HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001 08 27 Public Hearings D Second Reading - Ordinance 2001-48 Official Zoning Map
COMMISSION AGENDA
ITEM D
Consent
Informational
Public Hearing X
Regular
August 27, 2001
Meeting
Mgr./ Arty./
Authorization
REQUEST:
The Community Development Department requests the City Commission conduct a public
hearing for the second reading of Ordinance 2001-48 to amend the official zoning map of the
City of Winter Springs by changing the current designation of the 1.36 acre subject property,
located at 1135 State Road 434, from (Seminole County) A-I "Agriculture" District to the City
of Winter Springs' TC Town Center District.
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this Agenda Item is to request the Commission approve Ordinance 2001-48 to
change the official zoning map designation on property located at 1135 State Road 434, which
would allow the property owner to build an auto service center subject to the design standards of
the Town Center district.
APPLICABLE LAW AND PUBLIC POLICY:
Sec. 20-57 of the City's Code of Ordinances states "The planning and zoning board shall
serve... .to recommend to the City Commission the boundaries of the various original zoning
districts.. ..and any amendments thereto.. ..act on measures affecting the present and future
movement of traffic, the segregation of residential and business districts and the convenience and
safety of persons and property in any way dependent on city planning and zoning."
CDD/Augusl 17,2001/4:30 PM
AUGUST 13,2001
PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ITEM D
Page 2
SITE INFORMATION:
1. PARCEL NUMBER:
20-30-36-502-0000-00l0
2. ACREAGE:
1.36 acres
3. GENERAL LOCATION:
The property is located at 1135 State Road 434, between Tuscawilla Road and
Apache Trail, generally across from City Hall.
4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
(See Attachment A)
5. CHRONOLOGY OF SUBJECT PROPERTY:
The City of Winter Springs annexed the 1.36 acre site on June ll, 200 1
(Ordinance No. 200l-34).
Representatives from Dover, Kohl & Partners, the City's consultants for the Town
Center, met with the applicant and his agents and together they provided a
conceptual site plan and conceptual architectural renderings for the site.
June 25, 2001, Future Land Use Designation is amended from (Seminole County)
Office to Town Center District.
June 27, 2001, the Planning and Zoning Board voted unanimously to recommend
the City Commission approve the request to rezone the subject site from
(Seminole County) A-l to Town Center District.
August 13,2001, the City Commission voted to pass Ordinance No. 2001 - 48
and conduct a second public hearing on August 27, 2001.
6. DEVELOPMENT TRENDS:
Land uses along State Road 434, such as City Hall, Winter Springs High School,
COD/August I? 2001/4:30 PM
AUGUST 13,2001
PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ITEM D
Page 3
and the Post Office, demonstrate the general area's civic and institutional
character. Recently, the City adopted the Town Center FLUM designation and
established the Town Center District Code which currently apply to the subject
property. Developers have since contacted the City with increased interest, and
the first groundbreaking for the Town Center is expected to occur around the
intersection of State Road 434 and Tuskawilla by early Fall 2001.
7. EXISTING LAND USES OF SUBJECT PROPERTY:
The property is vacant with tree cover.
8. LETTERS/PHONE CALLS IN FAVOR OR OPPOSITION:
There were none at the time report preparation.
E. EXISTING LAND USES ADJACENT TO SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Northwest: There is an entrance road and signage for an adjoining residential
manufactured home subdivision, Tuscawilla Trails. There are also small
vacant lots also to the north of the subject property.
Southwest: A well-maintained, residential manufactured home subdivision,
Tuscawilla Trails, is present. A few of the manufactured home lots are
contiguous to the subject property line.
Northeast: State Road 434, City Hall, and vacant lands within the Town Center are
present.
Southeast: There is one low income single-family residence present on a large lot
with direct driveway access onto to State Road 434.
F. FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Existing:
(Seminole County) Office
Requested:
Town Center District
G. FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATIONS ADJACENT TO SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Northwest:
(Seminole County) Office & Town Center District
CDD/AugUSI17. 2001/4:30 PM
AUGUST 13,2001
PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ITEM D
Page 4
Southwest: Moderate Density Residential (3.6-6.5 DU per acre)
Northeast: Town Center District
Southeast: (Seminole County) Office& Town Center District (across State Road 434)
H. ZONING OF SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Existing: (Seminole County) A-l Agriculture
Requested: T-C Town Center District
I. ZONING ADJACENT TO SUBJECT PROPERTY:
Northwest: (Seminole County) A-l; Town Center District; and R-T Mobile Home
Park District
Southwest: R- T Mobile Home Park District
Northeast: Town Center District
Southeast: (Seminole County) A-I Agriculture & Town Center District (across State
Road 434)
J. CONSIDERATIONS:
· Prior to being annexed into the City, the subject property was located in
unincorporated Seminole County.
. On June 25, 2001, the City Commission adopted a small-scale comprehensive plan
amendment, which changed the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) designation of the
property from (Seminole County) Office to Winter Springs' Town Center District.
. The amendment of the official zoning map to TC Town Center would be consistent
with the current FLUM designation.
