Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009 06 08 Public Hearing 502 Request for Conditional Use 115 West Tradewinds RoadCITY COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM 502 Consent Informational Public Hearing X Regular June 8, 2009 .MGR. ~ ~~ /DEPT. Meeting REQUEST: The Community Development Department recommends the City Commission hear a request for a Conditional Use within the City of Winter Springs RC-I zoning District (Residential Rural FLU designation), to allow expansion (doubling the area) of an existing approximately 530 square foot detached accessory structure (private garage) on approximately 1.14 acres at 115 West Tradewinds Road. PURPOSE: The purpose of this agenda item is to consider the appropriateness of the proposed detached accessory structure (expansion of the existing structure to an approximately 1,060 SF private garage), pursuant to the criteria set forth in Section 6-84 of the City Code of Ordinances. Section 6-84 allows a maximum of 2 detached accessory structures and a maximum size of 240 SF each. Detached garages may exceed 240 square feet, but may not exceed one third the area of the air conditioned space of the principal structure. However, for those properties within the Residential Rural Future Land Use (FLU) designation, a conditional use may authorize variation of the number, height, and size requirements, subject to the specific criteria in Subsection 6-84 (3). FUTURE LAND USE & ZONING DESIGNATION: FLU Rural Residential Zoning RC-I APPLICABLE LAW AND PUBLIC POLICY: Cht. 6, Sec. 6-84. Accessory buildings. Cht. 9, Sec. 9-607. Residential compatibility and harmony regulations. Cht. 20, Sec. 20-1. Definitions. Cht. 20, Sec. 20-33. Conditional Uses. Cht. 20, Div. 3: RC-I Single-Family Dwelling District. (Sec. 20-141 thru 20-147). June 8, 2009 Public Hearing 502 Page 2 of 5 CONSIDERATIONS: The applicant, Todd Fante, has an existing home (3,298 SF of total area/2,121 SF living area built in 1985) and an existing 530 SF (26' 2" x 20' 3") detached accessory structure on approximately 1.14 acres at 115 West Tradewinds Road. The applicant proposes to extend the existing structure toward the front of the lot, doubling its area, but maintaining the same design and the same appearance from the road. The site is located within the "Ranchlands" portion of the City (Oak Hill Estates, Lot 3), an area with relatively large lots. It has a Rural Residential Future Land Use designation and is located within the RC-I zoning district. The applicable building setbacks are as follows: front - 50', side - 20', and rear 35'. The maximum building height allowed is 35' and the maximum lot coverage is 20 percent. The site is more than 340 feet deep, more than 138 feet wide, and backs up to a tall masonry wall that demarcates the Winter Springs/Casselberry municipal boundary. The Legacy Park subdivision, in the City of Casselberry, is located on the other side of the masonry wall. The proposed detached private garage is approximately 1,060 SF (40' 6" x 26' 2") and will be located at least 15 feet from the side property boundary and at least 14 feet from the rear property boundary, consistent with the existing structure. The private garage is proposed to be consistent with the existing portion and no taller than the primary structure. The applicant must provide evidence that the proposed structure meets the criteria set forth in Subsection 6-84 (3) of the City Code as well as the conditional use criteria in Section 20-33. The attached application package includes the applicant's responses to the Section 20-33 criteria, letters of support from neighbors, renderings of the proposed structure, a copy of the Oak Hill Estates final subdivision plat and the plot plan of the subject lot (with the existing structures). FINDINGS: 1. The request is consistent with all applicable goals, objectives and policies of the City's adopted Comprehensive Plan. 2. The site has a Residential Rural FLU designation and is located within the RC-I zoning district. 3. The applicant has submitted a plot plan and states that the proposed addition will be architecturally similar to the existing portion of the building. S:\dept -Community Development\Planning\2009\Commission\2009 06 08 COMM PH 502 Fante Garage CU.doc June 8, 2009 Public Hearing 502 Page 3 of 5 4. The request is in conformance with the purpose and intent of Subsection 6-84 (f) (3)of the City Code, and with applicable requirements, below, except as noted -the building setbacks: a. The proposed accessory building is compatible and harmonious with the principal structure and the surrounding land uses and structures. The finish, height, and roof of the structure are planned for consistency with the existing structure. The applicant must further demonstrate this as part of the Section 9-607 aesthetic review, before a building permit may be issued b. The proposed accessory building will not adversely impact land use activities in the immediate vicinity. Staff believes that the proposed private garage will not adversely affect surrounding land use activities. c. The height of the proposed accessory building does not exceed the height of the principal structure. The applicant states that the proposed structure will have an overall height less than or equal to the height of the house. d. The accessory building shall meet the requirements of the applicable zoning district including setback and maximum lot coverage. The application meets these requirements -with the exception of the building setbacks. A separate setback waiver is requested to allow the building to be extended forward in the most logical manner. The applicant must demonstrate these outstanding Section 6-84 requirements for staff to recommend approval. 