Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004 10 25 Public Hearings 406 CITY COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM 406 Consent Informational Public Hearing X Regular October 25.2004 Meeting Iff /~ IL Mgr. / Dept Authorization REQUEST: The Community Development Department presents to the City Commission an APPEAL of the Denial of a Variance request from the requirements of Section 9-3 of the City Code, to allow further subdivision of a platted lot, pursuant to the criteria set forth in Section 9-5, The property is located generally at the northeast comer of Panama Road and South Moss Road. PURPOSE: The purpose of this agenda item is to consider an APPEAL by M. Rebecca Furman of Lowndes, Drosdick, Droster, Kantor & Reed, P.A. (Applicant) of the Denial of a Variance to subdivide a platted property into more than 2 lots, APPLICABLE REGULATIONS: Sec. 9-3. Dividing platted property, Sec. 9-4. Waiver to subdivision requirements. Sec. 9-5. Variances, Sec, 9-6. Appeals from granting variances Chapter 20, Division 3. RC-I Single Family Dwelling District. Sec. 20-141 thru Sec. 20-147. Comprehensive Plan CHRONOLOGY: Aug.28, 1972- 5 ,163-acre lot purchased by Neil & Pearl Backus Aug. 13, 1990- Lot Split into one 1.5-acre corner lot and one 3.6 acre L-shaped parcel with 250' frontage on S. Moss and 150' frontage on Panama. @ October 25,2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 2 Nov. 3, 1994- Jan, 9, 1995- 1998- July 21,2004- Aug. 11,2004- Aug. 15,2004- Sept. 4, 2004- Oct. 7, 2004- Oct. 8, 2004- Board of Adjustment denied RC-1 Conditional Use for a church on the 3.6-acre parcel at 415 S. Moss Rd. Appeal of Board of Adjustment Denial, to the City Commission City sewer and water service lines were installed to the property Variance application and fee received by City Property owners within 150'ofthe subj property notified by Certified Mail Noticing in the Orlando Sentinel Request for continuance from Applicant's attorney. Postponed to date certain (Oct. 7,2004) to maintain advertising. Board of Adjustment heard the request and unanimously granted Denial of the Variance, Request for Appeal from Applicant's attorney. CONSIDERATIONS: In 1990, North Orlando Ranches, Section 1, Block B, Lot 6 (approximately 5,163 acres) was divided into 2 lots. The corner was established as one 1.5-acre lot (more or less) with the other 3.6-acre lot (more or less) configured as an "L-shape" surrounding the corner lot and with frontage on both Panama and Moss Rd, (See attachment.) Section 9-3 of the City Code allows a platted lot to be re-platted from one lot into two lots as long as each lot meets all applicable criteria established for that zoning district, as well as other applicable regulations. This unique lot configuration was the desire of the property owners, Neil & Pearl Backus. They were the property owners that requested the original split and are still the owners of both parcels, Currently, Neil and Pearl Backus are trying to sell the larger 3.6-acre parcel. They have a contract with Paul Ruso who is represented by by M, Rebecca Furman of Lowndes, Drosdick, Droster, Kantor & Reed, P,A. as the Applicant requesting a variance to subdivide the 3,6-acre lot into 3 new lots (2 approximately I-acre lots and one approximately 1.5-acre lot). Since the lot was already split in accordance with Section 9-3 of the City Code, the lot cannot be split again unless, according to Section 9-5, a variance is granted from this requirement, The code states that a variance can be granted if all of the variance criteria are met. Under the existing zoning of "RC-1 ", one-acre lots are the minimum lot size allowed. Lots are required to have a minimum lot width of 120 feet at the building line as well as other applicable regulations (e,g create buildable lots that do not compromise applicable zoning, building code, health department, or wetland setbacks). The proposed lots, meet the minimum dimensions required under the "RC-1" code. In Winter Springs, the "RC-l" zoning classification is the least dense residential zoning classification available, Lot sizes range significantly within this classification. The Applicant has also surveyed the wetland boundary and has determined that buildable lots would be created (as required under the City's Comprehensive Plan), The site abuts South Moss Road and Panama Road which are both paved, No new roadway construction would be required. October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 3 The water line adjacent to the property was installed concurrent with the paving of Moss Road in 1998. This gravity sanitary sewer extension was funded by Mr. Backus and conveyed to the City for ownership and maintenance in approximately 1997. The adjacent homes have connected to the system and it has the capacity for additional homes. Under the current future land use designation of Rural Residential, one dwelling unit per acre is the maximum density allowed, The Rural Residential future land use classification is the lowest density available in the City. Lot sizes range significantly within this classification. Section 9-5 of the City Code provides that variances may be granted from this requirement, "when such variance will not be contrary to the public interest, and where owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the provisions of this chapter would result in unnecessary hardships, Such variance shall not be granted if it has the effect of nullifying the intent and purpose of this chapter." The applicant must demonstrate "that special conditions exist which are peculiar to the lands, structures or required subdivision improvements involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or required subdivision improvements." The Applicant indicates that the special circumstances that exist are "the unique shape of the lot along with the physical features of the land severely inhibit the reasonable use of the property" and that these circumstances are not the result of actions by the Applicant. However, the unique shape ofthe land is the result of the original lot split as initiated by the property owner. The stream (or ditch) and its associated wetlands that cross this property and divide the L-shaped piece existed on the site at the time when the site was previously divided, (It has been suggested that ifthe configuration of the two existing parcels is a problem, they could be rejoined and reconfigured into two new lots that are not inhibited by the wetland and which are not "uniquely shaped".) The application states that granting the variance will not confer a special privilege because there are at least 7 other similar subdivisions that have been allowed (e,g. Moss Road Ranches, Seibert Manor, Morie Subdivision, Susan Woods, Bahama Ranches, VandergraffEstates, and Oak Hill Estates). These divisions include I-acre parcels but were approved over 20 years ago, during the time period from 1978 to 1985, The fact that Section 9-3 of the City Code has stood for 30 years speaks to the City's desire to maintain this requirement. Section 9-5 requires (the Board of Adjustment make a finding) that each portion of this section have been met in order to vote for the variance, The Board must "make a finding that the reasons set forth in the application justify granting the variance and that the variance is the minimum variance that would make possible the reasonable use ofthe lands, buildings or other improvements," The Board must additionally make a "finding that the