. Staff has read the minutes and listened to the tapes of the annexation and small scale
Comprehensive Plan amendment public hearings and has found no evidence that the
applicant addressed the City Commission with specifics for the proposed uses at the
Winter Springs Auto Center. The applicant's representative did, at the adoption of
the small scale amendment, state the applicant's appreciation and support for the
design proposed by the City's consultant, Victor Dover.
K. FINDINGS:
COD/August 23, 2001/4:04 PM
AUGUST 13,2001
PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA ITEM 0
Page 5
l. The subject site was annexed into the City of Winter Springs and subsequently
underwent a Future Land Use Map amendment from (Seminole County) Office
designation to City of Winter Springs "Town Center District."
2. The request to amend the zoning map from (Seminole County) A-l to Town
Center District is consistent with the City of Winter Springs Comprehensive Plan.
3. The adopted Town Center District Code allows automobile repair shops (routine
service) as a special exception. This use is consistent with the applicant's
developmental plans for this site.
4. At its meeting of June 27, 2001, the Planning and Zoning Board recommended
that the City Commission approve of the rezoning.
5. At its meeting of August l3, 200 l, the City Commission voted to pass Ordinance
No. 2001 - 48 on first reading and conduct a second public hearing on August 27,
2001.
ST AFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends the City Commission approve the second reading of Ordinance 200 l-48,
which would change the official zoning map designation of a 1.36 acre tract located at ll35 State
Road 434 from (Seminole County) A-1 Agriculture District to the City of Winter Springs' TC
Town Center District.
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD RECOMMENDATION:
At a special meeting on June 27, 2001, the Planning and Zoning Board recommended that the
City Commission approve the requested amendment to the official zoning map from (Seminole
County) A-I Agriculture District to Winter Springs' TC Town Center District for the l.36 acre
site at 1135 State Road 434.
A TT ACHMENTS:
A. Ordinance 2001-48
B. June 27, 2001, Planning and Zoning Board minutes
C. Maps of Subject Property
D. August 22, 2001 letter addressing proposed uses
COMMISSION ACTION:
CDD/August 23, 2001/4:04 PM
ATTACHMENT A
Ordinance No. 2001-48
Sent By: BROWN,WARD,SALZMAN&WEISS,P.A.; 407 425 9596;
AU9,8-01 12:33PM;
Page 5 -
ORDINANCE 2001-48
AN ORDINANCE OFTHE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, .FLORIDA, CHANGING
THE ZONING l\fAP DESIGNA nON OF THE REAL
PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED AT 1135 STATE
ROAD 434 SOUTH OF STATE ROAD 434, DEPICTED
ON EXHIBIT "A" AND LEGALLY DESCRIBED ON
EXlITBrp4B" ATTACHED HERETO, FROM SRMINOLE
COUNTY A-I "AGRlCUL TURAL DISTRlCT" TO CITY
OF WTNTER SPRINGS "TOWN CENTER DISTRICT";
PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; CONFLICTS AND
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
\VlIEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Board and City Staffo[lh~ City of Winter Springs
have recommended approval of this Ordinance at its June 11, 2001 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Winter Springs held a duly noticed puhlic
hearing on the proposed zoning change set forth hereunder and considered findings and advice of
staff, citizens, and all interested parties submitting written and oral comments and supporting data
and analysis, and after complete deliberation, hereby finds the requested change consistent with the
City of Winter Springs' Comprehensive Plan and that sufficient, competent, and substantial evidence
supports the zoning change set forth hereunder; and
WHEREAS, . the City Commission hereby finds that this Ordinance serves a legitimate
government purpose and is in the best interests of the public ht:alth, safety, and welfare of the citizens
of Winter Springs. Florida_
NOW, THEREfORE, THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WrNTF.R
SPRlNGS HEREBY ORDAlNS, AS FOLLOWS:
City of Winter Srnng~
Ordil\.1nce No. 200 I ~IR
I'"~C I of .1
Sent By: BROWN,WARD,SALZMAN&WEISS,P.A.; 407 425 9596;
Aug-B-Ol 12:34PM;
Page 6
Section 1. Recitals. The foregoing recitals are hereby fully incorporated herein by the
reference as legislative findings of the City Commission of Winter Springs.
Section 2. Zoning Map Amendment. That the Otlicial Zoning Map of the City of Winter
Springs as described in City of Winter Springs Code Section 20-lO2 is hereby amended to include a
change ofc1assification from Seminole County A-I "Agricultural District" to City ofWintcr springs
"T own Center District" for the property depicted on Exhibit "An and legally described on Exhibit "B".
which exhibits are attached and incorporated herein by this reference. City Staifis hereby directed to
promptly amend the Official Zoning Map upon the effective date of this Ordinance.
Section 3. Repeal of Prior Inconsistent Ordinances and Resolutions. All prior inconsistent
ordinances and resolutions adopted by the City Commission, or parts of ordinances and resolutions
in conflict herewith, are hereby repealed to the ex1:ent of the conflict.
Section 4. Severability. If any section. subsection. sentence, clause, phrase, word or
provision of this Ordinance is for any rcason held invalid or unconslilutional by any COUll of competent
jurisdiction, whether for substantive, procedural, or any other reason, such portion shall be deemed
a separate, distinct and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the
remaining ponions of this Ordinance.
