Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2003 03 24 Regular F Town Center Lighting Settlement ~~~1. ., ~.... .,~ 032403 Commission Meeting Regular "F" Town Center Street Lighting Settlement COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM F Consent Informational Public Hearing Regular X March 24, 2003 Meeting Mgr.~/ Authorization Dept. REQUEST: City Manager requesting the Commission to review a proposal for settlement of the lighting issue at the Town Center. PURPOSE: This agenda item is needed to resolve the current lighting issue between the City and the Developer. CONSIDERA TIONS: On September 9,2002 the City Manager advised the City Commission of site lighting violations in the Town Center in Add-On Agenda Item "0" of the September 9,2002 Commission meeting, Subsequent to review of this matter the Commission authorized the city manager to work with the developer to determine if a compromise plan could be worked out that would allow some of the improper style lighting to be saved thus eliminating the need to make numerous pavement cuts for the purpose of re-routing underground wiring. During this period of negotiations the developer has lowered the improper lighting from thirty- five (35) feet to approximately twenty (20) feet. Several different plans have been reviewed. In addition to the above, the developer is being requested to provide more intensive lighting for the fountain and to stain or paint the fountain a lighter color so that it will be more visible, and to replace the current white opaque spandle windows on the SR 434 side of Publix with the same spandle windows being used in the balance of the development. 032403 Commission Meeting Regular "F" Town Center Lighting Settlement Page 2 Of2 ALTERNATIVE: The Commission has two alternatives as follows: 1, Require the developer to go back to the original plan approved by the Commission. According to the city's lighting consultant the original plan met generally accepted lighting standards and the requirements of Publix. However, that plan required a large number of lighting installations. The advantage of this approach is a uniform ornamental lighting system, The disadvantage is it will be expensive for the developer to replace the inventory of modern lighting he purchased and installed with ornamental lighting, and to add the additional light fixtures needed to meet lighting standards. It will also require numerous pavement cuts to re-route underground wmng, 2, Accept some compromise that would allow the developer to utilize some of the modern lighting poles and fixtures in combination with ornamental lighting along the streets. The plan before you tonight is a Compromise Plan which allows the developer to utilize the modern pole fixtures he purchased in the parking field while utilizing ornamental lighting, The advantage of this alternative plan is