5. Pursuant to Section 20-33 of the City Code, "all conditional use recommendations and final decisions shall be based on the following criteria to the extent applicable: a)Whether the applicant has demonstrated the conditional use, including its proposed scale and intensity, traffic-generated characteristics, and off-site impacts, is compatible and harmonious with adjacent land uses, and will not adversely impact land use activities in the immediate vicinity." Staff believes the private garage at this location will not have a negative impact and will be compatible and harmonious, pursuant to Subsection 6-84 (f)(3), above. Staff supports the building setback waiver in this situation. S:\dept -Community Development\Planning\2009\Commission\2009 06 08 COMM PH 502 Fante Garage CU.doc June 8, 2009 Public Hearing 502 Page 4 of 5 b)"Whether the applicant has demonstrated the size and shape of the site, the proposed access and internal circulation, and the design enhancements to be adequate to accommodate the proposed scale and intensity of the conditional use requested. The site shall be of sufficient size to accommodate design amenities such as screening, buffers, landscaping, open space, off-street parking, and similar site plan improvements needed to mitigate against potential adverse impacts of the proposed use." Staff believes that the size and shape of the site can accommodate a combination of the existing home and the detached accessory structure. c)"Whether the proposed use will have an adverse impact on the local economy, including governmental fiscal impact, employment, and property values." Staff believes that this proposed use will have a positive impact on the local economy, employment, and property values. d)"Whether the proposed use will have an adverse impact on the natural environment, including air, water, and noise pollution, vegetation and wildlife, open space, noxious and desirable vegetation, and flood hazards." Staff believes that the proposed use will not have an adverse impact on the natural environment. e)"Whether the proposed use will have an adverse impact on historic, scenic, and cultural resources, including views and vistas, and loss or degradation of cultural and historic resources." Staff does not believe that the proposed use will have or create any of these adverse impacts. f)"Whether the proposed use will have an adverse impact on public services, including water, sewer, surface water management, police, fire, parks and recreation, streets, public transportation, marina and waterways, and bicycle and pedestrian facilities." S:\dept -Community Development\Planning\2009\Commission\2009 06 08 COMM PH 502 Fante Garage CU.doc June 8, 2009 Public Hearing 502 Page 5 of 5 Staff does not believe that the proposed use will have or create any of these adverse impacts. g)"Whether the proposed use will have an adverse impact on housing and social conditions, including variety of housing unit types and prices, and neighborhood quality." Staff does not believe that the proposed use will have or create any of these adverse impacts. 6. The applicant has provided documentation from the neighbors that they do not object to the proposed garage addition. BOA ACTION: At a special meeting on May 21, 2009, the BOA voted unanimously to recommend the conditional use request be approved, subject to approval of the associated building setback waiver. RECOMMENDATION: The BOA and staff recommend that the City Commission approve the conditional use request for the detached private garage addition at 115 West Tradewinds Road, subject to also receiving the building setback waiver. ATTACHMENTS: A. Location Map & Plat B. Section 6-84 C. Application package D. Draft BOA Minutes COMMISSION ACTION: S:\dept -Community Development\Planning\2009\Commission\2009 06 08 COMM PH 502 Fante Garage CU.doc ATTACHMENT A .. - -"... I _ v 16(1 249 ....., ~ .... . 195 ~ ~ . ` l40 150 .. , 175 ~ /8S 383 l3(1 ,. - ' 165 ...... I55 .... ,... ... I20 ~, .... l4~ '. .., . .~,~~ 13~ 199 .. ~ , X ' ~ H ~ ~ 4an J 4(/. 405 ' ~? 200 !, .. , ~. .... , ...... ; ~ 11(1 `............ • ...__.,._ , 3 ~ 170 " a14 . _..„ ~ , 160 ~. 150 ' ... _._ F . , _... - _.. .. l l30 ~ .."..,. !2(1 ___ ._..~ 201 11(1 .. ; ..," .. ........ .... ..4 . -...__- 135 ` •. ,S(15 .. 125 ..~ 500? ... ......._ _......... . ~ .. 115 ': ... _. /(1/ s ri ~/" ~ ry vs s/o `~ ~ E ~ -' ".. . . . ~ a `; .._ _ ~L :- _ ; a c 520 ~ -• ~ o a .. ~ '. ., 5l (1 U U` D ~~ 515 53a ~ !8(1 _. ` 16(l 170 , - 19 l2(1 .. 1 ' l30 765 175 ... .. 0(EAST) ~~~~.... ~"~ . •': ~` 185 :RANCH?. -- ..._,~ `° - I1 :_ 110 IYESTf" . _ . I55 ., Y,.. ~ i I45 ~. ~_ •., "~ 135 ': LANDS . `~P R K ,.. ._ C _ - - _....~. 1 ~5 .. .. •.. A ~~ 135 ;. _ .._ .. I_ ~ '~ 175 ~ 1 / 5 (II'ESTI ~-. ~' B r;~ / ,~ ' `~ ~°` i ~ `•~ ~~ P Southern Boundary ~ I N 1 • 2 • 3 • 4 • 5 • 6 • 7 • 8 Municipal Address Map Book D PRINTED: REVISED: ~ s~ 2 o K r `~ LJ fit.; d~'o 7 0 ~~ '3V d~'.~ ~~o ~~ 450 ~ Feel ~3~g ~S~ ~ 3q X gy ~(~Jl~~a 'N 3~ ,,~n.~- -t~ OAK Hl L L ESTATES SECTION lO, TOWNSHIP 2/ SOUTH, RANGE 30 EAST CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, SEM/HOLE COUNTY, FLORIDA OESCR/PT(ON Col 9, Block B, NORTH ORL A400 RANCHES SEC 1, acts rd my to the Plat thereo/ as retarded rn Pl of Boak 12, page 3, of the Public Records a/ Semrno le Lounl y, Florvda mesa ~ 116mw ~ R~ ~~~~ CITY O~ YVINT~R SPRINGS i~armittlnq - Ghri.sly &ss4~F~~ J i rgESb9< ~%,v~\ 04• 2E0? ~.$' BRr a~;a 'go.ao _' J L-- sicG cu+c ~e>'e°~o~-~~~0951'5r`E. Pa~ A. 