granting of the variance would be in harmony with the general purpose and intent ofthis chapter and will not be injurious to the surrounding territory or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare." Additionally, the Board may prescribe appropriate conditions and safeguards, if they vote in favor of the variance, Reasonable use of the land is available to the Applicant without granting the variance, No hardship exists, The request is driven by the applicant's desire to receive greater financial gain, October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 4 Letters/Phone Calls In Favor Or Opposition - A letter received on Aug. 31, 2004 from adjacent property owner D. Brad Phillips and Alisa Harper, opposing the variance. Opposition by four other property owners in the area was given at the Board of Adjustment meeting. However, one adjacent property owner was in favor of the variance because she wanted to do likewise with her property. FINDINGS: · The site has RC-I zoning and a Rural Residential Future Land Use (FLU) designation, . Section 9-3 of the Code allows a platted lot to be divided into 2 lots, subject to meeting all applicable regulations, North Orlando Ranches Section 1. Block B, Lot 6 (approximately 5,163 acres) has already been divided into 2 lots, The request is to further divide the one, larger 3, 6-acre lot, into 3 lots, . . Section 9-5 of the Code provides a mechanism for variances from this requirement, subject to meeting all of the criteria set forth for that variance (not the same variance criteria set forth for setbacks). . The Applicant has not justified the variance request based on the required criteria, BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT ACTION: At a regular meeting of the Board of Adjustment, the Board held a Public Hearing on the proposed variance and voted unanimously to DENY the variance request based on the findings presented, STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the City Commission UPHOLD the DENIAL based on the findings. ATTACHMENTS: A- Application & Supporting materials B- No, Orlando Ranches Sec. 1 Plat C- Sections 9-3 and 9-5 ofthe City Code D- Letter E- Excerpt from Draft Unapproved Board of Adjustment Minutes, Oct. 7, 2004 CITY COMMISSION ACTION: October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 5 ATTACHMENT A Appeal & Application with Supporting materials 10/15/04 FRI 09:55 FAX 407 423 4495 U>DKR Ii!J 002 Lowndes Drosclick Doster&: Kantor Reed, EA. . r;.t .. nee CUuuu,llM4 85 M, RI.sECl;,\ Fu1l.'IlMoI I)'ROCT DI"I.:407.41 8-6250 SOUlH OM.'1GI! ^ V'!NlJE OmCf. PoS'r OITlCE nox 2809 OlUA'llO, FLORIDA n802-2809 n::bcccil.furmal1@IO"ndcs-law.com f'~~~~.8!:~~1j A T TOR N E Y 5 AT LAW T'T' iTf MERITA5 LAW FIRMS WORLDWIOE October 11, 2004 VIA E-MA IL City of Winter Springs Eloise Sahlstrom, Senior Planner 1126 East State Road 434 Winter Springs, FL 32708 Re: Board of Zoning Adjustment ("BZA ") October 7,2004 Agenda Item A Dear Eloise; As you know, I represent Paul Rosu with regard to the above-referenced BZA request for alot split variance for the property located at 415 South Moss Road, Winter Springs, FLorida 32708. BZA denied the variance request. This letter shall serve as notice of appeal of the BZA decision to the Winter Springs City Commission, Please schedule a hearing for this appeal as soon as possible. Feel free to contact me should you have any questions, MRF/ajw c: Paul Rosu Anthony Garganese, Esq, Hal Kantor, Esq. ~;~lt OI040WI096lU711472YI 21' Nom" Eo,,", OltlvE OlUJ\'<1>O, FLOI1llA 3WlI.2028 'Im,: 407.&43-4600. ~AJ( :407-843-4444. """,wJo""dcs-lnw.c,,,n 450 SOUTH ORANG.A\~Ut:, Stlm; KOO ORLANDO, FUND" 3<801.:;3'" October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 6 ATTACHMENT A Application with Supporting materials CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 1126 STATE ROA,D 434 RECEIVE WINTER SPRINGS. FL 317<<18 407-327-5967 JUl 2 12004 FAX:407-327-6695 . CII'l'OFWlNl'mSPRIN L. CUHonl Planning BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION o SPECIAL EXCEPTION X VARIANCE o CONDITIONAl. USE o APPEAL OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION APPLJCMTT: BU('1I15 J I<;ck, or L1Sl f;,,1 MAlUNGADDRESS: '3Q) So....,I1, C't?~l 4vIIAe Ov l-ed17 , F l. PHONE: tf07Cir/ 3GS:- 103 C, $talC rfPN.'~V1 ~+('ve o.c t'avJ MiD<I1e -r I ,~.V1 32"&-? Zip Coda If ApplicUll does NOT own lhe property: PROPERTY OWNER: &~ ku s) tfle; I R.. ~ fb,-.f H. \,all '/) Finll MAILING ADDRESS: i {CJ Eo raf'ltll'wll f.JoaJ W/"'~: .spr;"'jS 1=L t..{07 'fJ691- '1223 Slate Middle 31702 Zip Cod~ PHONE: This request I, for Ihc property deseo1:d below: pRQPliRTY ADDRESS: 41 S- S. A105S /(oqol, Wi vrk,.. .sprl'~5 I r:L 32A::1;;' TAXPARCELNUMBBR: 02-2/- 30- 581-oBcv-oo~A SrlBOFPAllCEt.: 3.6 acres SqIllUC _ Atto CUI'I'CbI ftJTUllE LAND USE C1aulfic:adon: R Ur1:l1 ReiJeYl';"~ I CUnau ZONING CluaifJU1ion; R C - J Pleasesl1teYOtJRREQUEST: T"e 0ppoV'JuI4;f'l to Cr<<tte. -/-J,1"t'~ /ofs :.... 4Clov-tb.,ce w.fI.t J./le s",j,d.'I/;SJOh O."J""'ance, '''LJVE'HREF~SIIED 87115/8411 "ISC "ISCElLANEDUS CASH RECEIPTS Date 1 Tile : 87121184 14:44 P.y~nt Arc>l ""l!n6ti88. 88 ReceIpt A : 674BJ7 ChecklCredi t Cud I: Clerk : dascano Paid By : BACKUS, HElL October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Hem 406 Page 7 ATTACHMENT A Appeal & Application with Supporting materials The ft,PPL1CANT IS RESPONSIBLE for posting the bllle nmice card on the site at ICRst seven (7) days prior to the Board or AdjlH1n\l!nt M~til1g at wbieh the matta will be considered, Said notice shall NOT llC posted Wlthia the City right-of-way. APPUCANTS are adYi.cd, thot if they decide to Bppcalllny dccisiom made III the mcetings or hearings, with respect tiO llny malter considered at the meetings or bearings, ~ey will o,eed 8 record of the PTlXl<<dina~ and, for .ueh ptl~ll.\, they will need to iruure th:lI11 verbatim record of the proceedIngs is made, al their COSt, which includes the testimony llnd evidence upon whieh the appeal Is to he bllsed, per 286,0105, Florida SlllNtcs, Any VUlancll. special exeeption OJ' condition;,l, use which rruy be gran.ted by the city council (lUau expire she. (6) I1lOntbs aftllr tho effD(:tivc date (lrsucb actlO/l by the city commissio/l, unless a buddillg permit based upDllllUd incorpofllting the vllrlance, special neeption or COn.ditiODlll use: is obtllined within the aforesaid Ilill-Il\l)ulh period. HowoYllr, tbe ell)' COmmiWOll. may fCncw iNch variance, 5peeial exception or conditional use fot one (1) additional period ohix (6) month" provided good cause is shown and w lIpplicntlon for e?ttl:n.lon shall be filed 'lVidl tho board l\lleast thirty (30) days prior to the ClI:pirutlon o( the uilt-,month period. Any rrnewu l'IIIy be anntcd without public hearing; howcver, a Icapplication fee may be tbarged in an a!DOllnt Jlot to excced the amoul1t of the orisinal applicilllon ree, It ia Intendcd thaI proviriOll' contaiDed within mu subsection are to be rctroacnye to the exlenlth:lt IIny variance, !