Section S. EfTe~tive Date. Thi~ ordinance shall become effective immediately upon adoption
by lhe City Commission.
Cny of Winter Sprin~~
Onlinance No. 2001-411
PaGe 2 or J
. Sent By: BROWN,WAAD,SALZMAN&WEISS,P.A.; '407 425 9596;
Aug-8-01 12:34PM;
Page 7
ADOPTED by the City Commission of the City of Winter Springs. Florida. in a regular
meeting assembled on the _ day of
, 2001.
A TrEST:
Paul P. Partyka, Mayor
Andrea Lorenzo-Lullces, City Clerk
Approved as to legal form and sufficiency for
the City of Winter Springs only
Anthony A. Garganese, City Attorney
Fir!>l Reading:
Second Reading:.
Effective Date:
F"DOCS''{;il)' of W;"l<t :If'<'"19'1l "~I~\l.)/1jIlj;,J I3SSR <J' .~IXII..dJ( "f'd7
City of Winter ~prinp
Or<liruillCC No 2(J() I...;g
Pace J of J
.Sent By: BRO\I'!I~,WARO,SALZMAN&.WEISS,P.A.;
Rece~voo: 0/ 7/01 1 : 39Pl\A;
407 425 9596;
.>
Aug-8,01 12:34PM; Page 8
6ROWN.WARD.8ALZMAN&WEISS.PA; psgO:3
AUG-07-2G01
13:35
l
(
MAP OF SURVf;.-Y
. BouNnARY
~o~><~cinQ It U\c 00" [Utul, corner 01 tJ\.It o.rt 01 bloct '8' of O.R, I((!U1Cl.l.."S
SlATE'! OF OE l.EV'1' GRuiT_ u rcclV'dcQ In PIH llaat l. P~9C ~ III tile offlCt 01 Ulc
~Jer~ of ':Ireult Court 01 ~.I".I( Ca<Jo\tI' F1.d4~ 1.,1". ww<J\ 1Nl lIut 01 'Ulc PJVld MJ"
lOcllnq lroo s."rord to O"leQa; tlICJlCc r OIlQ cnt SoUlft"eSlulr side 01 t1w: one~ (<l~C
Hort!1 )8 dcqroC$ <5 ..1t\U(($ llut lsaG.OO (eel lo . COIICncc CllJ<W<lC/lt 10(' I paInt
of bcglnnln9: tM./lU cOl1tJJ-.llng tlort1l :J4 dt.~l"Cd ~ ..l/lutes lI<.l:t ~.OQ: tN.nGt
So<Jln 51 dcqrcr1 I~ .1I'<Jtcs Itc$l 2!l1.:Jo Ie:H ta t1w: sQ~11ttJ'ly tide: .1 I dirt ro.<t
l"cnCt Sout1l V. dcqrct:s IS ..I~ld EUl ~8.eo lect; tlIe/l(C Ilortll St <lc9rc:cs IS ol/\\I(u
E,ut ~l.IO feel to tllc POI,,1 0( ~cglN\I"9.
....'-:;r../~
~ .....~.{ ---> \.
,u...,.. ..
'.lAc.
.-
r,-7.,.
,
\ ~~
~-~....:';..
-\ ;,;.
\_-.J
\
~.~
...~
'l?,"
,"'"
..n .,,"
.<.rq
....\;~
.;.. .1,:
"';;,\.
1'4
\r {..T.
e'
...11 . tf
1'.'" ...J.
.~ ')1!'"
rP. .~
..~. .",'>
L.... -'S1
'~\
l
N
SCJ.u:
,- - (fQ.
\
a-"<f o<J """
'" tDA r><:r _; t<J'<<>' . UIll.' <l.o$6I ....
. ."~--<)IC.-l...,._.~..,..n-<~
~~f" ,.~odw:J11l~.r ..../~'. "~'ll"c
. -- ~~.....~~~~
...."..,.,..,
- ~ ~~f:.cn:w~.-:J ~~~~,.
." .-.< ...t~. ~CL-.c... .CD"'OIP eoo< 'J'4~ 4J...O
.. ~ ~ ~ r~ .. .o-.tC'ltrf".
.. "4.L I_~-rn ...af" ~ .... ~ tJJI'" ClI.,C'OIf"(
~ ":~ ~(~ c.~(!~\"Wi~ ':':$.
. '-. \"'
11'Q'IOIf"'~n~ n4.oI("'h:<'~'ty6.~'~ "';.f
~~'...~~~n,!f;!'~~~~40~
~~ V'<' ~ ... .....F\JIl """ .
...........-"""t--i,.....~~ I. p<<</"..
-P't..-c". f"l.o-tfO. S.
('O""oOrJ'llIO J. J .. J". ,.0. J,r.
~~~~(~~~ t~~~<:~e;:r;..f~
~ 01' . ^G11"D.& c..(~ JUIII'o1'''GI u.4 ~.
: ~~4E.~(=(
'-"1-
:~.w-
c.....,-
:~
.~
" .......
