PUD Low Density Residential
~/ParcelDetailInfo.aspx?PID=1221305HN00005300 Page 2/2
205
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Case: 2021CE002770
Address:700 Cottontail Ct.
Parcel: 12-21-5HN-0000-5300
Property Owner(s):Heather S Williams
206
City of Winter Springs
Code Enforcement Division
Code Board February 22, 2022
Violation(s):IPMC 304.7 Roofs & Drainage
WS CITY ORD. 13-2(C)
Overgrown Yard
Inspector: Terri Sanchez
Complaint: Self Initiated
207
Code Enforcement Division
Timeline of Events
•Date verified complaint: September 29, 2021.
•Actions taken: Notice of Code Violation was sent to the owner of the property.
October 08, 2021 the letter was received and left with an individual per USPS website.
•February 2, 2022 I went by the residence and the tarp was still on the roof. Vines were now dead on the back fence.
•February 4, 2022 I went to the property to post Notice of Code Board and spoke to the husband. He advised that they are having issues with the insurance company paying for the roof. He also advised he was going to be removing the dead vines from the fence. I gave the notice to him and explained the process. I also posted the notice at City Hall and sent it certified to the owner.
208
Photos of violations
209
Photos of violations
210
Photos of violations
211
Photos of violations
212
Photos of violations
213
Photos of violations
214
Recommendations
•As of this hearing, I ask that you find the homeowner in
violation of ordinance that I've given testimony to, and
would extend no more than 30 days (March 24, 2022)to
come into compliance. If no compliance is met after that
additional time, I ask that a fine of $250.00 per day.
•At this time I’m available for any questions that you may
have.
215