=pICW exception or conditional U1ie plcviollsJ,y granted shall become VC\id if a periCld of rime In exCCS.9 oC Iwelve (12) months sball bave lapsed. ami a btrildina permll based upon and incorporaliD.II the varianci:', ~peeilll ellecptioDl or conditiocal uset hIlS not been is!Ued prior 10 expiration of such. rime limit. Wlntel' Spring. Code ofOrdillancl:s, Seelion 20-'S3 (h) . THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE TO BE SUPPLIED WITH THIS APPLICATION; [J A copy of the most recent SURVEY of the s\Jbjecl property, o A copy 0' the LEGAL DESCRIPTION. o 11)( 17 MAP showing ADJACENT STREETS and o JUSTIFICATION for the Request (See AUached List) o NAMES and ADDRESSES of each properly owner within 150 fl. of each property fine, o Notarized AUTHORIZATION 0' the Owner, IF the Applicant IS oth91 than the Owner or Attomey for the Owner (see below), a APPLICATION FEES: FEES aro u SHOWN BEJ.ow plus AcnJAL COSTS ineum:d (or ADVERTISING (tf NOTIFIC^ nON, and (or REIMBURSEMENT for TECHNICAL ancUor PROFESSIONAL SEIWICES whicb may be required. in connection with the review, illspection or approv.al or Iny development (based on I~ounting submitted by the City's Consultant). payable prior to approval of the pcrtrne"t stage ofdevl:!opmenl. CONDmONAL USE I SPECIAL EXCEPTION IOP..NERALPERMIT V AR1ANCE APPEAL OF AN ADMINrsTRA T1VE DEClSION S 500 S soo S Soo TOTAL DUE $_ 2 October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 8 ATTACHMENT A Appeal & Application with Supporting materials ...................................................................................... FOR USE WHEN APPUCAN'f IS OWNER OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY: 1'bis is to certify that r am the Owner in fee simple of subject bmds deJ(;libed within thu Application for Board of Adjustment coasldeunon: Sipatun: or O'Mler Sworn to and aubscribed befoft: me dJi~ _dayof 20_. NOl1lry Public My Commis~ion expires: PeRonally KDoWll Produced Identification: (Type) Did take an Oath Did Not talc aod Oath ...................................................................................... FOR USE WHEN APPLICANT ~ NOT OWNER OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY: {, (]qc/rl6).AIe: I R. 4. ~...( i/. LA. hCf Tee.. h 10 rep~scnf me i.llthi.\ Applicati,ol1 related to my propert)'. The property is identifiedB$: Tax Plltcel Nllrnber{s) ()1-~ 1- 30 - 5"'BI - O$c;<), oo"A lAeD.d" 4f~ S. ~aS5 ~J/l;;;;<g ~,~..,eY~~.l--_ ~~ Sjgnanue ofOwnct(s) Sworn .. """ .-....... berm, "" dU, RJ:L. ~ r:il.J..!!:. day of JULy 20~, Notary Public .... My commisi'on pplres: q 3/0,,} , r do hmby with m}' oot':lTiud !ignature allow PcnoDill1y Known V Produced 0:>: (Type) ~'- j) L PAMElA B/l(OWICl Did tlke ID Oadl , Notary Public Stat Djd Not take and Ouh M' e ot AOIlda y comm. expo Sap'. 3, 2007 CO/Tlm. No DO 'Wto'.:!') ......................................................................\iVjvt........... . 3 October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 9 ATTACHMENT A Appeal & Application with Supporting materials VARIANCE REQUEST . Whm is the Vari;lncc ~ou arc reQuesl i ng',' Code of OrdilUUlecs Chapler <) Anicle I Section 9-3 Slah:s: An owner of 11 single 10\ of sufficicnt size, e:..ccpt in a plallcd area of a planned unit de\'cJopmenl. may. wilh prior apprmal of Ihe city cOlllmission. divide :111 originally plaited single lot once iuto no 1Il0re th;11I tllO (2) parcels or lOIS, An owner of a 101 \I hieh has bccn divided shall not be gnm\(.'d appro\'al for a replm \I hich \\ould rcsull in dividing Ihe originally plalled single 101 into 1\10rc Ihanl\l'o (21 parcels or lOiS, Each parcel or lot SO dh ided shall in e\'cry respecl mCCI the crilcria cstablished elSC11 hcre in llus Code for the calcgo,!' of zoning llnd Olher rclcv;uu Codes undcr which lhc propeny is I.oncd and each parcel or lot shall meet the engineering requirements sct out elsewhere in this ehaptcr, In such instancc. ;md only within thc stricl application of Ihis scelion, llIay the full provisions oflhis chaptcr be \l'ai\'cd and variances grnnted thereto. No building permil shall be issned for thc creclion of allY bnilding 011 a pre\'iousl~' plallcd lot which is di\'idcd conlr.l,! 10 Ihis section, The requcsl is for Ihe opponunity to crc:lIe nllolS in accordance wilh thc subdh'ision ordinancc from an originnlly planed parcel. . What special condilions and circumstances exist which are pecnliar to the land. structure or building in\'oked aud which are nOI applic:lble 10 olhcr lands, slnlclurcs or buildiugs inlhe $:lmc I.oning dislric!'! The special CQnditionthal exists is Ihe unique ShllpC of Ihe land along wilh the physical fC:llures of the (nnd sc\'crely inhibil the rC:lsonable usc of property if a striclly Iileral inlerpretalion of see, ')-J is laken. . Arc Ihese special cOlldilions and circulllstanccs the rcs\lll of nClions b~ the applicant'! No, . How will a lilcml interpretation oflhe provisions ofthc zoning districl deprive Ihe applicant of rights commonly e1lioyed by other properties in the SIIIIC I.oning districI and work unnccesS<I'!' h:lfdship on the applicllllt'! The current classification ofRC-1 and fUlllre land use classific:llion Rural Residential do. according to I.oning district pro\'isions. allo\\' for 101 si.fCS Ilml are one acre in size. . Will granting the variance confer any speciat pnvilege UtI! is denied to othcr lands. buildings or Slntclllres inlhe same I.onlllg dislric!" Gnmling Ihe \"lIriancc \\'ould not confer an~ special privilcge that is denied to olher lands, there arc cnrrently al IcaSI (71 subdi\'isions Ihat 11:1\'e recch'ed silllilar vari;lIIces inlhis SUllC .foning district. Thc~ are Iisled below: Moss Road Ranches Seiben Manor Morie Subdivision Snsun Woods Bahama R;l1\ehes Vandergr:lafT ESlates Oak Hill Estates . Is the \'ari1l11CC as requcsted thc minimlllll \'Ilrinllee Ilmt willlllake possible the rcnsonablc nsc of the land. building or slnJcture'! Yes. UIC only variallce bcing requested is in regards 10 Article I Sccrion 9.3. The subdivision would still be required to meel all olher criteria cswblishc..'d in the codc for subdidsion, October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 10 ATTACHMENT A Application with Supporting materials . 110\\ is the \'ariance in hamlOny with Ihe genemJ inlenl and purpose of the zoning dislriet? Thc zonillg distriel intends 10 1L:l\'c singlc famil) d\\clling IInilS on a 10ls Ihal arc nol smallcr Ih:1n olle acre, This \':1riancc would not de\'iate frolllth:n intcnt iu an~' respect and wOllld meel :111 requirements of thc Code of Ordinances for lhe City of Winter Sprillgs as set forth in Zoning Chapter 20 Arliclc III Di\'ision :; St.'Ctiolls 20-I.lllhrollgh 20-I-lK . Will granting thc Hlrianec be injurious 10 the neighborhood or olhcn\'isc dClrimcntalto Ihe public welfare'! ' No, this \'ari:1I\ce would conscrve Ihe general \\c1fare of the neighbors. the taxable vallie of land. and llIailllainlhe slandards sel forth ill b~' Ihe codes. ordinanccs and zoning districI for residclltialllse. . Idenli(\' how the requesl is consistent wilh Ihe objccli\'cs and policies of Ihe Comprehensi\'e Plan. This request for \'ariancc is consistcnt \\'ith Ihe objecti\'cs and policies of Ihe Comprehensi\'e Plan on sc\'crallc\'cls. This \'ariauce is consistenl wilh the fUlurc Land Use c1el11entth:n allows for d~'elopment while , minimizing ad\'crsc impacts on Ihe em ironmcnt and n;lIuml resourees by bcing cousistent with the fUlurc Ruml Residential land usc CiJlCgOT)' of onc dwelling unil per acre. The subdivision would meet the requirements sel forth for paved access. dmiJL:lge. wnler. and sewer. By meeting Ihe de"elopmcnl requirements, the prorx:n~ will nOI only prolecl exisling housing \'alucs bUI will assislthe apprecintion of thc neighborhood, Thc purposes of Ihc Comprehcnsive Piau would be ad\'anced by the gmnting of this \':lrillncc. In this C:lse the benefils 10 the COllllllLUlily fromlhc TC:lson:lblc use of Ihis land subslantially outweigh any possible detriment. The City dcvelops policies Ihat COlllribule 10 Ihe community's qualily of lifc and the snbdivision of this p:Jrccl conlribulcs 10 tll:ll COlllmon go;ll by allowing Ihc orderly and bcneflcial devclopmcnt. October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 11 ., ~ '~. ~~ ~ " ~i ~ ~ ~~ "p \ l\ y ;"-; \ 6'. 