that it will eliminate the need for numerous pavement cuts, The disadvantage of this alternative plan is that there will be three different lighting systems involved, and that the modern style lighting poles and fixtures will continue to be employed in the off-street parking fields, FUNDING: The city has no cost exposure. RECOMMENDATIONS: It IS recommended that the Commission approve one of the following alternatives, l-A. Accept the Compromise Plan, I-B. Accept the Compromise Plan with changes the Commission would like to see, I-C. Reject the Compromise Plan and require the developer to go back to the original plan approved by the Commission, II. Include proposed lighting and painting and/or stammg enhancements to the fountain and the replacement of spandle glass on the SR 434 side of Publix in the settlement agreement. 032403 Commission Meeting Regular "F" Town Center Lighting Settlement Page 2 Of2 ATTACHMENTS: Copies oflighting plan sheets will be available Thursday, March 20,2003. COMMISSION ACTION: Date: 032403 The following was provided to the City Commission during the discussion of Regular Agenda Item "F" on 03/24/03. ,,- ~ NATIONAl PRlNrF.ur NO. 111A . 24.31 e.... Fixture Types 1;, Single head acorn style fixture: 'J~fG. Double head acorn style fixture '..3. Triple head acorn style fixture ;;'~~['~14. Shepards hook style fixture · Single head modem style fixture . 6. . Triple head modem style "xture : /, .' . IS o ~r ~' ~ -:J",\ -- ~I ~ '~\ \ \./ rl~[J ~\ , ~ ~~ ~ t ~ ~ \. \ l~~[\~I= ~ l : ~J 1\ '1; \1i?: J) == :_ ~ :~~-II~ln\~\I~I, - ::f~ ; If If 1I11~1 r / ~~ rc;, o "" Publix ...., ..-."' , . ~. .. ~~ ~~ ~~r~~A.. .fY ~ ~ ~tI'''' .r. -~ ~~IW."" 'V' (J 6 ~ ~ , '\>' ~ ~ 'J? ~j .... \) \). .~. 'i\\ A At ~ ~c"'~~~- /~ '~~ ~~~ Q ~.' J U ...-.. . - ... . . -.. '. -- . .. . -..... - Site Lighting . ~ o \ - , , ./' J I ~ ~\\ ~\\ .- -- o ~~ ~ ~. ~ J' .~:. ! ~~ .\ ~ \ \ o 0 o c c ~ I f -r- J ' I -- ~'\ /1: l. -- l. REVISIONS BY ,.. -, I"~ ... CD. ,.. c: CD (.) .; -0 -- ........- -- .~ c:: It. Q. ~ .... CD ,., . . .5 ~ ~I .... ..... ~ ./ I \/ ,. DRAWN .., CHECKeD DATE! BCALS .JOEl NO. SHEET -~ fY' SE(f! - 'J.m ,......;... -- - ;' ..... ~I /~ \- \) ~ j ,<V ~ \) :t~ I ~ . . // ~ ':t~ . ~~lt ~~ / ~ ~~~:t~ ....",...~......~ ~I ~ .~~ ~~ ~>>~-~ ;r--~ ~~~j~~~ (a~ \ ,- ~h ~ ~,,~- ~ ~ ~ ~A-~~ 'I...'~~ ~~ l\t 'l,; ~~~"4' ~'~ ~ 'l:~~~~~ OY./ ~_~i'"'~~ 'I$>~'i!I~>> __ W~ ~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~ )Y' . ~~ ~ fl&.~~- ,. ~~ ~ ~ ~3"~.....~ ~ 6. 6. ':t ~,~~ ~ ~~~ty ,. ~~?~~.~."t~~~"'~~~ ~ \ ~ ~~ ~~~~.~.., .,,~~~~ ~~--~ll-c l."':~~"~ .~tli..\,~~~:;~~ ~~~ . --I ~ \) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~":t ~ ~,~.Y'~~ ~ i("_~L. t, ~.~ , ~ ~ ~ ~ ._~ -;.-~~. '~~ ~v:t ~\ AIf ~~ ~~ ~qy~ .A . ~/ .~ " -:t" ~ ~~ \' ,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~' ~~~~' ,~~~ \'\~~::I: ~~.