HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015 09 14 Informational 202 City Rankings-FDOT Highway Safety Matrix COMMISSION AGENDA
Informational X
Consent
ITEM 202 Public Hearings
g
Regular
September 14, 2015 KS KB
Regular Meeting City Manager Department
REQUEST:
The Police Department wishes to inform the Commission about the 2015 Florida
Department of Transportation Safety Matrix.
SYNOPSIS:
This Informational agenda item will discuss the findings of the 2015 Florida Department of
Transportation Highway Safety Matrix.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The Florida Department of Transportation released the 2015 Highway Safety Matrix in
January 2015. The matrices are designed to provide an objective data driven tool to
compare cities of similar sizes to each other regarding the number of crashes with injuries
and fatalities. Winter Springs is in the group of cities sized 15,000 to 74,999 residents. The
2015 matrices use data from the years 2009 to 2013. The matrix compares 94 cities in the
State of Florida that are in that size group. Cities included are Altamonte Springs,
Casselberry, Oviedo, and Sanford.
Since there are 94 cities in the group, cities receive a number of 1 through 94 according to
frequency. A city with the number 1 ranking has more crashes with injuries and fatalities in
a given area than the city ranked 94. Again, this is compared to all cities in the State of
Florida of similar size. There are ten different areas which the Department of
Transportation has gathered data for comparison.
The emphasized areas and our ranking in those areas are as follows:
Total Fatalities and Iniuries— 87th
Informational 202 PAGE 1 OF 3-September 14,2015
Impaired (both fatalities and injuries) —91st
Bicycle related (both fatalities and injuries)—76th
Motorcycle related (both fatalities and injuries)— 89th
Pedestrian related (both fatalities and injuries)—90th
Speed related (both fatalities and injuries)— 89th
Occupant Protection (both fatalities and injuries) —93rd
Aggressive Driving (both fatalities and injuries)— 87th
Teen Drivers (both fatalities and injuries)— 89th
Drivers over 55 years (both fatalities and injuries)—91st
For comparison, the Total Fatalities and Injuries ranking of our Seminole County neighbors
are:
Altamonte Springs—76th
Casselberry —4th
Oviedo—72nd
Sanford— 58th
In summary, there is no other city within Seminole County that is included in this
population grouping that has a lower ranking than Winter Springs. We would like to
attribute this to our proactive enforcement of traffic violations, prompt response to traffic
complaints and education programs aimed at various groups of drivers. The safety of the
motoring public is of concern to us.
The actual matrix as released by the Florida Department of Transportation is attached to this
document and can be found here:
http://www.dot.state.fl.us/safety/3-grants/2015Matrix/2015MatrixCityGroupiiy2.pdf
FISCAL IMPACT:
None
COMMUNICATION EFFORTS:
This Agenda Item has been electronically forwarded to the Mayor and City Commission,
City Manager, City Attorney/Staff, and is available on the City's Website, LaserFiche, and
the City's Server. Additionally, portions of this Agenda Item are typed verbatim on the
respective Meeting Agenda which has also been electronically forwarded to the individuals
noted above, and which is also available on the City's Website, LaserFiche, and the City's
Server; has been sent to applicable City Staff, Media/Press Representatives who have
requested Agendas/Agenda Item information, Homeowner's Associations/Representatives
on file with the City, and all individuals who have requested such information. This
information has also been posted outside City Hall, posted inside City Hall with additional
copies available for the General Public, and posted at five (5) different locations around the
City. Furthermore, this information is also available to any individual requestors. City Staff
is always willing to discuss this Agenda Item or any Agenda Item with any interested
individuals.
Informational 202 PAGE 2 OF 3-September 14,2015
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff requests the City Commission receive and review the information provided in this
Agenda Item.
ATTACHMENTS:
A-HSMV Safety matrix
Informational 202 PAGE 3 OF 3-September 14,2015
DOT FDO