0' ~'", -c ,~. \ "\ l.'~\ '" ,r,:iI' , ~\ t' ATTACHMENT A Application with Supporting materials ',:(t( 'i {'f ."1 ::..tI' ~~~OT J .,f!' ~_. ~~"'l..~~., ; . ., :, ,,'$! t " '< < . ..' ,t ~ " , ' " .. '. ~<t . , i" 'V., " . . ... ~ -. ~ " ~"~"L' , ..... ". ' ':, . ..... '!ii., .: r ..~tl'Z-' .' ct.\... . ,.'?- j ',i. 1"''f. ~ . . . 1 G' 'iI :t~:;j!f.' .... , ,:..:',. PRoP .. Lor'" f J I .. ~.- G 4- 1'tINT~iJ 1.0 ACRES 1: GUi'VA ~ ": :',.1. ~ .... :'l .....~-., \0 ", ,"- "I: ,." Q '": 9 \C) ~ c,. ~ "" ~ o ~ . ".'j 'f~ .f' .',;/? ~~OPOSF.:D '-OT 1 , ACREH" ,,' ~'.~\" ~~'+, ..' . "';~;'I""':':"~"~~~' '~. ,.~ :' , '~.', .'.. ':.':' ,::,Jj; I ~ ' ,,' . .~ '), . .::; -~ "ry " Noi'~~UDED'" ;,:;' ': ,,' .'. ':"::iA ", ,:, . :t i't ,.... '1i" :'2: ::.... oJt '.. t' ~' ,~, .! "~~ ' · .... ,~ " " ;. ':6~ ~ ;,' ~. .' ,,& ,'\.~. .~' i' '''''A r r,,'ra" 4".' '~.i/'~# ~;A., iI.> ~...~... .". . ". "",. - .Ji;.' ;'''''f~ ;: .. ~ .+.- ~ ~ ,: '- '~!'\ ,I. ~ . ~t' S 89'54'51'" W 475.00' "~ .. '/ " I PANAMA ROAD . , ' ~;';:' :;I~ ~ M . .~";.:.cv:' IIIAY) it .. "~~'<fI, ',., ,. .3h..1l ,'~;,~, . ,.,,'f~~ ',;,j, ;~}, '~,6 ~ ,'Wtt' .:~- '"-'~-D''' .t . ~. ~ 'T< :~Jll '~~' ' ",".~}f ,.._ ,I. October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 12 ATTACHMENT A Appeal & Application with Supporting materials II I I I I I ,;:., -f /ir- !, Q:: , '" /8/" Iii ~ I !' ;1/ !. I , I j I I ! // <:::t ill (/) J 1- 1 :1 , 'I ./ I' 1 1 , , .... l L1 (j October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 13 ATTACHMENT A Application with Supporting materials PARCEL DETAIL .' ~;.L:~w. J !~~~.J :-\:.~~ ~.*>~: ....J.U;.J!l~u j Back ,,j / 0r ': .t:. r ;,.,.... \~?~' ~'.- ..... ~ .,:"'. .. .r.~' ;~ ~",.:: 'l.'i:'"R:'~,- - ,....\:' ,,., ..' -." '('f1,=-~. :' ,: ':"~J.\I'. ~.;~.~~..~..,':. -:,.::. .~~~ . '; ~' ,'.. -, '.;.^"' ~ ': ~~"~\:\".".-. ,....~ - ~ ~ '~.!r~' . ..~~ ~~- ~ ". :..,;'f""~' i\\ ::f.t-.. ... ~~':.-.: ~....,~ ~""':~"~>' '. ,.~l".l"t'~~~~ ...,.....10':\ . ~ -, .,..... ~\. ..~e. ",. '..'\1' :;....... /~.::'.:: :}'~":'L~' .<-~)g~:('.~.:~~;,:,'t~~ fI' ~.:",,:~~;;.,",:;\" - ':..,~ . .,......"~~:'.., . ~..~..~;.I.. -.~. ..~~:-~.~~'t::.,~'1.~.1~:f!'1:" ~ . ." ... . '. ': ... . ~ ' .' ~-. . ......1 . \.' ~..:.:\.". It t. 'r"''(, ... ,." '.'_*,_..... ". .1t.~. :;";. ~'..:" ~.~~ to :,,-:. ~~~ -,:",..~.,..ti......:,.' -,' \',;':" . . '...-.:. ,.~......\:..~.., .... " "''s ~.:e ;.. ~ r/::~ .-;: '''-.~:;r'I)J'''''' '=t" I ~.' ...., .l~~.. 2004 WORKING VALUE SUMMARY GENERAL Parcelld' 02-21-30-561-0BOO- Tall District' W1-WINTER , 006A . SPRINGS Owner: ~~;~~~ NEIL R 8. Exemptions: Address: 110 E PANAMA RD City,State,ZipCode: WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708 Property Address: Subdivision Name: NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES SEC 01 Dor: OO.VACANT RESIDENTIAL Value Method: Number of Buildings: Depreciated Bldg Value: Depreciated EXFT Value: Land Value (Market): Land Value Ag: J,lstIMarl\\H Value, Assessed Value (SOH): Exempt Value: Taxable Value: Markel o SO SO $45.000 SO S45,OOO S45,OOO SO S45.000 2003 VALUE SUMMARY 2003 Tox Bill Amount; $855 2003 Taxable Value: $45,166 DOES NOT INCLUDE NON.AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS LEGAL DESCRIPTION PLAT LEG LOT 6 (LESS BEG SW COR RUN E 325 FT N 204.5 FT W 340,97 FT TO El Y RiW MOSS RD SEl Y ON RIW 205,13 FT TO 6EG I BlK B NORTH ORLANDO RANCHES SEe 1 PB 12 PG 3 OTE: Assessed values shown are NOT certified values and t/Ierefore are subject to change before being finalized for ad valorem tax urposes ... If 'OU recentl urchased a homesteaded 0 SA LES Deed Date Book Page Amount Vae/lmp ,..-.t :..".I)':'''rJ:-;.H I.; '::.(1 i",:- .... ;r.... :".~ .;. .!".;:,: '. .:...... LAND land Assess Method Frontage Depth Land Units Unit Price Land Value LOT 0 0 1000 45000.00 $45,000 October 25,2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 14 ATTACHMENT A Application with Supporting materials Abutters to 02-21-30-SBI-OBOO-006A Owner Name Gould-Spenc.e Janel Trustee Owner Address 101 E Pllnama Road Winler Springs, FL 32708 Proper! y I D 02-21-:l0.5BI-OCOO-0040 Property Address '10'1 E Panama Road Winter Spnngs. FL 32708 Owner Name Pagano Ross J & Sylvia L Owner Address 115 E Panama Road Winter Springs. FL 32708 Property 10 02-21-30-5BI-OCOO-004A Property Address 115 E Panama Road Winter SprinQs, FL 32708 Owner Name Jordan James 0 & JaCQuelyne V Owner Address 125 E Panama Road Winter Sprill~s, FL 32708 Property ro 02- 21-30- 58 I-DCOO-OO30 Property Address 125 E Panama Road Winter Springs, FL 32708 Owner Name Harper AIi~a D & Phillips David B Owner Address 120 E Panama R03d Winter Spring:;, FL 32708 Property ID 02-21-30-581-0800-0070 Property Address 120 E Panama Road Winler Springs, FL 32708 Owner Name Amalo Roseann Owner Address 135 Bahama Road Winter Springs, FL 32708 Propeny 10 02-2 i - 30-5BI-0800-004A Property Address 135 Bahama Road Winter Sprinas, FL 32708 Owner Name Bush Mary J Owner Address 125 E Bahama Road Winter Springs. FL 32708 Propeny 10 02-21-30-581-0800-0040 Properiy Address 125 E Bahama Road Winter Springs. FL 32708 Owner Name Bledsoe Marvin & Sandra & Elise M Owner Address 405 S Moss Road Winter Sprinas. FL 32708 ProDerty 10 02-21-30-581-0800-0050 Property Address 405 S Moss Road Winter SpnnQs, FL 32708 Owner Name Wiltshire Valerie Owner Address 110 W Panama Rand Winter Springs. FL 32708 Property ID 03-21-30-SBJ-OAOO-0070 Property Address 110 W Panama Road Winter SprinQS, FL 32708 Owner Name Wardley Debra B & Bennell Bruce G Owller Address 5652 Jack Brack Road 51. Cloud. FL 34771 Properly ID 03-21-30-58J-OAOO-OO80 Properly Address 410 S Moss Road Winter Springs, FL 32708 October 25,2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 15 ATTACHMENT B Portion of No. Orlando Ranches Sec, 1 Plat ~ ~~p ~A I"'" .,. L 4'~v~" ~~~~iy.v~ tes~ , ~.o.1-t::' ..... '" ~ \ SEe TlO -} r-. '. - - 17.; .".If ...i; Ie- If I I.' l..,,, : 3'.l&'&<' .jr.ti ~ d'\ !o-$-gJ ;. ,~'.i'" 4 ~ ,:,\I~~, . I . ,...'Yl, J " .: .:.' .. f"" 'r" I .. - ,,~'- ,P' I tC5 lO6' .! ,~t; ';_4 ''Ii d 5 l ,. ~r.,- ..:.... - I 'I .. r t'1 ..~. :J.Q: ',' ',r~ I1:i:\ ,r "~.~.f -~..~.,;. '" ,-j ~~. ~ ~'" I ~A ~~.t:'" -;':". ". ," , :' . 1<4/~- C\,4~ ,?~i _. ,l" l " 7~,..< I;} " ~ ': ,- "'~ ~ 4 t; rl ..,l... ~ .,' " ,:, 1 I H Ii- (~ r ~-t: ~ ~ " ",,',I 1 {,.' ~ \11> 41 I ~ I - ;/ 1\0 \",,0.,.... \90 ,.. C) . ~,...... j' \"1C " . ....( ~ " . 'I , t J ': I, ':l6 '. ~. ...... \0\. . II) :In _.' V):~ ~"'\' ,,:r \:) ~~ ~ J . ,. ..,. '.. y~~~=-:'T~ I S Ii '. _I .... ':~ t. , .' , ~ .~ . (uotr ,'I " , \90 ~ ., ... .' ,,- , 1105 ~ .-i1S . It>$: I -c. - t @J ... October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 16 ATTACHMENT B Portion of No. Orlando Ranches Sec. 1 Plat - @\ r-- , , (!>\ \ \ \ 1 BAHAM A RO /.& 3.71}e;... 2.0 At:.. Ae.,. 4. ~ A",. I. & 3. (p5 Ae.. AG. 1.1 /.2.- 1.7Ac.--. /Ie;... Ae.-'A ~O V'J p /Xt'lAM PANAMA E 3.12,4". 