4\C"""-
.~
.f.~
.-......
....
~
""'
r-
......
......
eN'
" ~ .......-
.._f__.~*'
: =~~,:-;~
: --.~r--:J~ ~
.. :r;:, ." "'.#
.,.~.-4
.
'.'
""
l
~I."
".
"''-' <r~-r( ~
'.t.'.'- ,_.........-......~
~;:::: : ~;':.=::~~~rt_
'._ ..._ _'" _ 4f~
rcl :;~~;...~,.
~. ..
::s;
..~.
( . .
-
,
;;
PflANKUN. /;[[20. k n.Ero
N'oJfcr 1~"Ar(()-J
~/E!!..--:1. 1I.'da
11'...- 0". toC
-'-"f'.'1~
~n(r~n(r(o~ OLr~
,,-;:-=\ ."",:,,,-
(.'IVII. A'r/CftiA'l:ltS . ut'n ."'/lI",:,.onI
l.......~.
-..
-"--'
--
~ :~:'::!.::""._--
. )c:r1 ">::1 "''':-c-' ,"""f.'. fI(!:=':~c. r,. JU..
I"ftU~f. If.r, - t,'ll# .. 4' C/.', ".Id' J I
'.' ,"'.:{(4U ,.., ,., r.r."-:
",,' ~~.:;. i.
. . I ',1 ;.'1:.
.' -? :,::..=...,.~
:~-<
P.03
I
EXHIBIT
~'A n
~/-<{S-
....~ -.
..:~'''':'':
...f :...
".
........
.~....
.'
'~..'
j./
'"
. .
:..: :
-:;..('"
..
.'
......~'.
1..~~#' . . ':-.'"
..... - '.~:.'...
;c.ev~..~,..
.,: ~: '..
.....::. :.:9i --'~"' ~~~:.,.;. .
~.~~~~~ .,.'
:'.'''~:~'f'
'f' . :l~~;';:. ~ .
.~c:. ..
. -.
...
.,,:'
;.
.~:. .
. . I~. -
.~.. -;;.. ...;. .
~- ..~.,
:.:~::{~~'.'.
~:.;t~... '.
.." ~~~~""
. ..~"'~..
. c.: ':f.t<:.. .
:~.:.~~:?'; ~~.~:.:
. ~~~~:.....-.~-
'r. _. .-_
~'" c;.-: '.' .
:~".::~t: ."
:-:. . ....t-... ",
,"'
.
!
. .
Sent' 8)1': BROWN,WARD,SALZMAN&\'IEISS,P.A.;
H9C(>~VOO: 0/ 7/01 ':39PM;
AUG-07-2001 13:36
407 425 95913; Aug-8-01 12:34pr,l; Page 9/16
,> llROWN,WARO,sALZMArJs.wEree,PA; Pogo 2
P.02
EXHIBIT
(
i
"\3"
-y?
a.QJ.n.t\.lO'l At: t:h. co;;>..c. It..u~l.y co.cnCJ: ot U.C p~t"Q' lllO<:::<. 'eM of
0_ SL IUTClto..t.'j; SVItVn or TU::"L..r.iY ClV.tl'r, a" rCQOcded. 1n. 1"1..." Boo" 1,
1"49<:: 5.. in the: oal..Gc o( tho. (,loc1t. ot Clt1::\Llt: Co.fct' oL ll:_lnolc:
COUn~. FloCl<1",.lyl..n9 $O'\<l:ll ~ ICoIIC ...f I:h4 p.a~ r_tI JA64J.nW .c"Cl<a
$aotorn Co Q\,I~I Cl\c:IICC 1110"9' tt.. SQ\(t~dy DL10 ot c:s~ p.aV*"
ro..a Uorcl1 ..YO dC'9'CC14C. 4.5 "lnuc<<c. Ic.u:t 158Go.Oo t.e.::t. to .. ClOn=ot4 "",n=onc
~ 4 J>dLnc: ot ~9~lQ'11 th..nc:. COl1c..lllllLn1 tlCU:d-i J4 c1I1VC:_" .1> ~Lr"'H:.c.:.
~&AC :200.00 f4.H.1 CMnc;. SQut:h Sl dqgr04~ ti 1II.1.l\~ WeJl:t. 291,Ja !C~t:
tI2 eke Sou t:hA....ct..r1.y c 1..4.. or .. d trc ~; clt4t\.C4 ~~ 12 ~.;.;r1l0l.Q 1S
II!J.uQt4. ~rt ~0lI.40 {lIotl t:hAn<:" w,)rtA 51 d,,'l'='us l~ ~~ c...t. J:H.lo
tuc to tJ'tc paLM: o( ~<1l""l"9. . .
I..os3 road right of w"-y descooc:d in Onk( ofTlldnlt CCUlnic:d In O.R... Book 280J, hgc ~02J.
""
g.
LE"GIrt-
1> ~C fl.t. ~""Tl.~
t=v tL
1(')5""
5. R...
!fIQ(1-st
~~
FoR.
~~
cwrcP It
H~
(v<f~~
l'ur:1.: , (11'1
rorr'.( P.!))