'o .r3•r!. ON ____ n 5 B.. arTPW ~ ~[ ,~ o wN y- /n L.r3~ a3' 0 iB~ OT 10196' 1 b v Pi e6 ~6 o• o* I ,` _ %'1'IHii~_r.c_ .`.f ~. W C" ..~ ~r. ti~ f'~. r , u. 4- ~ W ~ T m 3 ~,' -.V ;r.~f. .. m WI O o ~ ~ bh u' O „ m a m ~~ w'~3 n •O a o a ~^ ~ ~ O ,- O ~ Z } I ~ a ° q ~ 2 3 4 A' v 2 i '~ o 2 __ 1' 11969'_ r ___i3B.49 ~'__ _ _ _J COCATlON MAP I i i I M/ ROIO ~ ~ B~M t y m 5. Q V = a W/NTE t $PR/N6$ I NI RI OI ~{ J . ~ ' SEC S C P S Lv ' ~~~ .n E W ./O 2 r~.DSt Ro. s w Z I ~+' srre Q ~ ei -L .. - z~_.J `e LJD CI SSEL E~I e t~' L =`a• -- 'i TOWNSN/ I 2/ SOUTH 5.89'02'46"W 500.55' Tii: ~ v Y t:+.4:: ;YT NOTES • PERHINENT REFERENCE MONUMENT / F R M,J BEAR/N65 B/$EO ON PLIT OF NONTN ORL ANOO gANCNES SEC.1 Pp r2 PBr. 3 BR6. 3 LINE GOT9 B<M O, BE/N6 5. B9'02'i6'sY 5C4CE~/' GRAPH $C. aL~ 00' 1C PLAT BOOK 3/ PAGE /9 DEDICATION KNOW ALC NEN RY THESE P6ESEl1T5, that CARLOS REYI ERA, bei nj the owner o! the lands described hereon, does hereby dedico}a said lands and Plat for the uses and Purposes thereon eepressed and to be known or OAK HILL ESTATES and inW~1iNE55 Tf£ EO nf(is his hand and seal ihrssaZ~iday of 1984. T'f iNE55 B CARLOS REVIERA ACKNOWLEDGEMEN STATE OF FLORIDA l COUNTY OF SEMIHOLE 7N15 15 i0 CER7I FY, Ihof be tare e, on duty auf hori zed fa Coke ocknowledgemert/ REVIERA. whose signature appears above cute the lp regoinB dedreot ion as a Tree deed. IN WI iNE55 THEREOF, I hove beret hand and .teal this~paY oI cfl7.,. ~. 1984.. ~ _ "t~~ Hy Commi ssr on Expires: ~i'd-•~+. .~ ~, ~~ _ CERT/F/CATIONS NORTfi rY+EE hereby consents to the Plolfiny of the lands hereon d<scr Poed and agrees in eel of Inreclosure the dedication above shallvremain fully a//eclive. I~!IESS~ -_ 7_ MARGARET MOWER This is to cerlily that o S rv, al the lands described hereon w mod• my direc- tion and the Plnf a shorn is correct representation of the one on ilh the requirements of CHAPTER 177, ~s. STATF. OF FLORIDA Registered land 653 This 3~r~doy of -TO ~~ GIN OF KINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA l-i App rored =) ~, / ~ y.-Y-~.4~ Roror At lest ~~, 7Zr~e.~~ Clerk This /7.U day of ~~ s~~~q 4' ,( '.a~~~y . t~• CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Correct as la Statutory compliance and li led for record So lard, Flon do, afM{g[N rlhrs /7 daY nfr(lLV7r1-rc~ 1984. HR of the LIRLU I7, SENINOLE COURT V KELLY SMITH REfiISTEREO LANG SURVEYOR NO 165.1 1807 French Ave Son lord, Fla 305/322-2213 ARTICLE III. BUILDING CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS* Page 2 of 5 ATTACHMENT B engineer or architect currently registered to do business in the state. Such certification shall be to the effect that a structural analysis has been made of the building and such building can safely support the specific antenna with a minimum wind loading of one hundred (100) miles per hour. (3) Television dish antennas or satellite antennas shall not be installed in front of the front line of any residential, commercial, or industrial building. (4) Television dish antennas or satellite antennas may only be installed in side yards or back yards of any building. (5) No portion of any antenna or support structure shall be closer than five (5) feet from any property line. (6) Television dish antennas or satellite antennas shall not be located on any public way, easement, or parkway. (7) Television dish antennas or satellite antennas shall not be installed in any designated parking area of any building. (8) Mobile mounted television dish antenna or satellite antenna structure shall comply with all requirements (1) through (7) above. (b) Apartment and condominium buildings. Apartment or condominium buildings above three (3) stories in height shall be treated as commercial structures for the purpose of these regulations for television dish antenna or satellite antennas. (c) Height restriction. The installation of any television dish antenna or satellite antenna shall not exceed the height restriction set forth in the zoning ordinance for that location. (Code 1974, § 5-9) Sec. 6-84. Accessory buildings. (a) General. Accessory building means a detached, subordinate structure, the use of which is clearly incidental to, customarily associated with, and related to the principal structure or use of the land, and which is located on the same lot as the principal structure or use. Accessory buildings shall include storage buildings, toolhouses, private, detached garages, bathhouses (used in conjunction with swimming pool) and similar uses. No more than two (2) accessory buildings shall be allowed on any single lot. Accessory buildings shall not be used as living quarters, except that private, detached, private garages may be used as living quarters or office space where permitted in the Town Center and R-3 zoning districts and subject to all applicable permitting requirements for such use. (b) Height and size restrictions. The maximum height of an accessory building shall be twelve (12) feet measured from ground level. The maximum size of any structure shall be two hundred forty (240) square feet. Notwithstanding the restrictions set forth in this subsection, detached, private garages may exceed twelve (12) feet in height without city commission approval provided the city manager or designee thereof determines that each criteria in subsection (f)(3) herein is satisfied. Further, detached, private garages may exceed two hundred forty (240) square feet, but in no case shall exceed one-third (1/3) of the air-conditioned square footage area of the principle structure. (c) Location. All accessory buildings shall be located to the rear of the existing buildings line. (d) Permits. A building permit