10At... 3./'l. Ae.. ---@l I.OA~ \ /. t' ~.3 \ A", Av' \ I. e, /. f) Ac.., Ac... E TRI\OEWINDS Dates of approval of adiacent subdivisions: <D Bahama Ranches approved 03- I 2-82 ~ Moss Road Ranches approved 07-08-85 (1) Seibert Manor approved 07-08-78 VandegraiT Estates approved 06- I 8-84 @ Morie Subdivison approved 08- I 2-85 Oak 1-1 ill Estates approved 10-17 -84 Susan Woods approved 06- -85 PB 26 PG 32 PB 32 PG 92 PB 32 PG 97 PB 30 PO 37 PB 34 PO 9 P8 3 I PG 19 PH 32 PG 96 RD o RO October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 17 ~ 9-1 ATTACHMENT C Sections 9-3 and 9-5 of the City Code WINTER SPRINGS CODE tract of land, whether improved or unimproved, into three (3) or more contiguous lots or parcels of lands, designated by reference to the number or symbol of the lot or parcel contained in the plat of such subdivision. for the purpose, whether imme- diate or future, of transfer of ownership, or if the establishment of a new street is involved, any division of such parcel. The term includes a resubdivision and, when appropriate to the con- text, relates to the process of subdividing or to the land subdivided, SwaZI! means an open cut with a slope ratio of the front face, or roadside face, which is shallower than 3:1. 7ree preservation, see section 5-1. (Code 1974, ~ 14-1), Sec. 9.2. Sale of non platted property. No owner of real property being a subdivision as defined in this chapter, shall seUlots from such tract without first having, in accordance with the requirements hereof, such tract surveyed and a plat of the lots proposed to be sold prepared by n registered surveyor except as provided in section 9-3, Before such plat shall be recorded, it shall 'be npprovoo in accordance with the specific provi. sions of this chapter and F.S, ~h, 177, No permit shall be issued for the construction of any build- ing or for an electrical hookup on any lot sold in violation ofthis section, (Code 1974, ~ 14-3) Sec. 9-3. Dividing platted property. An owner of a single lot of sufficient sizo, except in n platted area of a plllnned unit devel. opment, may, with prior approval of the city commission, divide an orhdnallv platted single lot once into no more than two (2) oarcela or lots, An owner ofa lot which has been divided shall not be granted approval for a replat which would result in dividing the originally platted single lot into more than two (2) parcels or lots, Each parcel or lot so divided shan in every rMpect meet the criteria established elsewhere in this Code for the category of zoning and other relevant Codes un. der which the property is zoned and each parcel or lot shall meet the engineering requirements set out elsewhere in this chapter, In such instance, and only within the strict application of this section, may the full provisions of this chapter be waived and variances granted thereto, No build- ing permit shall be issued for the erection of any building on a previously platted lot which is divided contrary to this section. (Code 1974, ~ 14-3.1) Seo. 9.4, Waiver to subdivision requirements. For subdivisions where no now streets, water, sewer, or drainage structures are involved. appli- cation for approval of preliminary or final subdi- vision plans may be waived provided, however, that a plat, that can be recorded of tho proposed subdivision shall be submitted for review by the city staff, The recommendation of the city staff shall be subject to approval by the city commis- sion, The purpose of this approval is to ensure that the proposed subdivision conforms to appli- cable requirements of the subdivision regulations. (Code 1974, ~ 14-3,2) Sec. 9-5. VlIrinncl!s. (e) Before any vnriance shall be granted, II public hearing on the proposed variance shall be held by the board of adjustment, Notice of such public henring shall be published fifteen (I5) doys prior to the hearing in a newspaper of general circulation in the county, Such notice shall also be posted fifteen (5) days prior to the hearing in three (3) separate places in the city, and be mailed 562 October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 18 ATTACHMENT C Sections 9-3 and 9-5 of the City Code LAND DEVELOPMENT ' to all persons who are record owners of property within one hundred fifty (150) feet of the subject property, (d) The board of adjustment shaH make find- ings that the requirements of each portion of this section have been met. The board of adjustment shall further make a finding that the reasons set forth in the a lication justify granting of the variance an that the vanance IS 1e muumum Viiriiince that would make ossibJe the reasonable use of the land in s or other improve- ments. (e) The board of adjustment shall make a fur- ther findin~ that the granting of the variance would be i harmony With the generlll purpose and intent of thi r and will not be inw- ous to sumun 'to 0 otherwise detrimental to the, public welfare. (0 In granting any variance, the board of ad- justment may prescribe nppropriate conditions and safeguards, to such variance, and when made a part of the terms which the variance is granted a violation of any tenn or condition shalI be deemed a violation of this chapter 1I11d shall be punishable as such, (Code 1974, ~ 14-4) Sec. 9-6. Appeals Crom granting oCvarlances, (8) Any person, board, taxpayer, department or bureau of the city, aggrieved by the granting of any variance, or the failure of granting of any variance, or by the interpret.ation by the board of adjustment of t.his chapter may appeal the deci- sion of the board of adjustment to the city council. (b) Upon the rendering of an unfavorable de- cision upon aPI>eal by the city council, ony person, board, taxpayer, department or bureau of the city, aggrieved by the granting of any variance or by the interpretation by city officials of this chapter may seek review Ulrough a court of record of such finding or interpret.ation in the manner provided by the laws of the stat.e, (Code 1974, * 14-5) Sec. 9-7. EnCorcement and penalties. (a) The city council or any aggrieved person may have recourse to slIch remedies in law and equity as may be necessary to ensure compliance fi 9.26 with the prOViSions of this chapter, including injunctive relief, to enjoin and restrain any per- son from violating the provisions of this chapter and any rules and regulations adopted under this chapter. pnd the court may, upon proof of the violation 'of this chapter. issue such temporary and permanent injunctions as are necessary to prevent the violation of this chapter, (b) Any person violating or failing to comply with the terms and provisions specified herein, shall be punished, upon conviction and at the discretion of the court, by a fine not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500,00) or by imprisonment not exceeding sixty (60) days, or by both fine and imprisonment. Each day tbat a violation is per- mitted to exist shall constitute a separate orrense. (Code 1974, ~ 14-6) Sec. 9.8. Soil, rock, ete,. removal. (3) It shaH be unlawful for any person to remove from any real property w:ithin the city any soil, subsoil, rock. or sand without approml as provided herein, Prior to such removal such pcr- son shall file with the city manager an application which shall include a written consent of the owner for such removal. The city manager shall present the application to tho city commission for its approval. If the commission approves the ap- plication, the mayor shall issue a written pennit for such removal. (b) Unless such removal becomes 1I public nui- sance or endangers 'the public health. safety or welfare, no permit would be necessary other than a building permit for the removal which would be incident to the preparation of single-family homes or lluxiliary structures such as patios, swimming pools or driveways. (Code 1974, ~ 9-5) Sees. 9-9--9-25, Reserved. ARTICLE