.. "' I
ATTACHMENT B
P & Z Minutes
.,'
" I
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD/LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING
JUNE 27, 2001
I. CALL TO ORDER
The Planning And Zoning Board/Local Planning Agency Special Meeting was called to
order Wednesday, June 27, 2001, at 7:07 p.m. by Chairperson Rosanne Karr in the
Commission Chambers of the Municipal Building (City Hall, 1126 East State Road 434,
Winter Springs, Florida 32708). The Pledge of Allegiance followed.
Roll Call
Chairperson Rosanne Karr, present
Vice Chairman Bill Fernandez, present
Board Member Tom Brown, present
Board Member Brent Gregory, present
Board Member Carl Stephens, Jr., present
Also Present
Mr. Charles Carrington, AlCP, Community Development Department Director
Mr. John Baker, AlCP, Current Planning Coordinator
Mr. Eamest McDonald, AlCP, Advance Planning Coordinator
Approval Of The June 6, 2001 Regular Meeting Minutes of the Planning And
Zoning Board/Local Planning Agency
MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I WILL MAKE A MOTION
THAT - WE APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE JUNE 6, 2001 MEETING OF
OUR BOARD AS SUBMITTED TO US." BOARD MEMBER BROWN
SECONDED. DISCUSSION.
VOTE:
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
PLANNING & ZONlNG BOARDILOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING - JUNE 27, 2001
PAGE20F7
II. REGULAR AGENDA
A. Reece (Nursery Road Property) Rezoning
Mr. John Baker, Land Development Coordinator introduced the Agenda Item and stated,
"Staff has' looked at this proposal and we are not aware that the latest iteration of the plan
has been sent to the Development Review Committee before coming here. Based on that
information and the requirements of the Code for the Development Review Committee to
review the proposal we would recommend that this go back to our Development Review
Committee before proceeding on, back for this Board's review to get some necessary
Staff input."
Mr. Charles Carrington, AICP, Community Development Department Director suggested
that the Board hear from the applicant and residents that are present. Discussion. This
was agreed to by the Board.
Mr. Phil Reese, 561 Virginia Drive, Winter Park, Florida: address the Board regarding
this matter. The Board, Staff and Mr. Reese discussed various topics in a question and
answer format.
Tape )/Side B
Ms. Cindy Slack, 1220 George Street, Winter Springs, Florida: voiced her concerns
regarding the applicant's request: regarding parking on the street; regarding retention
ponds~ and complaints of the present use of the property. Discussion.
Mr. Melton Malcolm, 98 Melton Drive, Winter Springs, Florida; requested that the
retention pond remain in its present location.
Discussion followed regarding the time frame for this issue to be resolved.
Tape 21Side A
Mr. Joseph Miranda, 1417 Lambert Street, Deltona, Florida: spoke of leasing from Mr.
Reese~ and said that all the problems with the parking on the street should not be blamed
on him.
Ms. Slack spoke again regarding Seminole County denying Mr. Reece's request~ and
personally addressed Mr. Miranda. Discussion.
MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I'M READY TO MAKE A
MOTION THAT WE CONTINUE TillS MATTER AND DEFER IT TO A
SPECIAL MEETING ON THE SECOND OR THmD WEDNESDAY OF JULY-
TO BE HELD AT A FUTURE DATE TO BE DETERMINED BY STAFF."
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS. DISCUSSION.
I.,
" .
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MlNUTEs
PLANNING & ZONING BOARDILOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING - JUNE 27, 200 I
PAGE 3 OF 7
VOTE:
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
Board Member Tom Brown suggested that Staff research whether the County or City is
responsible for Nursery Road.
MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I WOULDN'T MlND MAKING
ANOTHER MOTION TO CLARIFY MY PREVIOUS MOTION. THAT IF IT'S
READY - THAT IT BE BROUGHT BACK AT A SPECIAL MEETING TO BE
HELD THE THIRD OR FOURTH WEEK IN JULY. IF NOT THEN THE NEXT
REGULAR SCHEDULED MEETING FOR AUGUST, IF IT'S READY."
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS. DISCUSSION.
VOTE:
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
B. W/S Town Center Auto Rezoning
Mr. Baker introduced the Agenda Item and distributed additional materials. Discussion.
MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "TIDS IS MY MOTION, THAT
THE CITY COMMISSION APPROVE THE PROPOSED CHANGE OF ZONING
FROM (COUNTY) A-I 'AGRICULTURE' TO THE CITY'S T-C TOWN CENTER
WNING DISTRICT BASED ON THE FINDINGS THAT THE CITY HAS
DEVELOPMENTAL STANDARDS AND IT'S LAND DEVEWPMENT
REGULATIONS TO INSURE MINIMAL IMPACT ON SURROUNDING
PROPERTIES SUCH AS BUFFERING. THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS AND THE SITE PLAN REVIEW PROCESS OF THE
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMfITEE CAN INSURE THE PREVENTION OF
ANY POTENTIAL NUISANCES. FINDING THAT THE CITY'S
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCESS INCLUDES REFERENCES TO THE
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS OF THE ST. JOHNS' WATER MANAGEMENT
DISTRICT FOR STORMWATER MANAGEMENT AND PREVENTION OF
POTENTIAL POLLUTION TO LAKE JESUP. THE CITY'S COMPREHENSIVE
PLAN HAS REGULATIONS THAT HELP INSURE PROTECTION OF LAKE
'1 "
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUTES
PLANNING & ZONING BOARDILOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING - JUNE 27, 200 I
PAGE40F7
JESUP FROM FURTHER DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES. BASED ON THE
FURTHER FINDING THAT THE PROPOSED REZONING OF THE PROPERTY
FROM (COUNTY) A-I TO THE CITY'S T-C TOWN CENTER ZONING
DISTRICT IS COMPATmLE WITH THE FLUM (FUTURE LAND USE MAP) IN
THE CITY. BASED ON THE KNOWLEDGE TRA T WE RA VE, TillS BOARD IN
DRAFfING THE TOWN CENTER REGULATION'S DESIGN; BASED ON THE
FINDING THAT THIS MAlTER WILL COME BEFORE THE SITE REVIEW
COMMITTEE WHICH IS MY UNDERSTANDING NOW CONSISTS OF THE
CITY COMMISSION AND THAT THEY WILL ENSURE THAT ADEQUATE
SAFEGUARDS ARE PUT INTO PLACE FOR THE DEVEWPMENT OF TIDS
PROPERTY, THE BUFFERING OF THIS PROPERTY. BASED ON ALL OF
THOSE SPECIFIC FINDINGS I RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO THE CITY
COMMISSION TO REZONE THIS PROPERTY TO TOWN CENTER ZONING."
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER BROWN. DISCUSSION.
Mr. Miranda stated, "We would be willing to do whatever the City recommends. We
already met with the site plans from Miami. We all agreed to it so whatever the City
Commission asks and everybody - we are willing to work, to do whatever is necessary."
VOTE:
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
C. Rebecca Ann McLay Home Occupation
Mr. Carrington asked at the request of Staff for "A Motion to defer action until the next
Meeting. "
MOTION BY VICE CHAlRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO
TABLE TIDS AGENDA ITEM UNTIL THE NEXT FUTURE MEETING WHEN
THE ITEM IS READY AND THE APPLICANT CAN BE PRESENT. I WOULD
SUGGEST THAT ALL OF US BOARD MEMBERS OR ALL OF WE BOARD
MEMBERS MAKE A SPECIAL TRIP TO CHECK OUT TillS HOUSE BEFORE
WE VOTE." SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS. DISCUSSION.
VOTE:
" th" i
CITY OF WINTER SPRJNGS
MINUTES
PLANNING & ZONING BOARDfLOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPEC TAL MEETING - JUNE 27, 2001
PAGE50F7
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
~CECHA~FERNANDEZ: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
II. ACTION ITEMS
· Comprehensive Plan
Tape 2/Side B
· By-laws (Absences)
MOTION BY ~CE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I'LL MAKE A MOTION
THAT THIS BOARD RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COMMISSION THAT
THEY AMEND THE ORDINANCE - THE ORDINANCE THAT SPECIFICALLY
DEALS WITH ABSENCES AND SPECIFICALLY THE PORTION THAT SAYS
THAT A MEMBER IS AUTOMATICALLY REMOVED FOR THREE (3)
ABSENCES WITHIN A TWELVE (12) MONTH PERIOD, THAT SHOULD BE
AMENDED AND LET THEM ADDRESS THAT."
MR CARRINGTON ASKED, "TO CONSIDER OR RECOMMEND THAT THEY
CHANGE IT?" ~CE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ REP~IED, "MY MOTION IS
TO RECOMMEND THAT THE CITY COMMISSION CHANGE THAT
PORTION OF THE ORDINANCE - 20-53., MID LINE, THE SENTENCE READS
AS FOLLOWS 'MEMBERS SHALL BE SUBJECT TO REMOVAL FROM
OFFICE BY THE COMMISSION FOR FAILURE TO PERFORM THEIR
DUTIES OR OTHER MISCONDUCT IN OFFICE' AND THIS IS THE PART
THAT I'M RECOMMENDING THAT THEY CONSIDER CHANGING, 'OR
AUTOMATICALLY FOR FAILURE TO ATTEND THREE (3) MEETINGS
WITHIN ANY TWELVE (12) MONTH PERIOD OF TIME.' THERE OUGHT
TO BE THREE (3) CONSECUTIVE, IN A ROW, MEETINGS WITHIN ANY
TWELVE (12) MONTH PERIOD OF TIME." BOARD MEMBER GREGORY
SECONDED. DISCUSSION.
AMENDMENT BY BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS. "I WAS GOING TO MAKE
AN AMENDMENT TO THAT. IF THE CITY COMMISSION CONSIDERS
AMENDING THAT PARTICULAR ORDINANCE THEY SHOULD - THE
WORDING SHOULD BE, 'CONSIDER SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES,
WHETHER IT BE THREE (3) IN A ROW OR WHATEVER THERE ARE
SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES.'" SECONDED BY VICE CHAIRMAN
FERNANDEZ. DISCUSSION.
t' J.. .
cn'Y OF WINTER SPRrNGS
MINUTES
PLANNING & ZONING BOARDfLOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING - JUNE 27. 2001
PAGE 6 OF 7
VOTE: (ON THE AMENDMENT)
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
VOTE: (ON THE MAIN MOTION)
BOARD MEMBER BROWN: AYE
VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ: AYE
CHAIRPERSON KARR: AYE
BOARD MEMBER STEPHENS: AYE
BOARD MEMBER GREGORY: AYE
MOTION CARRIED.