~ 0 t~ ~ ~ ,_-'-:lIt' ~'H .::;~ ..>> ~ ~ )~:Lf. .~ ,.J~\1' ~~ ~.--= ~.':ft ~. ~ ~~~~ ~ ~ \'P ~~€:.>>~\i~ ~/ .' ~..\a'~~~~~~~~:r~ :~~~,: ~ '-~~~~l':$' ~~~.,. A2"T ;o;~~ ~~. ;~:>~~ ~~~~:~:~~"I~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~ : ~ ~,.., =iJr.-.} "" ~A:t ~ ~ ~ ~ J r... ~' ".;S ~; ..~ .... "'l>: '\i' ~ ~, :tY,( · .. ~ ~'a ~ ~ ~~ :t,..::tJtvRf,~~: ~~~~i~ ~ :ti~_,:,# ~V3t~~~I~~ ~~... ~l...~P.'I~~""'~'IA'vl .~ ~w ~~, ttl ~ ~~ ~ :t~~>> ~~~ ..l'~~ . ~ )001\)'". ~ u. ~..g, ~ ~ ,,~ ...~ ~ ~~ .-~tI.. ~ ~_~. l..~~ ~~\~ .... :.. ~~~ y 'I~ ~ ; ~ 'tI ~'lI"~~ . '"_ . ~ ~ "k:~..,;~ ....~, ~~ ~ "^ 'V~""\.i ':t\.. ~--. ~~' ~~. '!.P~"'h"'~'~":' .., t:117~ \~...~.-.-. ~), ~ ~ ~ , .. iy: :~ 1 ~~ " ~~ ~~.. 'Ii "J ~ 'I7:d"'.... ~~ ~"5s~ ':Il :r.:;;: ~~~ ..,~~ ....f.-. ..,:~. ~ '~.::. ~ E b'" 'ff~" ~l':l ':t~ ;o.~;!~ ~-~~~=.. ~~ v -, ~~.'.t..~?,l ~~~~~v .:~~ ~:.v-,^ilI'~ . . ~ ~ ~ "ltJ ~ .~ ~1lII1I"" V ,& u;: -- .'U" ..........w ... iiiiIIwit.... ~ :0_ - .,........ - ~ ~ l\O ". ~ ~ ~ ~...... _ U ;;Y nil ..... _ _. rm "'" 'loIlo :li o:r 'IY oj'" 13" "'.Q . 'li~ ~~, _ J~~ ~ -~~~~ ~~ ~-.;~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~.. ~ .~ ~~ ~~... ~ ~~.~ -;---~ · ~ ..,.:~. ~~ - '~~},'\l"....~,~~:, . '~v,,~"":t"';~~ ~ v . ~. ~,~~~0 .~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~ '. .. ~~ ~~ v~~, ~ ~ iF,l'~ ~ · t1' ~'\~'iIf\J\:I\ ~- ~,~~~~~W\~~~..~~...\"'1.' w ~~k ~~. ~ ~~U~~~, :~~~~"t. .~';..., ~ ~ .~~,~, ~~ ~ ~1t :~~~~.,. . ~D '~~~~,~'JIl~~~A<< ~~~~~~~~~~W~~~~~i~.~.t:~~h~~~i<<~~~~,,-~~~~~.~\t ~.~ ~ '4'~~~ ~;i~ ~"I (;; I.. C ~~..)t ~~;t~..~-:,._ .~~ ~ ~ '\..~~.~,.~ >>\~ l,~\,,~,,:~~:"-;'$ ~l':$~:~.,f~:.~;'~W~~~~~~.~~~~:"""'4>~~~~~~~f]~~~1 ~~ ~. c ~~~~ .~~~~.~~...~.~~~ T -~-~~~~~>>~ ~. ~v"-.~M~~~~~'~.~H~~r,~~~ ~ ~ \~ :IJ~~. ~ ...~ ~ "" '~~.~~~ ~ ~ ... ,.. ~~ ~ It....~: ~:t~ ~~~'>>'''''+ol).~ ~. .. l'~ "iJ' ~ .\>~ F '>? ~ -J. 'y.:?:.:r.:;r-: ~#. ~ . ~ 'i- 't~:& '"A~ ~ ~ ~~\: "..'\l'.& ~~~~~~. ,~~ · .~':t ~ ~ ~ '''~T ~ ~ ~~ '-1m~ '~~~.'9,CJ~.~~~'" ~ \.. ~ v .. ry ~p~~ ;~, 'V. ..y -;.. v \a'~. ;"~~'V~~ ..~ ..,."..x,..;:>>~.J'~~~-l)' ~ ~ ,. ~ .../'~ >A '!rI ~ ~ ~ ~~.:e ~... ~ ..i~: 9' . ~ I ~ ~ -- ~ - ..., ...... ~ ...... >> >> :r; ~. _ ~.~ ~ .... ~ ou. l.'o ~ ~ .. 1"~>,,, ~....>> . _ ~..... ~... ~ >> ~ <f?'t -iT :t ~ .~ "...... ~ ~ ~.., ':I- rti. ~ __ ~_ ,.. :tI_ ~ "if,>> - >;f, .,. _. ~ .:J~..... ......~ i ~ ~ ~ \.. . 'ij' ~ ,~"I,l li:I ~..,. ~..... iV. 9'. . tIT 'V ,--". ~ 17 .... y - ~ \Y'" . ~ ~ 'Qy-. \' ... '\'l ~ II I'~'.~- 'V ~ ~,. v , .....!Ut. ~ .. ~ ~ ~..."."'':$' ,_.~ ~~~...Vl!l~~~~ >> 9' P bl- r~~~~~~ ."~ ~ ~ 11 ~ 'l: ~~ '>>~"A'~ ~ ~~~"6'#~'4~ ,;~~~~~~~~~~ :~ ~\i~~ .~~~, ,'~ ~~"~."'~ ~ ~'>>~"41~~"#~ ~ ...... ~ ;t~~.,.;~b~~:t~l"~' iV.~~ '!J:..~~~~ ~~ ~ I I IX ~ ~~~~:t' >>~ l i1 ~~~~~"'if....~':t..il: '~~~'L..Y...:.~'.&~.~"$>~:~~ I~~~ ~ ~~';,~.~~~~".:t ...-:;. ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~,.,., ~... ~..t79 ~~~ ~, ~ """ -:"11 V [ ~ ~ ~ \'P u ~'>> ~ ~ ':t~ "$ ~ ~ ", ~ ~.