II. PROCEDURE FOn SECURING APPROVAL OF PLANS AND PLATS DIVISION 1. GENERALLY StlC. 9-26. Maps, engineering plans and plats to be submitted in preliminary and final Corm. Nine (9) copies of all maps, engineering plans or plats of subdivisions of any land within the city 563 October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 19 ATTACHMENT D Letter Mr. Baker: My wife and I wanted to send you this letter since we will be unable to attend the meeling on 9/2/04 in regards 10 the property on South Moss Road and Panama Road being rc- platted from two lots imo four lots, My wife, Alisa Harper, and rare vcry much against this plan. When we moved here over two years ago we specifically picked this area because of the large lots with acreage and few neighbors. There is no other area like this any'where nearby, We noted when we were buying that the zoning and deed restrictions stated that the four and five acre lots could only be divided into two 1011' to preserve Ihe feel and value of the community. We strongly relied on these written rules when purchasing our property. We teel that the City of Winter Springs should uphold the zonmg and deed restriclions of the Ranchlands, The sign when enlering the Ranchlands says "Dedicated to Country Living" not dedicated to subdivisions. Vole do not want a mini subdivision in our ba~kyard wilh three morc neighbors, We will do whatever we need to do to fight this change, If this re-plauing takes place then we will request that our property be re-platted so we can build a subdivision on our property and then we wilt move. By allowing the rezoning you arc opening it up for all Ranchland property owners to do the same. There are plenty that will if this changt: is allowed, There is also the problem of drainage. I believe the back of the property in question is partly wetlands and should not be built on, Much of this property is lower than our property and ifbuilt on the property will be raised and drainage diverted right toward our land, If the re-platting is done the Ranchlands wjlllose their uniqueness and we believe the value of these lots will decrease. If \ can give you any other information please contact me at the number below, ~/ ,Si",&~ , ..;_' " /" . v '..... ~J.". ..'" \, ' - : "Y~'" D. Brad Phill'ips 1'[' )jl> Alisa Harper 111/St:~<. 1-fjI'fJ4!-' \20 E Panama Rd Winter Springs, FL. 32708 407-696-0557 cell 407-687-568\ f-... AUG) 2004 October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 20 ATTACHMENT E Excerpt from Minutes, Oct. 7, 2004 CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS DRAFT UNAPPROVED MINUTES BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT REGULAR MEETING OCTOBER 7,2004 III. PUBLIC HEARINGS AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS Community Development Department A. Presents To The Board Of Adjustment A Variance Request From The Requirements Of Section 9-3. Of The City Code, To Allow Further Subdivision Of A Platted Lot, Pursuant To The Criteria Set Forth In Section 9-5. The Property Is Located Generally At The Northeast Corner Of Panama Road And South Moss Road. Ms, Eloise Sahlstrom, AICP, ASLA, Senior Planner, Community Development Department presented this Agenda Item. Chairman Waters opened the "Public Input" portion of the Agenda Item. Ms, Rebecca Furman, Attorney, Lowndes Drosdick Doster Kantor & Reed, P.A" 2 J 5 North Eola Drive, Orlando, Florida: addressed the Board on behalf of the Contract Purchaser, Paul Rosu and asked that the Variance be approved at this time, Ms, Jo Bush, J 25 East Bahama Road, Winter Springs, Florida: spoke of her opposition to subdividing the property, Ms, Tory Collins, 626 Sailfish Road, Winter Springs, Florida: referenced the 'City Code 9,3 and 9.5' and is opposed to dividing the property, Mr. Vincent Murphy, 255 East Panama Road, Winter Springs, Florida: spoke of his concerns on the Variance and is opposed to dividing the property, Ms. Elsie Bledsoe, J 80 East Panama Road, Winter Springs, Florida: addressed the Board and is in favor of the Variance. Ms. Linda p, Kenny, 256 East Panama Road, Winter Springs, Florida: spoke against dividing the property, There was no other "Public Input. " October 25, 2004 Public Hearing Item 406 Page 21 ATTACHMENT E Excerpt from Minutes, Oct. 7, 2004 Ms. Sahlstrom said, "Staff recommends denial of this Request." Ms. Sahlstrom stated, 'Unlike some of the other Variance requests, your decision will stand unless it would be challenged to the [City] Commission, but you're not making a recommendation to the Commission in this case, you are actually making the decision. Staff believes that the Variance Request would be detrimental to the public interest and would set a precedent that's not been substantiated by the Applicant that there are not Special Conditions that would result in an unnecessary hardship and that if they had documented that there were Special Conditions that existed, peculiar to the land that in fact, anything peculiar to the land would have been self-created hardship because the configuration of the land as it is today was based on a lot split by the current owner. So, therefore, the unique characteristics of the parcel are not beyond the control of the property owner and economic disadvantage by not being able to sell the land for the price he desires does not rise to the level of a legal hardship. And, any Variance that would be granted would need to be the minimum Variance that could be granted to make the reasonable use of the land, And, since the land can be used as it stands today, Ijust conclude by saying Staff recommends denia1." Discussion. Reverend Neil R. Backus, D.D" 110 East Panama Road, Winter Springs, Florida: spoke regarding his concerns regarding the Variance Request. "I MAKE A MOTION WE DENY THE VARIANCE." MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER CASMAN. SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER FAIRCHILD. DISCUSSION. For clarification, Chairman Waters asked, "The Motion is to deny the Variance, you vote 'Yes', if you're voting to deny the Variance. If you vote 'No', you are voting to permit the Variance, Is that correct?" There was no objection from the Board Members, VOTE: BOARDMEMBERFAIRCIDLD: AYE BOARD MEMBER CASMAN : AYE CHAIRMANWATERS: AYE BOARD MEMBER COLLINS: AYE MOTION CARRIED Date: 101104 This Petition was noted on 10/25/04 during Public Hearings "406" by Reverend Neil Backus ~ , """~y,.,~~,..~..",~,Ag,~.Y.~,?..P.~.P.~",..,."..,.,..,...'"'.........."",."...."",...".,."",,,.,.."..,.,...........",.""".,.".,."