Highway Safety Matrix- Ranking of Florida Cities
F T�
DOLT (Based on fatal and injury crashes during 2009-2013.) �
Group 2-Population of 15,000-74,999-94 Cities
u' a a ai a 10 v a)
m o m v ? + v m m C '> w +
Florida City o6 X at c X ° p Florida City 6 ° p
(Group III v a >, m a o _N c j (Group II) a) a i. c�' o N E T5_ E U m cl O a v Q M o `o a 0 a H in
M U -d 01 H m N U) 6
�l O a- tT LL 2 d Q cn
LL � a Q
Altamonte Springs 761 44 40 38 48 751 591 47 771 671 New Smyrna Beach 19 5 161 4 29 181 71 16 17 15
Apopka 54 25 64 42 62 25 44 52 641 69 North Lauderdale 41 871 61 76 55 45 41 73 63 77
Aventura 22 75 47 53 11 42 83 25 46 13 North Miami 23 62 55 62 17 83 26 39 52
Bartow 391 791 69 51 66 80 19 48 141 49 North Miami Beach 30 69 49 43 221 761 33 30 49 43
Belle Glade 511 491 63 91 24 49 11 67 581 57 North Port 21 62 82 71 871 581 57 81 52 61
Bonita Springs 801 631 60 77 83 90 50 85 911 63 Oakland Park 9 311 15 19 121 91 14 12 201 26
Boynton Beach 421 401 56 69 461 32 52 61 711 41 Ocala 35 181 24 15 13 461 18 11 91 8
Bradenton 1 81 5 7 51 71 42 1 21 1 Ocoee 77 521 86 59 76 261 76 79 80 86
Casselberry 4 331 12 50 431 651 35 33 62 48 Opa-locka 82 901 81 92 85 69 27 83 86 90
Clermont 6 481 71 44 771 301 67 45 31 r 54 Ormond Beach 29 191 22 3 39 10 28 20 27 19
Cocoa 2 121 32 12 81 21 1 10 31 21 Oviedo 72 611 58 57 81 77 68 65 30 88
Coconut Creek 32 511 59 61 451 391 65 29 261 25 Palm Beach Gardens 33 22 36 37 59 8 66 31 18 27
Cooper City 86 64 68 64 88 55 64 71 43 62 Palm Springs 49 24 23 47 32 17 24 54 68 78
Coral Gables 11 46 18 36 23 85 73 13 26 11 Palmetto Bay 63 89 50 63 69 81 61 68 22 56
Crestview 69 65 80 55 52 38 58 44 12 51 Panama City 13 314 6 18 3 2 3 1 2
Cutler Bay 94 94 94 94 94 94 94 94 93 93 Parkland 93 92 90 93 93 56 90 93 79 94
Dania Beach 5 30 29 21 41 15 16 28 37 47 Pensacola 12 6 19 22 15 24 17 9 7 20
Daytona Beach 7 11 9 2 2 11 5 8 13 23 Pinecrest 47 80 79 86 82 74 86 36 11 46
DeBary 88 78 93 49 92 57 85 90 85 75 Pinellas Park 16 10 3 8 20 47 22 15 23 22
DeLand 10 14 21 5 16 28 6 7 5 14 Plant City 67 77 67 52 74 67 62 69 59 73
Delray Beach 25 27 8 32 9 7 34 24 61 17 Port Orange 64 50 30 16 67 52 80 58 54 40
Doral 34 68 52 70 51 82 69 43 33 68 Punta Gorda 46 26 73 18 57 40 39 21 41 9
Dunedin 57 32 26 54 71 61 78 75 73 28 Riviera Beach 38 41 45 48 26 31 9 53 56 65
Edgewater 55 37 35 17 61 27 55 63 81 39 Rockledge 44 83 42 67 80 43 54 80 78 76
Eustis 81 36 70 25 44 78 46 51 29 34 Royal Palm Beach 61 60 75 65 65 34 53 70 45 64
Fort Myers 18 9 11 13 6 4 4 5 6 6 Safety Harbor 83 88 72 84 78 79 92 84 88 81
Fort Pierce 50 34 25 33 27 29 21 35 19 37 Sanford 58 42 34 28 38 60 25 40 34 60
Ft Walton Beach 78 21 41 30 37 16 31 46 35 35 Sarasota 14 7 2 9 3 21 10 2 10 4
Greenacres 56 29 33 79 53 33 36 55 65 58 Sebastian 89 72 87 40 86 73 82 89 92 74
Haines City 48 70 83 75 49 70 37 62 50 36 Seminole 24 15 1314 34 6 40 17 24 7
Hallandale Beach 3 56 17 41 25 62 81 22 76 24 St Cloud 92 35 84 78 73 87 77 92 87 84
Hialeah Gardens 65 86 78 80 64 93 72 76 83 89 Stuart 15 2 4 10 4 1 3 6 4 3
Homestead 71 59 51 72 63 86 47 74 74 85 Sunny Isles Beach 79 85 39 81 10 91 89 76 94 83
Jacksonville Beach 20 4 7 20 7 13 26 18 15 42 Sweetwater 28 47 65 45 47 72 51 23 8 29
Jupiter 53 16 31 56 60 23 43 66 55 50 Tamarac 68 53 62 60 56 14 63 39 51 18
Key West 17 1 1 1 1 12 8 4 67 66 Tarpon Springs 37 28 28 24 28 36 30 42 16 30
Kissimmee 85 67 43 39 33 68 71 57 60 80 Temple Terrace 52 55 46 73 58 66 70 60 72 79
Lake Worth 27 13 20 23 21 5 23 27 36 55 Titusville 73 45 44 26 54 54 38 59 53 45
Lauderdale Lakes 66 66 57 90 19 22 32 41 32 70 Venice 31 39 27 27 42 50 79 38 48 10
Lauderhill 59 81 66 85 31 59 48 56 69 59 Vero Beach 60 17 10 35 40 35 12 34 42 16
Leesburg 451 201 53 11 141 64 29 19 401 5 Wellington 84 73 74 87 841 511 84 82 571 82
Lynn Haven 81 541 91 66 911 46 60 72 361 38 West Melbourne 75 581 38 31 751 201 49 49 471 33
Maitland 26 431 77 46 791 53 20 14 441 32 Weston 74 931 85 82 891 37 87 66 661 92
Marco Island 90 76 88 68 72 44 91 88901 72 Winter Garden 70 74 48 83 701 84 88 77 75 87
Margate 91 71 89 68 501 92 74 91 84 71 Winter Haven 40 57 54 58 36 63 15 50 251 31
Miami Lakes 43 84 92 74 681 88 56 64 21 53 Winter Park 36 38 37 34 35 19 45 32 70 44
Naples 62 23 6 29 30 41 75 37 82 12 Winter Springs 87 91 76 89 90 89 93 87 89 91
LEGEND
Highest 25%in a category.
Florida Department of Transportation
Published:111512015
State Safety Office