shall be required before construction or placement can take place. No accessory building shall be permitted prior to construction of the principal building. (e) Setback requirements. When an accessory building is attached to a principal structure by a breezeway, passage or otherwise, it shall become a part of the principal structure and shall be http://library8.municode.com/default-testlDocView/ 12019/ 1 /37/40 5/29/2009 ARTICLE III. BUILDING CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS* Page 3 of 5 subject to the required setbacks of the principal structure. (1) Corner setback--On all corner lots the minimum open sideyard setback shall be that of the principal building. (2) Rear yard setback--Shall be a minimum of six (6) feet. (3) Side yard setback--Shall be that of the lot on which the building is to be located (4) Easements--If an easement on the lot where the building is to be located is greater than that addressed above, then the easement size shall prevail. No building shall be constructed or placed on an easement. (5) Detached, private garages which exceed twelve (12) feet in height or two hundred forty (240) square feet in area must meet the setbacks of the applicable zoning district for the principle structure. (f) Upon application filed with the city, the city commission may vary the number, height, and size requirements set forth in this section or approve an accessory building on an adjacent lot by conditional use permit under the following conditions: (1) The subject property has a residential rural future land use map designation under the city's comprehensive plan. (2) The applicant submits for review and consideration a detailed architectural rendering of the proposed accessory building and a plot plan drawn to scale. (3) The city commission finds that: a. The proposed accessory building is compatible and harmonious with the principal structure and the surrounding land uses and structures; b. The proposed accessory building will not adversely impact land use activities in the immediate vicinity; c. The height of the proposed accessory building does not exceed the height of the principal structure; and d. The accessory building shall meet the requirements of the applicable zoning district including setback and maximum lot coverage. (4) An accessory building may be constructed on a lot adjacent to the lot on which the principal building is located under the following conditions: a. The conditions set forth in subsections (1), (2), and (3) are satisfied. b. A legal instrument reasonably acceptable to the city is recorded in the public records of Seminole County that provides that the principal building lot and the adjacent lot are unified under common ownership and that in the event said ownership is ever separated, the accessory building shall be removed or a principal building shall be constructed on the adjacent lot within one (1) year from the date the lots are separated. (Code 1974, § 5-10; Ord. No. 460, § 1, 6-26-89; Ord. No. 2003-02, § 2, 4-28-03; Ord. No. 2008-05, § 2, 6-9-08) Sec. 6-85. Screen enclosures. (a) Defrnition. For purposes of this section, the term "screen enclosure" shall mean an enclosure consisting entirely of screen mesh, except for minimum essential structural framework required for its support. http://library8.municode.com/default-test/DocView/12019/1/37/40 5/29/2009 ZONING DIVISION 3. R-CI SINGLE-FAMII.Y DWELLING DISTRICT Sec. 20-141. Designation. This classification is intended to apply to azeas designated R-CI within the city and shall be governed by the regulations and requirements set forth in this division. (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.9, 1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 2, 7-29-74) Sec. 20-142. Uses permitted. Within any R-CI Single-Family Dwelling Dis- tricts, no building, structure, Iand or water shall be used except for the following use: (1) Single-family dwellings and their custom- ary accessory uses. (2) Horses and ponies, allowing three-fourths of an acre per animal not to exceed ten (10) animals per lot; provided however, horses and ponies can be permitted on less than three-fourths of an acre upon recommendation by the board of adjust- ment. (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.10, 1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 3, 7-29-74) Sec. 20-143. Conditional uses. There shall be no conditional uses within the R-CI Single-Family Dwelling Districts, except the following: (1) Churches; (2) Schools; (3) Public recreational areas and facilities. (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.11, 1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 4, 7-29-74; Ord. No. 240, § 4, 5-26-81; Ord. No. 2004-49, § 2, 12-13-04) Sec. 20-I44. Building height regulations. In R-CI Single-Family Dwelling Districts, no building or structure shall exceed thirty-five (35) feet in height. (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.12,1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 5, 7-29-74) § 20-160 Sec. 20-145. Building area regulations. Each single-family dwelling shall be located on a lot or parcel of land not less than one (1) acre in size and such lot or pazcel of land shall have a minimum width of one hundred twenty (120) feet at the building line. (Ord. No. 44, § 44.27.13,1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 6, 7-29-74) Sec. 20-146. Front, rear and side yard regu- lations. The following yard regulations shall apply in the R-CI Single-Family Dwelling Districts: (1) Front yard. The front yard shall not be less than fifty (50) feet in depth. (2) Rear yard. The rear yazd shall not be