..",..,....,..,., p, O. Ho,", IY521(l Wintcr Springs. Florida 32719,5216 407-699..4223 NciIBackm1a..CS.col11 RECEIVED OCT 2 5 2004 October 25,2004 CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK The Honorable Deputy Mayor Robert S, Miller City of Winter Springs, Florida 1126 East S.R. 434 Winter Springs, Florida 32708-2799 Re.: Proposed North Orlando Country Estates Subdivision located at 415 S, Moss Road (3 lots) consisting of (2) 1 acre lots facing Moss Road and (1) 1.565 acre lot facing East Panama'Road"( "L" configuration); total land 3,6 acres which was split off of 5.2 acres in 1990. Board of Adjustment denied October 07, 2004. Dear Deputy Mayor Miller: Am enclosing a Petition of adjoining property owners within 150 feet of lot line and beyond ( incomplete as we are still adding names) Seven out of nine adjoining property owners have signed or promised to on return from vacation, Please submit this to the City Commission, Regular Meeting; Monday, October 25, 2004-6:30 P.M. Thank you. Yours sincerely, ~,9;~~~//J,.P.. Rev. Neil R. Backus, D,D. ce.: File ~, ~ -.. ".: ~ . "" ~ - * PImI(ll Sht.Io. / O~ 4- To; The f1onorable Ra,or and City ec.ission of The City of IiDter SpriDgI, nOlida. , SUImrl:PropIIt Iorth OrlaD Camtry Istates SuhtiYiSiOD located at 415 S. bs bel (3 lots) CIIISialiJMj of (2) 1 acre Iota facing loss lbtd mI (1) 1.565 aCIe lot fac:iIIj East Panana Road (~. ccmfi,ration); total land 3.6 aares lhich DB split off of 5.2 acres iD 1990 for JIOImm Faith Bible 0IInh site whim ns denied on lor.. 3, 19M br brd of MjuatDnt ~~ , Jt.l mlitiODilI use do. to protest by'.. ~oiniJKj ~ omen _ others liYiBlIp to 2 miles nay. .1 of B.O.A. action .. denisd January 9, 1995 putiaUylued olrfalBe-infOl1lltion ill a letter ,tritteD to IaJor JoIm F. Bash am CtIIIIIiSBicm dated Jmmy 3, 1995; IlJol Bash read the letter into record. Since then a Sanitary Serer Eneosian Iau heeo designed am lIilt OD city streets as a recpilie&t for a sabliYisicm Iml split at a at of $ 36,36113 Jlid for by.BeY. Ieil R. JicbI,D.D. to sen property ml relate. Also, there has heeD 2 enviroIBtal smeys,aerial }iotas, mI other upenses since then. ' . Iote: s~ tbis JltiliOD in fafor of tile sulxliriOCII split does DOt ~i9ilte JCI fiDaDcially or in IDJ other DY; (t) before .. ilKlic:ates . .,' . ~~ 1i~.1~ teet o( ~~. ~ .~'. .-.NftJne . I r A. Street Ad ress Te) ep'hone No. Da e ~ O"'^-- H-. ~ '2.. B (Zo. ('(0' ~C'f~-St?g (0 '2..t 2,oolj "t .., "* * -* * ~, ~ -. -.! -: ~ " * Pm.TI(I a Sht.Io. Z drf To; The lJonorahle .,or and City CcmDission of the City of linter SpriDgI, nOlida. . SUlm1T:PropIIt Iorth OrlaD Country Estates SulxIiyiBion located at 415 S. bs bel (3 lots) CIIISialiJMj of (2) 1 acre Iota famg 1088 lbtd a (1) 1.565 acI8 lot facing East Panana Road (~. afiflDtion); total land 3.6 aares which DB split off of 5.2 acres iD 1990 for pt0(X)8ed Faith Bible 0Irch site thia fU denied on lor.. 3, 19M br Baud of Mjua_t ~~, Jt.l cmlitiODilI use due to protest by'.. ~oiniJKj ~ CIIleII alii others liYiBl'P to 2 miles nay. Appell of B.D.! . .- ---- actioffm denial Jmmy 9, 1995 putially Iued on false infOI1lBtion'"in a letter ,flitten to Ifayor John F. amh am Ct-iaicm dated Jmmy 3, 1995; IlJol Bash read the letter into record. Since then a Sanitary Serer lIteasion III heeD desiped am lIilt OD city streets as a recpilie&t for a sabliu.imalDl split at a at of $ 36,36113 prld for !Pf . BeY. Ieil R. P.a4u1,D.D. fo sen property mI relocate. Also, there has been 2 enviroIBtal smep,aerial phot., am other upenses since then. ' . Bote: 8~ tbis JltitiOD in DYOl of the salxtirioCII split does DOt rA>>ligate '(I fiDaDcially or in IDJ other laY; It) before maD ildic:ates . lirilj within 1~ ~eet o( ~ property. !!wi p. .':; . ; ...... .." -. - ":' ~ . . .-. - . Name Street Address Telephone No. Date " ~ - ~ '.: . '.. - ..- * Pm.TI(ll Sht.Io. 3 d' 4 To; The lJonorahle Bayor and City ConRPssion of The City of linter SpriDgI, nOlida. "'. ." . SUImrl:PropIIt Iorth OrlaD Camtry Istates swm,iBion located at 415 S. ibis bel (3 lots) CIIISialiJMj of (2) 1 acre Iota facing ba IbId aM (1) 1.565 aCIe lot facing East PaDaua Road rL- CODfiflDtion); total land 3.6 lares which DB split off of 5.2 acres iD 1990 for JIOImm Faith Bible CImIa site which ns denied on Iovellher 3, 19M br Ikmd of MjDstDt ~~, It-l mlitiODilI use doe to JIOlest by'.. ~oiniJKj ~ CDII ami others liYiBlIp to 2 miles nay. .1 of B.O.A. action. ~.JmJuy-9, 1995.pu1iall, Jued on false infOl1lltion ill a letter ,nitleD to IaJor JoIm F. Bash am o.muicm dated Jmwy 3, 1995; lfayolllsh .read the letter into record. Since then a Sanitary Serer lItension hu heeo desigoed aDd lIilt OB city streets as a reqUrDDt for a sabliYision 1Dl split at a at of $ 36, 363~ 13 J8id for by. Ref. lei} R. lBcbs,D.D. fo sen property BJKI relate. Also, there has _ 2 enYiroIantal smeys,aerial photos, mI other upenses since then. ' . Jote: 8~ this petitiOD in D_ of the sulxlirisiCll split does DOl d>>ligate JCI fiDaDcially or in any other BY; It) before nail ilKlicateB ~.~~wi~.l~~eeto(~~. ~.~'. Name Street Address Telephone No. Date . it- .~ 9;~~11f15.4. ~& ~2d!J';:?~#J3. /<?~.?Z~H ~C 13'1 S. lfto~ v4-, I-/J !tJ-Z3-fJy ) 7/7f duep,o/1/ ~e I/IIL /()-23-{) /<" ... Y ~07 S 'I09l'Aw k~ . IV- U - o~ (; - -- '10", W. 13.1'.1 uA- 1':" ID - d?'-O - "* S.CJtL....J. ,K'$>A10P.g ~Ma~~41t) s'JI1eJ>-!i 4'''7-~~5'... ~/?6 ("tV' t/4~~T/'e!/N.... Pt€~N '~Q/ T/J 5/6"# d'A;1 f~~/tt) " ~ -. .~ "t .., * PmTI(I a Sht.Io. -4 d,4 To; The lJonorahle layor and City Comission of The City of liDtet SpriDgI, nOlida. . SUImrl:PropIIt Ilorth OrlDfo Ccmtry Estates SaMi,iBion located at 415 S. bs load (31ots) CIIISialiJMj of (2) 1 acre Iota famg loss Road mI (1) 1.565 acre lot facing East PaDaua lbK! (~. afi91Rtion); total land 3.6 lares which DB split oft of 5.2 acres iD 1990 for prop8d Faith Bible CJIrc6 site thij _ deoied on loresbeI 3, 19M br brd of MjustBt for , It-l comitionaluse doe 0 to protest by". ~iniJKj ~ _ _ otllers liYiBlIp to 2 miles nay. .1 Of B.O.A. . action !as denial Jaoouy 9, 1995 putiallriued on faolse infOl1lltion ill a letter ,nitten to IaJor JoIm F. Bash am o.p.ion dated Jaumy 3, 1995; IlJol Buh read the letter into record. SinGe then a Sanitary Serer En_an bas heeD desigoed aDd lIilt on city streets as a IecpJirlBlt for a sabliYision laII split at a at of $ 36,36113 Jlid for by. Ref. IeilllBcbs,D.D. fo sen property and relate. Also, there has been 2 enm.ntal smeys,aerial pholos, mI other upeues siBee tben. ' . Bote: 8~ tbis Jltition in fuor of tile sulxlirisiCII split does DOt obligate ,eI fiDaDcially or in IDJ other faY; (t) before .. iDdic:ates lirilj within 150 feet of above property. W p. .";' "~"'. . p. -:..:.:..- - . -: p . --. - . . . 11 0 Na - - 10 fJr~L -- s-/ tp.. -~s ?~ .a~ /6Z/ EPo~.~tj<fl-~/f6$/6/IJY5''''' 10/19/04 08:40 FAX 407 47ll-06Y~ ........_...-:L---- . ~" . " '.~ :ala \AJ.rAl'llll.~ WUV.I. ~ 10: City of Winter Springs City Commission IIe8Iin8 Date: 0ctab8r 25. 2004 Mayor John Bush Robert Miner, Commissioner Michael Blake. Commissioner .Donald GIlmore, Commissioner Sally McGInnis, Commissioner David McLeod, Commissioner I oppose Ihe proposed variance requested by Land Tech, of the second subdividing of Lot 6, Block a, Section 1. into 3 additional piR8Is which would create a new subcivlsian. I strongly urge the Mayor and City Commissioners to abide by SectIon 9-3 of the City Code and deny this request. I believe thallhis variance would haVe the elfect of nullifying the intent and purpose of this chapter (Section 9-5). The original zoning charIBr of the North OrIllllClo Ranches must be observed. lJ2..0 Zt./J f. It cJ~...'~r r---.-.-.-----.------ : \0 I~'i Ie;, ~ : ! ~(-s P4'-J,'r- ~~ ~eV-..J.~_..( \ W\..... .,:) "'- l ()f..). <;(~ ~7 ~..J.oc.. i.Lt.~s n~~~ ~ ~l p~ 11.0 '&J~f. ~ r- J. ~<)~ 1 . IL- - r\-4- .~~..1 v ~ K.~. 3H.""f~ L~<;~ ~ ~~ s:----- ~S--' ; dk.). ., .~ .. :- TO: City of Winter SpnllllQS City Commission NleaUilg Date: <>debar 2S, 2004 Mayor Jollin Bush Robelii MiIl1er. Commissionell" MlcrnaeD IB'UaCw, Commisslcl'llef l!)Iotraald Gilmore, CommlssionsD" SallVy McGinnis, Commisslonerr IDlm<<il fMJclLeOO, CcmmSssnoner I OPPOSE the proposed variance requested by Land Tech, of the second subdlvldlng of Lot 6. Block 8, Section 1. into 3 additional parcels which would aeate a new subdivision. I strongly urge the Mayor and City Commissioners to abide by Sectfon 9-3 of the City Code and deny this request I believe that this variance WOtJld have the effect of nulfifying the intent and purpose of this chapter (Section 9-5). The origins! zootng c:twrter oi fue NII)~ Orlando Ranches .must be observed. NAME. ADDRESS, PHONe SIGNA 'UlJRE l!It:i'Jl~~ o I~o g~~" <1> ~&L~ . ~'47{~OL . 