~ ~ ,.. "A. ,:&.."" 3 ~.. ~._ ~... ~ ~ !9 "Jb ..., "& ~~ ':t. "$'__ '4'.. ~t ~ · :r:t. ~~;, "';; .. .v ill' y u · ~ 'l9' ~ ~ ~ '4' ~ ~ -:;__ltJ ~: \\!!:~ >> v "It> ~ ~~'" ~ ~ "It ~~ .., ~ ~.. ...-. ~ ~ ~~:;p~ · ~ ~ ~ ~'" ~(~~..,. . '\.~~~.~:Pi.J _1~~~~~ :__lfIi!' Wwb'''~6Y,,~~~....->>>>~. ~~..~~ _~~ ~ ~~~1Io ...:,~ l~A~>>_~'~'b.~~"& ~ ~. oCV. v ~~ ~ ~~ o,J' 6i'"' "'Clo.~' ~ 1fcD. I 1iF\.... ~ ~'"~ ...I ~ v. IT" " Ie... V V 'V ow '\.~ ....., 2tJ' fW .... ~ -..,. "'" . ~ I~."" 1!6" t:\2, ~ ~ · 7 YrQ. J ~ ~ :lj) 'l1 ..'V'6 '7.." .... ~ ~ .......... "t" ...." ~ .. -.0 ~ % II' lS :I . ,~ ..... "':' : ~ ~ 1idl' "" V '~:V' ~, V \1' ", ~ or ~ ._~.. .. ~ '. l!;; ~ .... 'Y ,_ V' , "I...... ,., . . ~ ~ .., ~~~':~;~.~~i(~~~~;~~~~~:-i ~. ~~ ~.p;. , -.;f?'.; ....:~>> ~ ~'~:!-':-~!40~~~~~;~~ ~,;tI,.:~~:~~~~~~~~~~~I~~~~':~:V~':~~~~~"'~~18;~~~;~'~ ~~~~:~:~~" ._ gfi'l; ~ ~ ~ '" t. L \i:::l ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~1,., .. ~ ~ "......... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~; ':t~ ~ ~~~' v. -~ ~'- ~~~~ ~;t.. ~: ~ ~'" H~ ~... ~ '. '" ~. 7 'Uo ~ V. V' ,,&'" ~ .., I~::...... ':I',. ~ ~~ i9' ~ ~ Ilt :t t:s'n -;; .... -.: .... ~ ~~.. '4' ';j :,."" ~ ~ ~ ~J I - ... -. .... 'J'TO ...,. II" ~.""' ~ 'li> ~ W'!'A.. ~ ~ ~~~)!} ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'i' " ' W' -. -. 'II v y .., ...- ~ _ ~ . IIII I I r ~ ~~~~ E~~ ~~ ~~~~~~.~ i ~"<<o~ ~\.~ea rl~~'J.l~. ~~~~~. . .~~ C ~ ~~:~:~~ / [~)J~~~-~~~:'~"~~ ~ ._~.~~~>>~.~~~ ~,:~: · ~:~::~ '~~ l -j ~~~!<<o~:l. ~1l n::.".;:.~~y"7.l~..:l!t~..~A:~~~~~~~':-,a4~ ill ~ ~:... ~ ~~~~1~ ~~. f~t ' 'IL" -.;~ -~ [ . r~ ~J"" ~. ~"#I W' ~_, o/~"">>/a~ L"t ~ ~. 'V :, ~..... ,. '" .... " .,,- ~:t r I -"-:f' ~.. u" -r:n ~ W'!..... :t> lff .v.. _ ~ ~ 7;-:'" ~ ~ >> ~. iV _ "'~A .,. '^ .... .....". '111!; ~ ~ ':;1' ~ 1 ~ 10 ~ ~ . :f' ~ ~ ~ .. ~, I .. ~ ~ ~~;:;r -...J ~~. ~ ~. ~.... Y'~ ""~ ~ ~.... ij"._ ..~">> ~ ~_ .......1"'"\..... '!!IO ~111li!. ..'J1_~ ~_. -q"..;:!' ~:fb v ':S> ~ .,~_ ~ "" g..... ~~ ~v ~ ~ :ji' il'. !A ~ ~~ ~ ~ · '.. ...,. .--, ~ ~"-:t_ ~u~...._, >> >> ~..>>, _ ~._~..... _ 'JI. ~ :ll. ~... ~.... ..... ..:.r.:\IlI ~ ~__ ~._ ..._ '.' - ,.." -. -.- Of .... ~..... ... - ~" v -.... -- · ~ ..... ...- ~ -- -.... - - .. .. riiA .... "'" OIIT .... v..' ,A "^ - ""..... ... .. ~ .... ,.. J!jf .".. .... ."'A ...~ ... ,... .rJ" ... _'" _ ...~ ~ ..... ".. '"..... V _. ~ . _ -....""- -_- oW .. ...... ~ ~ H .... -- -- ....... 2IJI' "7 -V' V"" ... ~ t:J' 'li17: V ..... ...... ~ "l'" V .... !I!!' ~. \ ~ ... - ... ... . ..'----... _. .. .... .. ..-". ,. _;- .__ --L..-- Site Photometries N"",(tnAL PR.'Nf'PA$f NO. '88A. 24.38 .,m - t .,. ""'Iii REVISIONS BY .... I i .... ~ ,., '. c: ~ U .; ~ & .E' ... : ... ~ ,.. .E ~.. ---- ~ .811' , I \7 7 DRAWN ..., CHECKED DATE SCALS ..oa NO. SHEET .SE2 -- -- ---~- -