less than thirty-five (35) feet in depth. (3) Side yard. The side yards shall not be less than twenty (20) feet on each side of the dwelling structure. (4) Corner Zots. On corner lots, the front yard setback of fifty (50) feet must be main- tained on each side of the lot. (5) Minimum floor area shall be one thou- sand six hundred (1,600) square feet (in- cluding utility room but excluding car- ports, gazages, breezeways, screened or open porches). (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.14,1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 7, 7-29-74) Sec. 20-147. Lot coverage. Twenty (20) percent of the lot area is the maximum which maybe covered by the principal and accessory buildings or structures located within R-CI. (Ord. No. 44, § 44.27.15,1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 8, 7-29-?4) Sec. 20-148. Off-street parking regulations. All parking within R-CI Single-Family Dwell- ing Districts shall be off-street parking. (Ord. No. 44, §44.27.16,1-8-68; Ord. No. 107, § 9, 7-29-74) Secs. 20.149-20.160. Reserved. Supp. No. 6 1327 ATTACHMENT C CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 1126 STATE ROAD 434 WINTER SPRINGS, FL 32708 Fl'ECEIVEC! 407-327-5966 ~ ~~ Z~ FAX:407-327-6695 G9TY 0.= K'7~EF3 SFF~i3y~ PAD' fty9l~f BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION ~ ~ CONDITIONAL USE /SPECIAL EXCEPTION VARIANCE ^ WAIVER APPLICANT: CuP ~oc~1 ~~. Last First Middle MAILING ADDRESS: ~~ 5r `~• ~~-Q'rQ~ w •~~ Ci State ,~ ,Zip Code PHONE & EMAIL 3~-1 33~ ~i 1 ~ ~' ~~7 7 ? lJ;nf~%~L~L ~ ~ ~- ~ `~+'"~ If Applicant does NOT own the property: PROPERTY OWNER: MAILING ADDRESS: PHONE & EMAIL This request is for the real property described below: PROPERTY ADDRESS: ~ ~ ~ Vt'~! l '6.-d~~l~ W ~~~~ ~~ TAX PARCEL NUMBER: ~, CJ - Z~ ' ~ C~' y ~ P ~ - Gtr (~~ _ G C.~_~ SIZE OF PARCEL: E ~~ Square Feet Acres EXISTING LAND USE: ~~~ Z i~ ~~ ~ ~L- Current FUTURE LAND USE Classification; ~ ~`^~_ Current ZONING Classification:-~'~ ~~ ` Please state YOUR REQUEST: \ C~ ~ ~y G' ~ ~ ~ ~~ - ~ l ~ ; Z~ ,~ ~ ~cST ~~ ~ : t- ~ ; `~ '~ ~ Maw zoos .., .,ww ...,, .,.,.._ The APPLICANT IS RESPONSIBLE for posting the blue notice card (provided by the City) on the site at least SEVEN (7} DAYS prior to the Board of Adjustment Meeting at which the matter will be considered. Said notice shall NOT be posted within the City right-of-way. All APPLICANTS shall be afforded minimal due process as required by law, including the right to receive notice, be heazd, present evidence, cross- examine witnesses, and be represented by a duly authorized representative. The CITY COMMISSION shall render all final decisions regazding variances, conditional uses and waivers and may impose reasonable conditions on any approved vaziance, conditional use or waiver to the extent deemed necessary and relevant to ensure compliance with applicable criteria and other applicable provisions of the City Code and Comprehensive Plan. All formal decisions shall be based on competent substantial evidence and the applicable criteria as set forth in Chapter 20, Zoning. APPLICANTS are advised that if, they decide to appeal any decisions made at the meetings or hearings with respect to any matter considered at the meetings or heazings, they will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purposes, they will need to insure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, at their cost, which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based, per 286.0105, Florida Statutes. Any CONDITIONAL USE, VARIANCE, or WAIVER which may be granted by the City Commission shall expire two (2) years after the effective date of such approval by the City Commission, unless a building permit based upon and incorporating the conditional use, variance, or waiver is issued by the City within said time period. Upon written request of the property owner, the City Commission may extend the expiration date, without public hearing, an additional six (6) months, provided the property owner demonstrates good cause for the extension In addition, if the aforementioned building permit is timely issued, and the building permit subsequently expires and the subject development project is abandoned or discontinued for a period of six months, the conditional use, variance or waiver shall be deemed expired and null and void. (Code of Ordinances, Section 20-36.) THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE TO BE SUPPLIED WITH THIS APPLICATION: ^ A copy of the most recent SURVEY of the subject property. ^ A copy of the LEGAL DESCRIPTION reflecting the property boundaries. ^ 11 x 17 MAP showing ADJACENT STREETS and ZONING AND LAND USE classifications on the ADJACENT PROPERTY. G~JUSTIFICATION for the Request (See Attached List) Crl' NAMES and ADDRESSES of each property owner within 150 ft. of each property line. ^ Notarized AUTHORIZATION of the Owner, IF the Applicant is other than the Owner or Attorney for the Owner (see below). ^ APPLICATION FEES: FEES are as SHOWN BELOW plus ACTUAL COSTS incurred for ADVERTISING or NOTIFICATION, and for REIMBURSEMENT for TECHNICAL and/or PROFESSIONAL SERVICES which may be required in connection with the review, inspection or approval of any development (based on accounting submitted by the City's Consultant) ,payable prior to approval of the pertinent stage of deve~ent. CONDITIONAL USE /SPECIAL EXCEPTION WAIVER $ 500 VARIANCE $ 500 TOTAL DUE $ SCi<% r~r, 2oos By submitting this application you hereby grant temporary right of entry for city officials to enter upon the subject property for purposes of evaluating this application. FOR USE WHEN APPLICANT !S OWNER OF 7HE SUBJECT REAL PROPERTY: This is to certify that I am the Owner in fee Board of Adju nt consideration: Siena of Owner of subject lands described within this Application for Swom to and subscribed before me this day of 0 ' ~ 20Q~. Personally Known Produced Identification: (Type) Did take an Oath Did Not take and Oath ..