4/S.r:!:>7~)~)o '107 ('t!:-76{.o?> : ~- yo: city of Winter Springs City Commission Meeting Date: Odober 25. 2DU4 ..--..... Mayor John Bush Robert MiUler, Commissioner Michael Blake, Commissioner Donald Gilmore, Commissioner Sally McGinnis, Commissioner David McleM, Commissioner I OPPOSE the proposed variance requested by Land Tech, of the second 5ubdMdlng of Lot 6. Block B. Section 1. into 3 additional paroels which would create a new subdivision. I strongly urge the Mayor and City Commissioners to abide by SectIon 9-3 of the City Code and deny this request. I believe that this variance would have the elfecl of nuJlifyina the intent and purpose of this chapter (SecUon 9-5). The original zoning char1l9r of ihl'North Orlando Ranches must be observed. NA1't1E. ADDRESS, PHom: SIGNATURE 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 r'"' r r. . ~ ! I ; I . ,.. . ~......'" '~"I "'10 h......'"9 "'.!lit 4 !\J[~~(0~ :~d<:J~~~ ~bJ; ~( '-k it-- C~ cWL b1~; I).,,,-,~ w. k)\; - (<-. l~-l ~ p~c-> '~i~5' \' .Job I( 2004 3:27PM No.6675 P. 2 r.'" r ., ...,;.....,,~.~.:. ~ ,. or r. . . I I t I I ! ~ ! j ; I .~.,I u, ~ ........ '"9 Ioo.!llt. 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 roo' r i. . ~ J J f I 1~\lI'1 ..,,, ,.".,....., ",.!ut., 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 r'" r -, ....;-..."'~.::.:. ~ ,. ~ i. . . I I ~ I I ! ~ J j ; I '~"l ..,to.........'"9 \o.!llt. 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 r"" r r. . . I I t I I ! ~ I j f I .~.,' ..,~...w'"9 \o.!l1t4 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 r.'"' r .. ,'.~tr",,~.::.:. ~ "? j. , I I t I \ I ~ j J I I .~.., ...t, ---""'9 ....!It 4 r i. , ~ j j '~"l "'~""";''"9 loo.!llt 4 2004 3:27PM No. 6675 P. 2 r."' r ~ . I I i I I I ~ J I ! I 2004 3:27PM No.6675 P. 2 f!I:.'"' ,r .. ,....;...,.."':.:.~..:. ~ . to( i. , t J I ! I o~.., u" ..,....;.'"9 \o.!llt 0/ Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A LANG LJSE CLASSIFIC'.ATIC~N LEGEND Rural Residantia I Industrial i1 e~.l ~4'1v bl ~Y6§t L1~ DensRy Resideniial ~~~u~; lvlaed Use a,L~la~acu„~~~ r _<~~~,: htk3~um (~nsiry Residerriial Recreation 13 f ClJ b 9. fl txJ' n,,w1 H ie~Ft Rensi ty ~~~ ° ~ " Residential ,,~. ~ Conserva0on ~~ f~iLilr.,zlarJ'r>.mF Tam C:entar &'', ~ Semi-Puit lic Pubes District s i Greenaway Cc~nxnaraal I nterclianga ff~ Crar~sarvation li overlay Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A w M", L.~NCa USE C:LASSIFI~:ATIC~N LEi~~Et~lC~ Rural Rasidainial Industrial N Cu ° ~a ~~.~~ Iwss~ Lavr Dansdy Residential ~~~, tvlo~ad Usa ii~~[ur~~zCUra~~i ti Medium Dansiiy Residential Racrentian 1~ ~ ~~ ~ n o Gll ~ a-'roi =' High Density Residential ~' ". Cansenraiian ,,. jB 1CU A7 ..".1 OhUt~7c1 ^ Town Gaoler Public t Sami-Publie District s C~raenaway G~mmarcial I ntarchanga G~ansanratian %% Ovarl~y Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A 4 ~, ~~,~. LAND USE CLASSIFI~ATIc~N LEt~~END Rural Re~er~tia I In~J ustrial ~irti ~~.~~~m~; L~}~. Deity R id ~ es ential hlaed Use ~ t i L1.1 b 3.5 Gam= ALKe) ,,... -. IV~~~um Density Residet>tial Rficreritian ~s r- CU ~, e ~ W ! n,_ss) High Density F Residential "~ ~' Conservation .... )N trll k+714rJ1~1 .4~'AiM ^ Town Center P bt~ ° S i-P Gli District u : em u c Con~~raal Gf 6An8NIdy Interchar~ ; ~ C+~r~rvation ,,, ~`i:~ overlay Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A E Y. LAND iJ~E CLAS~IFIC:ATIQN LEUEND Rural Residantia l R~ r..u ° ~-,~ _,~ i8~~ Industrial Lea: Density Residential ~. ' Mixed Usa 1~ tpJpaaCllrAnal _, Medium Drensity Residential Racreatic+n 13 G rYJ b 9_D aJ.'W:,N,~ ., ,` Hi~~h Density Residential '! Consarvatian '~ j9.1 riU G 21 D CU `a..-to1 Tovtrn Center District w` Fublic :Semi-Publ~ Gomrnaraa l C-,raanaway I n tarchanga i '. - Gans6rY8tl[Nl ,~ ,; r:~%>. Overlay L Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A E ,; . v ~,,: LANG USE CLAS~IFIc:ATic_~N LEGENC! Rural Resrclential Industrial E~ cu ~~.~~~.~ l_oar Der~Ay R ad rii l N es er a ~ ~, 1aed Use Medium CJensity Rc~sider~ial Recreatic+n i~~fY!nsetxl'aaa- °x High Rensity Resklantial ~ Conserua6on .~~ X9.1 CU 1? 21. D ClJ? A~.7C1 ^ Town Center ~' ~ S R bG i-P~li District em u c c C,reeneway C~nrneraAl Interchange ~i Conservation •~~; overlay Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-5 81-0800-006A E L~1NC) USE CLAS~IFIC:ATIt~N LEGENC3 Rural Rasid antis I Industrial (~ Ct~ r a_~~ ~~ mss Lour Density Residential P,1aed Use !I 'I C.~.1b8.S Gl~7 ~cm) Medium Densiiy RASidential Recraati~n is r, filaggf.`t!°gcwl ~ High [)ansil~~ Rdsidential Conservation f~trUr,zi~Cti a,-~a} Ta;~n Ginter District ~- ~- Fublit: r Semi-Fublic Commercial ~;reeneway I ntarchange G~nsenration :%:% c~verl~y L Future Land Use Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A LAND USE ~GLASSIFI~ATIt~N LEGEND Rural Re std enl is I I ntl ustr i:~ Ei cv: ~„~,~~ w~~~ Law' Densty ResirJa~ial • . RAixed Use II irYJ la 8.5 C11r+~M ,.. Me+~um f:aensiry Residet~ial Recreation ~- Hic~i Density Rasrtierdial Gor~sereation ` {s 1 GU r~ ai v CU `.t6-ia} ^ Tawn Censer Pubic i Semi-Public District Greenguway Ce~rmnercial Interclxu>~e i%`;: Conserv~atian /"`i Qverlay TUNING t'LAS,SIhIC.'~TION I.I:GtNI) R-1 R-lA alara.m 0.,A, ,,. R-lAA RG1 f~...~.n ~>, ~. R L~ pLrD ~F'Lrrca Yzs I'r wkFnrrn GtD ~~% +(:xvxr+w i..:~tu~ I~mnf R-~ y ~Nil~t~.nty~ R-T k.Fi, lirsse.t Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A It)N~N~~ C-L~1S~IFIC.~TI+C)N 1.I:GI:N1) R-1 ,z,.:~.m~.8~.~~ ~.~ R-lA Et-lAA RC-1 ~ifoaam f xer Mer RU ~.4Pnmerz ; cir is < j PUD GID t~~..a ~..~..,~ ~rir R-3 r u~1,~ r..ayf R-T ,~.~,<<3,,...k Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A A u. Y..} t s.M •n t IA dA x c~ ex ra ~ ~ ._.n2r, l(~N~N(~ CL.,'~S41FItr~T1ON l.l~:(,1~:N1) R-1 K-? ~~h~f t~x~t'. fi.N Y_i~fi.~Nr ~~A y(.jr~i~x~~~.. R-lA R-T ~.t..,~.<<,a,,,,~r~ i.,, at~,i<rt~...F~ R 1 A~ ' '"y~~ - G 1 ~ d~e.-~ f. ka~ ..a. ccsrn i-- y [;s ~cnlWna~l: IL ~- ~ r C-2 ~Stnr+.~+r i x~~ t. ~ fsf~.ar3. Et C~ ~ [- .., ~,.r,,,,.. ~.~:.,~:~ PUi) ANNX ~Ctawdt a C~.+„hgszsr~ h~n:a„F 7 nsa tl~ftur~ GID k f E - ~~' ~ T-C a:=.zvv?Y t.r. nae~. ~ ..F -(,ert~l'.•~af wrw.. ,o x V F•.~~tt(;S PC ,x 2~ Zt)N1NG C'[.;tiSSlt'IC e1"i~l{)N 1_f:C~1-:N1) R-1 ~Ainmav h,&Y? W ~. ~Ll) R-lA ,:~n...=«~,~,...~„ ~.,: R-lA~ :~raam tt~!+[•~ f 6x~ RC-1 ~a~,.~<a .,. t., RU ~, .,.m: ~ ~., ~o PUD ,rr~..~~~ ~ .. G~,.~..~.~~ CID R-3 R-T u.~,.tt,,..~E Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A ,. r ,~ :~ >_: ;., ,F ~ . o i eB na < ,~ ,~ ~~ G0 to 1 ~ 1 ?~~ 1 l ZpN~NG ~L:~SS1t~ICATICJiN 1.tGt~Nll R-1 ~ ~ R-~ K-1 A K-T R-IAA G-1 . ~t.nn..~ ~~~~,:e,~ ~ ~~ ,;a,.,.~H,,.,3. RC 1 C-2 '.k~.+na~ t ae it ~ , Ed~mA ~ RU ~ 1-1 PUi~ ~Cl,a:..at.a Gw „eA~ar. s~ ANNK rrm~wE t, aik •f:ez ctD •f.,.,.,. A'iserctY.p ts.ane ~ T_c ~'S..+s.4~nNt IeM0..' 4A ~ l6 ZC)NINCa C'[.,'~5~11~[C'.17~1(~N I.I:GI:N1) R~a1~ ~,,,~kF R-lA .....<. , ~, E . R I ~A Rc- ~ ~61rm.n . xrc 4t R U r~ , .ark., PUI~ GID R-~ t ~,~~,..,~,x R-T x~,e. FF,..,, ~- ,;.~.,,u+~.cs. C-2 . 1-1 t.4arui~ ANNX wr.:,..;t f.v.r [induEr Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A Zoning Map 415 South Moss Road Winter Springs Parcel ID # 02-21-30-581-0800-006A R-1 R-3 ~, ~ .b,,,f ~..c,,r R-T C 1 - ~t~rnnipEUi11 _ ~_~ ~LtuarN~ ^ I-1 • E f t . wr.+ ANNX xsutg u~fir3~u'~ T ~ '7<=..~1':. f~~<rt.~. IC>NIN(~ C'L.ASSIFIC:'1770N L.t~C;L:NI)