. EAR
. LDR
ill. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
· Swearing In Of Board Members
· Election of Officers
The Board agreed that it was not necessary that City Commission Agenda Items be
prepared for them. Vice Chairperson Fernandez said "Not a copy of every Agenda Item.
Just those applicants, - just the information that Staff was already going to give to the
City Commissioners about people who were interested in moving into - developing
businesses in Winter Springs. It was just that package plus annexations. That's just a
memo." Mr. Carrington replied, "That is totally different. Let's try that and see if that's
what you want."
v. ADJOURNMENT
MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN FERNANDEZ. "I MOVE TO ADJOURN."
SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER BROWN. DISCUSSION. WITH
CONSENSUS OF THE BOARD THE MOTION WAS APPROVED.
MOTION CARRIED.
Chairperson Karr adjourned the meeting at 9:44 p.m.
".. '.. ..
CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS
MINUI'ES
PLANNING & ZONING BOARDILOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
SPECIAL MEETING - JUNE 27. 2001
PAGE 70F7
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
DEBBIE GILLESPIE
DEPUTY CITY CLERK
APPROVED:
ROSANNE KARR, CHAIRPERSON
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARDILOCAL PLANNING AGENCY
Docs\ Word\BOARDS\PLANNING\aIlI\MINUTES\200 I \P&Z07260 I SPECIAL. doc
NOTE: These minutes were approved at the
. 200 I Planning And Zoning BoardILocaI Planning Agency Meeting.
f"'l ",1 ;.
ATTACHMENT C
Maps
..- -r - ...... -'. ':::::' -=: I . ~ r . c1 I c.: a. U I K 1 n 9
407 365 6927
P-02
/
!
\.
1]0/
~' o'
~ '<..
'....~.
IILOCIC 9
10.0
------
~----
\
\
I
\ l6....
\
\
\
---~-
\'~~ . /
\\ ~->- /
- / 2~.O / --~----::----. I
! ' <=--~::::~ ------ /
//r------.. ' ....,.,-.~:...--:'\r._-.-- -----.-.J J
~""'- ,.'/ ------.,------..
"--
f 26.C I ~--_____,
I ~"'- '.._____
lA
19
~ / ,I
.-.. ~- / /
-----~ ' /
24.0
.---
.IS' "CI1€ TR
--.
------..."--
--
-............-
---..
~
\J.O
<B
8L~ 8
A /
~/
/
/,:
OUT
$H... "N(( r R
/'
//
'"
",/" 1.0 /
//0 U-Y '0 /
./ /..< 1.0
// "',
-. .... , ,-( 1,\ "\ ,...
...... :1,,:: /:.//. ,'~'
," / .",./:.-: '.
9. .
,.
<
~ *~
s
; ~ <
. <-- ,.~".,
..., 0:.')
(... c......---
\(; C?,>)
fl site selectors
<D
'~'''.' .......
,.~
OBOO-OQUO
G-~
(0 ~~
:>- ~
<)l( <$) ~
1- <$l ~~
()
=~-'
-r-.
...
r:j
~-
7
8
8
.~
?
sri ______
~~
8.0
l!!ii~",",r'1111~1l~\~.. .
,.,'. .,,~ ,. ~... ,.'", ;.~i.~~~~;
MAP OF SURVEY
"BOUNDARY'
"""'-.. Al at the most Easterly corner of that part of blocK 'B' of a.R. MITCHELL'S
~of THE LEVY GRANT, as recorded in Plat BOOK 1, Page 5, in the office of the
"of Circuit Court of Seminole County, Florida. lying South and \lest of the paved road
"ding from Sanford to Oviedo: thence along the Southwesterly side of the paved road
~rth 3B degrees 45 minutes \lest 15B6.00 feet to a concrete monument for a point
~f beginning: thence continuing North 3B degrees 45 minutes \lest 200.00: thence
South 51 degrees 15 minutes \lest 291.30 feet to the Southeasterly side of a dirt road:
thence South 22 degrees 15 lllinutes East 20B. 80 feet: thence North 51 degrees 15 minutes
East 351.10 feet to the point of beginning.
F.I.R.C.J.....
1001 ~
HJ8'44'a4"1I ----- "-
184.09' I1iJ
~
.~~
'?JO. "
.... tOO;
'l,0; ~ .
.~ 'z;
_l'I .~
.Q",:,~
....~~~
~~"'....'z;
~~
1
p.
\$>\
...0 .~
.... ...&.
~~ to.
.~ ~?)