~G~-1~.f'k.~ /~ ~-C.Q.-~ Notary Public My Commission expires: •.•5,~.. TAMMY J. Bl1CHAN ~:__ MY COMMISSION N DD 585327 ~~~~ EXPIRES: July 28, 2010 '~ pF ~~d:+ Borded Tluu Notary PuECic Undervnhars FOR USE WHEN APPLICANT IS NOT OWNER OF THE SUBJECT REAL PROPERTY: I, do hereby, with my notarized signature, allow to represent me in this Application related to my property. The property is identified as: Tax Parcel Number(s) Located at Signature of Owner(s) Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of 20 Personally Known Produced ID: (Type) _ Did take an Oath Did Not take and Oath Notary Public My Commission expires: ******s**~*>«****~**~*****~******~**********~***************+*~**~**+***~*+******>k***** March 2005 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST Taken from Winter Springs Code of Ordinances, Section 20-33(d): All Conditional Use recommendations and final decisions shall be based on the following criteria to the extent applicable. Attach additional paper as necessary: ^ What is the Conditional Use you are requesting? ~ ~ ~ ~~'~? - ~~- ^ How is the Conditional Use (including its proposed scale and intensity, traffic- generating characteristics, and offsite impacts) compatible and harmonious with adjacent land uses? -~'~ iS : ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ w:l-(.. 13~ z' ~~ e~ t.~f ~" ~a ly 4,~ ~ i S i~ ~ ~~ar0= -~ ~ ~C- o ^ Will the Conditional Use adversely impact land use activities in the immediate vicinity? If no, why not? _ ~ ~s ~ ~= z~«c ~A~i~ ~{p„~7 / ~,~L~~ Sao Sc~ ~ fi; ^ Demonstrate how the size and shape of the site, the proposed access and internal circulation, and the design enhancements are adequate to accommodate the proposed scale and intensity of the conditional use requested. The site shall be of sufficient size to accommodate design amenities such as screening buffers, landscaping, open space, off-street parking, and other similar site plan improvements needed to mitigate against potential adverse impacts of the proposed use. iT ~ ~ ~~Yl.~ ~a~-~~~1 ~' M~.~e ~'~c- v2l~f,~~r[. ~e-~~~ ~~ F~ r,~ zoos ^ Will the proposed use have an adverse impact on the local economy, including governmental fiscal impact, employment, and property values? If no, why not? ~o, f T~5 A P~~~~~ ~~~-- ^ Will the proposed use have an adverse impact on natural environment, including air, water, and noise pollution, vegetation and wildlife, open space, noxious and desirable vegetation, and flood hazards? If no, why not? ~~~~ ~WF-~ '~hlt~~~ a t /~- t'~ A~-uiA+C~ tS ~~~ (rte a ^ WII the proposed use have an adverse impact on historic, scenic and cultural resources, including views and vistas, and loss or degradation, of cultural and historic resources? If no, why not? ts~, ALL ~~~~z ~~ ~-~- ~~-~-° ~+~'~ 1 r~ ~l-~ ,s ~ ~f 0 ~ . ^ Will the proposed use have an adverse impact on public services, including water, sewer, surface water management, police, fire, parks and recreation, streets, public transportation, marina and waterways, and bicycle and pedestrian facilities? If no, why not? N'-~~ i ~' t=~ <~ ~ ~~a'~'-'>''~0~~d ^ Will the proposed use have an adverse impact on housing and social conditions, including a variety of housing unit types and prices, and neighborhood quality? If no, why not? _ ~ ~5 P ti ~~~ ~«-~ Ta r~ C' a f~--~ Mazch 2005 t4 . ~. .~,~ ~ ~' ,,,,,,e . ~„~-m,-;-:.~ ~:..~.,~", ..,... ,;,.,., :~-,e.. '~.,..,.r ~*.-,.. ...."-,,.~-, .~-....,t rl-I,' ~ T f r~-r f, .-f' TO Waymont Court • Lake Mary, FL 32746 • Voice 407.688.7631 • Fax 407.688.7691 Lot 3, OAK HILL ESTATES, according to the ptat tnereo~ as recorded in Plat Book 31, Page(sJ 19, of the Public Records of Seminole County, FL. Community number: 110195 Panel: 0170 Sujf-x: F F.I.R:M. Date: 4/17/1995 Flood Zone: X Date ojfield work: 1/!3/1008 Completion Dale: 1/14/1008 ~. TR4D ta~,.,,,m) ,~ ' ~ , EW/NOSROgp Certifred to: 50')q/yy Todd Fante; Jennifer Fante; Equitable Title ojSeminole County, LLC; cR.r/2• _ -~ - -~ _ ~ _ ~ Lawyers Title Insurance Corporation; The Money Source, Inc., its' rLR.I/2- b successors and/or assigns. ~E C E I V E D N ~ ~~R 0 6 2Q09 F.I.R.I/1 _ : CITY OF NAT R.SPRINGS Perm P Cl ,oE ~ I • •ebae ~ ~ i ~ I I 'r~.4o J L-_ ~ SO R//W _ h ~m N Oi ~V1 ,L~C.J k~ NlJR:r U to 8 • , ~ •L• rnu i3 g: I o ni^i t ° Z 4 ~ 7. ~N LOCATION SKETCH OT 2 LOT 4 IvPL 1P s~Pre . - •} -• 7.J• .7.5.78 ~ :T28•y~ JJ. ' .. p ~ ; 21.9• 4P o4i q SJ• /SJ' o 'b ;; a /175 IJY ~~ ~I8.7 ~~ SGP£LNEP ENq ° ~ TREE C-I (P.J C-2 (P.) trIJ79'04' M477{7' w/ POL e N ~ ~ R=58fl 9Y R=J8fl 9Y ' t L=1]215 L-44.]2' a C=1]1.95' C-H.JI• CB=580Z224T C9=57178.59 E W d=IJ79'IY d=478.49~ R=58fl9Y R=38fl9Y 28.2• L=IJZJI' L-44.49• C=1J2P2• C=14. SB' o LOT3 a ~-seP71iME ~=571 :T2•.I•F 4 P.S. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 0.J. 4 ._ .P• f4'U.E 4J• fD. NAB. ~ r1R.l/2• av oAlr me[ 589172'46 ~W 138.49' P. ' ' ' Property Address: w 138.51 M. 589 06 JO 115 West Tradewinds Road C ~ S S ~ L 8 ~ ~ ~ ~~ Winter Springs, FL 31708 °'PRr nle ~ ceA~`R~ Survey number: SL 95357 P.B. I P4 3 SEND GENERAL NOTES - Wood Fence M W Water Mehr N.T.S. Not to Scale i. legal descdption provided 67 others. 12. FLOOD ZONE DETERMINAT10N5 ARE - Wire Fence . . TEL TNephone Fxilities O.R. Offidal Records 2. The lands shown hereon were not PROVIDED AS A COURTESY ONLY, AND Chain Unk Fence fL9 Covered Area O.R.B. Offidal Records Baok absVacfed for easements or other record- ARE DERIVED FROM THE BEST SOU1165 Fourd Nail B R Bearing Reference P.C.P. Permanent Control Point ed encrrmbranas not shown on the plat. AVAILABLE TO THE SURVEYOR. THIS C Concrete . . CH Chord P.R.M. Permanent Reference Monumerrt 3. Underground portions of footings, four- INFORMATON SHOULD NOT BE FxW Meawred MD Radial PG. Page lotions or other improvements were not REUED UPON FOR FLOOD INSURANCE Clear P/C Air Conditioner PVM7. Pavement located. PURPOSES, AND MAY DIFFER FAOM t Encroachment B M Bendr Mark E.O.P. Edge of Pavemerrt q. WaB ties are to the face of the waR. INFDRMATON PROVIDED BY OTHERS. Centerrine . . C Calculated P.B Plat Book 5. Only visible enooachments located. 13. Septic tank andror drainfKld kxations are Concrete . ZZ72 Bksds Wall P.O.B. Poim of Beginning 6. No identification found on property approximate and MUST be verified by Property Line Q Central AngldDelta P.O.C. Paint of Commmcemerlt corners unless noted. appropriate utility bcadon companies. Concrete Monument D.B. Deed Book P.O.L Poin[ on Line 7, Dimensions shaven are plat and measured 14. Bearing kasiz shown per plat unless Found InOn Rod D. Description or Deed P.C. Point of Curvature unless otherwise mted. otherwise shown. Found Iron Pipe D.H. DrIII Hole P.RC. Point of Reverse Curvature Elevatiom if shown are based upon 15. Survey is for ren only unless g Right of Way D/VJ Drivewry P.T. Point of Tangency . N.G.V.D. 1929 unless othervse noted. signed and seal a F Registered Nall & Disk ESM7 Easement R. Radius (Radiaq Adjoining b6 are within the carne block ~^d S yon. g ' Drainage Easement EL Elevation R.O.E Root Overhang Easement . unless otherwbe noted. 16 fin s a e [ ra, le unl the lRiliry EasenKnl F.E Finished floor 5.1.0. Set Iron Rod g Cap Thh rs a BOUNDARY SURVEY unless ^ t 70 Found FC.M. Found Concrete Monument S^N Sidewalk . otherwise noted 8. R c tific io doe not w[ an Pkt RP.K Found Parker-Kahn NaN T0.8. lap of Bank 11. Not valid unless sealed with the signing u J. Overhead UolRies L Length TYR TYPid surveyors embasud seal. Power Pole LB. Licensed Businea W.C. Whness Corner r hrreby ceniy r>rr rna awvey e a rive and cwrea or. dveceon. Transformer LA.E UmRed Access Easerent 10.05 Existing Elevation _ LB. 7132 ! r Cahk Riser -~- Line Break Not to Scale E.O.W. Edge of Water 1 ' Chord Bearing M.H. Manhole P.C.C. Point of Compound Curve ~`_y,~ Found Gros Cut O Found PI Point of Intersection ~ Ralph SwerdloH h SOrrera Na 3011 Flekl OHL Overhead Urres T.B.M. Temporary Bench Mark ~_ Loub R. Ramirez lesslmul Su,wyor aM Mapper N0. 6300 Seminole County Property Appraiser Get Information by Parcel Number Page 1 of 2 - -- --f --~ t.- --~ t~ ~3~ y 4.04A . . ~ ^< 1]avlD JoHlas~ei, CFA.ASA & f) 7 ^t5 $'Ajg ! 9 t H.A r tz t f A t a ~~-~` 3 ~ ' ~~+ QPF~T~ apPRA-[SEI~ Eh91NOLE C 1 1 . i ~-8.0 ~sF' ~i~ ~,y'<,~ ! ` ~ 8.A D , 2 7.A ~'~1~ f0 19 i L 3 y ? ~ . j .~ ~ S 6 IlYTY i- .. 'U 8 4.~-~ k'3 s'i ~~- D r_~ ' ~ I I01 E. FIasZST ~ ~ fd d7>~ r--^' f'Tiii9~ 1 t~ ~ i ~.,t'E ) _ srtearv7tU. Ft32371-f466 tj :T:A $ `~'!7 iLt ~1~ }'' i+d t8l EPd~ - 4Or7-665-750& ~ itS tc'!+ 15",~ '17~Y~Z '~' 'i'~1r y'4 {i~ E~ '~? ~, 7 i ~ id3 d °°:i. 3~-d] td ire ;~ i43.1v'8 t57.~~'7- 1 VALUE SUMMARY VALUES 2x09 2008 GENERAL Working Certified Parcel Id: 10-21-30-510-0000-0030 Value Method Cost/Market CosVMarket Owner: FANTE TODD B & JENNIFER L Number of Buildings 1 1 Mailing Address: 115 W TRADEWINDS RD Depreciated Bidg Value $179,158 $198,742 City,State,ZipCode: WINTER SPRINGS FL 32708 Depreciated EXFT Value $12,818 $13,375 Property Address: 115 TRADEWINDS RD W WINTER SPRINGS 32708 Land Value (Market) $92,150 $92,150 Subdivision Name: OAK HILL ESTATES Land Value Ag $0 $0 Tax District: W1-WINTER SPRINGS JusVMarket Value $284,126 $304,267 Exemptions: 00-HOMESTEAD (2009) Portablity Adj $0 $0 Dor: 01-SINGLE FAMILY Save Our Homes Adj $0 $0 Assessed Value (SOH) $284,126 $304,267 Tax Estimator 2009 TAXABLE VALUE WORKING ESTIMATE Taxing Authority Assessment Value Exempt Values Taxable Value County General Fund $284,126 $50,000 $234,126 Schools $284,126 $25,000 $259,126 City Winter Springs $264,126 $50,000 $234,126 Fire $284,126 $SD, 000 $234,126 Winter Springs Bonds $284,126 $50,000 $234,126 SJWM(Saint Johns Water Management) $284,126 $50,000 $234,126 County Bonds $264,126 $50,000 $234,126 The taxable values and taxes are calculated using the current years working values and the prior years approved millage rates. SALES Deed Date Book Page Amount Vac/Imp Qualified CORRECTIVE DEED O6l20D8 07019 1776 $100 Improved No 2008 VALUE SUMMARY WARRANTY DEED 02/2008 08957 1514 $325,000 Improved Yes QUIT CLAIM DEED 01/2000 03801 1215 $57,300 Improved No 2008 Tax Bill Amount: $5,334 2008 Certified Taxable Vatue and Taxe s WARRANTY DEED 11/1993 02683 1140 $168,500 Improved Yes WARRANTY DEED 06/1992 02445 0010 $142,000 Improved Yes DOES NOT INCLUDE NON-AD VALOREM ASSE SSMENTS WARRANTY DEED 10/1964 01588 1365 $26,000 Vacant Yes Find Comparable Sales within this Subdivision LAND LEGAL DESCRIPTION Land Assess Method Frontage Depth Land Units Unit Price Land Value PLATS: Pick... ACREAGE 0 0 .970 95,000.00 $92,150 LEG LOT 3 OAK HILL ESTATES PB 31 PG 19 BUILDING INFORMATION Bld Num Bld Type Year Blt Fixtures Base SF Gross SF Living SF Ext Wall Bld Value Est Cost New Building 1 SINGLE FAMILY 1985 7 2,121 3,298 Sketch 2,121 BRICK/WOOD FRAMING $179,158 $197,965 Appendage ! Sgft OPEN PORCH FINISHED ! 297 Appendage / Sgft GARAGE FINISHED / 460 Appendage / SgTt DETACHED GARAGE FINISHED! 