,,0 .~
." ~
.~ .'l,
.~ 0
,,,'" .~
""',p'"
~
N
SCALE
1. - 60'
\
y toOrES:
,ArNGS SH:lt/N 1ERE0H IJ'IE lIAS€D OH
lIGHT-{)f"-IIAY /UP PROVIDED OY TlE a.IENT.
, IESTER-Y RIGHT-CJF~AY LIHf! IS S38 ..." JOOE
os SHJ>IN IEREClH IEllE" NOT ABSmACTED
/ EASEHEHra. RIOHT-CJF-WAYS. Ofl AOJOINERS
RECtro.
. LAM) OESCRIPTON HEREON IS 111 ACCXRJ 111m
: IHST1U'ENT OF RECOIn IoH1 WAS PROVIDED
nE a.IEHT. OFFICIAL ~COAllS IJOOI( 1287 PAGe a3<!2
.] ~~ ~ 2'ff E. .JCHISTOH'S 6W1'EY
, II<PfIOVEJEJml NOT SlOtH SY 0I'l0E1t OF a.IEHT
~ l1Tl..rTlfS. FOtHJATlOHS. OR OT161
IUC~ ItE1lf:' NOT LOCATED BY mIS 6WvEY.
C ~Y CEIlTlFY THAT' TIE'jWJ 'tJF'6WVEY smtIH.
HEREOH CS III Ac;calOAHCl:'WIm TlIE"TECHlICAL" .
OTANOAIVS All" SET FORm lI1'" TIE IIOAllO OF. "
PROFES5IOHAL LAHl 6WvEYDRS III aiAPTER 01017-fl.
FlORIDA AONIIIISTt;RT CODE. pURSUAHT TO SECTlClH
472.027. FlORIDA S.
EDWARD J. H O' JR. NO. 3376
FLORIDA flEorsTERfD LAHl 8\.ffi'l:"YOR ANO w.PPf1I, NOT
VAlID wcnVUT mE SCGHATUlE , T/€ OflISCHAL RACSED
SEAl. OF A FLORIDA LICfNSfD StJIVEYOR IoH1 IUJ'PE}!.
:;...
r:
_ Ft;'UC C(YCAETE ~Hr
".c. - Fou<J ,new AX) AHJ c>>t
II. - F(JV4J tFWJttl ItOO
_ flHIStEO FlOCJ'l nEVArlCW
,..c. - 6E'r lf04 RXl AHJ CAP
c.o - FfV'(J ",A.lL AI<) OISl<
_ '10.0 ,*,A~"r
_ =a.u lED ,*,A6lA:KHT
C,"'. - ~rc ~T
P. r. - pOUlT OF UHOOCt'
P,C. - POINr oF CUlvATtJlE
U.E. - Urlfl."" r"'~:.Hr
O.E. - eMf"'''' €A9E>O'
C , a - CUlll , aurrm
"IV - AI",r t:F NAr
t - aJ<rm.l~
A
"./
./C
.
l
H, r."
""
(r.
_ onu CWl uwrlW.. IJG...E.
_ 1'01HT ~ IH~CTlOH
_ AlA C~UIOHIHO LMIT
- AJ,OI~
- UlC lI',,", rn
- Mll fa SCAlE
- mcPOSED
- EtlllTlNO
'01
ClIO
~
f{1
C<ltc.
(ASE.
COR
- Ff)Cti
- ClEAR
- ,O<XJ
- fUl
- nt"V..."C)llf
-~(
- €A g;A<!(l
- W\'EII
""
U
- I'fO'OSEO
- UUllJ<C
- Fl.DII LlIE
IEPJ.RJ. nON OJ.TE
FRANKLIN, MIZO,
CIVIL ENCINEERS - LAND SURVEYORS
1360 EASr VINE SrIlEU. KrSSIHHEE. FL 34144
PIIONE 046-/2/6 FAX 046-0037
r.m[rFICHE /10. UJ 6GO~
Pl.A"
WIT O.1/OVol
.......
"-.
ATTACHMENT D
8/22/01 Letter
~8/23/2001 15:13 407-331-3187
FL SITE SELECTORS
PAGE alien
F
SELECTO
...~..
August 22, 2001,
Mr. John Baker
City of W'mter Springs
Planning Coordinator
Via: FAX
Dear Mr. Baker,
In response to your request regarding the Wlnte; Springs Automotive facility, I offer you
the following description.
Winte,. SprinK$ Automotive will be a five bay light repair shop with three bays for sman
automobile repairs and two bays for express lube, It will be open to the general public of
Winter Springs and the surrounding neighborhoods.
Only cars needing to be towed in for urinor repairs will be dropped off at this location.
Any cars needing major engine work or wrecked cars will not be dropped off nor worked
on in this facility.
There wiD be no retail sales of automotive parts in this facility.
I have talked to Mr. Joe Miranda and am writing this to you at his request and to state his
given intentions as to this facility.
Sincerely,
i~/~~
(
Ronald L. Wllson, REALTOR
for Mr. Ioe Miranda, owner of the property and the new facility
(407) 331-3696 · FAX (407) 331-3187
A REAL ESTATJ: BROKERAGE &: DEVELOPMENT co.
116 E. Altamonte Drhe · Suite 210 · AJtamonte SprJngs. Florida 32701