420 NOTE: Appendage Codes included in Living Area: Base, Upper Story Base, Upper Story Finished, Apartment, Enclosed Porch Finished,8ase Semi Finshed Permits EXTRA FEATURE http://www.scpafl.org/web/re_web.seminole county_title?PARCEL=10213051000000030... 5/14/2009 Seminole County Property Appraiser Get Information by Parcel Number Page 2 of 2 Description Year Blt Units EXFT Value Est Cost New POOL GUNITE 1992 360 $4,140 $7,200 SCREEN ENCLOSURE 1992 1,990 $1,727 $3,980 COOL DECK PATIO 1992 330 $664 $1,155 CONC UTILITY BLDG 1985 30 $109 $210 SOLAR HEATER 1996 1 $440 $1,100 CONCRETE DRIVEWAY 4 INCH 1996 3,4D0 $5,738 $8,500 NOTE: Assessed values shown are NOT certified values and Therefore are subject to change before being frnalized for ad valorem tax purposes. "'If you recently ourchased a homesteaded orocerty your next year's orocertv tax will be based on Just/Madcet value. http://www.scpafl.org/web/re web.seminole county_title?PARCEL=10213051000000030... 5/14/2009 February 4, 2009 City of Winter Springs Winter Springs, FL 32708 To Whom It May Concern: RECE1~/E® ~,~~' ~ 6 ~a~~ CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS Permitting _ Christy We, Mike and Cathy Dwyer, live at 125 W. Tradewinds Rd., Winter Springs Florida are writing this letter on behalf of Todd and Jennifer Fante, our neighbors at 115 W. Tradewinds Rd. Todd has described to us his plans to enlarge the existing detached garage located on his property. We have no objection to Todd's plans, and support the approval of his request If you have any questions, or we if we can provide any further assistance, please feel free to contact me at 407-405-2660 Thank you, ~~ ~ w ~~~ CathyO'- Dwyer -~ .~ a/6~o~ ~~~~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~ _ CV ~ C Qil" n CITY OF WINTER SP / pe~~ RINGS p ' Christy U,,c,r ~e~~~~ Yv~of ~ari-~e~ ~.a~ .axb,la..n,es4 us 61 ~ ~~i,7 w ~ ~ 's ~ ~~rv~ '~zj (~QG~,r`~~ s-,~1~ gvr~p~ c~ ~ ~ -`~ icy ~J e~~ try. cx~`P- 40 7 ~ q 9' c~7// C o~-a--~% c~' ~~~-~. ~, atr~ ~ a V [ a ATTACHMENT D CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA UNAPPROVED MINUTES BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT REGULAR MEETING -MAY 21, 2009 (RESCHEDULED FROM MAY 7, 2009) PAGE 7 OF 10 Mr. John Streich, 805 Dyson Drive, Winter Springs, Florida: addressed the Board Members on this Conditional Use Request. Chairman Waters opened the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda Item. No one spoke. Chairman Waters closed the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda item. "I WILL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST FOR THE 1600 SQUARE FOOT DETACHED PRIVATE GARAGE AT 805 DYSON [DRIVE]." MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER PAINE- MALCOLM. SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER GASMAN. DISCUSSION. CHAIRMAN WATERS ADDED, "WE ACTUALLY NEED TO HAVE THAT STATE, RECOMMEND FOR APPROVAL." BOARD MEMBER PAINE- MALCOLM REPLIED, "CHANGE IT." DISCUSSION. VOTE: VICE CHAIRMAN TAYLOR: AYE BOARD MEMBER COLLINS: AYE BOARD MEMBER GASMAN: AYE BOARD MEMBER PAINE-MALCOLM: AYE CHAIRMAN WATERS: AYE MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARINGS 502. Community Development Department Recommends The Board Of Adjustment Hear A Request For A Conditional Use Within The City Of Winter Springs RC-I Zoning District (Residential Rural FLU [Future Land Use] Designation), To Allow Expansion (Doubling The Area) Of An Existing Approximately 530 Square Foot Detached Accessory Structure (Private Garage) On Approximately 1.14 Acres At 115 West Tradewinds Road. Mr. Baker presented this Agenda Item and stated, "I recommend Approval for each of those based on the unique circumstances and the fact that he does have recommendations of Approval from his neighbors." Chairman Waters opened the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda Item. No one spoke. Chairman Waters closed the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda item. CITY OF WINTER SPRINGS, FLORIDA UNAPPROVED MINUTES BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT REGULAR MEETING -MAY 21, 2009 (RESCHEDULED FROM MAY 7, 2009) PAGE 8 OF 10 "I WILL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE REQUEST FOR A CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST FOR THE DETACHED PRIVATE GARAGE ADDITION AT 115 WEST TRADEWINDS [ROAD]." MOTION BY VICE CHAIRMAN TAYLOR. SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER PAINE- MALCOLM. DISCUSSION. VOTE: BOARD MEMBER COLLINS: AYE BOARD MEMBER GASMAN: AYE CHAIRMAN WATERS: AYE VICE CHAIRMAN TAYLOR: AYE BOARD MEMBER PAINE-MALCOLM: AYE MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARINGS 503. Community Development Department Recommends The BOA (Board Of Adjustment) Hear The Request For A Waiver From The 20 Foot Side Yard And 35 Foot Rear Yard Setback Set Forth In Section 20-146. Of The City Code For Accessory Structures Exceeding 240 Square Feet (Section 6-84.), Pursuant To The Waiver Criteria And Procedure Detailed In Section 20-34., To Allow The Expansion Of An Existing 530 Square Foot Garage At 115 West Tradewinds Road, Within Approximately 15 Feet Of The Side Lot Line And The Existing Portion Of The Building To Remain Within Approximately 14 Feet Of The Rear Pronertv Line. Brief discussion. Chairman Waters opened the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda Item. No one spoke. Chairman Waters closed the "Public Input" portion on this Agenda item. "I MAKE A MOTION -RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF THE SETBACK WAIVER REQUEST." MOTION BY BOARD MEMBER PAINE-MALCOLM. VICE CHAIRMAN TAYLOR ADDED, "FOR 115 WEST TRADEWINDS [ROAD]". SECONDED BY BOARD MEMBER GASMAN. DISCUSSION.